News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Problem with Believing What We’re Told by dqpb on Monday September 02, 2019 @04:03PM (#20861446)
I think there is an information theoretic explanation for this.

The content of fake news tends to be more surprising than factual news. It is surprising because it is less likely.

Generally speaking, the more unlikely a message is, the more information it carries. Thus, fake news appears to have higher information content then factual news to people unable to detect that it's fake.

Re:The Problem with Believing What We’re Told by dredmorbius on Monday September 02, 2019 @05:53PM (#20862013)
Fake news isn't bound to the limits of truth.

Fake news can be generated with far greater volume than truth.

Fake news can be specifically engineered to appeal to various cognitive biases promoting virality.

Truth serves reality. Falsehood can, and very often does, serve specific partisan interests who have a hand in promoting its spread.

These are four powerful factors favouring falsehoods and their dissemination.

Re:The Problem with Believing What We’re Told by popularwarfare on Monday September 02, 2019 @07:01PM (#20862342)
What you have to come to terms with is that there is not a single 'objective' truth but multiple often contradictory truths. Individual Perception and psychology in addition to cultural and social norms play a large role as well.
Re:The Problem with Believing What We’re Told by TeMPOraL on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @05:22AM (#20864887)
> there is not a single 'objective' truth but multiple often contradictory truths

This is something that's usually said by people who want you to drop your defenses and believe in lies they concocted.

To the best of my knowledge, there's nothing we've seen so far that would suggest we aren't all inhabiting the same, shared, physical universe - so there is objective truth. There are facts about the world around us, and when you're reporting them accurately, you're reporting the truth. If you deny those facts, you are reporting falsehoods.

Now one of those facts is that we all observe the world through a limited and biased sensory and cognitive apparatus. We can't perceive the entirety of the universe, only a small fraction of it. This sometimes leads to "contradictory truths".

The best analogy I've come up with so far is projections. Imagine the universe as a 3D space, and anything of interest as a 3D shape - but what each of us is observing is 2D projections of it. So there is a cylinder in that universe, representing an issue. I can claim the issue is circular. You can claim the issue is rectangular. We've both identified the true aspects of an issue, but our views are incomplete. Our views combined can help us understand the full form of the issue. But what's most important, if someone comes in and says they see a spiked star, they're just wrong. There's no "multiple often contradictory truths here".

This is the way I like to think about the world and debates on issues. Each of us operates on a set of facts and intuitions that are a result of a heavy dimensionality reduction. We operate on projections. But there is an objective reality, of which our conflicting views are different projections, and that reality makes it so that only some projections are valid, and others are wrong.

And just because an issue is primarily social doesn't mean it's magically not about the observable reality. Human beings are physical, material objects. Just damn complicated ones.

Re:The Problem with Believing What We’re Told by tsimionescu on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @03:28AM (#20864333)
There are many types of events where there exists an objective truth. 'humans went to the moon', for example, is a statement whose truth is objective. You may choose to believe this truth or not, but you can't say 'the truth is more complicated than that'. Of course 'Americans went to the moon to further the human condition' is an example of statement for which there is likely not an objective truth - the terms themselves are fuzzy, people usually have multiple reasons and contradictory feelings about their reasons etc.

So if I post a story claiming Hillary Clinton is running a child sex trafficking ring from a pizza place basement, that is unequivocally false. If I run a story saying Hillary Clinton is an evil person seeking to lead the country astray, that may or may not be true depending on many different factors, definitions, personal beliefs etc. It would be wrong to label it as fake news,for this reason.

Re:The Problem with Believing What We’re Told by AstralStorm on Tuesday September 03, 2019 @11:28AM (#20867466)
It would be an opinion piece, not news. News have to bring new facts, by definition.
Re:The Problem with Believing What We’re Told by dredmorbius on Monday September 02, 2019 @07:10PM (#20862387)
I am very much at terms with that.

There are also deliberate actions, evicenced in documents and testimony, to obscure objective truths. There is a distinction between reasonable differences of opinion, and abject falsehoods.

The principle of anekāntavāda is of many sidedness. It is not of any sidedness.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anekantavada

Re:The Problem with Believing What We’re Told by newnewpdro on Monday September 02, 2019 @04:12PM (#20861482)
Wouldn't we just assume "fake news" is optimized for virality, being a contrivance in the first place.
Re:The Problem with Believing What We’re Told by dqpb on Monday September 02, 2019 @08:58PM (#20862895)
Yes. But the follow-up question is how is this news optimized for virality, moreso then factual news.

