News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Edward Snowden in His Own Words: Why I Became a Whistle-B... by cm2187 on Monday September 23, 2019 @04:25AM (#21046948)
I am a big Snowden supporter but I wouldn’t go as far as “beyond reproach”. A whistle blower is seeing wrongdoing, and reporting it. What he did instead is grab all the files he could get hold of, send them to journalists and tell them “I know there is wrongdoing there, find it among all this legitimately secret stuff that should have never left the NSA”. You can see why the NSA would find the approach more than cavalier.

I think given how it affected the public debate, he should certainly be given leniency if not pardon. But that is not to say he did nothing wrong.

Re:Edward Snowden in His Own Words: Why I Became a Whistle-B... by otalp on Monday September 23, 2019 @04:32AM (#21046978)
Snowden's trigger was seeing the Director of National Intelligence, James Clapper, lie under oath about mass surveillance to Congress when specifically asked about blind data collection.

When the head of the organisation commits federal crimes without reproach(he was not prosecuted after the details were revealed), who are you supposed to report to except the public?

Re:Edward Snowden in His Own Words: Why I Became a Whistle-B... by GVIrish on Monday September 23, 2019 @08:45AM (#21048348)
And Snowden was stealing files months before that happened. Maybe Snowden was on the fence about leaking and Clapper's lie pushed him over the edge. Or maybe it was what convinced him he was right.

But he had already been taking documents by the time Clapper got in front of Congress according to the unclassified house intelligence report on Snowden.

Re:Edward Snowden in His Own Words: Why I Became a Whistle-B... by ganoushoreilly on Monday September 23, 2019 @10:33AM (#21049253)
He'd also been denied some lateral movement on teams / projects from what i've heard. I think it's easy to reframe all his actions into hero worship but we have to acknowledge that his original motivations may not have been the end results we see today.
Re:Edward Snowden in His Own Words: Why I Became a Whistle-B... by cm2187 on Monday September 23, 2019 @04:36AM (#21047000)
I am not arguing against reporting wrongdoing, I am arguing against leaking secret files that have nothing to do with these wrongdoings.
Re:Edward Snowden in His Own Words: Why I Became a Whistle-B... by mmrezaie on Monday September 23, 2019 @05:24AM (#21047245)
The claim is so big that I think without those files he would have looked and treated as just another conspiracy theorist.
Re:Edward Snowden in His Own Words: Why I Became a Whistle-B... by spindoctor on Monday September 23, 2019 @06:09AM (#21047438)
So laws exist, but people don't always adhere to the law for reasons like ignorance and malicious intent. There are also laws which are bad laws & regulation, easily exploitable by clever people, financially lucrative in some cases.

The intelligence services have a difficult task, they need to be on top of their game so they need to know everything and try to prevent problems snowballing unless its not particularly harmful and could be quite educational for future improvement. You have a blank sheet of paper, what would you do to maintain or reduce harm to society?

I say this as someone who has met Andrew Parker, Stella Rimmington and Jonathon Evans and is wise to their ways but not someone who has signed the official secrets but has arguably an "autistic" interest in secrecy and quantifying all walks of life.

Re:Edward Snowden in His Own Words: Why I Became a Whistle-B... by danShumway on Monday September 23, 2019 @08:06AM (#21048071)
> but has arguably an "autistic" interest

A) Please don't use autism as a slur, and

B) Please don't imply that if someone cares about privacy, it's because their brain works differently. Hold yourself to a higher standard of argument.

Re:Edward Snowden in His Own Words: Why I Became a Whistle-B... by TeMPOraL on Monday September 23, 2019 @08:38AM (#21048304)
I don't think he meant this as a slur. As I parse the sentence, I see a high probability that he meant to use the word "autistic" on himself.
Re:Edward Snowden in His Own Words: Why I Became a Whistle-B... by saiya-jin on Monday September 23, 2019 @07:12AM (#21047736)
Ah man, those poor folks at 3-letter agencies screwing rest of the world and their own citizens. Of course it would be better for them to know everything, have everything, exploit everybody and so on.

That's not how modern democratic society can and should work though

Re:Edward Snowden in His Own Words: Why I Became a Whistle-B... by raxxorrax on Monday September 23, 2019 @05:57AM (#21047392)
That is what I would call a cheap deflection.
Re:Edward Snowden in His Own Words: Why I Became a Whistle-B... by mieseratte on Monday September 23, 2019 @10:12AM (#21049091)
I call it duty of care. If you're exposing X, and release files of unrelated Y you screwed up to a degree.
Re:Edward Snowden in His Own Words: Why I Became a Whistle-B... by raxxorrax on Monday September 23, 2019 @11:49AM (#21050011)
Without a further examination, I don't think they are unrelated.
Re:Edward Snowden in His Own Words: Why I Became a Whistle-B... by DoctorOetker on Monday September 23, 2019 @05:48PM (#21054109)
if the leaked files prove the very same wrongdoing, ... then it has everything to do with this wrongdoing
Re:Edward Snowden in His Own Words: Why I Became a Whistle-B... by raxxorrax on Monday September 23, 2019 @05:55AM (#21047379)
I would say beyond reproach is apt since the misbehavior lies with the agencies and there was no channel to prevent the crimes in question.

