News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by frabbit on Sunday September 15, 2019 @01:27PM (#20978321)
A bit OT, but related: there are no cheap, simple, FOSS mp3 players. It used to be that you could get a Sansa which was flashable with Rockbox¹, had a decent battery life, cost around US$30 and would take SD cards. Those options have now disappeared and been replaced with devices that do not have enough memory to be flashed with Rockbox. The default OS on these is terrible compared to Rockbox.

Would love it if someone would make a simple player which was controllable by the user.

1. https://www.rockbox.org/

Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by squarefoot on Sunday September 15, 2019 @01:47PM (#20978434)
I have the exact same problem: two (Rockboxed) Sansa Clip Zips I've taken everywhere for years, from snowy mountains to the beach; one is already dead and one about to take its final breath. They're not available anymore for purchase and the few used ones remaining in still good condition are sold ridiculously overpriced. To me there's only one solution: Either develop a a player from scratch or port a subset of Rockbox (no games, FX, etc.) on a small SBC plus added display, DAC, SD and LiPo circuitry. The SBC could well be the ESP32 which would add wireless functionality; *Pi and other Linux boards would be tremendously overkill for the task. Shouldn't be that hard for skilled developers, and it would surely sell among those of us who don't want to use a cellphone.
Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by DanBC on Sunday September 15, 2019 @03:05PM (#20978910)
I have loved all my Sansa MP3 players, but I find my current Sandisk Clip Jam a bit annoying for some things (very long files names; playlisting; working out what fields it sorts on and why). It won't take rockbox.

If you want a cheap device to run rockbox...

> Either develop a a player from scratch or port a subset of Rockbox (no games, FX, etc.) on a small SBC plus added display, DAC, SD and LiPo circuitry. The SBC could well be the ESP32 which would add wireless functionality; *Pi and other Linux boards would be tremendously overkill for the task. Shouldn't be that hard for skilled developers, and it would surely sell among those of us who don't want to use a cellphone.

...this feels like it's going to end up as being an expensive device. There are a bunch of other MP3 players available from companies like FIIO, Cowon, Shanling or others. Would you be able to build something that competes with these? https://www.advancedmp3players.co.uk/shop/Digital_Audio_Play...

EDIT: Thinking about it, if you had braille on the buttons and a clear simple layout you could push it to both markets: people who want a hackable MP3 player, and people who want an accessible mp3 player for things like audio books. (Which is something my Clip Jam is not great for).

Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by frabbit on Sunday September 15, 2019 @04:56PM (#20979449)
Just looking at your link the price of those is astoundingly high. It seems like they've taken a modest tool and sought to turn it into some sort of Veblen-good by replacing plastic cases and mechanical buttons with high res touchscreens and aluminum cases.

The rockbox-compatible sansas (and earlier cowons) were: 1. cheap (circa 30 bucks) 2. very small (I just measured my Clip Zip as: 5cm x 3cm x 1cm ) 3. very light 4. has an SD slot (I don't know its max supported size but 32GB works fine for my audiobooks) 5. is easily flashable with rockbox

Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by benologist on Sunday September 15, 2019 @05:19PM (#20979545)
There's a lot of funky semi-open handheld retro gaming devices that might repurpose if you're into buttons -

https://obscurehandhelds.com/

Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by squarefoot on Sunday September 15, 2019 @07:18PM (#20980034)
The very cheap Odroid GO, once fitted with stereo DAC and headphone jack, would make a nice platform to build an audio player. Surely not the smallest around, but good enough to generate interest to make a smaller version. https://www.hardkernel.com/shop/odroid-go/
Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by andai on Sunday September 15, 2019 @02:10PM (#20978585)
Why don't you want to use a cellphone? Privacy/surveillance and/or stimulation addiction? I miss my old mp3 players and RockBoxed iPod classic, and I've been meaning to get rid of my cell phone as well. Really I'd prefer a pocket computer to a cell phone, surprised there isn't anything like that for sale.
Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by TrueDuality on Sunday September 15, 2019 @04:40PM (#20979366)
When I'm on a longer hike I don't know how long my phone battery will need to hold out (don't get me started on solar and extra battery packs) so it stays off with periodic check ins to stay in contact.

Dedicated music players tend to have a much longer battery life, are lighter, cheaper to replace (weather, drops, being left on wet ground...). It allows me to listen to things without sacrificing my safety net.

Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by squarefoot on Sunday September 15, 2019 @02:39PM (#20978749)
"Why don't you want to use a cellphone? Privacy/surveillance and/or stimulation addiction?"

