The most obvious added value is faster delivery: ship today instead of in X days/weeks when the auction ends.
It also has weird value if you for some reason believe the BIN price is undervaluing the item, i.e. you can short-circuit the auction before anyone else realises.
> makes the whole system seem much more sensible
But doesn't it apply there too? Price discrimination has many forms, but a less pretty way of describing that one is the retailer creates non-monetary external costs and mixes them into offers, to discourage customers from simply switching to offers where less money changes hands.
Imagine instead of a "spend time clipping coupons rather than reading with your kids" proof-of-work, the retailer creates an offer which requires someone to degrade themselves, to crawl on the floor and beg, to obtain a low price. This happily permits the retailer to extend affordable service to the desperate, without more profitable customers thinking it worth switching offers! So... yay?
Issues include at least some created work functions not having inherent societal value (coupon clipping is perhaps more like bitcoin factorization than like ai-training captchas). And that created costs, and simply the customer categorization they are but one way to obtain, can have negative impacts on lives and society.
It seems economics conversations are often more explicit about value creation and flow, but less transparent about the creation of "negative value", where it ends up, and its effects. There's more involved with an avocado coupon than merely a pair of price discriminated avocado sales.
Assuming 1:1 $2:$4 sales, say the cost is $1. They make $4 if they sell w/ coupon or not. The coupon chasing customer is a lower value customer because it actually takes some overhead to make coupons and to constantly convince them to be a customer. Whereas you can price at $3 and look like a champ compared to your $2 (secret coupon) /$4 (advertised price) competitors...
But who thinks you look like a champ?
To Person A (the person who won't pay more than $2), they won't be a customer because you've outpriced them. To Person B (the shopper who doesn't care if they pay $3 vs. $4) you look exactly the same, because they probably put the Avocado in their cart without even checking the price.
Not only is the coupon strategy twice as profitable for you, more customers are walking out of your store paying a price they were happy with, so you've likely got higher consumer satisfaction.
Hence why price discrimination is somewhat win-win.
In other words...
Person A: Price sensitive shopper who won't pay more than $2.00 for an Avocado under any circumstance.
Person B: Convenience sensitive shopper who will pay up to $4 for an Avocado.
The grocery store can price using one of two methods... 1) offering the same price to all shoppers, or 2) offering a higher price to most shoppers so that they can offer a lower price to price sensitive shoppers (via coupons, arbitrary sale dates, etc).
With method #1, the grocery store can only sell Avocados to Person B because their prices are permanently higher than Person A is willing to pay. But with method #2, the grocery store can sell to both people because they've created a situation where a less price sensitive person subsidizes the cost of the product purchased by another more price sensitive person. The grocery store makes more money with method #2 in this example (at least hypothetically).
I think the key is realizing that people value things differently. Some people don't look at prices when they shop. Some do. Some people only shop when they think they're saving money, some don't care. Some people value convenience + time more than price, some are the reverse.
Obviously this example doesn't really apply to the first part of your comment about "Grief economy", just the 2nd part about coupons + pricing.