News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by hirundo on Saturday August 24, 2019 @07:30AM (#20786564)
In its long term effect this fraud is similar to serial rape. But that's also true of serial seduction under false pretenses. Should the punishment for these things also be similar? I don't know.

From a Darwinian perspective even the death penalty is insufficient, since reproducing copiously is worth dying for. The only effective punishment would involve also killing or sterilizing the resulting children ... which is entirely unacceptable from our cultural perspective.

So to a Darwinian insemination doctor this may be something like a perfect crime, in that there is no prospective punishment that outweighs the benefits.

Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by haihaibye on Saturday August 24, 2019 @08:29AM (#20786760)
http://veryshortscifi.blogspot.com/2015/08/not-even-their-ow...

Ghengis Khan was the world's greatest Dad, in sheer numbers.

Well, he was, 'til this creep started getting off on actual reproductive success. Sicko.

Got his jollies breaking into sperm banks. They caught him of course, but not before he had fathered over 700 children. That we could identify.

Not all of his sons felt the need. Some were really nice kids. Normal families. But some of them...

Sperm bank security improved, of course, til our present levels which are pretty much impregnable.

But those guys weren't the worst - an engineer working for a clinical DNA printer hacked the machine to randomly sprinkle some of his bases into everything that went through. Weird, huh? But it sort of made the kids equivalent of distant cousins or so. There were 11 months of births before it was discovered.

It wasn't even his own molecules that were involved, I don't know - I think it makes it worse

Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by aluren on Saturday August 24, 2019 @12:29PM (#20788062)
The Genghis Khan thing doesn't really say much - there's a statistical near-certainty that liteally everyone today is descended from every single human that 7000 years ago (whose line didn't die out obviously).
Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by opportune on Saturday August 24, 2019 @04:53PM (#20789642)
That’s assuming that the human population is well-mixed; it should be obvious that e.g. aboriginal Australians and native Americans will not have a common ancestor that close by

For example suppose you have two containers filled with elastically colliding particles. Over an arbitrarily long time you can say that each particle has surely collided with every other particle, however if each container is closed then clearly particles from one container will not have collided with those from the other container over any amount of time

Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by aluren on Sunday August 25, 2019 @04:12AM (#20791933)
>That’s assuming that the human population is well-mixed

Yes that's why I took the conservative estimate of 7000 years, otherwise with the panmixia hypothesis it only goes back 3000 years or so.

Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by haihaibye on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @10:32AM (#20809944)
If there has been widespread mixing why is there no sickle cell anaemia in South East Asia or Papua New Guinea, even though there is Malaria?

If an allele had made it there, wouldn't it have been selected for?

Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by aluren on Tuesday August 27, 2019 @06:34PM (#20815129)
Genealogical mixing and genetic mixing have little to do with each other - the pool is too diluted at these scales and there can be much local variation.

By the way, the fact that all of us share the exact same set of ancestors from a few thousand years ago isn't new, shocking or controversial, only the exact date is still subject do debate. You may find this link useful: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Identical_ancestors_point

Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by haihaibye on Wednesday August 28, 2019 @06:48PM (#20824852)
You're brushing off my point, why no selection on the allele? Why did they all die out? Easiest answer is it never made it.

The simulations are nice, and make a theoretical lower bound but a single remote tribe somewhere on earth would push it back tens of thousands of years.

DNA Sequence an Andaman islander and every bushman and Amazonian, then we'll see.

Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by aluren on Thursday August 29, 2019 @08:03PM (#20834829)
>You're brushing off my point, why no selection on the allele? Why did they all die out? Easiest answer is it never made it.

Evolution works in more complicated ways than the toy model of sickle-cell disease/malaria you've been taught in high school. Just having an edge in a particular situation is no guarantee for your alleles being selected. But even then, there could very well have been very little mixing while still everyone shares the same set of ancestors. Even a little mixing is enough.

>The simulations are nice, and make a theoretical lower bound but a single remote tribe somewhere on earth would push it back tens of thousands of years.

