News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by RcouF1uZ4gsC on Sunday September 08, 2019 @12:33AM (#20908627)
One thing that this analysis ignores is how the Roman Catholic Church stepped in and filled a lot of the void left by the collapse of the Roman administrative state. Although, the various Germanic kingdoms fought each other, by the time the Roman Empire fell, they had all converted to Latin Catholic Christianity. Because, of this the Roman Catholic Church could serve a unifying purpose and hold in check the worst impulses of an individual kingdom.

Now, there is no such authority. Maybe 10 years ago, we could have thought that multilateral institutions like the UN, EU, IMF, World Bank, NATO, etc could step up, now, if anything, those institutions might have more of a credibility gap than the US.

The collapse of the American "Empire" would be very painful for everyone, not least Western Europe.

Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by nordsieck on Sunday September 08, 2019 @01:52AM (#20908830)
> Maybe 10 years ago, we could have thought that multilateral institutions like the UN, EU, IMF, World Bank, NATO, etc could step up, now, if anything, those institutions might have more of a credibility gap than the US.

I'm skeptical. Fundamentally, the all of civilization is built on the rule of law, and the rule of law is built on enforcement.

The UN is nothing without the mailed gauntlet the US brings to the table. IMF/World Bank depends on international law, they can't enforce it.

The EU/NATO has the same problem as the UN. I suppose many of the EU countries have a functional military, but they just can't project power.

Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by DuskStar on Sunday September 08, 2019 @03:12AM (#20909061)
> The EU/NATO has the same problem as the UN. I suppose many of the EU countries have a functional military, but they just can't project power.

Only the UK and France have relevant militaries within the EU Nations as far as I'm concerned. Or at least they're the only ones with nukes - Germany's conventional forces might qualify otherwise.

And you need some sort of retaliatory strike capability to really take a seat at the big boys table. (Which they both do, with their SSBNs)

Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by adrianN on Sunday September 08, 2019 @03:29AM (#20909100)
Germany's army is barely functional.

What we need is a small, well trained and equipped, EU army and a disbanding of the national armies. It makes no sense that each EU member has their own army.

Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by nordsieck on Sunday September 08, 2019 @10:01AM (#20910597)
> What we need is a small, well trained and equipped, EU army and a disbanding of the national armies. It makes no sense that each EU member has their own army.

I understand why someone who wants to create a "united states of europe" would want that, but why would the member countries ever agree to that?

Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by dboreham on Sunday September 08, 2019 @11:14AM (#20911017)
Money? It'd cost less than 1 army each.
Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by coldtea on Sunday September 08, 2019 @01:27PM (#20911913)
It also gives them none of their sovereignty a national army does.

In fact it lets 27 others co-decide on their economy, social policy, foreign policy, and so on, with some top dogs like Germany getting undue influence, the very top dogs individual countries fought hard to push back in two worlds wars...

Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by bobthepanda on Sunday September 08, 2019 @01:52PM (#20912082)
The alternative is Britain and France asking for American help in Libya because they can’t actually even do the things they want to do. Regardless of the utility or desirability of action in Libya.
Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by coldtea on Sunday September 08, 2019 @07:29PM (#20914041)
Well, Britain and France have no reason being in Libya, besides plundering resources, and turning a stable, albeit autocratic regime, into a hell-hole of instability, civil war, and fundamentalism...
Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by coldtea on Sunday September 08, 2019 @01:24PM (#20911894)
>What we need is a small, well trained and equipped, EU army and a disbanding of the national armies.

So that the people of European nations would give up the sovereignty their ancestors and them fought hard to gain, for a bureaucratic federal scheme nobody asked for (it was built and promoted by bureaucrats and force-fed with promises, threats, and bribes) that prioritizes the top dogs (Germany, to a lesser degree France) to smaller countries detriment?

Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by jhbadger on Sunday September 08, 2019 @02:44PM (#20912486)
Ultimately, the EU (if it survives) will be something like the US. Where the substates have some sovereignty, but major decisions (such as military ones) are at the federal level.
Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by adrianN on Sunday September 08, 2019 @01:54PM (#20912094)
No, so that Europeans don't pay extra taxes for duplicate stuff. It's not like France will invade Spain anytime soon. There is no point of both having armies.
Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by coldtea on Sunday September 08, 2019 @05:51PM (#20913670)
>It's not like France will invade Spain anytime soon.

Well, Europeans powers fought twice among them in the 20th century. And in its beginning many said the exact same thing (there was even a popular book called "The Great Illusion" about how a great war in Europe is no longer conceivable, because peace and commerce). Similarly, after the collapse of the USSR a Japanese-American thinker smugly wrote about the 'End of history'. We saw how that turned out...

The main reason Europeans powers have stopped in-fighting in the latter part of the 20th century is because they were devastated by the previous wars, in the process of losing their colonial empires (and like Britain, France, etc) and so had their concerns elsewhere, e.g. France in "Indochina". Some were also under control (from USSR), and Germany was split into two and under US and USSR supervision. The power balance had shifted between the US and USSR, so there was little at stake for the European powers to fight, even if they had the might.

If more things get at stake, including after long and deep recessions, perceived or real threats to sovereignty, resources, etc, in a troubled climate-change-hit late 21st century, all bets are off.

>No, so that Europeans don't pay extra taxes for duplicate stuff.

The EU only makes sense if it's a shared political and cultural vision (which at the moment it's not).

If European countries want to avoid "extra taxes" and want to think of their economic interest, then should probably do the inverse, and split from the EU (keeping only the trade deals), so that they have their own local currency they can control, instead of a currency that's tuned to Germany's economy (or to some compromise that either hurts the weak economies or the strong ones).

Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by new2628 on Sunday September 08, 2019 @02:18PM (#20912288)
Yes, these cross-national committee-based institutions tend to be cost-effective and efficient.
Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by reinier on Sunday September 08, 2019 @08:32AM (#20910153)
No, we need each EU country to realize that they all need to have a functioning army that all train together and all contribute to a force that can possibly defend the EU together. Maybe we could standardize a lot of equipment across the armies, but why would we want a general EU army? Who would be in control of it? The possibility of an unelected comission ending up with control is unacceptable IMHO.
Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by SllX on Sunday September 08, 2019 @10:21AM (#20910701)
In essence, this is more or less what NATO is, and it does standardize a lot of equipment across different forces and provide a chain of command.

If NATO didn’t exist though, the other guy is right: you want one military with one chain of command. The more fractured you guys are, the more ineffective any kind of unified military you create will be because you have to convince Frenchmen and Spaniards it is worth dying for Poles and Hungarians and vice versa.

Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by i_am_proteus on Sunday September 08, 2019 @11:48AM (#20911228)
The existence of separate political/economic (EU/EEC) and political/military (NATO) unions in Europe is remarkably dissonant.
Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by hnmullany on Sunday September 08, 2019 @12:43PM (#20911599)
A reminder that the members of the EU Commission are proposed by the collective ministers of all European governments, appointed by the group of all EU Heads of Govt (prime ministers/presidents) and ratified by the EU Parliament (directly elected).

It's as unelected as the US Supreme Court is - which means - technically unelected, but definitely reflective of the wishes of the electorate via the people they elect to populate it.

Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by novaRom on Sunday September 08, 2019 @03:45AM (#20909139)
This is absolutely will be blocked by UK and other right-wing and euro-sceptical parties in Euro Parlament. USA will also oppose it with all possible means.

I think it's one of their greatest fears ( Russia, Turkey, USA)

Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by hyperman1 on Sunday September 08, 2019 @03:53AM (#20909164)
And this is exactly why a lot of Europe sees Brexit as potentially positive in the long term, even if it is painfull in the short term: The UK is the main blocker to further political unification of the EU.
Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by rayiner on Sunday September 08, 2019 @12:35PM (#20911560)
Maybe. Views of the EU were more negative in French polling than in the U.K. in 2016. Holding a referendum on Frexit was one of Le Pen’s campaign promises. (She lost, but still got 1/3 of the vote.) Further political unification may or may not make France more pro-EU.
Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by TMWNN on Sunday September 08, 2019 @01:31PM (#20911944)
Macron admitted in 2018 that the French would probably have voted to leave in a UK-style referendum.

