News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Report: iPhone 5 Will Be 'Completely Redesigned' by lukifer on Tuesday January 18, 2011 @09:05AM (#2115791)
I don't buy it. We might see an option to make Home inert, but to be completely buttonless hurts discoverability and familiarity with non-techy consumers.

(I won't say it's completely impossible that Apple would do it, just that it's overall a bad idea.)

Re:Report: iPhone 5 Will Be 'Completely Redesigned' by pohl on Tuesday January 18, 2011 @09:23AM (#2115861)
That would be perfect for my toddler. He sits on my lap and plays with Uzu (an app) but can't resist the home button. There seems to be many people asking in forums for cases that solve the same problem by obscuring the button. It could be great for a kiosk mode too, especially if the gestures to get out of the app could be a chosen secret.
Re:Report: iPhone 5 Will Be 'Completely Redesigned' by lukeschlather on Tuesday January 18, 2011 @10:44AM (#2116119)
Yes, it would make a great toy / embedded device.

However, as a phone I don't see how less than a back button and a home button is sufficient. It's a lot like the mouse debate. I need at least a couple hardware buttons.

Re:Report: iPhone 5 Will Be 'Completely Redesigned' by glhaynes on Tuesday January 18, 2011 @11:20AM (#2116297)
Lots of iPhone users are quite productive with just a home button and no back button. Not to say that it's definitively better that way (I think I prefer it, though I haven't spent nearly as much time with an Android device), but it's certainly not so much worse as to cause an outcry for it.
Re:Report: iPhone 5 Will Be 'Completely Redesigned' by vdm on Tuesday January 18, 2011 @02:29PM (#2117006)
I use an iPhone daily, and have only played with friends Androids, but the Android back hard key doesn't work as well for me. I think it's asymmetric position works worse for people whose thumb is on the other side of the device (if they're a lefty). No such issue with iPhones home button; there's no wrong option.
Re:Report: iPhone 5 Will Be 'Completely Redesigned' by sp332 on Tuesday January 18, 2011 @10:18AM (#2116040)
Discoverability isn't an issue if the learning curve is small enough to fit into a 30-second ad. By the time iPhone 5 comes out, everyone who watches major network TV will know how to use it.
Re:Report: iPhone 5 Will Be 'Completely Redesigned' by rahoulb on Tuesday January 18, 2011 @12:47PM (#2116628)
Maybe buttonless for the iPad, but I doubt it for the iPhone as you would lose the ability to use it one-handed.