News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Just Delete Me – A directory of direct links to delete yo... by amelius on Monday September 02, 2019 @11:10AM (#20859534)
But why don't they automate it? 1. It's standard practice to have a delete my account option. 2. It's easier for users. 3. It's easier for admins. 4. The presence of the option makes clear that one can delete their account without much trouble. 5. With the option they don't get frowned upon, such as in this case.
Re:Just Delete Me – A directory of direct links to delete yo... by giancarlostoro on Monday September 02, 2019 @11:14AM (#20859570)
In regards to posts you get an hour to edit / delete. Otherwise it stays once it gets replies just to keep history of conversations.

In regards to deleting accounts that is a good question above my responsibilities as a fellow user to answer. I would love to hear from mods about it. It certainly would suck if we see old convos lose context / content over the years.

Re:Just Delete Me – A directory of direct links to delete yo... by tilolebo on Monday September 02, 2019 @11:47AM (#20859805)
You wouldn't need to fully delete all comments: updating the author's name to "deleted user" would already be an improvement.
Re:Just Delete Me – A directory of direct links to delete yo... by jnordwick on Monday September 02, 2019 @11:22AM (#20859632)
I had a post yesterday that I wanted to delete. It was less than 30 minutes since the post, and there was no deleted button, but an older comment slightly more than 30 minutes old still had the delete button.

HN moderation is very secretive and manual, and that introduces a lot of opportunity for bias.

Edit: it's interesting that you cannot delete a comment with a reply, but you can edit it into nothing. I never noticed that. Seems like a useless distinction. So you can also force a comment to exist by just replying quickly so they cannot delete it. Neat trick.

Re:Just Delete Me – A directory of direct links to delete yo... by jolmg on Monday September 02, 2019 @11:28AM (#20859669)
You also can't delete a comment that has replies, so maybe that's what happened.
Re:Just Delete Me – A directory of direct links to delete yo... by jnordwick on Monday September 02, 2019 @03:31PM (#20861298)
Testing, can I delete this after I post a response that I then immediately delete?

Edit: apparently you can delete a comment if the child comment is deleted.

Re:Just Delete Me – A directory of direct links to delete yo... by Hitton on Monday September 02, 2019 @11:27AM (#20859660)
I think that after a comment has a reply, it can no longer be deleted.
Re:Just Delete Me – A directory of direct links to delete yo... by Jaruzel on Monday September 02, 2019 @11:21AM (#20859623)
Sometimes it depends on how the backend data is stored. I'm going to assume that HN uses linked data for your account name against posts and comments...

How do they deal with your delete account request? Do they just remove your account resulting in 'NULL' appearing against all your previous comments and posts? Do they remove all your previous posts and comments as well? This could result in broken comment threads - a workaround would be to replace your comments and posts with '[Deleted]' which could then make child comments lose their context.

If the whole thing was automated, what stops people abusing the system by creating, posting abuse, and then deleting the account? So many questions, and no easy/simple answers.

Deleting an active account on a busy site is rarely just a case of removing the user record from the users table.

Re:Just Delete Me – A directory of direct links to delete yo... by GrumpyNl on Monday September 02, 2019 @11:16AM (#20859585)
Automate it can bring bugs. Automating it can make it hack-able. If you can mail, its enough, gives you some thinking time to.