In other words...
Person A: Price sensitive shopper who won't pay more than $2.00 for an Avocado under any circumstance.
Person B: Convenience sensitive shopper who will pay up to $4 for an Avocado.
The grocery store can price using one of two methods... 1) offering the same price to all shoppers, or 2) offering a higher price to most shoppers so that they can offer a lower price to price sensitive shoppers (via coupons, arbitrary sale dates, etc).
With method #1, the grocery store can only sell Avocados to Person B because their prices are permanently higher than Person A is willing to pay. But with method #2, the grocery store can sell to both people because they've created a situation where a less price sensitive person subsidizes the cost of the product purchased by another more price sensitive person. The grocery store makes more money with method #2 in this example (at least hypothetically).
I think the key is realizing that people value things differently. Some people don't look at prices when they shop. Some do. Some people only shop when they think they're saving money, some don't care. Some people value convenience + time more than price, some are the reverse.
Obviously this example doesn't really apply to the first part of your comment about "Grief economy", just the 2nd part about coupons + pricing.
The most obvious added value is faster delivery: ship today instead of in X days/weeks when the auction ends.
It also has weird value if you for some reason believe the BIN price is undervaluing the item, i.e. you can short-circuit the auction before anyone else realises.
> makes the whole system seem much more sensible
But doesn't it apply there too? Price discrimination has many forms, but a less pretty way of describing that one is the retailer creates non-monetary external costs and mixes them into offers, to discourage customers from simply switching to offers where less money changes hands.
Imagine instead of a "spend time clipping coupons rather than reading with your kids" proof-of-work, the retailer creates an offer which requires someone to degrade themselves, to crawl on the floor and beg, to obtain a low price. This happily permits the retailer to extend affordable service to the desperate, without more profitable customers thinking it worth switching offers! So... yay?
Issues include at least some created work functions not having inherent societal value (coupon clipping is perhaps more like bitcoin factorization than like ai-training captchas). And that created costs, and simply the customer categorization they are but one way to obtain, can have negative impacts on lives and society.
It seems economics conversations are often more explicit about value creation and flow, but less transparent about the creation of "negative value", where it ends up, and its effects. There's more involved with an avocado coupon than merely a pair of price discriminated avocado sales.
Assuming 1:1 $2:$4 sales, say the cost is $1. They make $4 if they sell w/ coupon or not. The coupon chasing customer is a lower value customer because it actually takes some overhead to make coupons and to constantly convince them to be a customer. Whereas you can price at $3 and look like a champ compared to your $2 (secret coupon) /$4 (advertised price) competitors...
But who thinks you look like a champ?
To Person A (the person who won't pay more than $2), they won't be a customer because you've outpriced them. To Person B (the shopper who doesn't care if they pay $3 vs. $4) you look exactly the same, because they probably put the Avocado in their cart without even checking the price.
Not only is the coupon strategy twice as profitable for you, more customers are walking out of your store paying a price they were happy with, so you've likely got higher consumer satisfaction.
Hence why price discrimination is somewhat win-win.
I thought it would make him just go away. He produced the money instantly. I've always wondered about that...
That wouldn't work well in e.g. some chinese markets, where the vendors sell to touristy looking people for 5x or 10x the reasonable price.
So, they ask for $200, you make an initial offer of $150, they refuse, you leave, then come back and make an offer of $120. They accept it and you think you've won -- but they might have gone down to $50 too...
How this other guy was so bad that it made him look smart? Wow, head scratcher. Maybe he thought "Now HERE is a good negotiator, after all my BS he raises the price". Haha.
I have noticed their prices are consistently lower than the asking price at high touch dealerships. Especially when you remove hidden feels like "Doc fee" .
I will likely buy from a place with a fair advertised price sooner than walking in at an advertised price of 125% aiming to negotiate it down to 95%.
That's why you call them while you've got something else to do. Put them on speaker while playing a computer game, doing the laundry, or whatever else you'd prefer to be doing, as long as it's something that's easy to pause as soon as they pick up the phone.
Or better yet: do business with the company with the most responsive customer service.
This is sadly true of human relationships as well. I've seen it phrased as "the person who cares the least in a relationship has the most power". If you are madly in love with your partner but they are slightly cooler on you, they are in a stronger position because they are more willing to risk or even break the relationship to get what they want. If you're a very clean person but your roommate is a slob, you're screwed because they're just fine with a level of mess that will quickly drive you nuts.
IMO the treatment of such power speaks volumes of a persons character and would either attract or disgust me ...
