The nutty thing is WeWork could have worked as a well-executed business. The core thesis, that companies of all sizes appreciate the flexibility of spinning up and down remote workplaces as a variable (versus fixed) cost has legs.
There is a borrowing-short-buying-long aspect to their business, but that could be managed through a combination of first-loss guarantees and sandboxed leases (on both sides).
The problem is the CEO, enabled by Masa Son, showed zero discipline on any level. Nepotism, self dealing, lack of focus, cost inflation...about the only thing they did right, it seems, was expansively disclose all of this to their investors.
Forced summer camp, nepotism, back stabbing politics, etc. Sounds like a hellish place to work.
Side thing. I don’t know how things will work out, but SoftBank put in $9B and owns like 30% of the company. It’s valuation is below $20B now and who knows how low it’ll go. Or what will happen with them needing money. SoftBank and the fund are at best going to be out $4B. Is that what’s likely the case? That money is essentially flushed down the toilet for SB and their fund?
That is basically what they did, but they also marketed it really well and made the process seamless. Everyone points to Regus as an example of a company that already existed in WeWork's space, but as far as I can tell, most people have only heard of Regus because WeWork is so often compared to them.
Before WeWork, most people weren't aware that coworking spaces were an option. Startups would work out of homes or they would find cheap office space and sign long term leases for spaces they might soon outgrow. WeWork solved these issues for them.
Now, I don't think there's much of a competitive moat. I don't think there's much stopping companies from moving to any other co-working space. Their corporate governance issues are crazy. They are probably overvalued (at least as of their last raise in the private markets). But they certainly are the 900 pound gorilla in this space and the space has gotten much bigger as a result of them.
Is this true? I am skeptical. If it is true it speaks to the mindboggling ignorance of Silicon Valley decision makers. I was living in a small (<500k metro not in california in 2009, and there were already 2 branded “coworking” businesses (that were well marketed to the tiny tech community). I may be the exception but I had not heard of WeWork until much later, but I wasn’t in a talent resource decision making position at the time, it wasn’t really my need to know those things. If it was and I didn’t, I would have fired myself for gross incompetence.
I know they're in my city, but the website location quotes daily prices based on a 24-month commitment.
Either they don't feel threatened by WeWork and independent coworking spaces, or they don't feel the need to adjust their terms and contract conditions... which I find curious.
Have a feeling the newer, smaller players with more limited portfolios (and exposure) might survive better.
I frankly don't see We work having any long term advantage over any of the other big players.
This may well be true, but I'm not sure that's precisely a negative. Most people don't need to hear of Regus unless they're looking for ready-to-go space for a small company, or if they work for a company renting such space. (I'd heard of Regus, as I worked at a company renting space at Regus. And it was a really nice environment. This was back in 2010, by the way.) And I think anyone who was actually doing that search would have pretty easily come across Regus.
WeWork's "innovation" in some ways was marketing directly to developers, pitching themselves as "we're a tech startup ourselves, catering to tech startups just like you!", so people putting together startups would already know their name before they did a search for space.
They are very much not a 800 pound gorilla. That would mean that they could dictate the market, but with some of the most expensive prices for a mediocre offering in comparison to the competition, they can't really do that.
I remember co-working spaces and “live-work units” in London in the 1990’s.
I’ll admit that WeWork has a certain cachet, Millenials can’t imagine anything cooler than getting an Uber from the AirBnB to the WeWork, but that’s just a fashion and they’ll move onto something else soon.
There could be some value there, maybe, but I've looked at WeWork in my area and it's expensive... for having to share a lot of space. It seems like a high bar to get folks into that.
It also mentions the big problem with We, than in the next downturn the revenue will likely stop and it'll be in trouble.
If I owned a bunch of office space, I'd be exiting now (or would have already exited). I think it's probably like the bitcoin effect: bitcoin got notorious, so all the other coins went up too. IMO, uncoordinated pump and dump.
It could end up being a strong counter-cyclical model -- and outperforms as the economy tightens
Traditional office space is a 2, 5, 10 year commitment and a pain to move things around -- with WeWork you're paying monthly and relocating geographically is simple
CFOs will often look to pay more per month for shorter commitments which fit well with budgets and can be terminated quickly if situations change
WeWork also makes setting up an office in a new region super simple vs contracting with local landlords
In a bull period, you're right, CFOs will be willing to spend a little more on high risk projects to allow them to mitigate the risks of long term contracts, but that's not what happens during a recession. During a recession they're overwhelmingly looking to demonstrate a lean, low cost company to shareholders.
Like many of the wework stories, it'd be nice if it were true, but it's just simply not very likely.
If the economy is in the toilet it's hard to get funding to pay someone for office space to hold your startup that you can't fund.
I know there were some theories on cornering the market, or getting some sort of huge buy in / contracts with companies hiring remote workers but for the most part there's plenty of office space (at least in my area) and remote work that I see rarely involves the hiring company shelling out extra for expensive office space for remote workers.
I wonder what other folks selling office space in the market think about all this? They seem to operate just fine and financially seem to do so with a lot less risk than WeWork.