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2018/jan/21/emmanuel-macro...

Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by hyperman1 on Sunday September 08, 2019 @03:54PM (#20912979)
I think most people feel something is wrong with the EU. But this is apart of it: Is it an economical union, or a step towards a fully integrates US-like country. For now it tries to be both,and succeeds in neither. But removing the UK shifts the power balance in this story, and that influences the vote.
Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by darkerside on Sunday September 08, 2019 @02:22PM (#20912324)
Maybe the next fundamental step for humanity is detaching rule of law from physical enforcement at a macro level. This has already happened at the individual level. Most people treat their neighbor with respect, not because they fear arrest or a vengeful God, but because we've internalized that we're all better off when we treat each other better.

It's similar to getting off of the gold and silver standard. Money used to mean something because it was backed by a physical good. What we learned is that humans can operate at the macro level based on abstractions instead. Rule of law doesn't have to be backed by physical violence.

Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by mcv on Monday September 09, 2019 @06:18AM (#20916797)
The EU is not interested in projecting military force. They're interested in economy, trade, and human rights. And economically, the EU is doing fairly well, though I suppose it could be more effective in leveraging their economic trade power to improve human/civil rights outside their border.
Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by bontaq on Sunday September 08, 2019 @10:10AM (#20910635)
I'm skeptical of your idea that the UN is "nothing" without the US military. I think you overestimate what the US contributes. I'm also skeptical that it's beneficial to "project power", which I assume means has military bases in their country and parks a carrier somewhere near them.
Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by i_am_proteus on Sunday September 08, 2019 @10:13AM (#20910651)
It might not be anything with the US military.

This is a serious question: what has the UN successfully accomplished in the last 20 years?

Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by sdbryan on Sunday September 08, 2019 @10:24AM (#20910719)
What has the Roman Empire ever done for us?
Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by giardini on Sunday September 08, 2019 @11:20AM (#20911053)
Obligatory link:

"Monty Python: What have the romans ever done for us?"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y7tvauOJMHo

Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by mattmanser on Sunday September 08, 2019 @10:30AM (#20910761)
Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by wtdata on Sunday September 08, 2019 @11:35AM (#20911136)
For one, the major task of implementing a single currency shared by a big number of the world's richest nations.
Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by simonh on Sunday September 08, 2019 @12:49AM (#20908682)
>the Roman Catholic Church could serve a unifying purpose and hold in check the worst impulses of an individual kingdom.

When they weren’t actively inciting and promoting those worst impulses in the service of their own ends, that is.

Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by englishrookie on Sunday September 08, 2019 @11:44AM (#20911198)
Exactly which Germanic kingdoms do you mean? The Frisians did not convert until after 754 AD (when they killed Saint Boniface - Bonifatius - after he managed to upset them, probably doing stuff like cutting down their holy oak).

The Frisians were never properly incorporated into the Roman empire to begin with, just like many other northern Germanic kingdoms.

As for the EU having a credibility gap, we're doing just fine, thank you very much.

Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by HNLurker2 on Sunday September 08, 2019 @06:24AM (#20909628)
I could imagine in the future American empire being divided into many states who are at war with themselves suffering same fate as Europe
Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by booleandilemma on Sunday September 08, 2019 @10:54AM (#20910896)
I can’t. There’s a solidarity among the states that European countries don’t have. We all speak the same language, use the same websites, listen to the same music, and watch the same movies. We’re not just going to start killing each other.
Re:The End of the Roman Empire Wasn’t That Bad by _iyig on Sunday September 08, 2019 @12:48PM (#20911626)
It can happen here. Neighbors in the former Yugoslavia socialized together and got along well until the day they didn’t. I suggest the graphic novel “Safe Area Gorazde” for an account of this.

Also, it happened here once before.