News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jbk on Saturday January 08, 2011 @07:46AM (#2082955)
Disclaimer: VideoLAN Chairman and lead VLC developer here.

I've written the most important analysis on the matter http://mailman.videolan.org/pipermail/vlc-devel/2010-Novembe... and http://mailman.videolan.org/pipermail/vlc-devel/2010-Decembe...

Some VLC developers (for Mac mainly), with the company Applidium, have ported VLC on iOS. Applidium published it on the store, for free.

Some developer complained (quite lately, btw...) afterwards and quoted a FSF analysis. Their analysis was totally wrong (spoke about redistribution), and based on old version of AppStore terms.

After my remarks about changes of the AppStore terms that made this analysis obsolete and wrong, they shifted their criticism onto another part, which was the "usage" part of the ToS. They complained that the terms did not allow all uses, especially commercial ones.

Indeed, one part could be interpreted in different ways. Therefore, I've mailed Apple Copyright Agent for explanation, twice. Once in November, once in December...

Apple has refused to answer, to explain or to help in any matter. They then decided to pull the Application unilaterally from the AppStore.

Of course, they are allowed to do that, and noone can complain, but this is yet another push from Apple against VLC, that adds to the very long list of past issues. It just makes me think Apple doesn't really want competition...

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by martythemaniak on Saturday January 08, 2011 @11:39AM (#2083303)
Since volumes have been written about Apple's idiotic app store rules already, I just want to say thanks for making one of the best pieces of software out there! I've been happily using it for years and will continue to use it for years on less restrictive platforms.
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jbk on Sunday January 09, 2011 @05:17AM (#2085264)
Thank you...

Hopefully, I'll be able to calm everyone down and put it back on the AppStore...

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by st3fan on Sunday January 09, 2011 @01:32PM (#2085993)
What actions would be necessary to put it back in the store?
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jbk on Wednesday January 12, 2011 @04:48AM (#2095571)
Apple to finally answer the questions...
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jedsmith on Monday January 10, 2011 @01:25PM (#2089245)
An act of God, now.
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by alain94040 on Saturday January 08, 2011 @12:56PM (#2083473)
Apple doesn't have to spend their time discussing with you about legal dispute among copyright holders. If anything, you are lucky that they don't ban the developers who posted the app in the first place. I wouldn't mind a policy that said: "if you ever get us in a copyright dispute, you are banned forever from our store"

Instead, Apple was told that the app had a copyright problem, and it took them 2 months to take it down. Yes, it's slow, but no, they are not evil in doing so.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by commandar on Saturday January 08, 2011 @01:52PM (#2083659)
>"if you ever get us in a copyright dispute, you are banned forever from our store"

Talk about giving power to the trolls.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jarek on Saturday January 08, 2011 @04:58PM (#2084073)
> "if you ever get us in a copyright dispute, you are banned forever from our store"

Hey! Angry Birds stole my intellectual property.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by mambodog on Saturday January 08, 2011 @09:38PM (#2084639)
Maybe the word legitimate should have been in there.
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by danieldon on Saturday January 08, 2011 @10:34PM (#2084733)
That would conflict with "Apple doesn't have to spend their time discussing with you about legal dispute among copyright holders."
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by st3fan on Saturday January 08, 2011 @05:01PM (#2084077)
I just came accross this posting of yours:

http://mailman.videolan.org/pipermail/vlc/2011-January/01979...

Where you say:

"No. Apple decided to remove VLC from the AppStore by themselves."

You are either blatantly lying or you have no idea what actually happened.

Apple responded to a copyright infringement notification like they always do: they removed the app from sale.

This is the direct action of your colleague in the VLC project, Rémi Denis-Courmont.

Stop blaming Apple for removing the app. YOU GUYS, the VLC project, are the ones who are playing this game.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jbk on Sunday January 09, 2011 @05:35AM (#2085281)
First, I still don't understand why you are so aggressive, once again, against me. Then, again, you keep using "YOU GUYS" or "VLC project", which are no people or legal entities, and don't mean anything.

Then, the removal was done by Apple, and not by Applidium nor anyone else.

A complaint was filled by a copyright holder of some code on VLC. He represent himself and has the right to complain. It doesn't mean that his complaint is right, like any complaint.

But, the problem is that Apple has refused to explain the term of service and to help us finding a solution, and after being mute for more than 2,5 month, remove it without warning nor explanation.

So, yes, "Apple decided to remove VLC from the AppStore by themselves", even if you don't like it.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jedsmith on Saturday January 08, 2011 @06:04PM (#2084209)
I'd hope it's a simple misunderstanding, but my gut tells me that this was planned -- I don't see how the VideoLAN guys can suddenly forget that one of their own demanded removal of the application and then vehemently say "we had nothing to do with it!"

