News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Provocations of Camille Paglia by Animats on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @03:28AM (#20807055)
“These minor French theorists have had a disastrous effect on American education. Lacan encourages pompous bombast and Foucault teaches cheap cynicism, while Derrida’s aggressive method, called deconstruction, systematically trashes high culture by reducing everything to language and then making language destroy itself.”

She's right, but it really upsets many academics for someone to say that. Good.

Re:The Provocations of Camille Paglia by erokar on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @03:40AM (#20807121)
I think her analysis is wrong in that regard. American puritanism is more to blame. French universities do not suffer from the current campus hysteria.
Re:The Provocations of Camille Paglia by thinkingemote on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @05:26AM (#20807683)
I think having free education (e.g. in some EU) makes students appreciate their education. Education is a privilege and something to be earned for many. The universities have more power over the student life as they know best.

Having students pay for everything (e.g in US) makes their education into a product and they are the consumer. Students can then demand to have certain conditions met. The consumer knows best, is king.

Re:The Provocations of Camille Paglia by philipps on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @05:49AM (#20807810)
I had not seen this interpretation of the perceived value of education before and find it intriguing (and tentatively agree). I am surprised there aren’t more dissenting comments because it flies in the face of the free-market libertarian interpretation of value, which would argue that people do not value things that are free.
Re:The Provocations of Camille Paglia by upvotinglurker on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @12:04PM (#20811128)
A clearer way of stating it might be not "the euro students value their education more because it's free," but "the euro students value their education more because college attendance is determined by academic status rather than ability to pay. So, they had to work hard at their studies to get into college, and must continue to perform well academically or risk being kicked out."

Whereas in the US, college attendance generally* is determined by ability to pay, and a student who can pay will almost certainly be able to find some college that will let them attend, whether they take their studies seriously ("value their education") or not.

*Of course achievement still matters if you want to get into the most selective institutions ... but I gather you can do that with (a lot) of money, too.

Re:The Provocations of Camille Paglia by Animats on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @06:16PM (#20824620)
No, but see 1968.
Re:The Provocations of Camille Paglia by simonh on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @03:45AM (#20807156)
Are Lacan, Foucault and Derrida the pre-eminent influences on modern French academic literary theory? If so, why does she characterise them as minor?
Re:The Provocations of Camille Paglia by grey-area on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @04:17AM (#20807323)
Foucault and Derrida are certainly still read widely (and deservedly so IMO) - more widely than Paglia in Europe at least - describing them as 'minor' is a little silly. You don't have to accept everything they say to see that they have some relevance and value.
Re:The Provocations of Camille Paglia by simonh on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @09:28AM (#20819515)
On reading up on this, it seems Derrida particularly is quite influential in Continental Philosophy, but in contrast his influence in the Anglophone world is mainly in literary studies. So us Anglophones see, understand and in some cases apply his work in very different ways than is prevalent in France.
Re:The Provocations of Camille Paglia by DataWorker on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @09:58AM (#20809619)
They have relevance amongst themselves alone, and their value can be established empirically as more negative than positive. They add confusion and noise, and their utility is that of a Che Guevara T-shirt.
Re:The Provocations of Camille Paglia by lordgrenville on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @09:32AM (#20809383)
I wouldn't group all of those three together. My personal opinion is:

-Foucault is quite interesting and accessible (his writing contains much more facts and observations than jargon)

-Lacan is a complete fraud

-Derrida might have interesting things to say but it's extremely hard to tell

Re:The Provocations of Camille Paglia by namirez on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @06:43AM (#20808106)
>She's right, but it really upsets many academics for someone to say that. Good.

Is it "good" just because it upsets academics? Is she "right" just because you agree with her? To me, her comment sounds like a very uncharitable critique of those writers.

I'm not a fan of Derrida or Lacan, but I've noticed they get a lot of criticism from people who've never read them. They were not necessarily original thinkers with revolutionary ideas, but they definitely offered some new insights.

Re:The Provocations of Camille Paglia by DataWorker on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @09:48AM (#20809519)
“Offered some new insights” seems innocuous enough. I don’t think you’ll find such modesty in the claims these writers make. Despite the ostentatious self aggrandizement inherent in their critiques of our intellectual and cultural traditions, the best defense any honest person can offer for their work is a backstepping timid “they offered some new insights”. Well the newness of their insights is debatable. Listen to any child’s tantrum and you’ll hear echos of foucault’s whining about the unfairness of power.
Re:The Provocations of Camille Paglia by namirez on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @10:58AM (#20810238)
>Listen to any child’s tantrum and you’ll hear echos of foucault’s whining about the unfairness of power.

No offense but it appears you've never read Foucault. He never said power is unfair. It's like saying gravity is unfair because someone was hurt after a fall.

Re:The Provocations of Camille Paglia by vixen99 on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @03:47AM (#20807172)
And anyone who wants to know a bit more about some of these theorists might want to read 'Intellectual Impostures' by the Left-leaning physicist Alan Sokal.
Re:The Provocations of Camille Paglia by cdavid on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @07:36AM (#20808460)
Putting all the "French philosophers" in one bucket is not fair. Lacan is clearly a charlatan, Foucault, while controversial, is absolutely a deep thinker.

