News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tourists Heeding Utah’s ‘Mighty 5’ Campaign Overpower Moab by prawn on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @03:56AM (#20992718)
I'm a reasonably well travelled Australian (30+ countries, 40ish US states) and think that Southern Utah has one of the best concentrations of natural attractions on the planet. I've visited a number of times and would love to visit at least yearly if I could. I can appreciate that locals detest being swamped, but should everyone have a chance to visit such unique features for themselves?

National parks in the US have incredible brand recognition and cachet and I imagine that this campaign is only part of the story. The big name parks across most of the country are swamped - Yellowstone, Yosemite, Rocky Mountain, etc.

I don't know that there's a brilliant solution short of virtual tourism. Raising prices deters anyone but the rich. Adding carparks just reduces the magic of the wild. Increasing awareness of the second-tier features or developing more is an option. Naturally, the crowded experience will push people to visit outside primetime or peak season.

Absolutely do not be deterred though. As the article suggests, avoid peak times for the best experience. Get up early. Stay late. You can sleep in at home. In Moab specifically, loads of people start later than they'd hoped or concentrate in particular places for sunset or return to the town for dinner. If you want a meal in town, make it lunch when the light is most stark and the park is packed. See Delicate Arch at sunrise instead of sunset, as one example. On this year's trip, we started Devils Garden at 6-7pm and came back in the dark with headlamps - had an amazing sunset and only saw a handful of people out there (I wouldn't recommend this to first-time visitors as the primitive trail can be adventurous to follow).

Outside of the big five, there are outstanding places nearby that are popular but not completely overrun. Byway 12 is superb, Buckskin Gulch is fantastic, the slot canyons near Escalante, Coyote Gulch, Goblin Valley, Horseshoe Canyon, Cedar Breaks, Snow Canyon State Park, Kodachrome Basin, etc. Even in the big parks, there are top-shelf experiences that most people don't see - hiking into Canyonlands' The Maze is one of the best things I've ever done, hiking Trans-Zion is full of premium scenery without huge crowds, Fiery Furnace in Arches sans-guide is good fun, at Bryce you can get some great early/late viewing without hordes just by skipping the two main viewpoints.

If you need help with an itinerary, ask away or my email is in my profile.

Re:Tourists Heeding Utah’s ‘Mighty 5’ Campaign Overpower Moab by codingdave on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @05:38AM (#20993269)
I live in Utah, and comments like this give me mixed feelings of "I love living here" and "Stop telling everyone else about the quiet places." Not that I really want to keep people away - the only way to fall in love with the outdoors is to spend time there.

But that is also why your comment of virtual tourism really strikes home. One of the reasons I enjoy getting out so much is that I've had health problems that means it isn't always possible to get out. Sharing the landscapes out here with other people who can't get out has always been an interest of mine. With VR technology moving steadily forward, maybe a Streetview-style experience of all these parks would be a timely project.

Re:Tourists Heeding Utah’s ‘Mighty 5’ Campaign Overpower Moab by prawn on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @07:11AM (#20993660)
I think it would need to be more engaging than Streetview to offer anything serious enough to lure people. That said, I've recently finished playing through the story of Red Dead Redemption 2 and the environments in that are both mesmerising and often based on real world places. Horizon Zero Dawn is similar and features a lot of iconic Utah scenery.

Given decent VR tech and maybe a climate-controlled room that could heat up, gust wind, etc, I can imagine spending time akin to meditation in a virtual camp setting. Come home and want to relax for an hour. Pick the setting, put on the goggles, sit back and take in the view, sounds, etc. Golden hour forever.

Re:Tourists Heeding Utah’s ‘Mighty 5’ Campaign Overpower Moab by arethuza on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @04:13AM (#20992827)
Why not have a lottery and give non-transferable tickets to US nationals and have a fixed number of tickets for non-US nationals that are charged for?

[NB I'm not from the US but have been to a few US national parks].

Re:Tourists Heeding Utah’s ‘Mighty 5’ Campaign Overpower Moab by prawn on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @04:25AM (#20992885)
There is a permit system for Half Dome in Yosemite that expanded after we climbed it, and one for Machu Picchu that came in after we hiked the Inca Trail. The Wave has had an infamously brutal one for a while, and I think Buckskin Gulch has a limit for overnighting. So it's already done in a few places. It can be frustrating though - I've tried for The Wave a few times and never been successful. Their limit seems low.

