Forgive me, I don't understand your last sentence. It sounds contradictory vs "they got a lot more productive".
What would happen is the shop would start thrashing with people switching from one task to another trying to hurry one unit through production. You eat the setup time for each production task for exactly one unit.
Yeah, I misread your comment as saying they rushed units in before lunch :D :D
They got fewer returns/defects when they stopped rushing.
I realize that now. I initially read it as they rushed to get things done before lunch everyday. Oops!
Your choices are often between these two:
1. Higher throughput, higer latency and correctness on one side.
2. Lower throughput, lower latency and some risk of faults on the other side.
It's like the difference between tcp and udp.
The question is: Where do you need to be? What are your requirements?
After they started enforcing that they got a lot more productive and started shipping on time much more often. Turns out the mad rush to meet an arbitrary deadline absolutely kills productivity.