I'm suggesting that it has a general information theoretic advantage.

Re:The Problem with Believing What We’re Told by Mathnerd314 on Monday September 02, 2019 @04:21PM (#20861532)
Fiction is more popular than nonfiction generally, roughly 2x according to https://justpublishingadvice.com/is-writing-non-fiction-more..., which is about the effect size of the Twitter study.
Re:The Problem with Believing What We’re Told by yesenadam on Monday September 02, 2019 @10:52PM (#20863375)
>Fiction is more popular than nonfiction generally, roughly 2x

That stat refers to money spent buying new books and ebooks, I think. It excludes e.g. newspapers, journals, magazines, and online reading, like blogs and special-interest websites, doesn't it? An extremely large majority of which is non-fiction, I'm guessing.

Re:The Problem with Believing What We’re Told by smitty1e on Monday September 02, 2019 @04:19PM (#20861527)
The spectacle of seeing a nominal fact-checking site go after an overtly satirical one has been an astounding result for our day.

I like to point out the rose colored glasses of the early internet, when the awesome signal-to-noise ratio was going to have a catalytic effect on human knowledge.

#Whoops

Re:The Problem with Believing What We’re Told by kibibu on Monday September 02, 2019 @05:31PM (#20861912)
Do you remember Bonsai Kitten, and the breathlessly horrified email campaigns against it? People have had difficulty determining real from fake for a long time.
Re:The Problem with Believing What We’re Told by esmi on Monday September 02, 2019 @06:16PM (#20862124)
It’s way older than that. This is just one I know off the top of my head. I’m sure there are many other, older, examples.

https://www.mountvernon.org/george-washington/colonial-life-...

Re:The Problem with Believing What We’re Told by kibibu on Monday September 02, 2019 @11:36PM (#20863542)
Yes of course; but it's the earliest one I remember being a purely online phenomenon that suckered people in.

Besides, of course, the stupid lists of factoids that used to get emailed around - duck quacks don't echo etc.

Re:The Problem with Believing What We’re Told by dredmorbius on Monday September 02, 2019 @06:04PM (#20862070)
I'm increasingly convinced that what I call "naive fact-checking" misses the forest for the trees.

Facts matter, yes. But a false narrative, even, or especially where constructed at least in part on true facts, is vastly more significant.

A characteristic of virtually all Big Lie Narratives is that they contain, often major, nuggets of truth. But the arrangement of narrative amonst these, and eventual insertion of false (or at the very least, unverifiable) facts, eventually proves these out.

A classic example I've run across is "It's All a Rich Man's Lie", an epic 3h 40m YouTube conspiracy yarn which, at least in its first hour or so, sticks largely to the domain of underlying truths: yes, there are "secret societies" at Ivy League schools, yes, many major US industrial firms maintained operations or divisions in Nazi Germany, etc. But no, actually, Kennedy's "Secret Society" speech (mentioned about 20 minutes in) was not about the Yale Skull & Bones group, but instead about the Soviet Union, and its practice of leveraging unflattering or inconvenient reporting from the US itself against the US.

(The question of whether or not Kennedy was right in asking for self-restraint on this basis is a matter for another discussion.)

Often the individual elements and false narrative become apparent by pulling back ever so slightly from the presented story, and looking at the greater context of facts offered. A few paragraphs of surrounding context from the Kennedy speech ("catnip for conspiracy nuts" according to one source) make painfully clear that its topic is not what the conspiracy nuts would make it to be.

The fact that such checking is expensive and takes time makes the fabricators' job all that much easier, and the debunkers' harder.

Another interesting case is the "J.P. Morgan Bankers' Manifesto" hoax, by one Thomas W. Gilruth, first published in 1892, and still making the rounds on social media over 120 years later. I'd run across it by way of an meme whose message appealed to me, though thinking it might be too good to be true, I dug deeper.

To my knowledge, this is the most substantial debunking of the Gilruth hoax ever published:

https://old.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/39w8u4/jp_morg...

Re:The Problem with Believing What We’re Told by rosser on Monday September 02, 2019 @05:45PM (#20861982)