News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Earth to warm more quickly, new climate models show (By 2... by rekabis on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @02:20PM (#20998435)
And the really scary thing is that anything above +8℃ has a very real chance of flipping the planet into a Venus Scenario. Recent work has shown that the Earth sits at the very inner edge of the solar system’s habitable zone. As the sun has aged across billions of years and burned through its fuel, it has heated up and moved the zone outward. As such, the planet could have had higher greenhouse gas levels in the past with life still surviving, but it cannot have such levels now without life dying and the planet becoming a second Venus. At +8℃, equatorial cloud cover becomes impossible to generate, and the amount of oceanic heating accelerates. Methyl Hydrates begin boiling off everywhere, and it becomes too hot to live between the 60th parallels - humanity (or what’s left of it) must pack itself around the poles to survive. At some point, the amount of greenhouse gas creation exceeds the ability of life to counteract said gases, and things heat up until all life on the planet dies.
Re:Earth to warm more quickly, new climate models show (By 2... by spodek on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @03:51PM (#20999345)
The scariest thing to me is that people think their actions won't make a difference.

I was speaking to an organization about reducing its flying. In the spring they wouldn't consider it. One 16-year-old girl, Greta Thunberg, sailing across the Atlantic put the initiative on the table.

She didn't plan to influence that organization but she did.

We all have that potential.

I've given one TEDx talk on environmental leadership http://joshuaspodek.com/my-tedx-talk-is-online-find-your-del... with a second in a few weeks https://www.tedxwaltham.com/tedxwaltham-2019. My podcast http://joshuaspodek.com/podcast is creating role models among globally renowned people.

I've become somewhat of a role model -- in my fourth year of not flying, I haven't filled a load of trash in over a year, I pick up litter every day -- and people write me to tell me they're doing it, as are their friends.

These results aren't enough, and some disasters will happen, but each person's actions contribute, including yours -- mostly by leading others to contribute too.

Re:Earth to warm more quickly, new climate models show (By 2... by Richard_East on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @12:23AM (#21002367)
Re:Earth to warm more quickly, new climate models show (By 2... by narratives on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @12:36PM (#20997186)
Curious if anyone here has evaluated any of these models? I’ve done a cursory search and haven’t found a source to play with. I’m curious to know what variables were included, what variables were excluded, how the future is being predicted, and to what degree the creators any of these models have been accurate in predicting the future previously.

Does anyone have a good explanation as to why it’s prudent to attempt to predict anything about anything 80 years in the future?

Also curious if there is evidence of predicting the future in any field. If so, I’m wondering what the accuracy rate is one month out, one year out, five years out, etc.

I’ve done some modeling with sales data, trying to predict demand in a given market based on a series of variables. The issue is how much weight to put on each variable. With lots of market research and historical data, we were able to get decent estimates a couple of months in the future. Beyond that? It was complete speculation. Especially if we missed an important variable, which is common, since its impossible to know what variables will (and won’t) be relevant in the future.

I imagine climate modeling is more complex than my sales models, meaning more variables that were included, more variables that were excluded (especially the ones that are unknown unknowns), and a much larger margin for error (especially as time increases).

I raise this as I haven’t seen any push back from the HN community on articles like this. Not sure if I’m missing something, if it’s political bias, or a fear of ostracized for questioning these reports. Either way, I’d be fascinated to see some deeper analysis on the topic from the minds on this forum.

Have humans ever created a complex model that has enabled us to predict the future with any degree of accuracy? If so, how far into the future and with what degree of accuracy? If not, what is the purpose of a model extrapolated out to 2100?

Trying to imagine when technology will reach X milestone (AGI, for example) reminds me that it’s probably wise to be less sure of our predictions. The last US presidential election reminded me of this too.

Re:Earth to warm more quickly, new climate models show (By 2... by makerofspoons on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @12:41PM (#20997230)
The DOE Energy Exascale Earth System Model is on GitHub: https://github.com/E3SM-Project/E3SM

Here is some analysis of how the predictions made by some climate models have done: https://www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-how-well-have-climate-m...

They have done a remarkable job since the 1970s.

