I have a hard time believing that because so few sites opt out of Google indexing.
Google has been providing results right in search, meaning that I no longer need to click a link. I would say 80% of my searches are answered by the knowledge graph and smart answers.
In the past, Google created value for website owners by both directing traffic towards them, and sharing ad revenue with them. Now it's doing neither.
While a business can control the information on it's website, it can't control the information on Google's, and often that is not to consumers' benefit.
They generally do compensate web sites. For example, when I ask for today's weather, it comes from weather.com and if I ask for the exchange rate for Canadian dollars, it comes from Morningstar. Both of those companies have a deal with Google to provide that information.
The FTC found that Google illegally took content from competitors, but Google was able to lobby away any punitive action: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/mar/20/google-il...
If they do compensate any web sites it's only because the sites are too big to steal from or because they were sued and lost.
> Nobody's answer is going to be to refuse the crumbs.
Except those that think about opportunity cost.
Google's instant answers is a case of them putting the user first and that's hardly ever the wrong decision.
Instant answers is a direct threat to organized knowledge on the Internet, and that can't, by definition, be putting the user first. When we look at my link in my original comment, we discover that instant answers gets Google a larger percentage of the ad money (all of it), and suddenly, we figure out who Google is putting first: Google.
I think your worry about this overblown. If Google doesn't do a good job with these, then that's an opportunity for somebody to do a better job.
If you are stuck on an ad-supported model from the days of the dot-com boom, then I'm not sure you have a place in the current ecosystem where a lot of searches are started with a voice query and the user expects a short, definitive answer. The ever increasing number of searches that result in no clicks is surely influenced by the rise of Google Assistant, Amazon Echo, Siri, etc...
I don't think it holds up for commercial sites, but for news, hobbies, and blogs (which have been hit hardest by Google's vampire advertisement business) your statement is true for me!
1. User opens the browser, which defaults to the correct website the user is looking for.
2. User goes to Google instead, and searches for the company name. Clicks on the link for the company.
3. User navigates through the company website for the exact same page that the browser was set to open to by default.
Most people won't, perhaps, but I run a handful of reasonably popular websites, and I block Google's crawlers. I have no use for Google.
The rest, an implication of a desire for Google to fail even if the entire business model were based around privacy preserving techniques, makes the privacy saber rattling seem disingenuous and a means to a different end.
You could run ML locally.
If you want to know how long patients are waiting, you can just record wait time without recording details of the patient.
This doesn't prevent fingerprinting. If you send me enough data, even if it is not associated with an ID, I can still use that data to deanonymize or track you. People should read the papers on DP instead of just randomly commenting "you could just do X". The security researchers studying the threat models aren't just doing things in an overly complicated way for no reason.
> ML locally
ML training depends heavy on the training data set. You may not have all of the training data, and the training data may involve other people's private data.
Also, your phone is not the best place to run training for a model that takes 8 hours of training time and gobs of memory. However, you can slice up the problem, and people's phones can work together -- Federated Learning, which goes hand in hand with differential privacy.
Again, differential privacy is about finding excuses to justify the existence and protection of a company that is actively harmful to society. And we need to stop pretending your employer cares about it for any reason but protecting ad revenue.
Moreover, there are public safety reasons to use crowdsourcing. To give one very important example, early-warning earthquake detection for example, where seconds of warning are crucial. Millions of people are walking around with mobile seismometers, which in aggregate, could detect with high degree of accuracy, an earthquake as soon as it starts, and notify people within 1-5 seconds. It can only filter out false positives by sampling a vast number of motion sensors over a large area, and such a notification system can only work if it is virtually free of false positives (https://myshake.berkeley.edu/) This technology could save many lives, but needs differential privacy to be secure.
Differential privacy does not exist because of Google, was not invented by Google, and is part of the academic research of the crypto/security community.
I can't speak about my company in aggregate, but I can speak about myself, and I and many of my peers do care about privacy, with cryptographically strong guarantees. I've been doing this for more then 20 years, shipped one of the first anonymizing web proxy servers in 1996, worked on early forms of crypto-currency, remailer and onion networks, long before they hit the public consciousness. The people interested in these things work on them because they believe in them and are passionate. Not everything people work on is done because of ads. Chrome didn't need to ship RAPPOR in 2014, there's no business model for it. Likely, it was driven by people who felt deeply about the need to do it.
The other hyperbolic claims are not worth addressing.
Seriously though it was an insightful read.
It's throwing the baby out with the bath water and too limited of a view for my taste.
Also, only the government can generally turn a plate number into a person's identity reliably (I doubt Google knows my license plate, though I'd be interested to know if they did), and even then, a license plate is far less likely to always identify a given person's movements than their phone's GPS.
