Re:Report: iPhone 5 Will Be 'Completely Redesigned'
by glhaynes on Tuesday January 18, 2011 @11:20AM
(#2116297)
Lots of iPhone users are quite productive with just a home button and no back button. Not to say that it's definitively better that way (I think I prefer it, though I haven't spent nearly as much time with an Android device), but it's certainly not so much worse as to cause an outcry for it.
Re:Report: iPhone 5 Will Be 'Completely Redesigned'
by vdm on Tuesday January 18, 2011 @02:29PM
(#2117006)
I use an iPhone daily, and have only played with friends Androids, but the Android back hard key doesn't work as well for me. I think it's asymmetric position works worse for people whose thumb is on the other side of the device (if they're a lefty). No such issue with iPhones home button; there's no wrong option.
However, as a phone I don't see how less than a back button and a home button is sufficient. It's a lot like the mouse debate. I need at least a couple hardware buttons.