This is a psychological ploy, and it doesn't even have to be all that meaningful of an item. At trade shows, it could be yet another novelty pen, an uninflated balloon with an outdated industry joke printed on it, a sticker you'll never stick, or whatever -- something they gave you, and that you will carry around. They don't give out t-shirts or cheap raffle tickets for neon pink Teslas just because they suspect you need one. They're triggering your brain into wanting to give them something in return - your time, your money, your resources. Well, inevitably it's always to eventually sell you whatever their product is, to avoid returns, and get/keep you on board.
A coupon is only one step outward from there. With a coupon, you actively "clip" it or whatever, keep it aside, carry it to the store and then cash it in. Basically a coupon is lame schwag with a hint of psychological manipulation.
If they simply docked the price by 15 cents, nobody would care and the item would probably only sell at normal volume. But on coupons, your brain has been actively trying to pay them back for the honour of having that coupon. Notice, the store honours or redeems them, but only if you hurry and do it before the deadline. You always feel like you're holding up the line and inconveniencing everyone all around for the honour of using them, yet they happily abide you. Because that was the intent all along.
Yes, I'm a couch psychologist. But on this, I don't think I'm very far off the mark.
I think the fixes for this are largely going to be cultural. For example something that could help is everyone having more pride and simply refusing to jump through pointless hoops for a discount (even if it is technically worth their time).
Ideally, you'd use a functional captcha, but even without, it seems it would be as useful to society as most current price discrimination techniques.
I'd imagine people would be much more likely to make a purchase if they have already invested 20 minutes solving captchas to save a few bucks.
These customers are not price sensitive. So you do not want to give them the best deal. Instead the profit maximizing technique is to find customer who won’t pay your “reasonable price” but will pay some smaller amount. You make them jump through hoops so you don’t cannibalize your “reasonable customer” sales.
When done right every customer is paying what they consider “reasonable”. For some that is more money than others.
It was strange. Major sportswear brands make the items I want. I have the money. I'm willing to pay, frankly, much more than the product is worth for most people. But the issue seems to be, somehow, retailers do not stock enough of the kinds of things I want that I could actually buy them.
IOW, the maths of supply and demand seems to be a bit more complicated than one might expect.
The scarcity of the coupon diminishes the discount and wastes real people's lives on triviality.
I'd rather maximize profit by delivering more to my customers, not by extracting more for the same.
When people look at capitalism as a competitive system between multiple businesses, they're looking at an incomplete, broken system. Capitalism should be seen as a competitive system between (at least) businesses and consumers.
Open Source is one way that consumers are able to place competitive pressure on the software industry without starting their own businesses. Open Source products are available for free, often developed at a loss, and they subvert the expectation that software features have to be profitable to exist. Businesses are forced to compete with free, which forces them to implement consumer-friendly features that wouldn't otherwise be profitable.
Adblocking is another important force dictating online content rules -- it allows customers to directly reject a business model, by subverting the idea that profitable content can be forcibly bundled with unprofitable content. Then you have more grey-market pressures like piracy, which forces companies to compete on delivery mechanisms and not just on content.
This kind of subversion helps commoditize content, making it difficult for industries to monetize products that they'd otherwise tightly control. Industries describe this as a bad thing -- if a business model isn't profitable and if creators aren't making money, then something's wrong. But this is consumers doing what they're supposed to do. It is good for consumers to compete by circumventing business models.
In this case, what we'd like to see is consumers colluding to share coupons and deals, so everyone can get the best price. We want to force sellers to negotiate with consumers as a single group, not with each individual person. To a certain extent, we are seeing this, which is why you see certain businesses getting more aggressive about hiding their charges and making coupons harder to share.
Coupons and similar time-wasters optimize the revenue that you get from that 90%.
Nothing that a law that every businesses should have a one click cancel process you can easily and immediately use when you want to, can't fix...
Another example is the idea that some people get a better price because they jumped through arbitrary and non-cost affecting hoops. Things like coupon codes or buying on an arbitrary sale day.
The best customer is one that comes in and says "I want this item, I will pay a reasonable price right now and walk out a happy customer"... Instead we give the best price to those who waste sales people's time with negotiations and give the worst prices to those who dont first put in a bunch of work extract the information about the right price. We are increasing the total cost of our products by making the purchase filled with uncertainty (am I getting a good price?) and external costs (I searched 2 hours for a $5 coupon) .
I would propose this. If you're going to give a customer $5 off then give them all $5 off. If you cant give them all $5 off, then give none (maybe give them all $1 off?).