This stuff is all public...it makes no sense, honestly.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by st3fan on Saturday January 08, 2011 @06:20PM (#2084239)
It is not all public. Maybe Remi should make all his emails to Apple public. That will probably explain some things.
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by lwhi on Saturday January 08, 2011 @08:42AM (#2083028)
It's this kind of authoritarian behaviour that makes me dislike Apple.
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by st3fan on Saturday January 08, 2011 @10:35AM (#2083181)
Uhhh what happened here is that the VLC guys (specificaly Rémi Denis-Courmont) contacted Apple to urge them to remove the app. So that is what they did.

Kind of weird to blame Apple for following up to a copyright violation.

It is now between VLC and Applidium to figure out how to proceed.

Apple is not part of this. Developers need to play within the bounds of the App Store license terms.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jbk on Saturday January 08, 2011 @11:10AM (#2083254)
Totally not.

A VLC developer complained to Apple about a copyright violation in October.

Apple pulled it unilaterally yesterday, after more than 2 months of silence, after refusing to help people, notably me, to solve the matter. So, Apple is definitively "part of this".

Not to mention that you are speaking about "VLC" which doesn't mean anything, since it isn't a legal entity.

And to finish "AppStore license terms" change all the time... So it is hard to "play within the bounds".

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jedsmith on Saturday January 08, 2011 @02:24PM (#2083731)
> Apple pulled it unilaterally yesterday, after more than 2 months of silence, after refusing to help people, notably me, to solve the matter.

Of course they did. It took them two months to process the complaint after one of the VideoLAN developers made it, but they followed through on an action that "a VLC developer" initiated.

With respect, if a developer representing VideoLAN complains to Apple, and another developer representing VideoLAN and claiming to be in charge approaches and tries to "work it out", Apple is not going to step into what appears to be an internal dispute. I am never an Apple apologist as I think they're a bit heavy-handed with the App Store, but in this case, how would you expect them to act?

This is what "a VLC developer" wanted, and he got it. I don't think Apple is the bad guy here in the slightest. I hope you're not trying to shift blame from the developer who initiated this to an easy target, Apple, because your original comment in this thread would make it appear that way.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jbk on Sunday January 09, 2011 @05:20AM (#2085268)
> Apple is not going to step into what appears to be an internal dispute

No, here, the dispute was from one copyright holder against the distributor, Apple.

> how would you expect them to act?

Very simply, by answering to the mails asking for clarifications on the ToS, so a solution could have come up.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by st3fan on Sunday January 09, 2011 @09:22AM (#2085504)
"simply, by answering to the mails asking for clarifications on the ToS, so a solution could have come up."

Yeah, but unfortunately one of your team members, Rémi Denis-Courmont, had already used the nuclear option: informing Apple about a copyright infringement and asking them to remove the app from the store. So that is what Apple did.

The problem is that you guys are not working as a team. One person, Remi, is extremely bitter about this app being on the store (see the wording of his messages and that last blog post) and basically wants it to disappear forever.

I do not see any signals that Remi is approaching this the same way as you. You seem to want to resolve this, he just wants the app to be gone and never appear again.

You keep saying that there is no such thing as 'VLC the legal entity'. And that is probably how it looks from Apple's perspective: one guy requests the app to be removed, some other random person is trying to fix things.

In other words: you guys messed this up by not being a coherent team. Remi should have NEVER EVER sent that message. You guys should have come to agreement and worked with Apple as a team.

Fixing this is probably possible, but it requires cooperation from Rémi Denis-Courmont. You guys (here I say it again) will probably have to send a more formal letter to Apple to retract the initial complaint and then see if you can work together to fix this or to be more lenient and to simply say: we know this situation is not ideal, but thinking of millions of users who are using our software, we are going to let this happen anyway to see if we things can change in the longer term.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jbk on Sunday January 09, 2011 @10:12AM (#2085570)
> "you guys messed this up by not being a coherent team"

See it like that if you want. But the fact is that in project without copyright assignment, anyone can make things go haywire...

To close the matter, because this takes ridiculously too much of my time: Rémi sent a message 2,5 months ago; Apple refused to answer my questions to solve the matter in the meantime; and then Apple removed the application without telling anyone in before.

Turn it in away way you want, I still don't find Apple's way a correct (nor polite) way, and I don't care if they get bad PR for that.

In the end, people getting screwed up are the users...

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by st3fan on Sunday January 09, 2011 @11:05AM (#2085648)
"In the end, people getting screwed up are the users..."

Thank you for that insight. I just wish you guys had thought of that before filing copyright infringements.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jbk on Sunday January 09, 2011 @11:49AM (#2085737)
Seriously, why do you keep using "You guys"?

I've explained to you many times, that "You guys" doesn't mean anything and that one developer did complain alone. And that noone can control all developers in a non-copyright assignment project...

Your attitude is really annoying, and very aggressive around the whole thread...

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by lambda on Sunday January 09, 2011 @02:05AM (#2085054)
> Apple is not part of this

Apple is absolutely part of this. Apple is the party that has released a platform that you cannot install software on without going through them for permission (unless you jailbreak it using a remote-root vulnerability which is patched in more recent releases). Apple is the party that decides what can be in its app store under what rules; and it has decided to use a set of rules that are incompatible with the GPL. Apple has thus chosen to limit the software that is installable on their platform.