The subject is well-refined and the results are old news so I'm going to go on a limp and assume that the researchers who did the simulations know how to do their jobs and accounted for that possibility you described.

>DNA Sequence an Andaman islander and every bushman and Amazonian, then we'll see.

Ignoring the fact that the various peoples in the Amazon have not been isolated at all, or that the Adamans have been settled approximately in the time range of the estimated IAP and have known a few exchanges since, that's not how genealogy works. See, if a single outsider gets into the Adamans or Australia and starts having children with locals, and assuming the line doesn't die out, there's a statistical certainty that eventually every current living person in that territory will be descended from that outsider. Just one is enough. It doesn't matter that their genetic contribution is diluted to the point of being barely detectable. I invite you to read the link about IAP in more detail and do some rudimentary math on why it has to be the case (or more accurately, why the opposite is so statistically improbable as to be pretty much impossible).

Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by kanaba on Saturday August 24, 2019 @05:55PM (#20789963)
As the formatting is unclear, it is worth noting that the parent comment is a short science fiction story, quoted in its entirety from the linked page.
Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by buboard on Saturday August 24, 2019 @08:00AM (#20786638)
> From a Darwinian perspective even the death penalty is insufficient,

Darwinism has no bearing on legal matters. In fact the entirety of laws are opposed to darwinism

Plus we re probably the last generations that care for darwinism? It won't take long before it becomes normal to engineer your children.

Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by philwelch on Saturday August 24, 2019 @05:42PM (#20789871)
That’s like saying we’re the last generation that cares about gravity. Darwinism is part of how the world works. It’s not something to be accepted or denied or supported or opposed. It’s just reality, and at most it’s a constraint to work around. If you try to fix society by pretending that Darwinism doesn’t exist, that’s like trying to build a house by pretending that mold and water damage don’t exist.
Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by buboard on Saturday August 24, 2019 @07:15PM (#20790295)
There is no invention on the horizon that will counterweight gravity, as opposed to genetic engineering.I think it's fair to say that procreation will not determine our genetic future, but the choices of genes that the people of the next few generations will make. And people's vanity may compel them to perpetuate their own genes, but given the opportunity people always choose the best possible genes for their kids (i.e. choose healthy sperm donors with generally considered "higher genes" - i.e. Danes).

The OP describes a system where darwinism is used to determine how to punish people. i.e. darwinism is the source of law. That's not happening.

Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by philwelch on Saturday August 24, 2019 @07:47PM (#20790426)
I don’t know or believe that genetic engineering is anywhere close to ready for those kinds of purposes any more than waterproof materials are ready for house builders to stop worrying about drainage and other basic principles of water damage. And we’re a hell of a lot farther along in terms of waterproof materials!

In fact I think it’s slightly more likely that you’ve been suckered into a scam perpetrated by Danish men for reasons that are plainly obvious from a Darwinist perspective ;) Seems like more of a crackpot Nordic eugenic superman theory to me.

Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by buboard on Saturday August 24, 2019 @08:10PM (#20790521)
embryo selection is already a thing today, and there are already crispr'd humans. Considering the pace of genetic research it's not unreasonable to expect that genetic selection of traits will be available within 20-50 years.

Whatever scam the danism men are running , it's working

https://www.marieclaire.com/culture/a6134/danish-sperm-donor...

Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by philwelch on Sunday August 25, 2019 @04:12AM (#20791934)
There are roughly two Crispr’d humans and the scientist responsible has been under house arrest in China ever since. I’m not interested in your Nordic eugenic superman nonsense.
Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by hirundo on Saturday August 24, 2019 @08:11AM (#20786681)
> Darwinism has no bearing on legal matters.

To a Darwinian rapist / insemination fraudster / seduction fraudster, this is a kind of loophole that he can slip through. Modern law doesn't sufficiently incentivise him to desist.

Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by buboard on Saturday August 24, 2019 @08:15AM (#20786696)
It would be fun to see seduction outlawed. What would be the punishment for seductors and seductees?
Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by hirundo on Saturday August 24, 2019 @08:18AM (#20786711)
Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by buboard on Saturday August 24, 2019 @10:16AM (#20787244)
It appears the seducer would pay with monetary damages and the seducted would pay with a life in disgrace
Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by ZoomZoomZoom on Saturday August 24, 2019 @07:13PM (#20790282)
So, a marriage? /s
Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by andrepd on Saturday August 24, 2019 @09:38AM (#20787062)
Love it. That short page is absolutely filled with "gems" (for lack of a better word).
Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by tarunupaday on Saturday August 24, 2019 @08:30AM (#20786765)
>Darwinism has no bearing on legal matters.

While some laws are created to protect the weakest; a lot of inheritance, marriage and family laws follow their rationale directly from Darwinism.

Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by staticman2 on Saturday August 24, 2019 @01:10PM (#20788337)
Marriage and family laws predate Darwin and have nothing to do with "Darwinism". They are products of, in anything, human social psychology.
Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by philwelch on Saturday August 24, 2019 @05:46PM (#20789900)
Marriage and family laws are based upon centuries-old cultural traditions that evolved and survived to the present day by virtue of promoting their own survival. That’s Darwinism. The fact that they predate Darwin is as meaningless as the fact that Earth’s orbit around the sun predates Copernicus.
Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by DoctorOetker on Saturday August 24, 2019 @04:59PM (#20789666)
With Darwinism he obviously doesn't mean the field of study, but rather the subject of the field of study, which was already happening way before Darwin's discovery of it, shaping among other things human social psychology...
Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by buboard on Saturday August 24, 2019 @08:42AM (#20786809)
If there was one in the past, it certainly doesnt exist today. Marriage laws seem to have evolved to laws protecting the mother and ensuring the child can grow sufficiently comfortable.
Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by SantalBlush on Saturday August 24, 2019 @04:49PM (#20789621)
>In fact the entirety of laws are opposed to darwinism

I don't see how this is true. Can you explain this position?

Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by buboard on Saturday August 24, 2019 @07:25PM (#20790326)
starting with killing competitors, all egotistical traits are darwinian. If anything, laws exist to stop us from that
Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by SantalBlush on Saturday August 24, 2019 @11:27PM (#20791172)
Do you mean to suggest that cooperation is not a Darwinian trait? Or that social animals are not a product of natural selection? Because I'm pretty sure that is false.
Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by robbrown451 on Saturday August 24, 2019 @03:52PM (#20789324)
Capital punishment is/was considered a deterrent because we are programmed to attempt to avoid premature death by natural selection.

That's not to say people always understood this or even that today it is the way most people think about it, but at least according to a mechanistic/biological view of behavior, that is the basis.

Note that natural selection did NOT necessarily put a desire to pass on our genes into us, since that wasn't necessary. It simply put such things as a desire to continue living, a drive to care for children (which can easily be transferred to non-biological children, and we can easily ignore that drive for biological children that we don't bond to), and a drive to have sex.

Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by aluren on Saturday August 24, 2019 @12:24PM (#20788023)
There should be a moratorium on invoking evolution unless you're an evolutionary biologist. It's quite telling that whenever I read the word 'Darwin' on this site I immediately go 'aw shit, I'm not going to like this' and it never fails.
Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by deogeo on Saturday August 24, 2019 @03:33PM (#20789213)
Would you like to share with us where the parent poster made an error?
Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by Dude2030 on Saturday August 24, 2019 @08:08AM (#20786668)
Did you know France banned paternity tests?
Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by lota-putty on Saturday August 24, 2019 @08:16AM (#20786704)
French can't be trusted with fidelity in marriage?
Re:Fertility Fraud: Artificial insemination doctors who used... by thefounder on Sunday August 25, 2019 @07:59AM (#20792465)
>> serial seduction "under false pretenses"

So should we punish 90% of men?