News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Day Trading for a Living? by Kranar on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:20AM (#20941077)
I mean you may as well say: Study shows it is impossible for an individual to build a tech start up as a living.

Just because something is hard doesn't mean it's impossible. Day trading, like many other risky ventures, is something that is very hard and unlikely but for the few who succeed ends up being very profitable.

Re:Day Trading for a Living? by kevin_nisbet on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:26AM (#20941151)
The abstract of the paper seems to suggest otherwise: We observe all individuals who began to day trade between 2013 and 2015 in the Brazilian equity futures market, the third in terms of volume in the world, and persisted for at least 300 days: 97% of them lost money, only 0.4% earned more than a bank teller (US$54 per day), and the top individual earned only US$310 per day with great risk (a standard deviation of US$2,560).

My interpretation of this, is that those they tracked in this study, it's not even all that profitable for the few that beat the odds while being exposed to significant risk.

Re:Day Trading for a Living? by Kranar on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:37AM (#20941286)
But what should we compare those odds, how are we supposed to interpret this?

Imagine we tracked a group of 1000 randomly picked individuals who wanted to be a brain surgeon. I don't know for sure but I wouldn't be surprised if of 1000 randomly chosen people, only 3 people managed to succeed at it after 4 years.

But no one would ever say "Study shows it's impossible for an individual to become a brain surgeon." or imply that it's just random luck to be a brain surgeon. Instead we conclude that being a brain surgeon must be very hard and require a great deal of dedication and commitment.

The reason day trading is singled out whereas brain surgeons are not is that the barrier to entry to become a day trader is very low, anyone can try to become a day trader and many people think they can succeed at it.

The proper conclusion to take from this is isn't that the stock market is pure luck or just a form of gambling... it's that one shouldn't be deceived by the low barrier to entry into thinking that they can succeed at it. It's really hard, soul crushing work to be a successful day trader in much the same way it's really hard work to do anything in life that pays well.

Re:Day Trading for a Living? by ofibrvev on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:52AM (#20941480)
One major flaw in this reasoning..

Some group of people are guaranteed to become brain surgeons.. the demand is there, the training is there, so it is a near certainty. In fact in the US at least, you can know very closely how many brain surgeons there can be per year. Who will fill those slots isn’t too kind to all takers. It is dedication, hard work, and luck (ie ovarian lottery).

Also the majority of those that “fail” at obtaining a neurosurgery training. If they were on the path to medical training will end up falling back to any number of high paying jobs in medicine or surgery.

This study found no one did terribly well at day trading. Random chance implies there will be some outlying outcomes, but that is a fundamentally different objective than having too many people for few slots.

Re:Day Trading for a Living? by kritiko on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:49AM (#20941438)
What would you say the difference is between trying to make money on short term investments and trying to make money betting on sports?

Also your final paragraph seems to imply a causal relationship between how hard you work and remuneration. Hard work doesn't hurt, but luck is very important.

Re:Day Trading for a Living? by munchbunny on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @01:21PM (#20942519)
There is definitely an edge to be found, but the game heavily favors players with structural (I am able to know things you don't) or institutional (I have hundreds of subject matter experts and deep pockets) advantages, and individual day traders have none of those things.

Which isn't to say day traders can't get those things, it's just that you stop calling yourself a day trader and start calling yourself an investor when you start to intentionally build up structural/institutional advantages.

Re:Day Trading for a Living? by seiferteric on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:59AM (#20941575)
Isn't it possible that there is simple not enough information in the system to successfully day trade (at least in this particular market). Considering that the daily movements of stocks are like a random walk, I don't find it hard to believe.
Re:Day Trading for a Living? by Kranar on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @12:07PM (#20941701)
It's often difficult for me to discuss this since I do automated trading. I've been doing this for over 10 years now, have grown a company out of it that has 30 employees, and I maybe lose money 2 or 3 days out of the entire year and often times due to technical reasons...

Either daily movements of stocks are not at all like a random walk, or I am just one heck of an astronomically lucky guy. Now I do consider myself fortunate and privileged, for sure... but the amount of luck it would take to repeatedly make money on the market day after day that can fund a decently sized team of high paying engineers, data center costs/hardware costs, so on so forth... it's unthinkable.

