News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The China Cultural Clash by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:20PM (#21194609)
> We've all accepted the incredibly one-sided deal, in some kind of idealistic hope that the Chinese would latch on to "western" values of democracy etc just by trading with us

To expand on this, the history of economic and democratic development were thought to go hand in hand. Not only had it borne out in Western Europe, it also showed traction in post-war Japan and India. So the hypothesis, that a wealthier China would become more stable and democratic wasn't insane.

That hypothesis has been proven false. Part of this is the reduced number of people required to hold on to power in our age of digital surveillance. Part of it is the unique culture Mao's Cultural Revolution left behind.

The moment of reckoning came when Xi installed himself as dictator for life. Prior to that, China had been lurching towards mastering peaceful transitions of power under intraparty politics. There was legitimate hope it would think and plan for the long term. With a dictator, however, short-term political survival dominates all else. And so we get the absurdity of a billion peoples' productive power being channeled into stamping out Winnie the Pooh imagery.

Re:The China Cultural Clash by notebookstack on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @04:03PM (#21196565)
Democracy was forcibly imposed on Japan by the US when they lost WWII; India had been colonized by the British and its elites exposed to their cultural and political systems for 200 years before independence. In Western Europe, the process took a couple millenia, dating back to the legacy of Greece and Rome. The Magna Carta started to limit monarchial authority in England beginning in 1215; the French had not one but a whole series of revolutions from the late 1700's through the 1800's. And yet, in between, there were decades and centuries of backslides into fiefdoms and dictatorships and absolute monarchies; even when progress was made, it was incremental - giving political say first to landed aristocracy and clergy, then men, then women.

I think it's a little early to definitely say that this hypothesis has been proven false in China. Keep in mind that China's growth has really only taken off since the mid-to-late 90's. That's less than one generation. Look at the path that comparable economies in Asia took who developed much earlier. Korea's economic miracle took off in 1960, but it was basically ruled by military dictatorships in all but name until 1987. Taiwan saw it's main burst of economic growth in the 60's and 70's, but it was also ruled as a dictatorship by the KMT since they lost the Chinese Civil War. In fact, the first opposition party was not formed until 1986, and martial law, which had been in effect since 1949, was not lifted until 1987, a year before Chiang Ching-kuo, Chiang Kai Shek's son and successor, passed away. Singapore's government all during its economic miracle was famously authoritarian.

Re:The China Cultural Clash by mlyle on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:27PM (#21194681)
> So the hypothesis, that a wealthier China would be a more stable, more democratic China wasn't insane.

I think the jury is still out. China has a long way left to develop and a huge populace still toiling without the benefits of that wealth. And some of the ways the economic development has happened are IMO temporarily and not durable.

> There was legitimate hope it would think and plan for the long term. With a dictator, however, short-term political survival dominates all else. And so we get the absurdity of a billion peoples' productive power being channeled into stamping out Winnie the Pooh imagery.

In fairness, I'm not sure that's a huge fraction of the billion peoples' productive power. ;P

Re:The China Cultural Clash by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:34PM (#21194753)
> I'm not sure that's a huge fraction of the billion peoples' productive power

The Winnie the Pooh thing is amusing because we like watching powerful people be insecure about childish things.

The dirtier side is senior CCP members using the country's wealth for personal gain to a level not seen since the Soviet Union [1].

[1] https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/asia/china/936509...

Re:The China Cultural Clash by tpmx on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:47PM (#21194921)
I feel like this analysis completed my incomplete thinking. Bravo.