News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by cjslep on Monday September 16, 2019 @04:07AM (#20982006)
Clearly a waste of time if he wasn't getting paid for it. Imagine all the other wasted efforts of time and money that other people would do if we as a society paid them well enough to have excess time and money to do these sorts of pointless non-entrepreneurial adventures. What if he put all this effort in and makes the world a better place for nothing?

(Heavy satire / sarcasm)

Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by JulianMorrison on Monday September 16, 2019 @04:38AM (#20982147)
Corollary: it's worth recognizing the number of hidden people who want to do this, but because of the way society has been set up to goad them into "paying work", can't.
Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by CalRobert on Monday September 16, 2019 @08:23AM (#20983325)
Our entire society is built to trap you in to working on things you don't care about to make other people rich.

You go to college, get a pile of debt, and now you've lost the freedom to do what you like with your time because you have to optimise for income.

Or you don't go to college, don't have debt, but can't afford a reasonable home because the collegiates voted to make it illegal to build new ones, and DEFINITELY don't want any home that isn't gigantic and doesn't have parking. No modest townhouse for you!

You decide to follow your dream and get a part time job so with the rest of your time you do a net good for the world, and you get sick. You lacked insurance. You survive, but have learned your lesson and know not to step out of line, especially since you now have huge debts.

Every aspect of our lives has become an exercising in maximising profit. And yet most don't seem to feel very wealthy. We run ourselves ragged for the sake of others. Taking as path that means earning less money and more time is considered foolish at best, irresponsible at worst.

And we're doing all this to help rip the lungs and heart of our planet apart to help a few lucky psychopaths get a brief hit on the hedonic treadmill before they die, just in time to miss the gen z'ers in a dead world cursing their name.

I think it might be better to start with nothing than with the massive negative equity many young people wind up with when starting life.

Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by bsenftner on Monday September 16, 2019 @08:37AM (#20983422)
For these reasons and more, an increasing number of people choose not to have kids. It feels unethical to bring them into this rat race.
Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by Double_a_92 on Monday September 16, 2019 @06:07AM (#20982567)
At least some part of your work say to be "paying"... Otherwise you probably wouldn't have food, shelter or other luxury that you might want.
Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by JulianMorrison on Monday September 16, 2019 @06:55AM (#20982814)
In my opinion, none of those things should be contingent on being paid. At least at a minimum level, it should be possible to eat nutritious food, have homely and comfortable shelter, fresh water, warmth, clothing, medical care, everything you need to survive and thrive, just because you're human and society is not barbaric.

Then when you work it would be because you want to expand beyond that minimum, or because it's a thing that you want to do, for personal reasons, to serve the community, etc.

Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by Faark on Monday September 16, 2019 @07:31AM (#20983015)
Thing is it can be very cheap to "waste" your time and become harder and harder to get out of. I'm kind of trying that at the moment.

I totally agree that society should make sure peoples basic needs are met, but don't see a reason why this should not involve trading in some of your time. So yeah, why not having to offer 20h/week to the gov to get all that? This kinda sets a minimum wage while offering everyone a way to fulfill their basic needs. What job/task the gov has/can find for you is another problem, but doesn't seem unsolvable to me.

Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by JulianMorrison on Monday September 16, 2019 @07:45AM (#20983089)
The reason not to do that is that (1) it risks creating a serf underclass, and (2) a big part of the point of this is to free up time for people to do things they want to do but are not yet profitable - like study, like art, and like starting a business that isn't able to pay a subsistence salary yet. Which is completely obviated by taking that time away.

It's also based in the paradigm of forcing people to do things rather than having faith in their willingness to contribute to the community.

Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by Faark on Monday September 16, 2019 @08:24AM (#20983342)
> having faith in their willingness to contribute to the community

I feel like my parents subscribe to this view, that this willingness comes naturally for us. It did not. Might have been different a few generations ago, but its easier than ever to live with barely any contact to a community to contribute to. So your paradigm would likely have to "drag along" an increasing number of people.

> free up time

I didn't go with 40 for a reason :) This number has to be adjusted depending on societies ability, just like a minimum wage.

> it risks creating a serf underclass

Valid concern, but probably already reality, just harder to classify and right now less done by the gov. UBI/needs provided would kind of do the same, I think. I also don't see keeping some trade aspect making class mobility harder than what we currently have right now.

Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by JulianMorrison on Monday September 16, 2019 @09:11AM (#20983636)
I think the primary reason people lose their willingness to contribute is living in a situation that is both "unending famine" (from their perspective, not GDP) and "rivalrous" as opposed to "cooperative". Such a situation engenders sharp elbows and hoarding. But it reverses itself soon enough when either the "famine" ends or when cooperation is rewarded rather than stepped upon.
Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by Double_a_92 on Monday September 16, 2019 @08:03AM (#20983201)
> At least at a minimum level, it should be possible to eat nutritious food, have homely and comfortable shelter, fresh water, warmth, clothing, medical care, everything you need to survive and thrive, just because you're human and society is not barbaric.