There is some truth about their writing being too obtuse, but this is (was ?) unfortunately a requirement in some circles in Paris. Also, culturally, being pedant in French has been for a long time a sign of sophistication culturally speaking (http://www.openculture.com/2013/07/jean_searle_on_foucault_a...). I find French more "overfit" for pedantism than English, but that could just be because French is my native language / culture.

[edit] the link above in openculture.com actually links to a video when Chomsky and Foucault discuss about social organizations. Foucault is as clear, if not clearer than Chomsky. I find Chomsky's language extremely dry, to a point where it is difficult for me to stay engaged.

Re:The Provocations of Camille Paglia by jimbokun on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @11:03AM (#20810312)
> There is some truth about their writing being too obtuse, but this is (was ?) unfortunately a requirement in some circles in Paris.

In the article, that is one of the criticisms Paglia raised. That it doesn't make sense to apply the techniques of these French thinkers to non-French culture and art, when their work is so specific to French academic traditions.

Re:The Provocations of Camille Paglia by lordgrenville on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @09:37AM (#20809433)
Great link. It's amusing that the url Frenchifies him to "Jean Searle" (although the text gets his name right).
Re:The Provocations of Camille Paglia by chalst on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @04:25AM (#20807367)
It is funny that of these three names, two were among the four explicitly exempted by Sokal and Bricmont of being impostors in a 1997 letter to Liberation following publication of the book: "Famous thinkers like Althusser, Barthes, Derrida, and Foucault are mainly absent from our book"

Orig. https://next.liberation.fr/livres/1997/10/18/sokal-et-bricmo....

Cf. http://www.critical-theory.com/read-derridas-response-sokal-...

Re:The Provocations of Camille Paglia by yesenadam on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @02:24AM (#20817349)
I don't think it's fair to say they were "explicitly exempted of being impostors" - Intellectual Impostures focuses exclusively on the use of scientific and mathematical terms by philosophers, as it's often clearly evident when an author doesn't know what they mean, and/or is using them in a totally absurd way. It's easier to catch them in the act of perpetrating nonsense. The four you mentioned just don't happen to use mathematical or scientific terms in the same egregiously nonsensical way. That is very far from the only way of writing bad philosophy. For some of the many others, see David Stove's What is wrong with our thoughts? (which, by the way, features Foucault)

http://www.maths.unsw.edu.au/~jim/wrongthoughts.html

Re:The Provocations of Camille Paglia by tryitnow on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @12:18PM (#20811327)
No she's not. She's not a serious academic and nobody who studies Lacan, Derrida, and Foucault would take her seriously. She's a propagandist and entertainer. She's not even a popularizer of complex ideas because I honestly think she either doesn't understand the thinkers she critiques or she does understand them but decides to score cheap points by attacking straw man arguments.

If you want an easy way to engage with the ideas these French thinkers put forward I highly suggest listening to Stephen West's "Philosophize This" podcast. He not only covers "French Philosophers" but much of Western philosophy and does so in a pretty accessible and relatively unbiased manner.

The "Introducing" series of books can also be a good resource for understanding complex thinkers: https://www.amazon.com/Introducing-Foucault-Graphic-Chris-Ho...

Although honestly, it's just as important to understand other thinkers in the Western philosophy tradition to grasp where thinkers are coming from.

Having said all that, yes, there are many people in American academia whose understanding of these thinkers is just as bad if not worse than Paglia's and these folks give academic study of French philosophy a bad name. Paglia has built a career of attacking people like these, not by holding them to higher standards but by merely sinking to their level and engaging in simple-minded, yet entertaining, polemics.

But it's always going to the be the case that poor thinkers abound. There's also a lot of very poor thinkers in CS, physics and other so-called "hard science" fields. It's just that they're a lot easier to ignore because they're so boring.

Re:The Provocations of Camille Paglia by raverbashing on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @05:47AM (#20807803)
While no idea is impervious to criticism, I think Americans take those authors much more "serious" (as in their ideas as "hard truths") than them themselves take it (in France).

So her criticism might be right in substance (in the American context) but targeting the wrong thing.

Derrida is pretty much Gödel's incompleteness theorem for philosophers instead of just "reducing everything to language and then making language destroy itself"

Re:The Provocations of Camille Paglia by dlkf on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @07:57AM (#20808613)
Gödel's incompleteness theorem is Gödel's incompleteness theorem for philosophers. Derrida is fashionable nonsense.
Re:The Provocations of Camille Paglia by raxxorrax on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @07:19AM (#20808325)
If you summarize Derrida to one or two sentences, you could say he critiqued western civilization to have a tendency for black and white thinking. Quite ironic.
Re:The Provocations of Camille Paglia by normalhuman on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @04:04AM (#20807264)
Have you read any of them?