News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:F-35's radar invisibility cloak in question by vorpalhex on Monday September 30, 2019 @11:28AM (#21116366)
So they managed to pick up a stealth jet.. that was equipped with special markers to make it extra visible (for air safety outside of combat), with additional help from a strong polish broadcaster... with information knowing exactly when and where the aircraft would be?
Re:F-35's radar invisibility cloak in question by braythwayt on Monday September 30, 2019 @11:42AM (#21116554)
This was addressed in the OP. Their explanation is that the markers are optimized for the specific band of civilian radar, and that they do not assist with passive radar detection.

As for knowing when and where the planes were flying, true, true. But then again, they deployed one van to try to detect the planes, in the one farm, and if the objective was to suggest that the passive technology could end up being useful in a military situation, that might be enough.

The argument is that the F-35 is invisible. If passive detection seems to have any effectiveness, even slight, in detecting F-35s, that ought to guide investment into passive detection and into upgrading the F-35’s stealth to avoid passive detection.

INAE, but it feels like there is enough here to cast the claims of complete invulnerability to detection in doubt.

Re:F-35's radar invisibility cloak in question by akvadrako on Monday September 30, 2019 @11:46AM (#21116627)
The main argument for the F-35's stealth is to avoid target locking missiles. It's not to be "invisible".
Re:F-35's radar invisibility cloak in question by braythwayt on Wednesday October 02, 2019 @08:39PM (#21142407)
That is a very interesting perspective, thank you for sharing it.
Re:F-35's radar invisibility cloak in question by SiempreViernes on Monday September 30, 2019 @12:01PM (#21116795)
How does low radar observatbility help against IR missiles?
Re:F-35's radar invisibility cloak in question by vonmoltke on Monday September 30, 2019 @12:11PM (#21116899)
IR seekers have very (in air-air combat terms) short effective range, ~25km at best. Thus, a missile with an IR terminal-stage seeker needs to either be launched from close range (which would indicate the F-35 was probably detected via Mark 1 Eyeball) or the missile needs to be guided into range by radar. Guiding the missile that way involves painting the target with a fire control radar and having a passive radar seeker on the missile follow the return. Reduced radar signature obviously helps in the second case.

Edit: fixed seeker range

Re:F-35's radar invisibility cloak in question by dx034 on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @07:22AM (#21124139)
But in this case passive radar would help enormously? It could detect the aircraft and help to launch an IR missile, effectively rendering the stealth capabilities useless. Deployed at borders, it could provide good air defense against F35.

You obviously need strong signals for passive radar to work but those could be positioned inland and they don't need to be where the passive radar is, making it harder to disable it.

Re:F-35's radar invisibility cloak in question by 0003 on Monday September 30, 2019 @12:11PM (#21116898)
IR is only really effective in the short-range (see an aim-9 which is only effective less than 20 nm (really less than that practically speaking). When they talk about this, they mean protection against beyond visual range missiles.
Re:F-35's radar invisibility cloak in question by hguant on Monday September 30, 2019 @01:23PM (#21117623)
>(see an aim-9 which is only effective less than 20 nm (really less than that practically speaking)

I would really love to see the actual Probability of Kill numbers for the US missile fleet. I know that's never going to happen/they're going to remain classified for a _long_ time, but the kid in me really wants to know "does it actually work?"

Re:F-35's radar invisibility cloak in question by 0003 on Monday September 30, 2019 @03:04PM (#21118616)
You tend to get the results from who we sell the missiles too. Ironically, I believe Iran has the most kills for the F-14 / AIM-54 missile, which had a whopping 100nm range. Then, I think Israel has been demonstrating the most combat effectiveness of the the F-35 in attacks in Syria...

Air-combat is "hard" to answer the "does it actually work" because it is very much like high stakes chess in the air. A lot of times you fire 1 missile to make the bogey defensive, and multiple missiles to kill. This gets even more complicated when you factor in differences in pilot skill, numbers, chaff, and electronic counter measures.

