News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No evidence that testosterone reduces cognitive empathy by anon1m0us on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @07:43PM (#21142001)
It's amazing that something so sexist could have been suggested without backlash.

Imagine if studies indicated that low testosterone limited or in some way hindered another desirable human capability. People have been fired for it and reputations ruined.

Suggesting men are emotionally stunted. Oh that's fine.

Re:No evidence that testosterone reduces cognitive empathy by dang on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:59PM (#21143529)
Please don't take HN threads into flamewar.

I understand the feeling you're expressing completely. But if you just import this resentment into the thread in an unprocessed way, it acidifies discussion and makes it harder for people to be thoughtful and share information across divides. Not just the gender-ideological divide, but any divide.

We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21139988.

Re:No evidence that testosterone reduces cognitive empathy by anon1m0us on Thursday October 03, 2019 @05:08AM (#21145011)
Understood. Thank you.
Re:No evidence that testosterone reduces cognitive empathy by skizm on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @08:06PM (#21142165)
I mean, you should be able to claim either if you have evidence. We should be looking for truth, not virtue signalling by withholding findings because it might hurt some people's feelings.
Re:No evidence that testosterone reduces cognitive empathy by ping_pong on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @08:15PM (#21142242)
James Damore referenced scientific papers in his post and his intent got twisted, he got vilified and subsequently fired by Google. He never said women were unfit for engineering or women weren't as smart as men, he said that Google should change the nature of engineering such that the career is more appealing to a higher percentage of females.

Do you really want to be the one that endures an unfair attack and have your intent twisted and ruin your career, just to try to prove a point? You would be a stronger person than me, I would just pass at this point and move on.

Re:No evidence that testosterone reduces cognitive empathy by belorn on Thursday October 03, 2019 @08:41AM (#21146279)
Parent comment could have been written in better tone but the underlying aspect holds some very real historical truth. In the past popular opinion and scientist agreed that estrogen caused emotional instability, and it was infamously used as an argument against the suffrage movement. Now days we know that those studies in the past was severely flawed and that the historical research was shaped by culture rather than rigorous science and facts.

An observed fact and problem with behavior science is that they tend to align based on the culture of where the research is taking place. In Germany around 1940 you got very distinct results in behavior science compared to modern views. Behavior research made during the cold war looks very different depending which side of the Berlin wall it came from, even when accounting for sample size and scientific methods.

There are theories that tries to explain this, like for example that researchers tend to focus narrowly on questions that feel relevant in their personal culture, and then drawing larger conclusions.

Re:No evidence that testosterone reduces cognitive empathy by toop43 on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @09:01PM (#21142534)
That's a pipe dream in 2019.
Re:No evidence that testosterone reduces cognitive empathy by erikpukinskis on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @08:40PM (#21142417)
What’s your evidence there was no backlash? This kind of finding seems like the type of thing both MRAs and a majority of feminists¹ would object to.

I can’t even see the title of the original paper since this one is paywalled. I was going to go try to quantify this “absence of backlash” you mentioned.

¹ It is sort of an interesting question, which majority of feminists that is. Some liberal, trans-inclusive, biological-constructivist feminists who believe in a notion of a “female brain” would potentially see no problem with the study. That is quite a minority though. The vast majority of liberal feminists would be “social constructivist” feminists who believe male/female brain differences are overblown and would view the study incredulously. Similarly, some biological-essentialist radical feminists do believe in comprehensive sex differences, and would be amenable to the finding. These would be your typical “man haters”, who are vocal online because their ideas are not welcome hardly anywhere. However, the vast majority of radical feminists believe the male/female sex differences have primarily to do with reproductive organs and, again, brain differences are overblown. And therefore would also be incredulous of the result. So all-in-all the vast majority of feminists would by default object to the study. But there is a sex-essentialist slice that cuts across the liberal/radical divide who would entertain the ideas.

On the MRA side too I believe there are sex essentialists who would be fine with the study, although many more liberal MRAs would object to it purely on the grounds of it portraying men in a negative light. I’m less familiar with the ideological divisions in that group though.

As a side note, this is part of why liberal and radical feminists are able to hate each other and talk past each other: both sides can credibly accuse the other of harboring biological essentialists.

Re:No evidence that testosterone reduces cognitive empathy by anon1m0us on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @08:49PM (#21142476)
My only evidence is that I didn't hear of one. Didn't even hear about the studies. Perhaps they just confirmed what everyone already thought or wanted to believe or the gender disparaged by the studies didn't care enough to raise a fuss. Whatever the reason.

I did hear about the president of Harvard being fired though. I read about The Bell Curve. Damore. The list goes on and on. You must know what I'm talking about.

Maybe I'm just biased so I filter bubble out evidence that sexism is sexist.

Re:No evidence that testosterone reduces cognitive empathy by astine on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:41PM (#21143398)
For the record, I've definitely seen backlash against the 'male brain' hypothesis for autism, which is that this study is ultimately about. The guy who first proposed it was Simon Baron-Cohen who is a well known autism researcher and there were people, especially female autists who felt that they were being overlooked or compared to men, who complained about it. Some even accused of Baron-Cohen of bigotry of various sorts. I think the 'male brain' hypothesis has largely remained in the autism research sphere and so hasn't had as much visibility, which might explain why there isn't a huge 'cancel-culture' backlash. There needs to be a certain threshold of visibility before that kind of backlash can happen.

https://autistscorner.blogspot.com/2011/09/simon-baron-cohen...

