News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sauropod Neck Posture by marcosdumay on Friday September 13, 2019 @01:36PM (#20964350)
I don't get why blood pressure is relevant for heart energy expenditure. Animal bodies are full of blood, it's not like hearts pump blood up there, they just pump it into movement.

I also can't imagine how that long neck evolved (and stayed there) without a huge competing advantage. The and usual advantage of large necks is feeding high, so I distrust the claim that an animal with a long neck couldn't keep his head up.

Re:Sauropod Neck Posture by ncmncm on Friday September 13, 2019 @02:33PM (#20964985)
I think you may be assuming that veins are rigid, so can create suction at the top, like a siphon, as blood flows back down the neck. If that were true, it would not take much work to move blood through the neck and head. Maybe you are thinking the veins could be braced against surrounding bone structures, to be held open against such suction.

Unfortunately, that cannot work. All the capillaries in the head and brain would also need to be rigid, and strong enough to hold back that much suction. There's no way around actually doing the work to pump the blood up there, and letting it drain back down.

But that isn't a slam-dunk for extreme blood pressure. We have plenty of examples of valves in veins to help get blood back from lower extremities. A little musculature around a pair of such valves on an artery could easily develop into a secondary heart, and a series of them could eliminate much of the need for the actual heart to supply all the pressure, or for the aorta to resist it.

It is not unreasonable to expect to find novel adaptations in an extreme body plan. Supporting the idea in the absence of fossil evidence is hard, even when such a novelty would eliminate the need for such a novelty as absurdly high blood pressure. Biologists resist suggestion of soft -tissue novelties much more than suggestion of physico- mechanical absurdities because they are, after all, biologists, not engineers.

Re:Sauropod Neck Posture by marcosdumay on Saturday September 14, 2019 @10:11AM (#20970877)
Not so much rigid, and not so much suction, in a closed circulatory system, the column of fluid that is going down pressurizes the bottom just as much as is required to send the fluid back up.

Yes, that would require all capillary vases to support 1 extra atm of pressure against the air, what is a large issue. But it does not require rigidity.

Re:Sauropod Neck Posture by ncmncm on Saturday September 14, 2019 @04:56PM (#20973726)
Point conceded.
Re:Sauropod Neck Posture by marcosdumay on Saturday September 14, 2019 @07:36PM (#20974552)
Your point is taken. Looks like I wasn't much clear, but 1 atm is a sure huge amount of pressure, it's not likely that an animal would have this blood pressure, it could at most get some small partial savings from high pressure.
Re:Sauropod Neck Posture by sachdevap on Friday September 13, 2019 @01:42PM (#20964415)
> I don't get why blood pressure is relevant for heart energy expenditure. Animal bodies are full of blood, it's not like hearts pump blood up there, they just pump it into movement.

No, blood does not get pumped in your head with just movement. You don't swing your head below your heart to replace blood in your brain. Somehow the blood needs to be replaced with fresh oxygenated blood.

> I also can't imagine how that long neck evolved (and stayed there) without a huge competing advantage. The and usual advantage of large necks is feeding high, so I distrust the claim that an animal with a long neck couldn't keep his head up.

It is common consensus that Giraffe necks did not evolve just under competitive advantage, and the best proof for that is the fact that their necks are much much longer than any other species. If it was only competitive advantage, other species would have displayed similar trends. Sexual selection is a more likely explanation.

https://www.scienceabc.com/nature/animals/why-giraffes-have-...

Re:Sauropod Neck Posture by unwind on Friday September 13, 2019 @01:44PM (#20964441)
Huh?

I am no biologist (or physicist) but if a bulk(¿) liquid moves against gravity, then surely it needs assistance?

Getting the blood in a vessel to "just move" if that vessel leads many meters up, has got to be more difficult than if it weren't.

¿ I know capillary effects exist, and plants don't exactly get water up themselves by magic but ...