Where does this minimum level of comfort come from? Somebody has to do that minimal work, and on average everyone should do their share of "paid" work. (By paid I don't strictly mean exchange of currency, but producing value that everyone sees as valuable, i.e. food)

Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by cortic on Monday September 16, 2019 @09:24AM (#20983745)
It comes from the legacy of automation and technological advancement created by our ancestors and should be to everyones benefit.

Currently this flow of massive wealth is going into the pockets of people who need it the least and no one is asking where it is coming from.

Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by JulianMorrison on Monday September 16, 2019 @09:23AM (#20983740)
Right now, society's in a situation where an artificial number of "jobs" are created either by makework companies or by resisting automation of scutwork. If people are freed from the necessity to work useless jobs just to receive subsistence, it will suddenly become both economic and politic to reverse that.
Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by leftyted on Monday September 16, 2019 @09:33AM (#20983836)
> In my opinion, none of those things should be contingent on being paid. At least at a minimum level, it should be possible to eat nutritious food, have homely and comfortable shelter, fresh water, warmth, clothing, medical care, everything you need to survive and thrive, just because you're human and society is not barbaric.

Where does the food come from? Where does the shelter come from? Where does the heat and the clothes and the medical care come from? They come from other people's labor. Why would other people agree to labor in order to provide these things to you while you provide nothing in return?

Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by kmjg88nvf8 on Monday September 16, 2019 @05:17AM (#20982300)
Sadly, most people would just watch Netflix.
Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by madez on Monday September 16, 2019 @07:16AM (#20982934)
We are not used to be free. Economic restraints force us to do things we don't want to do instead of watching Netflix. So most don't understand what "just watching Netflix" means. If you set out to "just watch Netflix" as your main activity, you would very very quickly get fed up and depressed, and thus stop watching Netflix.

Those fortunate ones with enough wealth to have the option to just watch Netflix for a year and don't do much else, don't do that and are happy with it. And neither would the less fortunate once after an initial learning phase. Humans must learn to be free, but they can. We want to take part, show our contribution, feel proud. As soon as we have found a pleasant way to contribute, we do.

Yes, conditionless basic income would change work ethics. People who fill up supermarkets displays or serve food to unfriendly customers at unhealthy hours would maybe just stop going to work. I would be happy for them, and I hope it would happen today.

There is a lot of work that is needlessly tiring, badly paid, and in which you are badly treated, but people just stay in the status quo because they see no way out. Once there is a way out, the jobs will have to change, and that rapidly. That would be progress for society I still hope to see in my lifetime.

Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by tsmarsh on Monday September 16, 2019 @08:43AM (#20983455)
We have been free. We were free for millennia.

But... if you look at the most free animals in nature: cats, after domesticating humans and getting guaranteed safety, shelter and food. They have independently decided to sleep and murder their lives away. Their contributions to the art world via social media (a task they’ve mostly trained their humans to do) is probably the nost significant and vacuous the world has every seen. Their obsession with small mammal terminating is probably better for the biosphere.

Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by whamlastxmas on Monday September 16, 2019 @09:27AM (#20983763)
I have taken over a year off of work multiple times in my life and while I didn't do much that was productive with my time off, I was definitely unhappy with time wasting and lounging around all day. My motivation to eventually start working again would have assuredly been directed elsewhere if not for the pending need for income again eventually
Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by shkkmo on Monday September 16, 2019 @06:42AM (#20982741)
That is a pretty pesimistic presumption that AFAIK has no empirical evidence to back it up. Even without holding the threats of homelessness and starvation over people's heads, humans are highly status driven, competitive creatures. There is a lot of evidence that people will do massive amounts of work that has little to no material benefit, just for a bit of social status (or even for self satisfaction.) Otherwise, volunteerism, open source software and Indy Games couldn't be as successful as they are.

I don't doubt there are some people who would stay home and watch Netflix. I just suspect there are more people that are ground down by the daily grind and abandon their dreams.

Even if there are more unmotivated people than demotivated people, unmotivated people are low value anyway. People that lack self-motivation are never gonna be the most productive members of society so designing a system to extract work from them at the cost of wasting the time of more motivated individuals seems... backwards.

Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by Crinus on Monday September 16, 2019 @05:57AM (#20982524)
What is the problem with that?

Besides for most people to be able to watch Netflix, some people will need to make Netflix. If there aren't enough people to make Netflix, something else will be made but at the end of the day there is no way nobody will do anything - if nothing else, people will be bored and actively want to do something.

Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by chmod775 on Monday September 16, 2019 @06:31AM (#20982684)
There's nothing better than boredom for inspiration and motivation.
Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by dsfyu404ed on Monday September 16, 2019 @08:04AM (#20983207)
You seem to be under the assumption that the masses will find inspiration and motivation to do things you don't find disagreeable.