Re:No evidence that testosterone reduces cognitive empathy by tomlock on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @09:49PM (#21142796)
I've got a philosophy/gender studies background and I +1 this summary. The only point I'd make is that "radical feminist" doesn't necessarily mean anti-trans, and of the radfems I know, the vast majority are actually pro-trans. I get the feeling from news and commentary that radfems are overall welcoming to trans people.
Re:No evidence that testosterone reduces cognitive empathy by rossdavidh on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @10:18PM (#21142946)
Well there is a statistically (very) significant difference in the (diagnosed) rate of autism between men and women, so it's not so audacious a claim.
Re:No evidence that testosterone reduces cognitive empathy by rozab on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @08:22PM (#21142284)
There is still strong evidence that excess testosterone causes anger and other undesirable effects [0]. Why should there be a backlash when there is evidence?

On the other hand, it has been an accepted truism for many decades that the female brain is less capable of many tasks, and I haven't seen firings and ruined reputations over this. The science of this is now being seriously questioned.

[0] https://academic.oup.com/jcem/article/89/6/2837/2870329

Re:No evidence that testosterone reduces cognitive empathy by anon1m0us on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @08:40PM (#21142413)
> anger and other undesirable effects.

"other" could mean these from the linked article:

> The growing literature on androgenic anabolic steroid (AAS) usage suggests that some users can develop bouts of aggression known as steroid rage, mood disturbance, hypomania, irritability, and depressive episodes (9–15).

Whenever I think about ourselves, I think from an evolutionary perspective. All of the mentioned effects exist in species other than humans. I can list several reasons why the behaviors could be considered desirable.

Also note, the article says the only significantly increased emotion was anger hostility. Why does anger exist?

Re:No evidence that testosterone reduces cognitive empathy by Gibbon1 on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @08:59PM (#21142526)
I have no dog in this hunt, but body builders tend to claim that conversion of testosterone to estrogen and resulting high levels of that are what causes mood issues. Which is why they all take aromatase inhibitors.
Re:No evidence that testosterone reduces cognitive empathy by goblin89 on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:13PM (#21143219)
Why does anger exist?

Personally I can’t see how anger can be anything else but a manifestation of certain underlying fear as a defensive response. (That said, those emotions seem to be conventionally recognized as mostly unrelated.)

Re:No evidence that testosterone reduces cognitive empathy by taneq on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:41PM (#21143395)
I'd like to see Yoda cite his sources on that "fear leads to anger" thing. This whole construction that it's impossible to react negatively to something without being motivated by fear is, IMO, unsubstantiated at best. It's entirely possible to dislike something or be irritated by it without fearing it.
Re:No evidence that testosterone reduces cognitive empathy by goblin89 on Thursday October 03, 2019 @12:12AM (#21143618)
Like I wrote—it is my personal (and layperson’s to boot) view, I can only cite sources that treat them as unrelated emotions.

I distinguish between fear as in immediate flight response, and fear as in deeper insecurity or non-obvious harm avoidance, including things like social status preservation.

I would not bundle reflecting negatively among all that, though.

Re:No evidence that testosterone reduces cognitive empathy by igornadj on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @09:12PM (#21142607)
>the female brain is less capable of many tasks

That's a very problematic and dangerous phrasing. There is also no such thing as the female brain. There are distributions of biology.

Re:No evidence that testosterone reduces cognitive empathy by lone_haxx0r on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @10:53PM (#21143098)
And there's no such thing as a wealthy country, just distributions of wealthy people. Yet we all understand what it means when someone says "wealthy country"
Re:No evidence that testosterone reduces cognitive empathy by krilly on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @09:36PM (#21142742)
I should have made clearer that this view is now dated.
Re:No evidence that testosterone reduces cognitive empathy by lazyguy2 on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:47PM (#21143442)
It's not sexist to suggest that testosterone impacts the body and mind. Male hormones exist for a reason and one of those big reasons is to impact behavior in various ways, including sex drive.

What is sexist is assuming testosterone is responsible for autism and acting on that 'knowledge' without proof in some manner that impacts other people's lives.

Re:No evidence that testosterone reduces cognitive empathy by cjohansson on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:56PM (#21143505)
If their sample did not inlude autistic men you can’t really draw any conclusions about autism from this study
Re:No evidence that testosterone reduces cognitive empathy by chr1 on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:29PM (#21143316)
Maybe in part this is due to many men not considering it as a desirable human capability. If one considers reason to be much more important than emotion, strives to hide all displays of emotion, being emotionally stunted feels more like a compliment than offence.
Re:No evidence that testosterone reduces cognitive empathy by blarg1 on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:13PM (#21143220)
better analogy would be estrogen causing hysteria :)
Re:No evidence that testosterone reduces cognitive empathy by ShinTakuya on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @11:32PM (#21143342)
I think we should be able to suggest either thing without backlash, as long as you don't say it's certain until it's proven.