News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A man who destroyed his multimillion dollar company in 10... by skrebbel on Thursday August 29, 2019 @03:09AM (#20827380)
I've always been amazed at how important it appears to be to lie about selling crap. I find that invariably, businesses who compete on price make it iff they say it's good stuff, even if everybody knows it isn't.

Eg Holland has a number of cheap shoe chains. Schoenenreus and Scapino both breathe an air of cheapness, and one went bust and the other is struggling bad. Their direct competitor Van Haren sells exactly equally crappy shoes, and everybody knows it, but they are thriving, simply because the store feels like a proper high quality shoe store.

Or take ALDI, which competes on price and nothing else. In every country I visited has the words "the ALDI principle: low prices, high quality" printed on every storefront and on every page of their paper promo flyers. Granted, little of what they sell is "total crap", but little is of truly high quality either. Their bread goes stale faster and their coffee is bitter. This surprises nobody.

It appears to me that this weird dichotomy is the only way to successfully compete on price. Make it perfectly obvious that you're cheap and of mediocre quality at best, while loudly shouting that the quality is high. Nobody believes you, but nobody wants to buy from you if you're honest about what you're selling.

I find this surprising because blatant lies don't generally work that well in the long term, so why do they here? I generally hate dishonest messaging. Why don't I mind here? I buy ALDI and Van Haren all the time.

Re:A man who destroyed his multimillion dollar company in 10... by clort on Thursday August 29, 2019 @03:31AM (#20827501)
> Their bread goes stale faster

Interestingly, I wonder why this would be a metric of lower quality bread rather than higher? I mean, the obvious way to make the bread last longer would be to pump it full of preservatives, and the white stuff you buy pre-sliced in packs lasts for ages though it is not really bread and the quality is obviously low (or is it? The slices are so smooth, the bubbles so even and the crust not hard at all)

When I have been to France and bought a baguette in the morning, obviously it is normally eaten right away because fresh and delicious, but if you leave it until the afternoon it is already stale and chewy. Does that imply low quality?

(I do buy some food from Aldi, though I prefer my bread from the baker across the road :)

Re:A man who destroyed his multimillion dollar company in 10... by etage3 on Thursday August 29, 2019 @04:33AM (#20827780)
Common baguette is regarded as a low quality, industrial version of "real" bread (in France). Some traditional bakeries still use ancient methods (and flour and yeast), the bread is good to eat for more than a week.
Re:A man who destroyed his multimillion dollar company in 10... by dirktheman on Thursday August 29, 2019 @03:51AM (#20827582)
French baguette by law can only consist of wheat, yeast, water and salt. Since there are no addatives, the bread goes stale pretty fast.

The same goes for supermarket bread vs fresh bread from the baker's: supermarket bread is better suited for freezing and thawing later compared to fresh bread from the bakery. The latter tastes much better, but has to be eaten the same day.

Re:A man who destroyed his multimillion dollar company in 10... by tom_mellior on Thursday August 29, 2019 @07:11AM (#20828440)
> I mean, the obvious way to make the bread last longer would be to pump it full of preservatives

You can use sourdough, which is also "pumping it full of preservatives", just ones that are produced naturally right in the dough while it ferments. Sourdough bread takes more time, so it would make sense for it to be more expensive. So it makes sense for cheaper bread to go stale faster.

AFAIR if you go into a French bakery and order a "tradition" instead of a "baguette" you get a baguette made with sourdough.

Re:A man who destroyed his multimillion dollar company in 10... by pvaldes on Thursday August 29, 2019 @04:04AM (#20827649)
old bread dried and lasted much longer without any preservative. The difference is in the shift in production from manual to industrial. Less flour and more water and air means keeping the weight with less raw sources, more earnings for the producer, and more mold.
Re:A man who destroyed his multimillion dollar company in 10... by sacado2 on Thursday August 29, 2019 @08:03AM (#20828709)
I think it's Seth Godin who says (paraphrased): "people don't buy a product, they buy a story". You buy something because the story behind it is good, because it makes you feel good. And the story "you buy crap" does not make you feel good, while "best quality for the price" makes you feel like a clever money saver.
Re:A man who destroyed his multimillion dollar company in 10... by skrebbel on Thursday August 29, 2019 @08:23AM (#20828825)
I had read that quote before, but your comment made me understand it. This is exactly the reply I hoped for when I wrote my comment, thanks!
Re:A man who destroyed his multimillion dollar company in 10... by TMWNN on Thursday August 29, 2019 @04:15AM (#20827699)
>Eg Holland has a number of cheap shoe chains. Schoenenreus and Scapino both breathe an air of cheapness, and one went bust and the other is struggling bad. Their direct competitor Van Haren sells exactly equally crappy shoes, and everybody knows it, but they are thriving, simply because the store feels like a proper high quality shoe store.

