Nowadays with CVT or with PDK it seems to me that you're merely making a "suggestion" to put the transmission into Neutral. If the transmission software is borked, you're screwed?
But I'm not sure, maybe there is some fail safe override that occurs when you physically move the transmission control stalk into the neutral position?
I'd say that you could always turn the engine off. But Toyota made a mockery of that. Q: Who knew that you needed to press and hold the OFF button for a full five seconds before the car decided to comply? A: Not everyone knew --- people died!
Nice thing about a standard transmission is that unless the linkage breaks you can always pull it out of gear, even under load.
> I'd say that you could always turn the engine off.
You can't necessarily turn a Diesel off [1], and I would not be surprised if modern very-high compression gasoline engines are able to pull the same runaway off.
[1] Big Diesel generators have countermeasures for runaway, but cars don't.
Sure, it's got risks, but it is a key element of driver control. At least with my Mazda, I couldn't get a manual transmission, but the thing will go to N while rolling (haven't yet tried Off).
And yes, even with lots of experience, I'm not sure I'd figure out to hold the OFF button for 5 full seconds in a unintended acceleration scenario -- that's damn deadly!!
The trim is driven by a jackscrew. That jackscrew is driven by a mechanism in the cockpit (a large double wheel near each flight crew station). At low and moderate airspeeds, the jackscrew turns relatively easily. At high airspeeds and low elevator deflections (meaning "when the aircraft is approximately in trim"), the jackscrew turns relatively easily. At high airspeeds and high elevator deflections, the forces on the tail make the jackscrew difficult to turn due heavy forces. This would be the case where the aircraft is trimmed heavily nose down and the crew is holding large amounts of up elevator to compensate. (You're basically cranking the tail into a different position against the air loads on it.)
Slowing the airplane down would almost surely have helped the crew by reducing these loads. If you're going too fast (information the crew had available to them both in cockpit and confirmed by radio after they inquired while fighting), 94% N1 is not where you want the engines set.
It's not a popular or comfortable position to look into the actions of the crew and find areas for improvement in light of the fact that they were dealt a very difficult situation that morning.
Even with that, it appears that they correctly diagnosed the root of the issue, correctly disabled the electric trim [memory item on the checklist], for some reason left the engines at takeoff power [possibly just overlooked them, though overlooking engine power setting is like overlooking breathing to pilots], and when even knowing it was part of the problem, they correctly re-enabled the electric trim system in order to help them manage the situation, they then failed to command continuous nose up electric trim [which would have cut out MCAS and given them assistance in trimming the aircraft nose up]. The only reason to have the malfunctioning electric trim back on is to command nose up trim. Why turn it on, immediately command nose up, then stop and leave the faulty system engaged?
That crew was so close to saving the aircraft that it's frustrating as a pilot and a human. Slight adjustments to the above sequence and they're rightly heroes alongside Captains Sullenberger and Haynes.
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-ethiopia-airplane-procedu...