I'm emphatically for people having the resources to pursue whatever the heck the want (even if that's sitting around drinking beer) but I think that most of the UBI crowd is out of touch with how the people who will most benefit from UBI will use their newfound freedom. Covering poor people's housing and food expenses isn't going to magically make them want to spend their time acting upper middle class. You give people freedom and they will act how they want, not necessarily how you want. I'd still call that a win but many will not.

Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by chmod775 on Monday September 16, 2019 @09:55AM (#20984008)
> Covering poor people's housing and food expenses isn't going to magically make them want to spend their time acting upper middle class.

You seem to be under the assumption that the majority of "poor people" behave the way they are portrayed in "reality" TV shows or whatever you're consuming that makes you think this way.

In fact most are no different from the "upper middle class", except for the amount of money they can freely spend. Do you honestly believe they're somehow wired differently just because they're poor?

Watch less TV, interact more with actual people.

Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by dsfyu404ed on Monday September 16, 2019 @10:30AM (#20984370)
>You seem to be under the assumption that the majority of "poor people" behave the way they are portrayed in "reality" TV shows or whatever you're consuming that makes you think this way.

You seem to be making a lot of assumptions about my life experience and who I don't associate with.

>In fact most are no different from the "upper middle class", except for the amount of money they can freely spend. Do you honestly believe they're somehow wired differently just because they're poor?

Yes, people are very much the same on some level but it's pure lunacy to pretend that one's life experience does not have any effect on shaping a person's standards and preferences. If you give a poor person a good paycheck they will probably pick a few areas to indulge but they will not magically upscale their entire lives. Their standards and tastes will take quite some time (if ever) to adapt to the lack of economic scarcity. (Obviously I'm speaking in generalizations here and my statements are subject individual variance.)

You can leave the trailer park but the trailer park will never leave you.

>Watch less TV, interact more with actual people.

Since we're sinking to this level you should get out of your gated community and internet echo chambers.

Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by Crinus on Monday September 16, 2019 @08:16AM (#20983284)
FWIW i'd also call that a win... but perhaps i do not see what could possibly go wrong :-P
Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by kmjg88nvf8 on Monday September 16, 2019 @07:53PM (#20989716)
I have no problem with it, I just don't consider it a good argument for basic income.
Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by adrianN on Monday September 16, 2019 @08:10AM (#20983248)
When I take a few days of holiday I literally don't do anything but waste time. When I have longer breaks between work I start doing productive things after a period of decompressing. My normal job just sucks up all my productivity in a way that it becomes hard to even take out the trash.
Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by mac01021 on Monday September 16, 2019 @06:39AM (#20982728)
That would be _so_ much better for the environment
Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by rorykoehler on Monday September 16, 2019 @07:55AM (#20983154)
Does it matter? Even if only 1% of people used the time to do something constructive/beneficial to society and the environment that would still amount to over 70 million people worldwide. That could definitely move the needle away from the capitalist dystopia we have created.
Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by kmjg88nvf8 on Monday September 16, 2019 @07:52PM (#20989707)
We are not living in a capitalist dystopia. If you have an interesting thing you want to do but can't afford to do, head over to Kickstarter or Patreon and collect funding.

Thank capitalism later.

Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by rorykoehler on Tuesday September 17, 2019 @08:36PM (#21001448)
That is already dystopian not to mention people also use this to cover their medical bills. The gold fish doesn't know it's in a fish bowl.
Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by kmjg88nvf8 on Friday September 20, 2019 @04:49AM (#21024529)
How on earth is that dystopian?
Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by rorykoehler on Friday September 20, 2019 @08:26AM (#21025877)
To reply properly would warrant an essay about n order effects but long story short the fact that crowd funding exists in it's current state is a reflection of how broken our economic model is.
Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by jankotek on Monday September 16, 2019 @05:50AM (#20982474)
What makes you think that money would be well spend? I think most people would still sit on their asses watching netflix... now with a fancy job title and paycheck.

This butterfly is amazing and with good story, crowdfunding should be doable. Also Bay area already spends several billions on environmental protections, why this budget did not cover this project?

Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by pvaldes on Monday September 16, 2019 @06:01AM (#20982540)
Crowfunding here is a problem, because the animal is rare, beautiful and desired by collectors, and anybody less well-intentioned than this man could collect the funds and then breed the butterflies with the only purpose of sell it preserved on internet later.

Even if 50% of rare butterflies killed and sold would be better for the species than having no butterflies at all, it poses some legal conflicts and dangers for the wild population, would be trading of a rare species. With big butterflies cames a big responsability

Re:A man repopulated a rare butterfly species in his backyar... by pvaldes on Monday September 16, 2019 @10:09AM (#20984144)
Update: it seems that fortunately is just locally rare in the city, so I'm wrong and the former does not apply.