Re:Sauropod Neck Posture by mfoy_ on Friday September 13, 2019 @02:36PM (#20965012)
Blood vessels can expand and contract. That's why fighter pilots without legs can actually withstand higher-g maneuvers. That's also why compression socks can improve circulation and reduce swelling in your ankles if you have to stand all day.
Re:Sauropod Neck Posture by cbanek on Friday September 13, 2019 @08:58PM (#20968174)
> That's why fighter pilots without legs can actually withstand higher-g maneuvers.

You just wrinkled my brain. Is there an actual group of fighter pilots without legs who are taking advantage of this?

Re:Sauropod Neck Posture by pontifier on Saturday September 14, 2019 @02:56PM (#20972935)
I've often wondered if maybe sitting upright might not be the best position for a modern combat pilot. I can see pilot who is laying down pulling far more Gs than even a legless one sitting upright.
Re:Sauropod Neck Posture by Pinckney on Sunday September 15, 2019 @12:47PM (#20978108)
Re:Sauropod Neck Posture by cbanek on Saturday September 14, 2019 @05:49PM (#20974046)
I suppose that makes sense, although that would make visibility harder. Maybe if you went full virtual HUD helmets, and didn't need to see out at all... although then you might just want to have drones with AI dogfighting capability?

The other thought about legless pilots is the feet I think are used for the rudder control (pedals), so there is some loss of ability to control without using your feet. While I think computers could probably take this over, in the end it does mean two less things to interact with the plane.

Re:Sauropod Neck Posture by Udik on Saturday September 14, 2019 @03:48AM (#20969492)
Does this imply that in order to pump blood at the top of a very long neck you don't necessarily need a stronger heart, but just stronger muscles or thicker blood vessels in your legs? In that case the solution to the dinosaurs' problem might be very far from the the heart or the neck.
Re:Sauropod Neck Posture by mfoy_ on Monday September 16, 2019 @09:33AM (#20983824)
Well, I don't know about dinosaurs, but horses have small blood pumps in their hooves. So each step helps circulate blood. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frog_(horse_anatomy)
Re:Sauropod Neck Posture by ceejayoz on Friday September 13, 2019 @02:21PM (#20964851)
> Animal bodies are full of blood, it's not like hearts pump blood up there, they just pump it into movement.

If that were the case, G forces wouldn't make people black out. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/G-LOC

Re:Sauropod Neck Posture by htns on Friday September 13, 2019 @03:11PM (#20965341)
Does high G actually cause a higher or lower blood pressure at heart level? (search engines fail to give an answer) I think the problem there is blood packing to the lower body, and a sauropod would have enough blood and strong enough veins to be able to hold its head upright.

It's not really obvious to me why the sauropod heart->head->heart loop shouldn't be considered as a "siphon". For all the blood that's going up there should be an equal amount of blood going down.

Re:Sauropod Neck Posture by ceejayoz on Friday September 13, 2019 @03:16PM (#20965387)
> It's not really obvious to me why the sauropod heart->head->heart loop shouldn't be considered as a "siphon".

Because blood vessels are flexible. Siphoning would be disastrous for the body - capillaries would snap shut under the suction and we'd die.

Re:Sauropod Neck Posture by htns on Friday September 13, 2019 @03:42PM (#20965658)
What would be the force actually shutting the capillaries, if the veins themselves aren't collapsing? The upper part of a siphon still has internal pressure, just less than at its base.
Re:Sauropod Neck Posture by ncmncm on Friday September 13, 2019 @03:47PM (#20965718)
For a siphon to work at all requires negative pressure at the top.
Re:Sauropod Neck Posture by ncmncm on Friday September 13, 2019 @03:15PM (#20965382)
This is answered above.
Re:Sauropod Neck Posture by pontifier on Saturday September 14, 2019 @03:06PM (#20972990)
If the condition is brought on slowly, i.e. because the animal grew to a large size, I'd think that it would have enough blood to fill their vessels at the increased pressure required to have positive blood pressure everywhere.
Re:Sauropod Neck Posture by hinkley on Friday September 13, 2019 @01:51PM (#20964511)
Are you talking about arterial contractions or something else?