One thing worth doing is a shuttle system. Zion has one for peak months and as well as removing cars from the main canyon, you then have a captive audience which you can reach with messages about best practice in the wilderness though people ignore everything and feed animals anyway. Bryce has a shuttle too. Wouldn't surprise me if Arches was already planning one. That at least helps with the need for more and more parking.

Re:Tourists Heeding Utah’s ‘Mighty 5’ Campaign Overpower Moab by prawn on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @07:23AM (#20993717)
Another option is used in Arches. For Fiery Furnace, if you want to go in without a ranger-led guided tour, you need to pay $6 for a permit, and there are a maximum number issued. In addition, you need to watch an orientation video and then answer some basic questions about it. It's trivial for those who are interested but might limit the place getting flooded at least.
Re:Tourists Heeding Utah’s ‘Mighty 5’ Campaign Overpower Moab by rjtavares on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @04:19AM (#20992869)
This should be done more. I was absolutely bummed for not being able to the see Da Vinci's "The Last Supper", but in hindsight I understand and feel that is the way to deal with precious places.

At the time, you were required to book ahead, could only stay for 15 minutes, and the number os visitors was limited (so even in November you had to book weeks ahead).

Re:Tourists Heeding Utah’s ‘Mighty 5’ Campaign Overpower Moab by KineticLensman on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @07:40AM (#20993812)
The Tower of London which houses the Crown Jewels [0] has a conveyor belt / moving walkway that you have to stand on to see some of the exhibits. It thus controls access and limits the time you can spend in one of the rooms (I can't remember if it possible to get back to its start to go round again)

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crown_Jewels_of_the_United_Kin...

Re:Tourists Heeding Utah’s ‘Mighty 5’ Campaign Overpower Moab by prawn on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @09:27AM (#20994776)
Sorry to reply a third time, but the rangers of the story talk about a better distribution of visitors across the day. Half Dome permits started on weekends only and then adjusted from there. A permit system for hotspots between 10am and 3pm for example could manage the peak crowds but not prevent anyone seeing the highlights if they adjusted their schedule very slightly.

In some places, this could be done with paid parking at certain times of the day, perhaps besides those with disability permits.

Re:Tourists Heeding Utah’s ‘Mighty 5’ Campaign Overpower Moab by dsfyu404ed on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @08:05AM (#20993956)
The revenue is too sweet. Governments do not have the self control to pass up. If not initially there will eventually be a pay to play option for the wealthy. There will eventually be a funding squeeze and some administrator will get the bright idea to open up a pay to play system.

Where I live you can't take your own canoe/kayak on the state reservoirs because "invasive species" but you can take your motorboat (way more likely to transmit invasive species than a canoe) if you jump through all the regulatory hoops and then buy some special permits. The state will rent you a canoe for $20 though.

Re:Tourists Heeding Utah’s ‘Mighty 5’ Campaign Overpower Moab by gamblor956 on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @10:30AM (#20995537)
This is false if you're referring to CA. You can't take a water vessel, motorized or not, into reservoirs or lakes unless it's been washed/cleaned and inspected to be free of invasive and highly destructive clagga mussel.

Motorized boats tend to be cleaner than personal craft because most docks and marinas have dedicated facilities or equipment set aside for cleaning larger vessels.

Re:Tourists Heeding Utah’s ‘Mighty 5’ Campaign Overpower Moab by dsfyu404ed on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @10:47AM (#20995757)
I'm not talking about CA. I'm talking about a state where every body of water over a certain size has to have a public boat ramp and the vast majority of them have no facilities. This is not the yacht club with their complimentary hose for washing off your boat we're talking about. Human powered watercraft do not have inaccessible bilges and cooling systems to harbor invasive species making them much less of a risk of bringing new species with them to a particular body of water.
Re:Tourists Heeding Utah’s ‘Mighty 5’ Campaign Overpower Moab by gamblor956 on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @03:17PM (#20999035)
There's this thing called chlorine that's been around for a few decades, at least, which owners of motorized vessels can use to clean out inaccessible locations like bilge pumps and cooling systems.

It's actually more likely for personal watercraft to carry invasive species because they're less likely to be cleaned (even though they're easier to clean).