Apple could choose to allow VLC; they have the choice of making their terms compatible with the GPL (it's not that hard; just don't impose any additional restrictions on top of the ones that the GPL already imposes, and let the authors handle the rest of the GPL's requirements), or enabling people to side-load apps outside of the App store. Google does both on Android; the market terms are compatible with the GPL, and they allow side-loading (and even rooting on some phones).

However Apple chooses not to do this. Thus, Apple is limiting the set of software that can be used on their phone. If you use an iPhone (or iPad, or iPod Touch), you should be aware of this; you may not ever be able to get some software on it without cracking your phone's security, and Apple may be arbitrary and capricious in what they choose to allow and disallow. Apple may also remotely disable and uninstall software or content that is on your phone. If you want to choose what to install on your own phone, you should either buy a phone that gives you more freedom, or jailbreak your phone and then install whatever you want.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by adaml_623 on Saturday January 08, 2011 @08:23PM (#2084501)
Haha I think it's actually a case of Apple should make it's App Store license and operations more flexible. And clearer. And be more communicative.

I'm actually serious about all the above points.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by anigbrowl on Saturday January 08, 2011 @07:36PM (#2084397)
the VLC guys (specificaly Rémi Denis-Courmont) contacted Apple to urge them to remove the app

Citation please.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by st3fan on Sunday January 09, 2011 @09:32AM (#2085520)
See http://mailman.videolan.org/pipermail/vlc-devel/2010-October...

It is funny how Jean-Baptiste Kempf keeps telling us here that there is no 'VLC legal entity' but at the same time Rémi sends out messages like the above in a press release style as if they are officially coming from the 'VLC Group'.

Anyway, Apple was contacted because of a copyright infringement. As anyone who has experience with the App Store knows, their action is then to simply pull the app, inform the developer (which is Applidium in this case and NOT VLC) and then leave the matter in the hands of those parties.

As far as Apple is concerned this matter is over. Until Applidium contacts them (because they are the ones having a contract with Apple) with a good reason to allow the app back in the store.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by lwhi on Saturday January 08, 2011 @10:46AM (#2083206)
Apple needs to be willing to discuss issues.

Too often, their position can be summarised as 'my way, or the highway'.

--

Apple is not part of this. Developers need to play within the bounds of the App Store license terms

No - Apple needs to be accountable to an impartial regulatory body.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by st3fan on Saturday January 08, 2011 @11:23AM (#2083273)
"Apple needs to be willing to discuss issues. Too often, their position can be summarised as 'my way, or the highway'."

Well, it is their platform and their store. If you think the rules are unfair then you can also develop for other platforms.

First, Apple had ZERO problems with approving VLC and getting it on the store. The app is gone now, but that is not because Apple changed their position, they simply responded to an alledged copyright/license issue reported by the original owner of the code.

The reason that the app has been removed is because the VLC developers, specifially Rémi Denis-Courmont, has requested Apple to remove the app from the store because of what license conflicts.

They would respond in exactly the same way if the GPL were not involved.

Seriously, Apple is currently working in the best interest of the claimed rights holder of VLC: it removed the app so that VLC and Applidium can figure this out.

This is not a case of Apple Against GPL: As soon as Applidium and VLC think they can actually work with the terms of the GPL and App Store then they can send that message to Apple and resubsmit the app.

I sure hope they do, but from what I've seen so far, the VLC folks seem to be extremely anti-Apple. We all lose. Thanks VLC.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by lwhi on Saturday January 08, 2011 @11:42AM (#2083312)
Well, it is their platform and their store. [..]

I often hear this rhetoric provided as the de facto reason for why Apple (and other corporations governing IP-marketplaces) should be able to do whatever they like.

If this was true - why can't a telecommunications company operate in whichever way they choose? Why do we have regulatory frameworks which address the problem of monopolies or the formation of cartels?

Because sometimes corporations aren't working in the interest of the public at large; and they need to operate within a larger framework which has been put in place for the benefit of society.

To enable them to do so effectively - traditionally, regulatory bodies are put in place to oversee good practice.

I hope the same happens to regulate these new IP-focused marketplaces.

--

[..] If you think the rules are unfair then you can also develop for other platforms.

I don't think this is necessarily true.

People (customers, developers and businesses) have to invest a great deal of time, effort and money when they choose to develop for (or make use of) a specific platform.

Switching is expensive - and eventually common sense dictates that its more likely that those who have invested, are likely to put up with rules and regulations which they might otherwise see as unfair.

Also, once a developer has produced their iOS-based product - they are forced to sell through one marketplace; the Apple AppStore - which is also cause for concern in my opinion.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by redial on Saturday January 08, 2011 @01:06PM (#2083501)
Telecommunications companies have a regulatory body because their market is a 'granted monopoly'. They have a pseudo monopoly in the sense that for any other company to compete would require a giant initial investment, and possibly a concession from the government, as is the case in wireless communications, so immediately they have all the customers. The government says, ok, will lets you use this spectrum, but you play by our rules.

