News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by yostrovs on Monday October 07, 2019 @10:55PM (#21188227)
Does the ADA really apply and enforced at all publicly available businesses? Does every Chinese restaurant in Chinatown have a Braille menu? If we really start enforcing this, only larger businesses will survive.
Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by Retric on Monday October 07, 2019 @11:02PM (#21188274)
Restaurants don’t need a Braille menu to accommodate blind customers, a sighted employee can walk them through the ordering process. With websites that’s not always an option, which is legally and morally an issue.
Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by tylerl on Monday October 07, 2019 @11:38PM (#21188511)
It's curious then that they're suing Domino's.

Domino's has a phone number, and every capability the company offers over the web it offers over the phone. In fact, since this business in particular was built on telephone-based ordering, the the phone option is actually the first-class experience, with the web offering only a fraction of the options otherwise available.

So at least in this case, ordering pizza over the phone instead of web is precisely as suitable a substitute as speaking to a waiter instead of reading your Chinese menu in braille.

The plaintiff will argue that regardless of the fact that no business services are actually unavailable, it is the website itself that is being denied. And falling back to a compatible communication medium is inherently unsuitable regardless of whether the fallback is sufficiently functional.

And if that's the case, then it's functionally equivalent to say that failing to provide accessible menus in a restaurant, and falling back to having the menu spoken aloud, is a denial of rights.

I'm not going to say whether it's right or wrong, but it is certainly different than how the law had been interpreted in the past.

Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by jpollock on Monday October 07, 2019 @11:58PM (#21188633)
I believe the lawsuit is that there were deals which were web-only - meaning the blind person could not take advantage of them.
Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by snagglegaggle on Monday October 07, 2019 @11:50PM (#21188579)
That's a good point, though something I see commonly is a rather sizeable discount for doing an online-only order. Yes, you lose the discount if you call in.
Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by diebeforei485 on Monday October 07, 2019 @11:03PM (#21188291)
But you can call your local Domino's on the phone.
Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by DoreenMichele on Monday October 07, 2019 @11:12PM (#21188358)
You can't get (or use) Rewards points unless you order online. They also have online coupons and discounts.

They actively encourage customers to order online, pick up in person and do carry out. Most locations have minimal seating and minimal staff. Some don't even bother to have bathrooms for their customers.

Their business model actively tries to reduce the amount of overhead for the business by promoting online ordering and carryout service. So, no, ordering by phone isn't the same thing by any stretch of the imagination.

Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by notyourwork on Monday October 07, 2019 @11:28PM (#21188451)
Seems like they missed a demographic with their strategy. It shouldn’t be hard to add accessibility support to their site.
Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by tylerl on Monday October 07, 2019 @11:45PM (#21188548)
I think that misses the point. There's a mile of difference between adding sufficient accessibility to serve a demographic vs adding new legal requirements.

(Especially new requirements for which customers are financially incentivised to file suits, and for it's trivially simple to code up automated scanning to find businesses you can target.)

Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by DoreenMichele on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @12:04AM (#21188653)
Most handicapped people live in poverty. I'm quite convinced that a lot of privileged people are also moderately or significantly handicapped and hiding it. If you are important enough, people meet all your whackadoodle requirements without wondering why in the hell you can't do it "normally."

I've been in situations where I had privilege and I've been in situations where I couldn't get adequate accommodation for my handicap. Having privilege usually beats the tar out of having handicap accommodation.

If there are any genuinely blind people managing to supposedly "game the system" in the manner you describe, more power to them. Because trying to play it straight and do the right thing and earn my way and blah blah blah mostly seems to get me absolutely crapped all over.

Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by jakelazaroff on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @12:32AM (#21188794)
If fear of lawsuits means businesses end up making their websites accessible to disabled people, then… mission accomplished?
Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by tomnipotent on Monday October 07, 2019 @11:27PM (#21188442)
> Some don't even bother to have bathrooms for their customers.

At least in California, any business with eat-in food services is required (by law) to provide restrooms. If a Domino's franchise does not offer eat-in service, it's entirely reasonable (and legal) they don't have public restrooms.

Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by DoreenMichele on Monday October 07, 2019 @11:39PM (#21188519)
I've eaten at a Domino's with only one or two tables and no bathroom. I don't recall what state, possibly Arizona.