Re:Earth to warm more quickly, new climate models show (By 2... by slowhand09 on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @01:43PM (#20997978)
Unpopular opinion warning: Not an expert here but I worked on NASA's "Mission to Planet Earth" program for a few years. Cherry-picking of models that produce results that meet the current agenda is not uncommon. Just as researchers have a (deserved IMHO) reputation for publishing data that concurs with their topics...
Re:Earth to warm more quickly, new climate models show (By 2... by slowhand09 on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @04:20PM (#20999635)
https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal... [...]" found 64% of surveyed researchers reported they had at least once failed to report results because they were not statistically significant (cherry picking); 42% had collected more data after inspecting whether results were statistically significant (a form of p hacking) and 51% had reported an unexpected finding as though it had been hypothesised from the start (HARKing)."

https://www.env-econ.net/2017/07/cherry-picking-results.html

https://ori.hhs.gov/videos/case-study-list/3037

https://www.pnas.org/content/pnas/early/2018/03/08/171075511...

Re:Earth to warm more quickly, new climate models show (By 2... by tasty_freeze on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @01:28PM (#20997788)
Where to start?

Why attempt to predict future conditions decades out? We do it all the time even though we absolutely know our predictions will not be exactly right. A prediction, even if imperfect, is useful if the prediction contains some bounds or probability estimates. People individually and society collectively makes best estimate judgements based on imperfect data every day, all day.

You've done some modeling of sales data, and the difficulty of predicting human whims leads you to suspect that modeling physics is an impossible and useless task? "I imagine climate modeling is more complex than my sales models" is an understatement of supreme folly. Even if you are a genius, the amount of work invested by tens of thousands of researchers spending their lives on this problem is incomparably more robust that some sales data modeling you tossed off.

> Have humans ever created a complex model that has enabled us to predict the future with any degree of accuracy?

Eclipses and solar positions can be computed to extreme accuracy centuries out. There is no closed solution -- it is all modeled and computed numerically.

The IPCC reports do get revised upward just about every release because the estimates are always conservative. Despite what is widely claimed by doubters, the IPCC reports have not been alarmist, and we can go back 30 years now.

Go back 40 years to Exxon's own modeling of climate change and considering the limited amount of data as compared to today, their estimates are not far off.

https://www.theguardian.com/environment/climate-consensus-97...

Re:Earth to warm more quickly, new climate models show (By 2... by Mattasher on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @12:55PM (#20997386)
Outside of astronomy, I don't think there's any history of reliable 80+ year scientific forecasts that predict specific changes to our world.
Re:Earth to warm more quickly, new climate models show (By 2... by torpfactory on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @01:36PM (#20997871)
There’s so much modeling that couldn’t even be done 80 years ago. Electronic computers were in their infancy, climate science was just beginning, weather satellites (hell any artificial satellite) had not yet been launched.

The inputs, the models themselves, and the main way to compute an output had mostly not been invented.

This is a fundamentally unfair comparison. If it couldn’t be computed analytically, it wasn't really possible to compute it 80 years ago. That absolutely doesn’t mean we should just ignore these predictions. Are we supposed to always wait some arbitrary time before listening to long term prediction?

Re:Earth to warm more quickly, new climate models show (By 2... by Mattasher on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @07:09PM (#21000993)
We've had mathematical models of change for over two thousand years. We have reliable, precise ones for astrological changes. As far as I know, we have none related to ecology or other complex systems that have proven capable of making long-term predictions.

I never said we should ignore any prediction. My calculation is purely Bayesian: how much prior trust should you place in a model (or class of models) with no long-term track record of success?

Re:Earth to warm more quickly, new climate models show (By 2... by makerofspoons on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @11:23AM (#20996245)
In a world with such high climate sensitivity, is there still a realistic pathway to an acceptable outcome? SSP1 2.6 was already highly optimistic and with these two new models even it doesn't keep us below 2 degrees.
Re:Earth to warm more quickly, new climate models show (By 2... by trevyn on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @11:52AM (#20996674)
Perhaps it’s time to start considering how to choose to live given unacceptable outcomes.
Re:Earth to warm more quickly, new climate models show (By 2... by consumer451 on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @12:14PM (#20996938)
> Perhaps it’s time to start considering how to choose to live given unacceptable outcomes.

Maybe I am misunderstanding your statement, but to which period of time are you referring to? Your lifetime? 3 generations?

The long now includes a non-zero probability of a collapse of atmospheric oxygen, and complete human extinction within ~3600 years. [0]

[0] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5138252/

Re:Earth to warm more quickly, new climate models show (By 2... by AbrahamParangi on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @12:59PM (#20997410)
I may be misunderstanding it but that paper reads as completely ridiculous.