It's not the same as in IP-marketplaces, or any other kind of marketplace for that matter. As long as they are not violating any law, the government should not try to regulate them, it doesn't matter how invested society is in it.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by lwhi on Saturday January 08, 2011 @01:18PM (#2083553)
The world is changing; I believe that as we become more dependent on digital technologies, new legal frameworks need to be discussed and evolved.

It's not the same as in IP-marketplaces, or any other kind of marketplace for that matter. As long as they are not violating any law, the government should not try to regulate them, it doesn't matter how invested society is in it.

But why? - this is an opinion, not a fact.

Apple is acting as a self-governing private regulator of a marketplace - digital technologies have allowed this situation to become viable .. in the past markets have been inherently more 'free' due to their non-digital nature.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by redial on Saturday January 08, 2011 @02:06PM (#2083694)
It is not an opinion, it is in the law. The government has no law to enforce in a case like this one. That is why they don't tell Walmart what to sell. As much as they want them to only sell american made goods, they don't have any law preventing Walmart to sell china's merchandise. And that is why they can regulate the telecommunications industry, because they have laws that let them.

"The world is changing; I believe that as we become more dependent on digital technologies, new legal frameworks need to be discussed and evolved."

This might be the case, and I partially agree with you. But as it stands now, Apple are not doing anything wrong.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by lwhi on Saturday January 08, 2011 @02:28PM (#2083741)
I suppose much of this rests on whether you believe Apple is operating a 'store' or a marketplace.

It's complicated - I realise where the law currently stands; however, I feel that the law might need to be amended.

I believe the AppStore is a privately regulated marketplace operating within the free-market. This type of scenario is likely to become more commonplace in the future.

I can understand how the subject of the free-market (and possible government intervention) is at odds with a lot of people's politics, but I think the potential for abuse from the private sector is too great to ignore.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by sigzero on Saturday January 08, 2011 @09:00PM (#2084575)
Then developers can go play in another marketplace if they want. It's a totally "opt in" scenario.
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by lwhi on Saturday January 08, 2011 @09:40PM (#2084646)
In my opinion; if this model of commerce becomes much more popular, this excuse isn't going to be able to last.

Although it's a very extreme example - a sweatshop is often opt-in. There are circumstances where opt-in means nothing.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by sigzero on Saturday January 08, 2011 @08:58PM (#2084571)
"Apple is acting as a self-governing private regulator of a marketplace"

No no, not "a marketplace". It is "their marketplace" and it is an "opt in" marketplace at that.

There is zero reason to invite any kind of regulation into that.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by lwhi on Saturday January 08, 2011 @09:42PM (#2084651)
It's a privately regulated marketplace operating within the free-market.

It seems quite obvious to me why this can prove to be problematic in many scenarios, but I understand why many would disagree.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jonhendry on Saturday January 08, 2011 @02:19PM (#2083720)
"Also, once a developer has produced their iOS-based product - they are forced to sell through one marketplace"

They know that going in. Nobody's putting a gun to their head and forcing them to write iOS apps. If they finish their app and only then figure this out, they're too stupid to be writing software.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by lwhi on Saturday January 08, 2011 @02:38PM (#2083767)
Apple can change (and has changed) the terms and conditions of entry to the AppStore without notice.
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jonhendry on Saturday January 08, 2011 @04:04PM (#2083957)
Sure, but still, they know up front that they are essentially dependent on Apple's good graces. They know it's the App Store or nothing.

It's a risk. But then, there's also a risk that someone else will put out a better equivalent app first and win all the mindshare. Or that many different equivalent apps will ship first, and their app will have a hard time getting noticed.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by lwhi on Saturday January 08, 2011 @04:34PM (#2084031)
Well, I suppose this is essentially what I'm arguing for:

I think that this situation is less than desirable. Apple (and corporations in general) shouldn't be able to artificially influence how a (sub)market functions.

If this is accepted, I think the only logical way to stop these situations from occurring is via legislation or regulation.

It's not an ideal solution, but then - the alternative (of doing nothing) is even less ideal in my opinion.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jbk on Sunday January 09, 2011 @05:23AM (#2085273)
> This is not a case of Apple Against GPL: As soon as Applidium and VLC think they can actually work with the terms of the GPL and App Store then they can send that message to Apple and resubsmit the app.

Yes, and I hope that is what is going to happen...

> I sure hope they do, but from what I've seen so far, the VLC folks seem to be extremely anti-Apple. We all lose. Thanks VLC.

VLC has been on the mac platform since the very early days of OSX and was for a long time the only solution to play DVDs on Mac. VLC folks are not anti-Apple...

The problem is that each copyright holder has the right to do what he wants, because developers keep their authorship rights...

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by sigzero on Saturday January 08, 2011 @10:56AM (#2083228)
"No - Apple needs to be accountable to an impartial regulatory body."