Same in the US with Target and Walmart. They sell exactly the same discounted products, in giant stores that carry everything, to exactly the same customers, but Target has cultural cachet (both embodied and mocked as "Tar-jay"), while Walmart and its customers are mocked (if you're nice) and denounced (if you're not) incessantly. Somehow, the giant retail chain corporation based in Arkansas is seen as the embodiment of all that is evil with American business—to the point where San Francisco and New York City don't allow any within their borders—while the giant retail chain corporation based in Minnesota is seen as (relatively) hip and culturally/political acceptable enough to have outlets in the downtowns of said cities.

Re:A man who destroyed his multimillion dollar company in 10... by lotsofpulp on Thursday August 29, 2019 @08:31AM (#20828874)
I've always noticed Targets to be cleaner, better lit, and have more employees available to assist than Walmarts. I also have read many times that Walmart forces manufacturers to cut quality to meet certain price points for products sold in their stores, whereas I haven't heard anything like that about Target. This makes me trust Target more, plus their website doesn't allow resellers.
Re:A man who destroyed his multimillion dollar company in 10... by diminoten on Thursday August 29, 2019 @10:26AM (#20829768)
Everything Walmart does, Target also does, and as impossible as this sounds, Target cares substantially less about its employees.

And walmart.com is built to be a marketplace, like amazon.com, so of course it allows resellers.

You can hate what Walmart is and stands for, but to find Target acceptable is inconsistent.

Re:A man who destroyed his multimillion dollar company in 10... by earthboundkid on Thursday August 29, 2019 @10:42AM (#20829900)
Target is also really into surveillance capitalism. I don't know how Walmart compares, but Target definitely does its best to do creepytracking of every customer.
Re:A man who destroyed his multimillion dollar company in 10... by cosmie on Thursday August 29, 2019 @11:32AM (#20830377)
> I also have read many times that Walmart forces manufacturers to cut quality to meet certain price points for products sold in their stores, whereas I haven't heard anything like that about Target.

This is less insidious than it sounds. Walmart's strategy is a volume play - they optimize their product mix against selling the highest volume of products, rather than products that may have a higher individual margin but lower sales volume.

They're also intimately familiar with the elasticity of price for everything they sell. If a manufacture comes to them with Product A, Walmart won't purchase Product A if they can't price it at the optimal point for their target market (which encompasses a large cross section of the general population). But their procurement volume is so high that they can commit to absurdly large order quantities. So instead of just walking away, they'll work with the manufacture to comb through the bill of materials[1] and adjust things such that a Variant B of Product A can be produced more efficiently or cheaply, then sold to Walmart at a wholesale rate that allows them to hit their target retail price. This can be as simple an adjustment as reducing a 3 year warranty down to a 1 year warranty. Or swapping out a fragile but sleek looking component with a more robust but worse looking (or heavier) component, thereby reducing expected warranty claims and overall product cost. Or if they feel a particular component is likely to not be used by 90% of their purchasers (i.e. a marketing gimmick the manufacturer threw in for differentiation) they'll ask for it to be removed. Or if a particular component is overbuilt for their audience they'll ask it to be swapped out with a lower quality component (keeping in mind that Walmart has lots of data from returns to understand what does and doesn't work well). Or it could be a feature that is turned off/disabled to give the manufacturer cover for selling (and letting Walmart sell) the product below the equivalent product sold to other retailers.

Keep in mind that returns and warranty claims all cost money, as well. And at the volume of sales Walmart has, even minor increases in these can have very noticeable increases in costs/decreases in profitability and negate the entire benefit of creating a new product variant to hit a specific price point. So in that vein, you can be sure that the new variant will meet the consistent quality expectations of products purchased at Walmart, even if they don't necessarily meet the quality expectations you might have of purchasing that brand elsewhere. It's basically a private label product commissioned by Walmart that still happens to have the manufacturer's brand name attached to it.

Target and other large retailers do the same thing, they just don't necessarily have the volume to have enough leverage to get manufacturers to do it on as many things as Walmart does, nor the internal competencies to do it at such a deep level. They also have different points of price sensitivity for products, based on the particular demographics of their consumers. You're more likely to see fuzzying around with quantities/volumes instead, since the primary manufacturing run is the same and you only require a custom pack during final packaging.

And to that point, manufacturers do the same thing themselves frequently. Consumers are price sensitive and manufacturers for years have been absorbing price increases on raw materials while maintaining price points. They do so by either maintaining the same quality of individual units and just silently shaving off quantity, or else decreasing the quality and maintaining quantity. These changes usually come along with refreshes/redesigns of product packaging, in an attempt to mask them from notice.