Re:F-35's radar invisibility cloak in question by stallmanite on Tuesday October 01, 2019 @08:42AM (#21124671)
nm here I’m guessing is nautical miles? Nanometer range missiles would be tricky to wage war with.
Re:F-35's radar invisibility cloak in question by jmckind_ on Monday September 30, 2019 @02:13PM (#21118108)
Anyone claiming that the F-35 is invisible is either uninformed or propagandizing.
Re:F-35's radar invisibility cloak in question by PopePompus on Monday September 30, 2019 @11:34AM (#21116437)
Yes, if the countries deploying the F-35 have any sense at all, they will install equipment to make the aircraft trackable on all air show and most training flights, so that potential adversaries can’t accurately assess their ability to track it in full stealth operation.
Re:F-35's radar invisibility cloak in question by upofadown on Monday September 30, 2019 @11:37AM (#21116486)
The radar people claim that the "markers" intended for microwave frequencies would make no difference to passive radar. That seems quite believable as passive radar uses things like commercial VHF radio transmitters as emitters. The frequencies involved are vastly different. The features are simply too small to cause much of a reflection at VHF.
Re:F-35's radar invisibility cloak in question by ltbarcly3 on Monday September 30, 2019 @11:43AM (#21116571)
So... Microwave and VHF are not vastly different frequencies, Microwave starts at 300MHz and VHF ends at ... 300MHz.

Yes, they each span a wide range of frequencies, but every frequency range spans a wide range of frequencies. These two are as close as you can be.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microwave

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Very_high_frequency

Not coincidently, VHF Radar is defined to be between 50 and 330Mhz, which actually overlaps both Microwave and VHF television.

Now as to the main question, if I set up a device to interact with radar at some frequency and attach it to a stealth airplane, what frequencies would you expect it to effectively interact with it (assuming it's tuned at all, they could just be attaching a big piece of flat aluminum)?

Answer: If my device has peak interaction at frequency F, you will see harmonics, so you will see significant interactions at 1/8 F, 1/4 F, 1/2 F, F, 2 F, 4F, 8F.

Airport radar is around 3Ghz. So if the radar reflector operates at around 3Ghz, it will also work pretty well at 1.5Ghz, 750Mhz, 375Mhz, and even 187.5 Mhz. 187.5Mhz is TV channel 6 or 7, depending on country. Half again is 93.7 is FM (which the article specifically mentions).

Re:F-35's radar invisibility cloak in question by upofadown on Monday September 30, 2019 @12:08PM (#21116867)
A half wavelength at 3 GHz is 50 mm. A half wavelength of 93.7 MHz is 1600 mm. The retroreflector here is not being used as a retroreflector for passive radar as the transmitter and receiver are not in the same spot. Why would a small chunk of stuff stuck to a bigger chunk of stuff somehow disturb the high power VHF signals used more than the big chunk of stuff it is attached to?
Re:F-35's radar invisibility cloak in question by ltbarcly3 on Monday September 30, 2019 @01:55PM (#21117939)
I guess the glib answer is that the big thing is specifically designed to avoid disrupting those signals, and the small thing is designed to disrupt them as much as possible.

A tiny radar reflector has the cross section of a huge object, because it intentionally has right angles that send signals back to their source without scattering them in other directions (as much as is possible).

Passive radar still requires the object to reflect signals, it just doesn't require the signals to be reflected back to the source of the signal. Consider a monitor with an anti-reflective coating (so lets take a non glossy monitor). It is effective at reducing the reflection of the window behind you, it uses a thin film to cause destructive interference so that the light coming in the window not reflected, and you see a greenish-purplish image of the window instead of getting a bright reflection. However, if you take a flashhlight and shine it down on the monitor from near the top of the monitor, you will easily see the glare from the flashlight as it illuminates the monitor.

I think this is a good analogy for active vs passive radar. The F-117 was built to avoid right angles, this is like the light from the window behind you. The F-117 won't send radar back in the same direction it came from, so active radars are thwarted. However, if it is being 'lit up' from somewhere else, it is not as effective since by not sending radar back to where it came from it sends it in other directions instead.

However, it also has a coating to just straight up absorb radar. The F-35 is much more reliant on such coatings, and so it should scatter very little EM radiation in those frequencies, regardless of whether the detector is in the same location as the transmitter.

Re:F-35's radar invisibility cloak in question by upofadown on Monday September 30, 2019 @03:52PM (#21119086)
I thought radar absorbing paint didn't work much below 1GHz. So it probably doesn't really help against passive radar.
Re:F-35's radar invisibility cloak in question by dplavery92 on Monday September 30, 2019 @03:43PM (#21118989)
Harmonics occur at integer multiples of the fundamental. If a body resonates at F, you will see harmonics at F, 2F, 3F...

You will not see harmonics at fractional (1/2 F, etc...) frequencies of the fundamental, though you will likely still see some backscatter.