That is a ridiculous assumption.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by lwhi on Saturday January 08, 2011 @11:06AM (#2083246)
May I ask why my opinion is ridiculous?

Other industries (telecommunications for example) have regulatory bodies which oversee good practice.

I don't see why it's ridiculous to imagine a regulatory body overseeing good practice for privately created IP-focused marketplaces.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by raganwald on Saturday January 08, 2011 @12:23PM (#2083400)
It's not ridiculous, but it's also not compatible with the principles of free markets that are in force in Canada and the USA at this time.

Apple is not a monopoly. It has a monopoly over those who choose to be its customers and those who choose to be its developers, but that is no different than saying that Levis has a monopoly over the black jeans that Steve Jobs wears.

Things become different when someone can show that Apple has a monopoly position over an entire market, or that Apple's product or service is an essential product or service.

For example, although there is plenty of competition amongst landlords for apartments, most jurisdictions have specific laws that limit the enforceable provisions of a lease.

At this moment in time, I don't personally see Apple enjoying a monopoly position in its market, not do I see video player applications as an essential good or service.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by lwhi on Saturday January 08, 2011 @12:57PM (#2083476)
It's not ridiculous, but it's also not compatible with the principles of free markets that are in force in Canada and the USA at this time.

I agree, regulation has traditionally been put in place to deal with the creation of monopolies.

Personally - I think the question of whether Apple's AppStore constitutes a monopoly is a grey area. They are the only company authorised to sell applications developed for iOS. Supporters of Apple's current policy would argue that other application platforms are available.

To this, I would offer the counter-argument that prior investment (time/money/effort) encourages developers and customers to stick with (and put up with) most rules Apple decides to enforce. Choice is (theoretically) available, but many developers and users will be placed in a situation where there they aren't.

--

These IP-marketplaces are new - and, as with most things that are digitally-based, a great deal of power is available to whoever is in charge. More power, provides more scope for abuse.

I think that some kind of regulation - either through new legislation or a regulatory body needs to be provided.

--

Lastly - as Apple isn't providing a free-market to those who sell through it's AppStore, isn't it a little ironic that a desire for free-market economics is provided as a reason against regulation?

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by Anechoic on Saturday January 08, 2011 @01:12PM (#2083520)
I think the question of whether Apple's AppStore constitutes a monopoly is a grey area.

Not even close to a grey area unless you want to argue that Nike has a monopoly on athletic shoes that have the Nike 'swoosh.'

To this, I would offer the counter-argument that prior investment (time/money/effort) encourages developers and customers to stick with (and put up with) most rules Apple decides to enforce. Choice is (theoretically) available, but many developers and users will be placed in a situation where there they aren't.

How is that different from pretty much every other market where some business decides to create a product that relies on another business' product?

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by lwhi on Saturday January 08, 2011 @01:48PM (#2083644)
Not even close to a grey area unless you want to argue that Nike has a monopoly on athletic shoes that have the Nike 'swoosh.'

In what way is Nike's swoosh comparable to Apple's AppStore?

I think the situation is much more complex; we're talking about a privately regulated marketplace within the free-market.

--

How is that different from pretty much every other market where some business decides to create a product that relies on another business' product?

A single company can be in complete control of a marketplace - this isn't so possible in non-digital market without help from an organisation like the Mafia.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by ghshephard on Saturday January 08, 2011 @10:13PM (#2084708)
There is no difference (in this context) between a digital and non-digital market. Apple provides a curated store to sell apps for their IOS devices. Their market, so they get to chose the rules. If you wanted to go sell products in Costco, or Walmart, you would have to play by their rules.

If you, as a developer, or user, don't like those rules, then thankfully we have superb open source operating systems, such as Linux, and OpenBSD that give you almost 100% freedom to build, sell, and use the applications of your choice.

In fact, if you have a jail-broken IOS device, then you can even purchase apps for those devices from places other than Apple's curated store.

The Droid, RIM, and WP7 platforms also provide varying degrees of freedom.

If, in fact, Apple had a defacto monopoly, then their behavior might come under some form of legislative oversight - but, they certainly don't have a Monopoly on the mobile computing platform, and we really don't need some external body providing regulatory oversight as to what/how Apple should approve applications landing in the store.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by lwhi on Sunday January 09, 2011 @06:41AM (#2085340)
"There is no difference (in this context) between a digital and non-digital market."

There is a huge difference between a digital and non-digital market. In a digital market - one company can control (or curate) everything that occurs. This kind of control has only been made possible by digital technology.

--

"If you wanted to go sell products in Costco, or Walmart, you would have to play by their rules."

Costco or Walmart purchase products which they later resell. The AppStore provides an economic space where people can sell direct to the consumer. There's a distinction.

If I produce a product that can be sold in Costco or Walmart - and I don't like their policies, I can take my product and sell it elsewhere.

If I produce a product for sale via the AppStore, and I don't like their policies I have to redevelop my product to sell it via a different marketplace.

--

"If you, as a developer, or user, don't like those rules, then thankfully we have superb open source operating systems, such as Linux, and OpenBSD that give you almost 100% freedom to build, sell, and use the applications of your choice."

