Re:Introducing nushell
by JohnBooty on Saturday August 24, 2019 @03:03AM
(#20785719)
I love the core idea of nushell, but reimplementing them seems rather insane, given the incalcuable number of programmer-hours that have gone into coreutils.
That seems like a real mistake, rather than simply having nushell's "ls" be a wrapper for coreutils "ls -la" or some such.
I understand the benefit of reimplementing everything from scratch, as that way you have a more consistent nushell experience everywhere, regardless of which version of "native" ls your system has. And allowing "^ls" is a useful and necessary hedge.
But, wow reimplementing nearly everything seems like an enormous undertaking.
(It is of course possible that I'm completely misunderstanding things! Perhaps the devs can comment?)
Re:Introducing nushell
by lozenge on Saturday August 24, 2019 @11:13AM
(#20787568)
Check the ls man page and remove anything related to sorting, filtering, or formatting information (as under this system all this functionality is provided in a shared and generic way). There is not much left.
That seems like a real mistake, rather than simply having nushell's "ls" be a wrapper for coreutils "ls -la" or some such.
I understand the benefit of reimplementing everything from scratch, as that way you have a more consistent nushell experience everywhere, regardless of which version of "native" ls your system has. And allowing "^ls" is a useful and necessary hedge.
But, wow reimplementing nearly everything seems like an enormous undertaking.
(It is of course possible that I'm completely misunderstanding things! Perhaps the devs can comment?)