Sure, if you rob a bank and bury the money it can't be confiscated either.
However, if you are ordered by a Court to turn over funds (bitcoin or otherwise) and you do not comply with the court order, you can be held in contempt of court and arrested until you comply with the court order.
What good is "many lifetimes of freedom" if you only have 1 life and you're not free?
- torture
- imprisonment and then finding his private keys written down in his house (or similar opsec fail)
This is in contrast to bank/financial accounts (easily garnished by court order), physical paper currency (easily seized by a SWAT team), or physical gold (easily seized by a SWAT team).
They can put you in jail, but they can't take your btc.
Who said debtor's prison?
There is a difference between going to jail for a debt and violating a court order, even if that court order is to turn over assets. Why don't you look up the penalties for violating a court order (HINT: civil or criminal the remedies are the same). In fact not only can violating a court order from a civil court result in imprisonment, additional criminal charges can occur for the violation itself, so you can be sitting in jail anyway and be hit with criminal charges.
>he could just say no and go about his business.
You think you can just ignore a court order without penalty? Why would anyone comply with a court order then? I'll tell you why, because they Courts have broad powers including imprisonment until you comply (even orders from civil cases).
>They can put you in jail, but they can't take your btc.
Yes, I think I acknowledged that, just as they can't take the cash you robbed from a bank and buried either (notwithstanding your point about how easy it is to seize). How is SWAT going to seize cash that they can't find?
This is simply wrong. It's not an issue of "debtor's prison" it's an issue of being in contempt of court by failing to comply with a court order.
If this was a criminal case, the government would need to pursue a separate action to seize the coins because criminal cases can't result in the seizure of property, only fines and imprisonment. (When police seize property, that's a separate but related civil case to the criminal case.)
They can put you in jail, but they can't take your btc.
This is true, but they can keep you in jail for as long as you are in contempt of court, i.e., the rest of your life.
It can't be confiscated if you manage to keep it completely hidden since the second it was mined... just like any other currency. In some ways Bitcoin is a lot more traceable than regular money, which can change hands as cash repeatedly with no traceability.
If a court asks you to hand over something and you refuse you might as well spend time in prison until you have a change of heart. You can be compelled to produce the wallet and since transactions are traceable it's possible to calculate how much BTC was mined.
Unless the BTC was mined into an obscure wallet that can't be traced back to this guy there's no easy (any?) way to hide how much he mined. Because this isn't about how much BTC the guy controls now (he could just transfer it all and claim there's none left) but how much was mined.
But the claim made above was that the whole point of BTC is that it cannot be confiscated. In reality it can be confiscated to the same extent to which any currency/valuable can be confiscated. You can't confiscate things you don't know about or can't get to and this is applicable to anything: money in hidden off shore accounts, art in an obscure warehouse, jewelry buried under a house, etc.
[0] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2017/mar/23/francis-r...
See e.g., Chelsea Manning.
That's debatable. How do you even go about liquidating that much cryptocurrency? Selling it all at once would crash the market; even signalling that such a large amount might be put on the market would probably have an adverse effect on prices.