Inspections for invasive species have been a major issue for at least a decade, because nobody wants to repeat what happened in the Great Lakes, where invasive species nearly destroyed the lake ecology and its many fisheries.

Re:Tourists Heeding Utah’s ‘Mighty 5’ Campaign Overpower Moab by tonyedgecombe on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @05:50AM (#20993310)
Raising prices deters anyone but the rich.

I don't buy that argument, mainly because the poor aren't visiting these places in any numbers. They are too busy trying to put the next meal on their table.

Re:Tourists Heeding Utah’s ‘Mighty 5’ Campaign Overpower Moab by prawn on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @07:20AM (#20993703)
Which is why I didn't say "Raising prices deters the poor." I think reading it in good faith covers things and that my intent was clear? Really, it's not going to help encourage anyone that is price sensitive for whatever personal reason and would be quite easily criticised. I think if you are going to respect the environment, you should have every right to witness the best of our planet.
Re:Tourists Heeding Utah’s ‘Mighty 5’ Campaign Overpower Moab by tonyedgecombe on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @07:52AM (#20993875)
I think if you are going to respect the environment, you should have every right to witness the best of our planet.

Even if visiting that place destroys what you supposedly cherish?

Re:Tourists Heeding Utah’s ‘Mighty 5’ Campaign Overpower Moab by prawn on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @08:33AM (#20994191)
National parks are generally massive. It's possible to visit the most stunning parts with a light touch, and for the broader ecosystem to endure in other areas. I don't think they need to be the same place within a park - e.g., endangered bird atop Delicate Arch, or bears on Clouds Rest.

Obviously we can impact the park from a distance too, but I'd say "destroys" is overly strong language for the respectful traveller I'm discussing. I suspect we damage it almost as much whether we step into the park or not with everything else we do collectively. Certainly a lot of the iconic geological scenery will survive our personal influence.

Re:Tourists Heeding Utah’s ‘Mighty 5’ Campaign Overpower Moab by tonyedgecombe on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @08:45AM (#20994306)
National parks are generally massive.

I sometimes wonder if this is why America has such trouble with environmental issues. When your landscape is so vast it is hard to imagine human activity having an impact on it.

The trouble with the "respectful traveller" is that they are a minority, as we can see from the article linked at the top of this discussion.

Re:Tourists Heeding Utah’s ‘Mighty 5’ Campaign Overpower Moab by prawn on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @09:22AM (#20994726)
Everywhere has trouble with environmental issues. We're selfish. And respectful travellers are indeed a minority.

I actually think that there is a subset of Americans, more than many other countries, that across all age brackets have a great appreciation for the outdoors. In Australia, we have families going camping and grey nomads, but we don't have anything like quantities of college friends camping together that the US has. Makes me quite jealous. Most of our parks have nowhere near the prestige or modern cultural history (s'mores, log cabins, the romantic stone inns in Yellowstone, Yosemite, Zion, Grand Canyon, etc). We have damper and I don't know what else.

I've seen comments in other discussions about uncouth Chinese tourists en masse, and Chinese explaining that these are newly middle-class Chinese now with money to head abroad, but perhaps not the awareness to always do it politely. But I don't think it's unique to China. Almost anyone worldwide would've seen domestic groups playing music on their phones or portable speakers while hiking, etc. Others feeding chewing gum to squirrels. I don't know how you get through to these people, because they obviously don't care about signs and park brochures.

Re:Tourists Heeding Utah’s ‘Mighty 5’ Campaign Overpower Moab by mft_ on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @08:24AM (#20994085)
(Again reading the comment with good faith/will) presumably "if you are going to respect the environment" covers that aspect?
Re:Tourists Heeding Utah’s ‘Mighty 5’ Campaign Overpower Moab by someguydave on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @08:37AM (#20994230)
Nevertheless, there is an admission price that will restore visitor traffic to something more reasonable.
Re:Tourists Heeding Utah’s ‘Mighty 5’ Campaign Overpower Moab by Ensorceled on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @08:45AM (#20994310)
You should realize wealth is a continuum. Destitute, Poor, Lower Class, Lower Middle Class ...
Re:Tourists Heeding Utah’s ‘Mighty 5’ Campaign Overpower Moab by tonyedgecombe on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @10:38AM (#20995632)
Yes, I am aware of that.