We're talking about the emerging IP-marketplaces, which are currently only viable for a handful of commercially operated platforms. The problem isn't that commerce is allowed to take place - it's that the rules of commerce can be artificially influenced by a corporation.

--

"In fact, if you have a jail-broken IOS device, then you can even purchase apps for those devices from places other than Apple's curated store."

This isn't a desirable scenario for many users, and isn't an economically viable market for many developers.

--

"The Droid, RIM, and WP7 platforms also provide varying degrees of freedom."

The problem is, there are no safeguards in place to stop these other platform vendors from artificially influencing the economic sub-markets associated with their own platforms.

A situation could quite easily develop where platform vendors unanimously agree to progress in a direction that inhibits developer (and/or user) freedoms. What happens then?

There is definitely a barrier to entry to the platform vendor market - because a huge amount of capital is needed get a business into a position where it can compete with the larger players.

--

"If, in fact, Apple had a defacto monopoly, then their behavior might come under some form of legislative oversight - but, they certainly don't have a Monopoly on the mobile computing platform, and we really don't need some external body providing regulatory oversight as to what/how Apple should approve applications landing in the store."

I think we need a body regulating the behaviour of all emerging curated IP-marketplaces. Digital commerce is very open to abuse - measures need to be put in place now while the stakes are relatively low.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by sigzero on Saturday January 08, 2011 @02:50PM (#2083792)
Thanks, you answered better than I could. I used "ridiculous" and that was not quite the right word.
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by lwhi on Saturday January 08, 2011 @03:30PM (#2083876)
touché ;)
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by Anechoic on Saturday January 08, 2011 @11:30AM (#2083286)
telecommunications for example

Telecommunications (in the USA) used publicly-owned airwaves and in too-many cases have de facto or de jure monopolies. Neither applies to Apple.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by lwhi on Saturday January 08, 2011 @12:05PM (#2083368)
Which other company can I use to sell my iOS-based application?
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by Anechoic on Saturday January 08, 2011 @01:10PM (#2083510)
If you're going to define "monopoly" and "platform" than the word monopoly loses all meaning. If I create a business making 3rd-party wire harnesses for VW Passat and VW decides to change to a different harness and that change would kill my business, should there be some regulatory body that can force VW to stick to its old tech?
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by lwhi on Saturday January 08, 2011 @02:35PM (#2083761)
If VW actively encouraged tens of thousands of people to form businesses developing and selling harnesses, perhaps there should.
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jad on Saturday January 08, 2011 @12:59PM (#2083478)
iOS or iOS-based devices are not a market. Smartphones or tablet computers or personal computers are markets.

Consider that the government concern with Microsoft in the 90s wasn't its monopoly position in "Windows," which is tautological, but PC operating systems broadly, which includes Linux and Macs.

The smartphone and tablet computer markets are among the most competitive in the country right now. By definition this means no one has a monopoly.

[deleted]
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by innernette on Saturday January 08, 2011 @03:10PM (#2083832)
This is a core issue in antitrust. One factor is the SSNIP test. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SSNIP

"The relevant market consists of a 'catalogue' of goods and/or services which are considered substitutes by the customer. Such a catalogue is considered 'worth monopolising' if should only one single supplier provided it, that supplier could profitably increase its price without its customers turning away and choosing other goods and services from other suppliers."

So the question is this: if Apple were to increase its share of revenue by 5% to 10%, would developers move to Android, BlackBerry, or WP7? Absolutely. Even at the current level, there is plenty of cross-over between Android and iOS applications. In antitrust terms, the AppStore is not a market.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by lwhi on Saturday January 08, 2011 @03:43PM (#2083907)
Sorry, I deleted my previous response as I wasn't sure it was adding to the discussion - I've added the original text below.

Thanks for the clarification - but how can you be sure that developers would move platforms?

--

I'd like to know what your definition of a market and marketplace is.

I'd define a market as a place (or economic 'space') where people sell a related class of products or services.

I'm not defining an iOS or iOS-based device as a market. I'm referring to the market for iOS applications (i.e. the AppStore).

Why is the AppStore not a marketplace?

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by ptomato on Saturday January 08, 2011 @12:32PM (#2083423)
You can, however, develop for plenty of different smartphones.
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by lwhi on Saturday January 08, 2011 @01:10PM (#2083512)
To avoid duplicating too much information, the second part of this reply[1] provides reasons why don't feel this is necessarily a good argument.

[1] http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2083312

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by maximilianburke on Saturday January 08, 2011 @12:42PM (#2083446)
Or, from the consumer's point of view, what other service can I use to buy iOS applications?
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by redial on Saturday January 08, 2011 @11:09AM (#2083252)
And the position of some of the VLC developers isn't my way or the highway?

They requested Apple to (a)change the policies of the store or (b)remove the software from it, and they got exactly that. Then they complained.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by tmp476234 on Saturday January 08, 2011 @01:32PM (#2083597)
There are 3 groups of developers here.