The punishment of Snwoden cannot be determined as long as there is no consequence and assesment for the misbehavior of agencies. You cannot determine whether it was justified to leak the info if the crimes committed were not investigated. It is a basic protection allegation to focus the discussion on the misbehavior of Snowden.

This is the same in every case government abuse. Don't defend Snowden, accuse the agencies in question instead. Because that is the topic. The defense will build itself. Other approaches will fail as they did so often before. It doesn't matter if justified or not. So the question about leniency is the wrong one.

Re:Edward Snowden in His Own Words: Why I Became a Whistle-B... by brbrodude on Monday September 23, 2019 @10:00AM (#21048992)
What sucks is that the 'wrong' of small people are always so easily seem and easy to point the finger however small it is, the wrong done by actual power holders, which will impact innumerable people, which lays ground for systemic abuse, catastrophic failure(e.g.: Nassim Taleb's "ruin problems") etc are always too much to grasp and get proportionally much less attention.

In Brazil what we now have I can't describe another way if not societal insanity, all the real problems are probably "too much", too complex, people have decided to stop facing them and decided regressing to fetish, cliches, downright modern superstitions instead. Some weeks ago an Avengers comic with a gay kiss panel generated more commotion than a 8 year old shot by police(which in itself would be a sign of the obvious much bigger systemic problems we're not properly dealing with. We're all fucked.

Re:Edward Snowden in His Own Words: Why I Became a Whistle-B... by goatinaboat on Monday September 23, 2019 @08:21AM (#21048195)
What he did instead is grab all the files he could get hold of

This is addressed in the book.

Re:Edward Snowden in His Own Words: Why I Became a Whistle-B... by emilsedgh on Monday September 23, 2019 @04:28AM (#21046961)
How else would you handle it?
Re:Edward Snowden in His Own Words: Why I Became a Whistle-B... by cm2187 on Monday September 23, 2019 @04:35AM (#21046992)
Only leak the files that are relevant.
Re:Edward Snowden in His Own Words: Why I Became a Whistle-B... by emilsedgh on Monday September 23, 2019 @05:56AM (#21047387)
By releasing it to journalists he:

* Removed the target from his back. At this point, all his value is "to be made of an example" not "a former operative with incredibly sensitive information, potentially worth neutralizing"

* Recused himself from being a political player like Assange wanted to be.

Also, who says he is a good judge to make the right call for each document?

Journalists can do a far far better job of responsibly handling the material, with enough time, resources and expertise to investigate the material, even get in touch with the government, etc.

Doing it personally would've been incredibly irresponsible and actually a power-play for personal gain not whistle-blowing for the better.

Re:Edward Snowden in His Own Words: Why I Became a Whistle-B... by GVIrish on Monday September 23, 2019 @08:52AM (#21048403)
Thing is, that by stealing and releasing documents he did not read (by his own admission) he could not have known what collateral damage he would've done to US and allied intelligence capabilities.

One might argue that any damage to intelligence interests is superceded by the public's interests in learning about abuses, but had he made a more targeted leak collateral damage might not have been an issue.

Trusting journalists to do the job is a cop out. He took the action of taking the documents, then foisted responsibility on someone else. And make no mistake, intelligence services spy on journalists and have compromised journalists. Snowden had no way of knowing whether other intelligence agencies could get to what he gave the various media outlets. Even some carelessness on their part could have revealed secrets to others.

Re:Edward Snowden in His Own Words: Why I Became a Whistle-B... by emilsedgh on Monday September 23, 2019 @02:49PM (#21052177)
I actually believe he read them all personally. It's just that he didn't make the judgement call to decide which one to release.

It was Chelsea Manning who a did dump without reading them first.

Re:Edward Snowden in His Own Words: Why I Became a Whistle-B... by GVIrish on Monday September 23, 2019 @03:08PM (#21052411)
Check out Snowden's inteview with John Oliver. Snowden outright admitted he hadn't read all the documents. He said he was 'familiar' with them.
Re:Edward Snowden in His Own Words: Why I Became a Whistle-B... by cm2187 on Monday September 23, 2019 @06:18AM (#21047479)
If he is not a good judge for what document supports wrong doing, then he is not a whistle blower in the first place. And I am not suggesting he is not. I have no doubt that he knew what a compromising document looked like.
Re:Edward Snowden in His Own Words: Why I Became a Whistle-B... by pepesza on Monday September 23, 2019 @04:50AM (#21047075)
Technically unfeasible considering how much time he had to go through those docs (likely - very little).
Re:Edward Snowden in His Own Words: Why I Became a Whistle-B... by lern_too_spel on Monday September 23, 2019 @12:04PM (#21050154)
He had been collecting the documents for months even before the incident that he says prompted him to blow the whistle. He knew that detailed lists of Chinese targets were not needed to blow the whistle on phone metadata collection, but he grabbed those lists anyway and immediately showed them to the SCMP.
Re:Edward Snowden in His Own Words: Why I Became a Whistle-B... by nullc on Monday September 23, 2019 @06:28AM (#21047515)
I think you miss how mind-numbingly boring all this stuff is. The evil is in the overarching character of the programs and infrastructure -- not the minutia. But without seeing the minutia you cannot see the program.