Retroreflectors[0], to include the Luneburg lenses[1] mentioned in the article, function by directing radar energy parallel to its incidence direction. These reflectors will not significantly increase the plane's RCS for passive/bistatic receivers. Even if these reflectors did increase RCS omni-directionally, it is unlikely that a reflector designed to operate at 3 Ghz (10 cm) would also be designed to operate at 187.5 MHz (1.6 meters).

[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Retroreflector [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Luneburg_lens#Radar_reflector

Re:F-35's radar invisibility cloak in question by SiempreViernes on Monday September 30, 2019 @12:03PM (#21116824)
More importantly, how does the intensity go with the order of the harmonics?
Re:F-35's radar invisibility cloak in question by ltbarcly3 on Monday September 30, 2019 @01:46PM (#21117853)
I don't know enough about the reflector. If it works like a boat's radar reflector, an 20 cm reflector would have a equivalent cross section as a metal sphere with an area of about 30 square meters.

I mean the goal of a radar reflector is to send radar signals back to their source, they are super effective. They don't really work like antennas generally, but the pictures of the F-35's reflectors do not look typical, or like a boat's radar reflector, and I have no idea what principle they use.

Re:F-35's radar invisibility cloak in question by blantonl on Monday September 30, 2019 @12:08PM (#21116877)
That is definitely not true.

Sensitive VHF radio receivers, tuned to transmitters that are located beyond line of site, can very easily detect VHF communications reflected off of a very small airborne target.

I can sit in my office with a spectrum analyzer and watch the signal strength of a distant digital TV broadcast station come in and out of view when an aircraft flies overhead.

Couple that technique with a DF network and far more sensitive receivers and GPS timing, and building a passive radar to defeat stealth technology become far easier than you think.

Re:F-35's radar invisibility cloak in question by GhettoMaestro on Monday September 30, 2019 @12:30PM (#21117101)
Yeah I wondered when someone would just create a super dense (networked) phased array system.
Re:F-35's radar invisibility cloak in question by burnte on Monday September 30, 2019 @11:39AM (#21116510)
Exactly. It was tracked with radar reflectors to make it visible, and from a position they knew the jets would be close, while also tracking their transponders to correlate with the reflection data. This is the equivalent of saying they successfully completed the Daytona 500 by driving a Honda around the track a few times at 45 miles an hour with the track closed to everyone else.
Re:F-35's radar invisibility cloak in question by bayesian_horse on Monday September 30, 2019 @11:42AM (#21116558)
Those markers may actually be irrelevant for the tracking, because they are very small and are meant for different frequencies. ADS-B also doesn't come into it, if they designed the system or demonstration correctly.

More interesting would be whether those planes actually had the full stealth coating and various other "stealth settings".

Re:F-35's radar invisibility cloak in question by ianhawes on Monday September 30, 2019 @11:35AM (#21116456)
This. It's common knowledge that F-35 and F-22 both fly with markers to ping on radar. Additionally, the fact that the F-35 was squawking their ADS-B indicates that they were not flying in operational mode.
Re:F-35's radar invisibility cloak in question by velox_io on Monday September 30, 2019 @12:14PM (#21116928)
It's quite a change going from not exporting any F22s to the F35s, which feels like they'll sell them to anyone that wants some (minus the usual suspects). Especially when the F35s stealth technology is said to be more advanced.

It's hard to get your head around a plane the can climb over 1000 feet per second (F22: 62,000ft in 60 seconds).

Re:F-35's radar invisibility cloak in question by onion2k on Monday September 30, 2019 @11:41AM (#21116529)
Picking it up "with information knowing exactly when and where the aircraft would be" makes it a better test - there's no ambiguity about what they picked up.

The important question is whether or not they can pick it up when it doesn't have markers fitted as they claim they can. To quote Carl Sagan, 'extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence'. If (and it's a huge if) they can do what they say they can then stealth might be rendered pointless, and that changes a lot.

Re:F-35's radar invisibility cloak in question by _fizz_buzz_ on Monday September 30, 2019 @11:50AM (#21116666)
That quote kind of goes both ways. Claiming that your plane cannot be picked up by any form of radar might be an even more extraordinary claim. In particular Lookhead makes it really hard for anyone to verify this claim. While it seems like Hensoldt was very willing to demonstrate their capabilities at the air show.
Re:F-35's radar invisibility cloak in question by russdill on Monday September 30, 2019 @11:36AM (#21116469)
Re:F-35's radar invisibility cloak in question by freeone3000 on Monday September 30, 2019 @01:40PM (#21117790)
It was also actively broadcasting its location at the time.