A) The ones who ported VLC and posted it on the App Store. B) The ones who complained about the terms of the App Store. C) The ones who are complaining now.

I'm sure there is some overlap, but I don't see how you can criticize members of group C who are not in group B.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by sigzero on Saturday January 08, 2011 @02:56PM (#2083801)
I don't think he made a distinction nor do I see a reason for him too. He could have same "some" instead of "they" I guess.
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jasonkester on Saturday January 08, 2011 @09:37AM (#2083093)
Would you mind giving a lay explanation as to what happened? I'm having trouble parsing what you've written, likely from a lack of context.

First, what's an FSF analysis? And who is the developer in question? One of yours? One of Apple's? Random guy off the street?

What exactly was your application doing that Apple didn't like?

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jbk on Saturday January 08, 2011 @10:06AM (#2083136)
FSF is Free Software Foundation

The developer is one of the VLC main contributors, but you have to understand that there is no official "VLC" company/organisation.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jasonkester on Saturday January 08, 2011 @10:22AM (#2083167)
Ah, so back in the day you guys put a license on your code that was so restrictive that now you can't release a version of it to live in the app store? Ouch.
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jbk on Saturday January 08, 2011 @11:12AM (#2083255)
The problem is that this license doesn't allow distributors, like Apple, to limit users rights...
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jasonkester on Saturday January 08, 2011 @12:05PM (#2083366)
Right, but you chose to use it for your project.

It's a shame one of your developers is being nasty about it, but ultimately it's a problem you guys brought on yourself. If you hadn't put a license on your thing, your thing wouldn't have any license conflicts.

In other words, I suspect that next time you start an open source project, you'll pick a different license for it (or simply not use one).

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by astrange on Saturday January 08, 2011 @05:59PM (#2084198)
Code without a license cannot be used for any purpose, because you have no rights to other people's code unless they grant them.

Anyway, VLC is useless without FFmpeg, which will always be at least LGPL.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by zppx on Saturday January 08, 2011 @02:50PM (#2083791)
Having no license means that you have no guarantee that the copyright owner will not change his mind and sue you in the future for using or distributing his software, licenses are a boring part but necessary.
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by askbjoernhansen on Saturday January 08, 2011 @01:39PM (#2083619)
If there's no license there are no rights for the user – they'll basically not be allowed to do anything with the code (or their lawyers can reasonably tell them to stay off it).

My preferred license for "please do whatever you want with the software" is the MIT/X11 license.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jbk on Saturday January 08, 2011 @12:28PM (#2083417)
Well, truth be told, I am fighting hard to move VLC to LGPL :D

And I didn't start VLC...

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jsz0 on Saturday January 08, 2011 @08:06PM (#2084455)
There are dozens upon dozens of video players on the App Store including commercial services like Netflix and Hulu Plus that directly compete with Apple's own offerings. Claiming this is an anti-competive move on Apple's part frankly makes no sense at all.
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by ryanpetrich on Saturday January 08, 2011 @08:22AM (#2083004)
There is another media player for sale based on VLC still on the App Store that you should look into: http://itunes.apple.com/app/id406779775?mt=8 (the licensing incompatibility likely applies to it as well)
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by trotsky on Saturday January 08, 2011 @09:10AM (#2083057)
Would you be willing to be more specific about the terms that changed in the Apple TOS, and what they are now? And which license terms are in dispute about commercial use? I've read the FSF post about VLC dated october ( http://www.fsf.org/blogs/licensing/vlc-enforcement ) is it safe to say you disagree with the FSF here?

Thanks for any insight!

EDIT: This seems to cover the technical questions: http://mailman.videolan.org/pipermail/vlc-devel/2010-Decembe...

I'd still be curious if you have any insight on current FSF thinking here.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jbk on Saturday January 08, 2011 @10:06AM (#2083137)
I would love the FSF to explain their current position, but they don't want anymore...
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by ali-r on Sunday January 09, 2011 @10:31AM (#2085593)
I want to thank Jean and all VideoLan and Applidium developers for their great softwares that I use on my Mac and iPod touch.

I just don't agree that Apple pulled VLC because of their fear of competition. They did not remove BUZZ Player,OPlayer,yxplayer, CineXPlayer, etc.

I just think App Store is getting very big and hard to manage for Apple so they may make mistakes or they just chose the easy way, pulling the App instead of further investigating the copyright claims.