Pretty much all of this, plus not risking a device that I have to rely on for communications. Each of my Sansa players fell like a dozen times without getting a single scratch because they were very light and the screen was small and sturdy; had I used a cellphone I would probably have destroyed at least its screen multiple times or ruined it from prolonged exposition to salty air at the sea. Also I don't use smartphones due to the above points, and I still have to see a traditional phone with a decent player (and a decent camera, but that's another story).

The PinePhone might change this, however. Silently waiting for it to hit the market.

Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by frabbit on Sunday September 15, 2019 @05:01PM (#20979477)
That's pretty much it on all points for me: light and small with a sturdy plastic case meant that dropping it was not disastrous.

Am definitely interested in the PinePhone, but suspect that its dimensions will mean that I shall be restricted in not using it while running/cycling and (more importantly for me) as a cheap audiobook player that I fall asleep to in bed and occasionally drop out of the bed onto the floor or sleep on top of.

Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by squarefoot on Monday September 16, 2019 @07:04AM (#20982869)
A hint for the folks at pine64: please take into consideration the PinePod :)
Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by tllim on Thursday September 19, 2019 @05:40PM (#21021010)
Check on my response :-)
Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by _emacsomancer_ on Sunday September 15, 2019 @02:50PM (#20978819)
The physical interface on a standalone player is also better than a cellphone. I always take a standalone player when I travel - it's easy to be able to control it just by feel (and I don't have to worry about running down the battery in my cellphone).
Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by serf on Sunday September 15, 2019 @02:38PM (#20978744)
my reason : phones (mostly) make lousy MP3 players.

high battery use, bad DACs, and clumsy interfaces.

There are exceptions, but not many.

Single purpose devices that are designed to do a specific thing just work better -- go figure.

Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by fouc on Monday September 16, 2019 @02:46AM (#20981629)
Maybe some raspberry pi or arduino setup could do the trick?
Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by Scoundreller on Sunday September 15, 2019 @04:32PM (#20979332)
> They're not available anymore for purchase and the few used ones remaining in still good condition are sold ridiculously overpriced.

Thanks! I have one in original packaging somewhere. Bought it to give away but never did for various reasons.

Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by tllim on Thursday September 19, 2019 @05:39PM (#21021001)
I am TL Lim, PINE64 community founder. The PineTime watch using NORDIC nRF52832, thos chip has i2s output and do you thinks this SoC good enough for an open source MP3 plater just like Sansa Clip?If the answer is positive, I can pass some PineTime devkit to RockBox developer to try out, then just redesign the schematic with audio DAC plus phone amp and a suitable touch screen case. Please note that this is just an exploration, we are currently fully loaded with various projects. P/S: don't mind the PinePod name :-)
Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by rahimnathwani on Sunday September 15, 2019 @04:00PM (#20979181)
What's wrong with the Xduoo X3?

It works with Rockbox[0], has a monochrome OLED screen, can take 2 MicroSD cards, and has two 3.5mm sockets: one for line out, and one for headphones.

The only thing I don't like about it is the headphone socket, which is prone to fail. It feels tight on insertion/removal, and the extra force can eventually cause it to lose connection with the mainboard.

They cost about $100 new, or half that used.

Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by naraic0o on Sunday September 15, 2019 @05:17PM (#20979532)
i have one called the "agptek rocker", it has basic rockbox support but a pretty leaky cheap lcd. i like that it has bluetooth, but i don't believe it's supported yet in rockbox. it's available under various other names but i believe it can be had from about 50usd.

it's quite interesting with more modern rockbox supported pmps, rockbox is run as an SDL program stuck into the modified linux firmware. this device is moderately powerful with a 1GHz MIPS ingenic x1000 CPU. fun to tinker with.

fiio has some nice devices (some with RB support, e.g. the M3K), too. but i wish they had bluetooth. i guess it's not cool with audiophiles so intentionally excluded.

Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by steve19 on Sunday September 15, 2019 @04:44PM (#20979392)
That looks like a pretty good option. The downside is the price and it looks at least twice the size and weigh of thr SanDisk players.
Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by rahimnathwani on Monday September 16, 2019 @11:09AM (#20984817)
Yeah it feels at least twice as heavy as the Sansa. Maybe even heavier.
Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by nzgrover on Sunday September 15, 2019 @06:27PM (#20979823)
Is there such a thing as this with Spotify support?
Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by Sendotsh on Sunday September 15, 2019 @07:23PM (#20980053)
There’s the Mighty[0]? It’s pure Spotify though and not MP3s as well.