Imagine that the year is 1942 and someone leaks you a stack of bookkeeping records from some german labor camp in poland. In it, the records account for gassing prisoners by the truckload, but to your eyes it's all just just the cryptic numbers and administrative filler of any complex bureaucracy. To make any sense of it, you need many layers back of the surrounding documentation-- not just to establish what you're looking at, but to establish what you're not looking at. Communication that shows that the data is real, not an exercise, that the prisoners are being killed rather than that the accounting is just covering deaths from natural causes, that it's really a big intentional program sponsored from on-high and not just a fluke where a local administrator or two went nuts.

Without a wealth of supporting material it would be easy to dismiss Snowden's reports as "sure well, there was some overreach here and there. It wasn't officially sanctioned and the relevant parties have been sacked, James Clapper had no idea and did not perjure himself and we haven't been systematically lying to the public for a decade." In a world where the NSA was accountable to the public, Snowden would only have to reveal enough to force them to account and disclose and continued inquiry would unearth the rest. But we do not live in that world: The NSA's actions are not open to public inquiry. One shot is all we got for any real transparency into the mass surveillance apparatus. Consider the byzantine dismissals that Jewel v. NSA experienced. ( https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2019/04/judge-dodges-legality-... )

It seemed pretty obvious to me that Snowden purposefully obfuscated what documents he took by accessing everything-- a fact you seem to have exploited in a number of posts to exaggerate the scope of the documents he took, according to our best understanding of his actions per the journalists he worked with-- in order to create a situation where the administration's ability to tell additional lies to cover up the situation would be limited by the risk that somewhere in the stash Snowden had a document which blew the latest lie apart.

For another example: There is an absurd number of patents filed on most of the technical tools being used for the mass surveillance on the internet-- and their feature sets often end up leaked in product documentation and internet standards. They're not even particularly well hidden, some with co-authors who's linked in pages brag about their TS/SCI and work in intelligence... Yet, pre-snowden, people pointing to this wealth of details even combined with first hand accounts of how it was deployed, were just treated like kooks. Without the ability to open a real inquiry it isn't enough to prove that something suspicious is up, the proof must be utterly overwhelming to have a meaningful effect.

Re:Edward Snowden in His Own Words: Why I Became a Whistle-B... by cm2187 on Monday September 23, 2019 @06:31AM (#21047528)
The powerpoint decks that were published were pretty self explanatory and graphical. Journalists would not have been able to make any sense of a bunch of log files anyway.
Re:Edward Snowden in His Own Words: Why I Became a Whistle-B... by vidarh on Monday September 23, 2019 @07:34AM (#21047859)
And despite that we've seen multiple levels of deflection and outright lies even with the level of details provided.

Norwegian newspapers backtracked and apologised for writing articles exposing Norwegian participation in illegal metadata monitoring, arguing that the monitoring that for all of the other parties involved was about domestic monitoring in Norway's case for some reason was about Afghanistan.

Had it not been for the amount of surrounding context, the lies would have been believable. Even then it took the then head of military security to step up and make claims about operational issues in military security that they never talk about, to draw attention away from the vague denials of the police security service.

But the sheer amount of data, coupled with the revelation that the US itself captured full recordings of the same conversations that Norwegian surveillance supposedly captured valuable metadata about made it stand out as a ludicrous cover-up.

And still the newspapers did not dare challenge it even with all the extra details.

As it stands, Snowden released too little - even with all the material he did provide, it was still something that proved possible to sufficiently deflect from that it had shockingly little impact.

Re:Edward Snowden in His Own Words: Why I Became a Whistle-B... by nullc on Monday September 23, 2019 @06:42AM (#21047593)
I think we have a test case for your hypothesis. The snowden disclosures started with a single court order and then the prism slide deck. Go look at the initial redirections and denials about the first prism slides for a pretty good taste of where things would have stopped if that was all he put out: https://www.google.com/search?q=prism+slides+denial
Re:Edward Snowden in His Own Words: Why I Became a Whistle-B... by lern_too_spel on Monday September 23, 2019 @12:05PM (#21050171)
Snowden very clearly did not understand the PRISM slides due to technical illiteracy, and the NY Times and subsequent reporters got the story right.
Re:Edward Snowden in His Own Words: Why I Became a Whistle-B... by empath75 on Monday September 23, 2019 @10:34AM (#21049255)
Nobody is beyond reproach and anybody that is going to blow the whistle on something is almost always going to have an ulterior motive. That doesn’t mean we should ignore them, though.