But I've done a fair amount of traveling and Domino's seems to position themselves as basically a carryout window. You can call and you can order in person, but most locations seem to do the vast majority of their business via the online ordering system.

They print off labels, slap them on the appropriate boxes and begin making the food. Some locations do a brisk business while only having one or two employees on site, plus one or more delivery drivers.

The employees sometimes clearly find it to be a hardship to take orders by phone or in person. It interrupts their workflow and they are frequently very busy just trying to fill orders coming in off the website.

Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by joegahona on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @01:37AM (#21189090)
This is a state-by-state thing. In Michigan, restrooms are required if dine-in is available. In NYC and Boston, there are numerous eat-in places with no bathroom. Good luck washing your hands before eating.
Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by wlesieutre on Monday October 07, 2019 @11:34PM (#21188488)
"Sighted people only" discounts is really not a good look though.

If they argue that the website doesn't need to be accessible because blind people can call, that's what all their online only coupons are.

Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by tootie on Monday October 07, 2019 @11:02PM (#21188276)
ADA in general has different levels of mandatory compliance based on business size and type. I can't find specific rules about website compliance though.
Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by toomim on Monday October 07, 2019 @11:06PM (#21188320)
Where the ADA applies is different than where it's enforced. This ruling only permits individual blind people to sue a business-- it doesn't force anyone to sue a business.
Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by weberc2 on Monday October 07, 2019 @11:05PM (#21188300)
I’m not usually one for more regulation, but I think this is a good thing. As far as regulations go, this is one of the cheaper ones, or at least it will be when developers are properly trained in accessibility and every serious CMS supports accessibility out of the box.
Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by Mirioron on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @06:49AM (#21190803)
Properly trained in accessibility is basically impossible. Freelancers are not going to be trained in it nor are people from all across the world.
Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by weberc2 on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @07:56AM (#21191226)
One of two scenarios will happen depending on how easy it is to retrofit an existing website for accessibility. If it is easy, some subset of developers will specialize in retrofitting. If it is not easy, all developers who want to compete for contracts that require ADA accessibility will have to do so. If some freelancers here or internationally refuse to learn for whatever reason, then they will not be eligible for those contracts, plain and simple.
Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by tibbon on Monday October 07, 2019 @11:05PM (#21188301)
It’s a myth that reasonable accommodations are too much of a burden for a small business to handle. Having a menu made into Braille for example isn’t going to cost a ton. On the upside, they would also now have business available that they didn’t have in the past.
Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by mikeg8 on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @12:04AM (#21188657)
After a few years in web development I began working for my dad’s business - we sell commercial doors and hardware and do a lot of work in SF. ADA requirements now force many restaurant to add an auto-door operator (push button that opens door) to their main entry. The total cost can be in the range of $10-15k for hardware, electrical work, union labor etc. this absolutely is a burden that some owners really struggle to afford so I’d argue the “myth” is very much alive. And I’m one of the people making money off this transaction. I have mixed feelings about it.
Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by DoreenMichele on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @12:10AM (#21188692)
Most likely, a large part of it is the extra burden involved in trying to understand what you actually need to do in order to be in compliance -- what's actually required and what's not.

I'm handicapped and also a freelancer and I have six years of college and I worked for a Fortune 500 company at one time. I feel I'm better positioned than a lot of individuals to figure out what I need to do without an accountant and a legal team and yadda, but I have my moments when I would like to go hide under a bed and cry and try to figure out how to kill myself because our highly regulated world sometimes seems like it is actively designed to make it impossible for people to make their lives work (without being part of a megacorp -- and what if that doesn't work for you?).

Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by Mirioron on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @06:46AM (#21190768)
>because our highly regulated world sometimes seems like it is actively designed to make it impossible for people to make their lives work (without being part of a megacorp -- and what if that doesn't work for you?).

I thought that everybody being part of megacorps was the intended outcome of a lot of regulations. Isn't that why there are no clear guidelines and limits to a lot of regulation? It's particularly ironic that the government themselves can't even seem to keep up with a lot of regulations (reminds me of GDPR and how the EU commission's websites didn't follow them).

Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by DoreenMichele on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @08:56AM (#21191714)
... intended outcome...Isn't that why there are no clear guidelines and limits to a lot of regulation?

"Ninety percent of everything is crap."

"Never attribute to malice what can be adequately explained by stupidity."