Speed cameras in the US aren't just radar, they photograph you, and even mail you a photo of yourself when you're caught speeding. This has lead to famous cases, like when a guy was caught speeding, and his home was mailed a speeding ticket of him in the car with his mistress, which his wife opened the mail.
Seems to me you're now hand waving away the long recognized danger of government surveillance, as in, actual danger, wherein government sanctions you based on surveillance, as opposed to theoretical dangers of someone showing you a Nike ad.
So while you're worrying about GDPR, this is happening: https://www.politico.eu/article/berlin-big-brother-state-sur...
The government has problems but trends towards the people's benefit in the long run. Corporate greed trends towards enriching the lives of sick and disturbing rich men like Larry and Sergey.
Corporations are a far worse and far less regulated threat than government, with far less checks and balances in place to protect us. Throwing out the government bogeyman hasn't worked on me before and isn't going to work on me now.
This is exactly what I would say about someone cozily working at Google in Silicon Valley. I literally deal with the costs imposed on seniors and less technically literate users by Google's ad nightmare on a daily basis.
And before you get high and mighty about how bad the government is compared to Google, remember that Google is built upon and protected by that very same government, and that Google's NetPAC is actively contributing chunks of many Googler paychecks (perhaps even yours?) to fund the very worst members of that government: https://twitter.com/Pinboard/status/1164945275066056704
I've rate-limited your account again and we will ban you again if you keep using HN as a platform like this. I know your views are sincere, but the way you pursue them has obviously left intellectual curiosity behind a long time ago. Worse, inundating HN threads with whatever agenda you're prosecuting has a destructive effect on the discussions. This is not cool, and has happened more than once before (e.g. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17216664). This is not a site for platforms, agendas, megaphones, campaigns, or harangues. It's for thoughtful conversation about curious things: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
Since the mechanics of the internet will now lead others to accuse me of pro-Google bias, I'll add that we've repeatedly banned accounts for pro-Google agenda-ness just the same way. Our concern is not Google or any other $Bigcorp, it's protecting HN.
Hand waving away US government's vastly more destructive tendencies, and the demonstrated abuses of government surveillance doesn't strike me as helpful. On the long laundry list of bad things Trump is guilty of, misogyny sits below the current proxy war in Yemen which started under Obama but has been boosted by Trump and Kushner.
It's now up to almost 100k dead, 45k wounded, and an incredible 84,000 children dead from starvation.
But hey, we have checks and balances on this right, thanks to FOIA? Can we get Trump's tax returns yet?
How do you know the cameras aren't recording? How do you know the resolution isn't lowered before being made public? How do you know there aren't other cameras that aren't made public?
If you're going to use a threat model that assumes malice on a "trusted" organization, you should do so for all such organizations: whether they be google or a government. It's only if you assume google isn't trustworthy, but governments are, that your threat model makes sense.
If you don't make that particular set of assumptions (and even if you do in many cases!) differential privacy is a net win.
FOIA. That falls into the whole part where government has checks and balances that Google does not.
How are those FOIA requests for stingray usage and tracking information going? Still blocked, last I checked. Like I keep saying: these arguments only work if you assume that the usg is all sunshine and rainbows, which is a naive assumption to make.
If you're willing to call NetPAC bad, which you do, you've got to agree that it's only bad if the people taking money do so and support the $badthings you claim google does, by not outlawing them. But if they're corrupt enough to do that, why aren't they corrupt enough to torpedo a few FOIA requests?
To put it another way if google is so bad, and you can't even get the USG to police google, how can you expect them to police themselves?
This was a recent story I read: https://cdt.org/blog/digital-is-different-pole-camera-ruling...
Meanwhile, Google hid Dragonfly from the internal team that was supposed to review it's projects for ethics issues. And it was pressure from journalists, and then the US Congress that inevitably forced Google to shut it down.
Thankfully, despite NetPAC, it looks like enforcement for Google is finally coming. The hand of justice moves slow, unfortunately, but it eventually gets there.
No. It was pressure from employees, employees who had ethical concerns. Employees who, I'll note, you consistently badmouth for continuing to work at Google. It's not like a journalist just magically inferred that Dragonfly was a thing one day and wrote an article one day. And Congress had almost nothing to do with it, lmao.
> The government doesn't "police themselves", the system of checks and balances ensures one branch polices another
That's true for things that aren't FOIA. But you mentioned FOIA. Which exists as a way for the executive to police themselves. The courts do exist as a check on the executive, (and local governments). So again, how are those stingray FOIA requests going? Note also that "law enforcement" is an FOIA exemption.
> This was a recent story I read: https://cdt.org/blog/digital-is-different-pole-camera-ruling....