I hope you can find a solution and VLC appears again in App store soon.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by macco on Saturday January 08, 2011 @09:29AM (#2083080)
Of course the don't want competion. They do everything they can to protect their ecosystem.
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jonhendry on Saturday January 08, 2011 @08:00AM (#2082976)
"Of course, they are allowed to do that, and noone can complain, but this is yet another push from Apple against VLC, that adds to the very long list of past issues. It just makes me think Apple doesn't really want competition"

Maybe they don't want the hassle of dealing with flakey politics-ridden groups who don't have their shit together.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jbk on Saturday January 08, 2011 @08:01AM (#2082980)
Sure, and maybe you could be polite... Or just try to understand what open source groups means...
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jonhendry on Saturday January 08, 2011 @08:20AM (#2082999)
Apparently "open source group" means "high maintenance and unprofessional goalpost-shifters who suffer the delusion that they are in charge".
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by kindly on Saturday January 08, 2011 @08:38AM (#2083024)
You make open source groups sound a lot like apple.
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jonhendry on Saturday January 08, 2011 @08:48AM (#2083033)
Except when it comes to the App Store, Apple is in charge.
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by lwhi on Saturday January 08, 2011 @10:09AM (#2083147)
No, if Apple decides to create a new marketplace - to which tens of thousands of small business have a stake; Apple has a duty to act in an impartial and fair manner.

The fact that Apple created this economic space, doesn't give it the right to behave like a feudal overlord might have behaved in the Middle Ages.

--

It's very much a case of 'who watches the watchmen'.

An independent complaints or regulatory commission needs to be established which can be used to lodge complaints about unfair action within any privately created IP-focused marketplace. I believe that laws should be introduced to ensure that Apple (and Google / Blackberry etc.) would have to subscribe to any guidelines put forth by such a body.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jonhendry on Saturday January 08, 2011 @02:14PM (#2083706)
"No, if Apple decides to create a new marketplace - to which tens of thousands of small business have a stake; Apple has a duty to act in an impartial and fair manner."

Apple didn't change their terms to exclude VLC or GPL. A developer (not VLC) put together the iOS version of the app, and, being fully aware of the terms of the App Store, the model of distribution, the use of DRM, and the likely incompatibilities with GPL submitted the app to Apple.

Blaming Apple for this is completely wrongheaded. It's essentially a disagreement between a VLC developer and the developer of the iOS app.

You might have a point if Apple had changed their terms after the app was submitted in order to exclude the app.

If anything, they loosened their terms to remove incompatibilities.

The iOS app developer screwed up. You should be calling for a regulatory commission to prevent developers from doing stupid things with GPL-licensed code like making business decisions that require abusing GPL.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by borski on Saturday January 08, 2011 @10:33AM (#2083179)
Unfortunately that's just not true. While I agree that is "ideal" and the way it "should be," if I own a clothing retail store, and only want to sell designer Italian clothing, I'm allowed to. I don't also have to allow any and all Chinese, French, and American tailors to put their clothes in my shop.
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by lwhi on Saturday January 08, 2011 @10:41AM (#2083197)
Apple in no way analogous to a retail clothing store;

1. They are not buying products for resale - they are providing a marketplace for other businesses to sell their own products.

2. The products that are created for the iOS AppStore cannot be sold anywhere else.

Content creators can't vote with their feet - they're tied to using Apple's system. They have to invest in very specific technologies to participate in the Apple ecosystem. This creates a situation where Apple is provided with an unwarranted amount of power.

Whether you agree with me or not - I strongly believe measures will be put in place which attempt to rectify the situation.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by zaphar on Saturday January 08, 2011 @12:15PM (#2083385)

    Content creators can't vote with their feet - they're tied to using Apple's system.
This is not true. There are other marketplaces. They the Content Creators are the ones who decided the AppStore was a necessity and they are perfectly capable of changing that. In fact on HackerNews we have in the past seen Content Creators do exactly that. Choosing a different distribution mechanism or a different platform entirely for their Content.

Point 1 still stands but point 2 does not since it's too restrictive to be applied to the debate.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by lwhi on Saturday January 08, 2011 @12:23PM (#2083401)
I'd heard that there are ways to circumvent the AppStore - but are these alternative AppStores economically viable?

A couple of questions;

1. Could an application developer make a living by selling their Apps via the alternative mechanisms - and would a regular (non-technical) user, be able to obtain these Apps without much effort?

2. Could Apple decide to 'outlaw' these alternatives if it chose to?

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by zaphar on Saturday January 08, 2011 @07:32PM (#2084389)
You don't have to circumvent the app store. You can choose a different platform. Saying that the iOS platform is the only market worth mentioning in this debate is a needless restriction. They can choose instead to go the android route or move off of Mobile completely and do something else.

iOS and the AppStore are popular for many reasons some of which have a lot to do with the Content Creators who are publishing there. It is not however the only marketplace and Creators have other choices.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by lwhi on Saturday January 08, 2011 @07:51PM (#2084427)
So my original point still stands;

There is only one marketplace [for iOS applications] ...

2. The products that are created for the iOS AppStore cannot be sold anywhere else.

--

There are multiple commercial marketplaces available for Android - so I don't think highlighting the Apple AppStore is necessarily a needless restriction.

Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by lwhi on Saturday January 08, 2011 @11:08AM (#2083250)
I realise asking for clarification often involves subsequent down-voting, but I'd like to continue the conversation.
Re:VLC for iOS Pulled from the App Store by jbk on Saturday January 08, 2011 @01:17PM (#2083541)
Open Source means that this is a collaborative work where anyone can do what he wants with his copyright.