People tend to make rules that reflect the kind of environment that is typical for them. Federal government is large, bureaucratic, etc. It's no surprise that rules coming out of it implicitly assume that everyone works in a similar environment.

Another contributing problem is that people need to justify their paycheck. Writing more rules is how politicians look productive.

I don't know what the solution is. But assuming malice rather than trying to understand the problem space in more neutral terms is not a constructive path forward.

Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by Mirioron on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @03:04PM (#21195868)
I agree with you that a lot of the forces that push regulations are "random noise", but I find it difficult to believe that big players in these industries aren't pushing this along. They have something to gain from this after all.
Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by DoreenMichele on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @03:11PM (#21195947)
That's true, but is fundamentally a different idea than your earlier framing suggested to me. Lobbying is absolutely a thing and tends to be funded by people with deep pockets.
Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by StanislavPetrov on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @12:05AM (#21188659)
The issue is deciding what "reasonable" means in this context, which is the crux of this whole debate. This lawsuit allows blind people to due retailers for their websites, what if someone was both blind and deaf? There are a range of disabilities that put burdens on businesses from small to massive depending what disability we are talking about and what sort of services are being offered by the business.
Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by chrisco255 on Monday October 07, 2019 @11:10PM (#21188344)
I wonder why Domino's having a phone number to call in orders isn't enough of an accommodation in this case?
Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by Pinckney on Monday October 07, 2019 @11:18PM (#21188399)
My understanding, from a quick 5 minute skim, is that it may be. It's being sent back to the district court for reconsideration.

Basically what seems to have happened is this:

1. Robles sued Dominoes alleging their website violated the ADA.

2. The district court dismissed the suit, saying the DOJ needs to provide guidance on the standards that websites must meet, if the court is to hold them to the ADA. They don't examine the question of the phone.

3. The appeals court steps in and says that no, the district court was wrong to dismiss it for that reasons, and sends it back to the district court.

4. Dominoes appeals to SCOTUS, saying "help, the appeals court got it wrong, please step in!" SCOTUS declines to get involved, so the case will go back to the district court, which may still find that the phone access provided is an adequate accommodation.

Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by couchand on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @12:02AM (#21188645)
From footnote 4:

> However, the district court did not reach whether a genuine issue of material fact existed as to the telephone hotline’s compliance with the ADA, including whether the hotline guaranteed full and equal enjoyment and "protect[ed] the privacy and independence of the individual with a disability." ... We believe that the mere presence of the phone number, without discovery on its effectiveness, is insufficient to grant summary judgment in favor of Domino’s.

Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by Mathnerd314 on Monday October 07, 2019 @11:15PM (#21188380)
It probably is sufficient; the issue here was Domino's said the website wasn't covered by the ADA at all.

And there might be trouble with some of Domino's coupons being online-only.

Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by mattl on Monday October 07, 2019 @11:22PM (#21188426)
How do you know what’s for sale at Domino’s?
Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by belltaco on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @02:04AM (#21189242)
You can call them and ask?
Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by mwcampbell on Tuesday October 08, 2019 @08:28AM (#21191474)
How would you like it if you couldn't thoroughly peruse a restaurant menu and coupons at your own pace, but instead had to call a customer service rep and ask them to talk you through it, knowing that they need to get your order completed and get you off the phone as fast as possible? Putting these things online is really ideal for everyone, as long as the web developer doesn't screw up accessibility.
Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by zamadatix on Monday October 07, 2019 @11:12PM (#21188359)
It depends what is considered "accessible enough". E.g. they may not have a braille menu but there is a person you can communicate with. In the same regard maybe a site that signals "you can call this number to have assisted service" is alright.

I haven't read into what the exact ruling covered I'm just pointing out it doesn't have to be black and white to the point it runs all guy large places out of business.

Edit: apparently my phone typing speed is no match for the interest in this topic :)

Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by smnrchrds on Monday October 07, 2019 @11:02PM (#21188278)
I am not familiar with the details of ADA. Would it not suffice if a server reads the menu out loud upon request by a blind patron?
Re:Supreme Court allows blind people to sue retailers if web... by freeone3000 on Monday October 07, 2019 @11:43PM (#21188539)
Yes, it would! This is actually an example used in compliance guidelines: https://www.ada.gov/regs2010/smallbusiness/smallbusprimer201...