We haven’t had a hypoxic atmosphere in the history of the earth since the evolution of photosynthesis (that’s a 2 Billion Year track record). The support for the plausibility of the author's hypothesis is that if you fit a parabola to the data over a certain time window, you get 100% decrease in atmospheric oxygen in a few thousand years??

That model is just nuts. By the same token it predicts we will have negative oxygen shortly thereafter.

Re:Earth to warm more quickly, new climate models show (By 2... by consumer451 on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @01:38PM (#20997897)
I would love to have someone convince me that this paper is utter rubbish, so I really appreciate your comment. I am also likely a bit annoying as I don't have a science background.

However, you said:

> We haven’t had a hypoxic atmosphere in the history of the earth since the evolution of photosynthesis (that’s a 2 Billion Year track record).

This research seems to disagree, doesn't it? [0]

> Climate change triggered by volcanic greenhouse gases is hypothesized to have caused the largest mass extinction in Earth’s history at the end of the Permian Period (~252 million years ago). Geochemical evidence provides strong support for rapid global warming and accompanying ocean oxygen (O2) loss, but a quantitative link among climate, species’ traits, and extinction is lacking. To test whether warming and O2 loss can mechanistically account for the marine mass extinction, we combined climate model simulations with an established ecophysiological framework to predict the biogeographic patterns and severity of extinction. Those predictions were confirmed by a spatially explicit analysis of the marine fossil record.

[0] https://science.sciencemag.org/content/362/6419/eaat1327

Re:Earth to warm more quickly, new climate models show (By 2... by gus_massa on Wednesday September 18, 2019 @10:37AM (#21005867)
In the first article, fitting that data with a parabola+trigonometric is a very big red flag. The error interval for the quadratic coefficient must be huge, but I can't find it.

It may be fit with a line+trigonometric to get some approximation for the next few years (10? 100?). With a line you get 50000 years to the 0 oxygen level, that is less alarmist than 3600 years.

Also, without a good model it's a bad idea to extend these projections too much. There are a lot of natural process that depend on the concentration of oxygen and will change. For example, under 15%-10% concentration of oxygen you can't burn wood so you solve the problem of forest fires https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Limiting_oxygen_concentration

Re:Earth to warm more quickly, new climate models show (By 2... by AbrahamParangi on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @07:12PM (#21001021)
See [0] for atmospheric oxygen levels over time. That dip from ~35% to ~15% atmospheric oxygen corresponds approximately to the permian extinction (~250 mya). My understanding is that there have been a number of oceanic hypoxic/anoxic events[1] in the history of the planet but that atmospheric oxygen levels have been relatively high since the oxygen holocaust[2].

[0]https://www.pnas.org/content/pnas/96/20/10955/F2.large.jpg

[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anoxic_event#Anoxic_events_in_...

[2]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Oxidation_Event

Re:Earth to warm more quickly, new climate models show (By 2... by Scarblac on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @11:52AM (#20996672)
Maybe only Peak Oil can save us. How much carbon is there? Surely we can't continue unabated indefinitely?
Re:Earth to warm more quickly, new climate models show (By 2... by Ancalagon on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @01:01PM (#20997447)
With new tech like Fracking, there's a lot of un-tapped resources still unfortunately :/
Re:Earth to warm more quickly, new climate models show (By 2... by consumer451 on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @01:47PM (#20998021)
Indeed. My intuition here is that climate change is an investment problem at this point. The technological solutions already exist.

How do we convince all investors to walk away from a nearly guaranteed and superb return?

This is the main problem which we currently face in my view.

Re:Earth to warm more quickly, new climate models show (By 2... by rmilejczz on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @02:04PM (#20998229)
By hampering the viability of non renewables via a steep carbon tax, read more here:

www.forbes.com/sites/howardgleckman/2018/10/10/bill-nordhaus-the-nobel-prize-climate-change-and-carbon-taxes/

The real barrier is making something like this policy imo

Re:Earth to warm more quickly, new climate models show (By 2... by Scarblac on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @06:05PM (#21000563)
Or just making them illegal outright.

But the whole world has to participate...

Re:Earth to warm more quickly, new climate models show (By 2... by slowhand09 on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @01:48PM (#20998037)
A Pinatubo, Laki, or Krakatau event can easily move the ground truth of climate change.