Re:A man who destroyed his multimillion dollar company in 10... by ansible on Thursday August 29, 2019 @08:02AM (#20828704)
The Walmarts I've been in recently have improved considerably on the presentation front.

Shopping at a local Walmart 20 years ago was an unpleasant experience. Junk in the aisles, which were quite narrow, making it hard to maneuver past other shoppers. Insufficient fluorescent lighting. All kinds of things that spoke "cheap". Just overall bad.

Nowadays, there's little to distinguish Target from Walmart... aside from the red vs. blue color scheme.

Re:A man who destroyed his multimillion dollar company in 10... by spuz on Thursday August 29, 2019 @06:45AM (#20828315)
For what it's worth, I think Ryanair successfully markets itself as both cheap and poor quality. Whenever for example they announce they are considering charging passengers to use the loo, or in fact charging people to carry on a bag, it negatively affects their brand which paradoxically increases their presence in the minds of customers looking to fly in Europe cheaply.
Re:A man who destroyed his multimillion dollar company in 10... by skrebbel on Thursday August 29, 2019 @01:18PM (#20831559)
Another comment in this thread suggested that they do this because otherwise people will be afraid they skimp on safety. By treating their customers as cattle, they underlines that that's where the savings are and not elsewhere (eg maintenance).

I guess the trick only works because it's a safety sensitive business, and the same approach wouldn't work for, say, a supermarket or a jewelry brand.

Re:A man who destroyed his multimillion dollar company in 10... by jmkni on Thursday August 29, 2019 @10:08AM (#20829598)
I'm not sure if this is an urban myth or not, but I've heard many times they intentionally had a tacky looking website for years for this reason.

Granted their current website is fairly decent/usable.

Re:A man who destroyed his multimillion dollar company in 10... by novaRom on Thursday August 29, 2019 @03:20AM (#20827441)
>ALDI, which competes on price and nothing else

They offer lots of good quality things, so better to say they have the best price/quality ratio.

Re:A man who destroyed his multimillion dollar company in 10... by ajsnigrutin on Thursday August 29, 2019 @07:02AM (#20828392)
And not just that.. they optimize sales as far as they can. Everything is in a box (no need to arrange things carefuly on shelves), huge barcodes (faster scanning), larger items on pallets (just bring a new pallet in when old one is empty), just a few people work there and do everything, etc.

They sometimes also buy everything you have to get a cheaper price (a friend of mine has a rather large vegetable farm, and they offered to buy literally all the produce to get a lower price.. he doesn't have to deal with sales that year, and they get it cheaper).

I like aldi, and buy a bunch of stuff there (i'm not sponsored by them), but at the same time, you know what you're buying - need a drill? They sell a perfectly ok one for really cheap... for a casual user, who uses a drill once every few months.

What I don't like is some other stores selling the same items (just branded differently) for 2x the price. If you need a good drill for professional use, there are just a few companies that make them good - and you probably know them all. If you need something cheap, you'll get it cheaper at a store like aldi (or lidl, or similar) than at [hardware store] under their brand, or even some reputable brands.

Stupid example: https://www.productreview.com.au/listings/aldi-food-dehydrat... This was sold here for 30eur at aldi.

Gorenje is/was a reputable brand here, and they sell theirs for 50eur: https://www.mimovrste.com/susilniki-sadja/gorenje-susilnik-h...

Just look at the photos and compare.

Re:A man who destroyed his multimillion dollar company in 10... by Scarblac on Thursday August 29, 2019 @03:51AM (#20827581)
> Their direct competitor Van Haren sells exactly equally crappy shoes, and everybody knows it,

I'm Dutch and I didn't know that. I don't buy shoes frequently enough to notice such things, so I might be fooled by their looks.

So the looks matter.

Re:A man who destroyed his multimillion dollar company in 10... by skrebbel on Thursday August 29, 2019 @01:19PM (#20831576)
If you actually dare enter a Scapino, you'll find that the shoes look pretty good. It's just the surroundings that's off-putting.
Re:A man who destroyed his multimillion dollar company in 10... by doyoulikeworms on Thursday August 29, 2019 @04:04AM (#20827644)
> but they are thriving, simply because the store feels like a proper high quality shoe store.

Shopping isn't just about the products themselves. It's also about the experience of shopping, wouldn't you say? If I had to choose between cheap + bad shopping experience and cheap + nice shopping experience, the latter would be a no-brainer!

Re:A man who destroyed his multimillion dollar company in 10... by tapland on Thursday August 29, 2019 @06:38AM (#20828290)
People don't like feeling as if they are buying cheap crap. Making your customers feel comfortable ins stores and on the web is very important.