[0] https://bemighty.com/

Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by kingosticks on Monday September 16, 2019 @03:49AM (#20981913)
Nice! I've been looking for exactly this product (or to build something like it) for ages. Shame about the lack of mp3 support and the bad reviews regarding the software. For £80 I'd expect something less buggy so I'm not sure I'll try it.
Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by frabbit on Sunday September 15, 2019 @04:58PM (#20979460)
It is HUUUUGGGEEE :)
Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by xtagon on Sunday September 15, 2019 @01:43PM (#20978409)
Agreed! My Sansa Clip+ is still going strong (magically, the battery still works after all this time) and thanks to Rockbox it can do hundreds of things it couldn't do originally.
Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by bArray on Sunday September 15, 2019 @11:53PM (#20980954)
That's my hopes for PineTime, I would love for it to be a standalone "fitness tracker" and MP3 player rolled into one. It's a very nice price point for a watch to hack with.

All it would need is an ESP32, IMU, heart rate sensor, micro SD card reader, audio jack, LiPo and touch display. Make it work with the Arduino IDE and things get very exciting for hack-ability.

Honestly, the watch makes me more excited than the phone.

Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by blihp on Sunday September 15, 2019 @05:58PM (#20979720)
When it's released, the PinePhone should provide a good platform for mp3 and other media. If all you want it for is music, disable all the wireless (both for security and max battery life) and you've basically got an open source iPod touch with a microSD slot for $150. Seems like a natural 'stripped down' distro/image use case for the device.
Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by jayd16 on Sunday September 15, 2019 @02:05PM (#20978560)
These days you can get a cheap AOSP phone and run a lot more so I'm not that surprised this stuff is dying off.
Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by frabbit on Sunday September 15, 2019 @09:48PM (#20980524)
None of those are small. And they are not that cheap either. I think this is an obvious market opportunity -- small, cheap, open devices doing one thing well. No need for massive screens, touch screens , just a couple of buttons, a battery, DAC, USB and headphone jack, SD slot. I am agnostic on bluetooth support, not a deal breaker for me without it, but if it did not add too much to the price, then sure.
Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by icebraining on Monday September 16, 2019 @04:57AM (#20982221)
I think that market opportunity is well covered, except for the "open" part. Gadget sites are overflowing with cheap and small music playing devices with those parts.
Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by frabbit on Monday September 16, 2019 @02:22PM (#20987035)
I disagree.

The F/OSS part is the most important. Rockbox allowed an incredible degree of customization. For something like a music/audiobook player personal tastes in interaction with the a small device mean that configurability is key. That, I suspect is why there are only larger devices with loads more buttons and touchscreens available.

The ability to set timeouts and restart from last position on power-on, led light-level, sort-order etc made devices supported by them something that I could use. I have tried various Alibaba sourced devices that were in the US$20-50 range and none of them had the right form-factor and customizability.

Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by ksangeelee on Sunday September 15, 2019 @06:07PM (#20979747)
This what I did to replace my iRiver running Rockbox. One problem to watch out for with cheap phones is that the audio can be noisy, even if only when charging, which will be particularly annoying when listening to audio books or talks.

I found an Android app called MortPlayer which is very close to Rockbox in terms of functions and configurability. It hasn't been updated in a years, but still works well.

Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by _emacsomancer_ on Sunday September 15, 2019 @02:52PM (#20978833)
I think at this point, probably getting a rockboxable ipod is a better valuable proposition than trying to find a viable sansa device (I still have a working sansa clip that I use, and hopefully it'll last for a while).
Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by smcleod on Monday September 16, 2019 @07:58AM (#20983180)
Oh those were FANTASTIC! I used to buy them, put Rockbox on them and give them as Christmas and Birthday gifts - really good audio quality, battery life and the perfect size for the price.
Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by fnord77 on Sunday September 15, 2019 @07:36PM (#20980116)
Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by ZoomZoomZoom on Sunday September 15, 2019 @06:05PM (#20979743)
Sansa wasn't FOSS, it was just supported by the community and was killed by the complete lack of vendor interest. Now there's AGPT Rocker/Benji T6, which can be flashed with Rockbox. For how long it's a viable option, we don't know. I don't know of anything really open by design in the field. It's really disheartening.
Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by frabbit on Sunday September 15, 2019 @09:51PM (#20980536)
True about Sansa not being FOSS, but it was at least flashable with FOSS due to the effort of the Rockbox community. I looked at the AGPT Rocker, but again, it's way too large (IMO) for its simple function. And needlessly expensive.

Here's hoping someone tries to fill the market hole.

Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by ReverseCold on Sunday September 15, 2019 @11:26PM (#20980855)
If the device can't connect to the internet and therefore doesn't have tracking/etc, does it need to be FOSS?
Re:PineTime Is a $25 Smartwatch / Companion for PinePhone Li... by bArray on Sunday September 15, 2019 @11:46PM (#20980927)
The ability to make contributions to improving hardware and software is important. Perhaps I want my MP3 player to support a new audio codec, or to display a large clock, or to track my steps when I go for a walk - you get the point. When it's open source, I'm able to make these changes, or use the work of others.