Even if they turn out to be the criminally incompetent party in this relationship, I feel kind of bad for the contractors. They're facing felony charges for making what was clearly a mistake. I can't imagine they're consistently this incompetent - surely one of their previous clients would have noticed if they were physically broken into and didn't anticipate it. So either they've never done this before, or they messed up their contract.
I've seen plenty of similarly boneheaded, incompetent things in Big Tech (losing massive amounts of data, getting systematically defrauded in pretty stupid ways, etc) that resulted in getting fired at worst and a reprimand at best, so I feel kind of bad that these guys face felonies for being bad at their job.
If the company these two were working for had a "plan" much like building documents, or a scope of work document/contract then there should be no reason for these guys to get in trouble as physical penetration testing would be listed.
I see two possibilities.
1) Company did not have a good scope of work, which at the end of it all this should fall on them and not the employees in charge of performing their work. These guys should be let go, compensation to them paid from the employer for their error, and said employer has to pay everything, including fees and having their reputation tarnished.
2) There was bad miscommunication. There was physical penetration listed in the scope of work, however the police were not informed and acted as they would with anyone breaking into a courthouse. This would then fall on the department who hired them, which should pay the employees for their time/trauma and make an apology exonerating the company who was hired to pen test.
A mistake or incompetence is no excuse for breaking the law. This was a courthouse. There is either CYA in writing they can request in discovery for that lawsuit or as evidence against the charges they face to demonstrate to a jury that they should be innocent or that an experienced prosecutor will see then look to drop charges.
But unless the charges are dropped, the jury favors the contractors, or the judge halts proceeding until a determination can be made, they may be SOL on the charges.
Caveat emptor
These folks do this stuff for their livelihood. They test contractor, state, and fed systems at all scopes and levels.
And if 2 broke in (yes, you work in teams ABSOLUTELY onprem), they had the contract explicitly allowing physical penetration ON THEIR BODY. That contract is the difference between felony trespass and 100% legal.
I would LOVE to be a fly on the wall and watching the conversation between State IT and the public safety community there, and especially with the AG, who will have to release them.
No way coalfire would embarrass a client if they can avoid it.
I feel bad for the contractors who now have arrest records. They are the victims here.
Exactly. We won't hear of it. They do work all across the US in the state and federal space. It's too lucrative to give up to shame them into submission publicly. Privately, sure.
> I feel bad for the contractors who now have arrest records. They are the victims here.
Well, they've been arrested. So their clearances have been yanked already, as per standard for Confidential/TS/SCI. Unless they can get complete restoration, including expungement of the arrest, and admission of unlawful arrest, they're done in federal/state infosec.
https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2019/09/check...
That said, yes, Coalfire is large enough and old enough that I would be very surprised if they made such a mistake - but I still think it's quite possible. Consider that such an established firm would also be absolutely expected to coordinate this kind of testing with the PD beforehand - a blind test of a PD's response on a contract with another agency of the state government is something I have never heard of before and raises huge concerns for personal safety and taxpayer expense. I would consider Coalfire to also be extremely irresponsible for knowingly entering such a situation.
"I didn't mean to break in" holds no ground in court if they actually were breaking in.
Fun fact, Mary's son Ollie works for Nate Silver.
Without the contract and/or other agreements it isn't clear who's at fault here, the pentesting firm involved may very well have been an incompetent one that exceeded their SOW or did not even produce one to be agreed on--and I tend to suspect that this is the case, because physical intrusion testing will almost always include measures to prevent the police being called or make them aware of the test due to both the expense of an intentional false alarm call and the risk involved in triggering a law enforcement response.