This was a targeted piece of tracking that requires a warrant. Dragnet monitoring often does not require a warrant. In other words, setting up a single camera to monitor a single house needs a warrant. Setting up a hundred cameras to monitor the public doesn't, although getting data from them to target a specific person might, at least if it was being used to imprison them. When was the last time Google imprisoned anyone again?
It's also really, really amusing to see you claim that Google is subject to no public accountability. There are absolutely ways you could try to hold Google accountable, if you actually think that they've done something wrong. You just need to be able to convince a Judge. Same as for the executive branch of the government.
But apart from that leak, it was Congress, not employees, that shut down Dragonfly. Google is happy to dismiss employee concerns, as they've done over and over again. But after Sundar was dragged into Congress and repeatedly questioned about helping China, shockingly, Dragonfly disappeared. It's very revisionist to suggest Google shut it down to placate their own employees, rather than avoid action from Congress.
Remember that after some 20% of Google's employees walked out with a list of demands, Google dismissed 6/7ths of those demands without any further comment on the matter... and the employees didn't do anything further to retaliate. Google is well aware that ignoring employee complaints works, but ignoring Congress does not.
People can barely get their stuff back from civil asset forfeiture. Local and state governments are often far more corrupt and less transparent.
Meanwhile, I'd like to request Google's search algorithm, and any emails revolving Google's discussion of searches for "mapquest". Any takers?
Which is to say, suggesting FOIA isn't all-inclusive is a pretty bad logical fallacy, when Google is subject to no public accountability whatsoever.
https://www.aclu.org/issues/criminal-law-reform/reforming-po...
"For people whose property has been seized through civil asset forfeiture, legally regaining such property is notoriously difficult and expensive, with costs sometimes exceeding the value of the property. "
Anyone with a long history on the internet, and in civil libertarian, privacy, and security circles would be aware of the long history of abuses, including targeting internet activists. Local law firms in the 80s and 90s, often pushed local governments to use CAF to seize computers from people suspected of piracy or hacking, often without evidence or conviction.
In a country with the highest per capita incarceration rate in the modern world, with a trail of dead and damaged bodies around the globe from military adventures, with systemic racism still in force today, and kids separated from parents and held in internment camps, some unable to even be reunited with parents and turned into orphans, I don't want to hear how easy it is to reign in our government because the evidence suggests restraint has been largely a failure.
The fact of the matter is, our government is not being checked and balanced, not by the legislatures, not by the fifth estate (news media), and not by the people. So on my hierarchy of needs: fighting climate change, war, poverty, gun violence, racism, disease, malnourishment, lack of access to healthcare and education, all of which are being held up by forces that have captured the government and by the apathy of the people and even the news media these days, your obsession that ad targeting is the top evil, and that the other things will be taken care of by oversight, rings hollow.
We are still living with the Patriot Act, the AUMF, National Security Letters, the Five Eyes agreements that enable problems like MUSCULAR, and that's been going on for 18 years now. Do I think FOIA requests will reign this in? Even Snowden didn't really reign it i much. And things like widespread automatic license plate readers and face detection being used by local governments, like with the voting machine changes, gerrymandering, and voter suppression, will largely be installed with only a wimper.
FWIW, that's how I read this too: If Google can get people on the "Differential Privacy"† bandwagon it diffuses their own culpability.
(I think privacy is effectively dead, so from my POV this DF BS is just propping up its corpse.)
†In practice, "Differential Privacy" is a euphemism for "no privacy".
We don't usually call something infeasible "a solution", especially it means a fundamental structural change without giving a viable alternative to power a 300B market. So tell me, what is your proposal to give an approximately similar amount of efficiency to the market? If you don't have the one, that's fine but your criticism doesn't really resonate since at least Google tries to improve the status quo.
I don't see Google trying to do that at all. I see them trying to ensure that the status quo will never change.
Which market are you referring to?
Advertising? Search engines? Other?
Update: Bueller?
Why would that happen? DP is a compromise. For people who are concerned about data collection, surely "none" is preferable to that compromise.
I'd love a tool like differential privacy to gather statistics in a provably anonymous way. Without a tool like that, only companies with shedloads of money (like Google, Microsoft, Apple) can afford the market research (or the amount of spaghetti to throw at the wall) to compete.
Why? They're paying moneys through conversions, which is a pretty significant commitment and proof of its usefulness. You can argue that there's no real incrementality here, but I can tell you that at least half of ad revenues in general very likely have causal relationships from my observation.
We can't instrument websites and applications. Data, once collected, never dies and nobody can be sure of where it will end up. We have to stop. The model itself is broken. Now it's up to the public policy folks to figure a way to get us out of this mess. I am not optimistic in the short run.
In a world where Google is now hurting content creators and site owners more than it is helping them[1], I see no reason to help Google via differential privacy when outright blocking tracking data is a viable solution.
[1] https://sparktoro.com/blog/less-than-half-of-google-searches...