The stock market, at least to the degree that I am involved in it, very short term market microstructure, doesn't behave anything like what economists say it does.

Re:Day Trading for a Living? by flatline on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:34AM (#20941242)
I know people who made millions day trading commodities, for no one in that cohort to have made any real money over two years is surprising to the point of disbelief. This may be something particular to the Brazilian exchange.
Re:Day Trading for a Living? by melling on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:39AM (#20941316)
I’ve noticed a lot of successful traders trade commodities versus equities.

What makes commodities easier to trade?

Ed Seykota has been doing it for decades:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ed_Seykota

Re:Day Trading for a Living? by Kranar on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:47AM (#20941404)
Commodities are generally harder to trade compared to equities. The reason successful traders do it is because you get access to much greater leverage compared to equities.
Re:Day Trading for a Living? by reverend_gonzo on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @12:01PM (#20941605)
Leverage.

You’ll quickly get big or go home.

Re:Day Trading for a Living? by JackFr on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @12:38PM (#20942053)
No inside information on commodities.

(However trading on embargoed government press releases is illegal. Though rather than kidnapping Clarence Beeks on the train, you can just interview the Florida farmers yourself.)

Re:Day Trading for a Living? by Macross8299 on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @03:26PM (#20943769)
There is definitely inside information on commodities, it's just rare that insider trading on commodities is prosecuted.

You would definitely have an advantage in trading oil/gas futures if you had access to ExxonMobil's seismic exploration reports, for example.

Re:Day Trading for a Living? by boulos on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @04:40PM (#20944442)
Indeed! I found Matt Levine's post last Fall [1], particularly useful, as he believed you couldn't be prosecuted for insider trading of commodities (only securities). Then he received a nastygram from the CFTC :).

[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/amp/opinion/articles/2018-10-24/it...

Re:Day Trading for a Living? by JackFr on Thursday September 12, 2019 @01:32AM (#20948336)
Wow. But if Matt Levine can get it wrong too I don’t feel so bad.

But the insider trading you suggest above, is predicated on having material non public information of ExxonMobil’s.

Re:Day Trading for a Living? by gnopgnip on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @12:07PM (#20941689)
Many who make millions are risky and lose it all, or more. How many of them are net positive over more than a year?
Re:Day Trading for a Living? by hn_throwaway_99 on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @12:11PM (#20941741)
While I don't necessarily agree with Kranar's conclusions, I think his point is that the same can be said for many highly risky endeavors, like building a startup.

IMO the main difference is that, while in both cases you'll see a small number of successes and a huge number of failures, in startup land the net expected value is positive while in day trader land it is negative.

Re:Day Trading for a Living? by cptaj on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:23AM (#20941119)
Playing the lottery is also very profitable for those who succeed.
Re:Day Trading for a Living? by vonmoltke on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:27AM (#20941165)
Correct, and the statement "it is impossible to become rich by playing the lottery" is absurd. It's part of an annoying tendency to conflate "extremely low probability of success" with "impossible".
Re:Day Trading for a Living? by firethief on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:34AM (#20941245)
Is that the original goalpost? Because I'd say it is impossible to make a living playing the lottery. To make a living doing something, it needs to provide enough positive cash flow.
Re:Day Trading for a Living? by vonmoltke on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:40AM (#20941318)
It's the goalpost of the post I was responding to. I may have misunderstood the point, though.
Re:Day Trading for a Living? by tobr on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:38AM (#20941290)
Ignore the link text here. They’re saying it’s “virtually impossible”, which would be true of the lottery as well.
Re:Day Trading for a Living? by vonmoltke on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:41AM (#20941330)
I'm on the fence about whether adding the weasel word "virtually" is any better.
Re:Day Trading for a Living? by ajscanlan on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @12:28PM (#20941936)
I think the term "for a living" is more important.

How would you interpret the phrase "It's impossible for an individual to play the lottery for a living"?

Technically we both know it IS possible, technically. But in the real world? I don't know, but I wouldn't be suggesting anyone out there try make a living playing the lotto.

Re:Day Trading for a Living? by tobr on Thursday September 12, 2019 @04:29PM (#20956089)
It’s not a weasel word. A weasel word is used to mask a lack of sources or data, that’s not the case here.
Re:Day Trading for a Living? by mrandish on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:33AM (#20941227)
Yes, the title should have been something like "impossible for an individual to day trade stocks for a consistently reliable living".
Re:Day Trading for a Living? by wasdfff on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:53AM (#20941493)
If you loose the lottery you end up with a piece of reciept paper, but if you buy a stock you have it for as long as you want.

The market always goes up. Even if right after this comment, if the sp500 tumbles and we enter a recession, your share of vix doesn’t go anywhere. Youd just wait for the market to recover and hit the price you bought it for.

However, day trading isn’t really viable unless you have a lot of money to take advantage of every dip and hill and get around day trading restrictions.

Re:Day Trading for a Living? by PopeDotNinja on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:43AM (#20941363)
The problem with day trading, and stock trading in general, is that you can't predict the future. No one can. You can diversify your risk by buying the market (e.g. S&P 500 index fund) & hope the trend of going up N% per year continues, but even that isn't guaranteed. Essentially if you try to time/guess/predict the market, you're going gambling & the fees you pay on trading on the rake taken by the broker. Some gamblers do well. Most don't.
Re:Day Trading for a Living? by arghwhat on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:43AM (#20941366)
This is not correct.

If we consider a tech startup a single gamble, then living off trading is a continuous stream of independent gambles.

While individual gambles may turn out better than the average (even many in a row), repeated gambling will always see the total outcome return to the normal.

This is why the house always wins.

Re:Day Trading for a Living? by tylerhou on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:25AM (#20941137)
> Day trading, like many other risky ventures, is something that is very hard and unlikely but for the few who succeed ends up being very profitable.

> the top individual earned only US$310 per day with great risk (a standard deviation of US$2,560).

The very best day trader made around the same as an entry-level SWE, which does not scream immense profit to me.

Re:Day Trading for a Living? by soneca on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:34AM (#20941248)
I agree with your point totally. But just to put in perspective that U$310/day in Brazil would be the equivalent of the top 10% software engineer salaries in Brazil.
Re:Day Trading for a Living? by lm28469 on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:31AM (#20941219)
> an entry-level SWE

In a major tech hotspot, working 8 hours a day

Re:Day Trading for a Living? by adrianmonk on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:28AM (#20941177)
Or you could say: it's impossible to win the world championship at anything.

It would be easy to find data to show that 99.99% of people aren't the best tennis player or fastest runner or best Scrabble player in the world; therefore, nobody can be the best at it. According to this reasoning, at least.

Re:Day Trading for a Living? by kritiko on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @12:12PM (#20941761)
The point of the article is to dissuade people from pursuing careers in day trading based on marketing that it's an easy way to earn money (from people whose business is selling instructional materials... not day trading). If there were lots of people selling courses on "Become a WTA Tour Player, make millions winning tennis tournaments!" the same type of paper might be warranted for tennis playing.
Re:Day Trading for a Living? by adrianmonk on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @02:15PM (#20943071)
On a high level I agree. The way I see it, "impossible" is the wrong label. What you must do, though, is have a rational basis to believe you're in (making up a number) the top 0.01% of people skilled in that area. If that's true, then it might be a reasonable plan. For the other 99.99%, it's a bad plan.

And when I say rational basis, that's its own challenge. There is a huge potential for emotional thinking disguised as rational and for self-delusion. Everyone wants to believe they are the top 0.01%, and most of them are wrong.

Re:Day Trading for a Living? by ClumsyPilot on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @01:50PM (#20942823)
That would be a perfectly accurate statement. If none except world champions got paid, it would be an atrocious career choice
Re:Day Trading for a Living? by smt88 on Wednesday September 11, 2019 @11:23AM (#20941115)
A better way to put it is that day-trading is like gambling. You always lose money in the long run, even if you have spurts of success.