News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by ebg13 on Thursday August 22, 2019 @08:57AM (#20767492)
Oh man. This thread is really something else.

Like...for miles in every direction, all I can see are pitchforks, and here I am standing alone on a small hill thinking to myself "Holy shit. That's the Spiderweb software guy. I've played every single one of his games, EVERY SINGLE ONE, and loved all of them."

The graphics in the games are exactly as good as they need to be to make wonderful story-driven RPGs.

Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by LugosFergus on Thursday August 22, 2019 @09:18AM (#20767697)
You and me both! I thought this thread would have a bit more praise for Jeff's work after all of these years, but it's just a bunch of Debbie Downers taking a collective dump on it just because they don't like the look.

While the style may not be modern, the gameplay and stories tend to be quite good. I would also argue that a game that looks great doesn't necessarily imply that the game is any good. Battlefront 2 is a great looking game that is ultimately a soulless, lootbox filled shitshow with painfully bland gameplay.

Anyone saying that he needs to hire an art director have completely missed the point of his article: his business can only support his family. He has also been able to maintain this business for 20 years, which is a lot more than can be said about any other indies.

Ultimately, this is a style that Jeff likes, and it makes him money. If people don't like it, then they can go play something else. He still has his fan base that keeps him afloat.

EDIT: grammar

Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by nothis on Thursday August 22, 2019 @02:26PM (#20770983)
I'm with you on the games being excellent examples of a super niche style done well but he's basically writing an article attacking the very concept of art direction as a waste of resources. That comes off a little disrespectful towards people who care.

I think there's no point in making their games looking any different than they do (because it's part of their brand, now) but the correct response to a question of why they don't make a "better" looking game is that they don't care. Or, maybe, it's a taste issue. Flailing your hands about how people totally did not appreciate you going through the trouble of making the graphics isometric or hiring underpaid artists is not the way to go. It's maybe "honest" but it's IMO at best a misunderstanding of and at worst a severe lack of respect for art direction and visual design.

Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by johnnyanmac on Thursday August 22, 2019 @08:36PM (#20773677)
I think I interpreted the article differently from you. I saw this as a cold hard look at what works and the dangers of changing your brand (or rather, the fact that "better X" doesn't always mean more success when you're Forte is Y), not some general argument against the idea of artistic integrity. Doing what Vogel can now do after 20 years and an established audience would lead to ruin for 99.9% of devs today aiming for financial success because the market is very different. And I'm sure he knows that.
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by Fr0styMatt88 on Friday August 23, 2019 @05:38AM (#20775832)
This was what I took away from the post as well. The realism was refreshing and to me very positive. It shows there actually can be a middle-ground in indie development and not just the two extremes of “Have a viral hit and earn millions!” and “Spend more than your life savings and go broke!”.

All too often I think people are happy to throw their hands in the air and presume that indie success is just ‘impossible’. This article, for me, added some much-needed nuance to the discussion.

Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by tripzilch on Friday August 23, 2019 @07:43AM (#20776468)
Yes the business reasons were perfectly fine, and he didn't explicitly argue against artistic integrity, it's just that he didn't display any, while making arguments about artistic choices.
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by mumblemumble on Friday August 23, 2019 @09:32AM (#20777360)
There's an interesting unstated major premise here, that "art" exclusively means pictures.

Spiderweb tends to focus on different aspects of game making that are admittedly a lot less visual, but are arguably no less artistic. This is a wildly hyperbolic analogy, but it seems to me that suggesting that Jeff Vogel doesn't care much about art because his games are weak on the visuals is a bit like suggesting that Led Zeppelin didn't care so much about art because their shows didn't offer the same visual spectacle as a GWAR performance.

Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by jimbokun on Thursday August 22, 2019 @06:12PM (#20772867)
> but the correct response to a question of why they don't make a "better" looking game is that they don't care. Or, maybe, it's a taste issue.

No, he plainly states it is a cost issue. He can't afford to hire the people who could create truly "good" art for his games.

Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by nothis on Thursday August 22, 2019 @06:46PM (#20773063)
Steamspy lists their games as having sold [in the millions](https://steamspy.com/dev/Spiderweb+Software). If they wanted to, they absolutely could afford a B+ tier art guy going through the basic steps of making their backgrounds not look like programmer art, for a few months.

You can actually see some decent concept art and character design in their current games but they're drowned out by a stubborn refusal to actually change the overall balance of detail, suffocating those decent artworks in a sea of blurry/noisy backgrounds. It's a colossal waste, really, only explainable by a stubborn refusal to "learn art", which I can respect by itself, but the post comes off as utter denial of that even happening.

It's okay to dismiss art direction and make that some kind of design philosophy, it works for their games. But blaming it on everything but dismissal feels wrong.

Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by demiskeleton on Thursday August 22, 2019 @07:33PM (#20773349)
Using Steamspy to just declare how much money he has made and that it is enough to support his family, continue development and hire someone for more art direction when the entire article is about he doesn't have enough money to hire someone is exactly why he wrote this article.

People keep posting in the thread that games with "bad art" still look good with "good art direction" but art direction also costs money, which he still doesn't have.

Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by dalore on Friday August 23, 2019 @11:38AM (#20778699)
You say they, but it's only one guy as explained. It's not that he sees art direction as a waste of resources, he sees it as a risk to his future. To expend resources in the art direction he would have to hire more people, and try and ensure the same art style. Which would mean he would need more sales. Plus he would have to upfront these expenses and he might not make it back.

It's an extra risk he doesn't want to his lifestyle that has worked for him for 25 years.

Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by sprafa on Thursday August 22, 2019 @05:47PM (#20772688)
Disrespectful ? The dude says his games look like crap. He doesn’t say everyone else’s should. He’s explaining why it makes business sense for him to do so! This is business 101 from a sucessful indie game dev
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by tripzilch on Friday August 23, 2019 @07:46AM (#20776491)
He also says his games look like crap because that's how old games look to him. Yes he has business sense, he also has no taste.
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by infectoid on Monday August 26, 2019 @09:16PM (#20805415)
Now this seems disrespectful.
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by barbs on Thursday August 22, 2019 @06:30PM (#20772976)
> he's basically writing an article attacking the very concept of art direction as a waste of resources. That comes off a little disrespectful towards people who care.

Sounds like "people who care" are people that have spent a lot of money on art and need to respond to this post to justify it. Or are artists themselves and need to prove their worth.

Money talks.

Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by NoodleIncident on Thursday August 22, 2019 @06:40PM (#20773033)
If he only was talking about his own art, then fewer people would be rubbed the wrong way. However, at regular intervals throughout this article, he feels the need to accuse his critics of also disliking other games with simple art. I think it's these quotes in particular that are the most pitchfork-worthy of the lot:

- (Screenshot of Ultima V) - "This is what looks normal to me"

- "Queen's Wish has a very retro square-tile top-down view, reminiscent of old Ultima games, old Pokemon games..."

- (Screenshot of Baba is You) - "If a game that looks like this can be a hit, maybe there can be room for me?"

- (Screenshot of Atari Adventure) - "If you don't like it, maybe the problem is you."

Apart from maybe(!) Atari Adventure, all of those games look far better than Queen's Wish. Even Ultima V shades one side of its walls, something none of his games have accomplished based on these screenshots.

It's an insulting strawman to say that the people criticizing his art would also reject these other games with simple art. It's also insulting to the artists who worked on those games, producing better results in a similar budget. Maybe the insult is unintentional, because he genuinely can't tell the difference himself. But if that's the case, he should just admit that, rather than hiding behind his choice to use a top-down perspective.

Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by tripzilch on Friday August 23, 2019 @08:09AM (#20776643)
> Even Ultima V shades one side of its walls, something none of his games have accomplished based on these screenshots.

It's the hundreds of tiny details like this, that make for great design and good art, regardless of how retro the medium is. That's what this guy seems to be utterly blind to, and it really rubs against people who DO like to spend the effort and time on such tiny details to get the design just right ... only for this guy to call it "looks good enough for me" and then imitate it badly.

Just stick to the business explanation, because there's nothing wrong with running a business on shitty art.

Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by bsder on Thursday August 22, 2019 @07:07PM (#20773196)
There are two problems: 1) the poor art actually causes one significant design fault and 2) I think the problem is actually that his art is too good in places.

1) If you look at Avernum 3 and Queen's Wish, the characters you are supposed to control don't "stick out" visually. I must have looked at the Avernum picture half a dozen times and actually missed the 3 other characters in the picture other than the cloak and the dragon. That's a huge mistake in visual design--and that is the fault of the designer not the artist. QW has similar issues in that the character design isn't very distinctive: without those horrible colored circles you can't tell friend from foe. And the visual design of the characters makes distinguishing classes difficult. Again, that's designer failure--not art failure.

2) If you look at QW, there are 4 different levels of art. The bottom icons are gorgeous and would fit in a AAA game. The portraits look like potato cam from 1999. The characters look like bad pseudo 2.5D from 1993. And the background sprites look like they are from "My First RPG Maker". You can choose any of those, be consistent, and people won't feel too bad. Look at Exile and Avernum--they have a consistent art level across everything and don't strike me as ugly. What you cannot do is mix and match the levels--that's very jarring and people will complain.

Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by crooked-v on Thursday August 22, 2019 @05:31PM (#20772575)
> The graphics in the games are exactly as good as they need to be

I feel like "exactly as good as they need to be" would actually be quite a bit simpler and, through lack of clutter, easier to use. See, for example, the Caves of Qud art style - https://i.imgur.com/Tul3mn3.png - which is substantially less visually complex than any of the Spiderweb Software games but, IMO, much easier to interpret.

Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by CobrastanJorji on Thursday August 22, 2019 @05:46PM (#20772674)
Could not agree more about simplicity, although I don't think he's using "good" to mean "complicated." Simple, minimalist art can be nearly as difficult as rich, complex art, and these games are neither of those.

"Exactly as good as they need to be" means "graphics and interface are of a sufficient quality to not significantly hamper interaction with the game, but just barely."

For example, a chess board drawn freestyle in crayon with a bunch of black and white poker chips that have "pawn", "knight", etc written on them in sharpie is "exactly as good as it needs to be," but it sure as heck isn't the same thing as an elegantly minimalist chess board.

Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by grawprog on Thursday August 22, 2019 @05:47PM (#20772686)
Looking at the screenshots in the article, I actually liked the graphics in Avernum 3 and even Escape from the Pit, they seemed consistent and actually pretty well done if a bit simple. I understand the complaints about Queen's Wish. They're not necessarily bad, I don't mind a lot of the tiles, but something does seem off with it. That being said, I've seen far worse and if the gameplay's good then it doesn't seem like that big of a deal.

I've actually been tempted to buy Avadon the black fortress a few times. It keeps showing up on steam(after reading this I had to double check, for some reason I had a feeling it was one of his games), again i find the graphics to be appealing. I'm just not sure if i want to invest the time into an RPG right now.

It seems like an easy solution would be to allow the tiles in the game to be editable and let people make new ones if they're unhappy with the ones that ship with the game.

Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by duskwuff on Thursday August 22, 2019 @06:18PM (#20772907)
> They're not necessarily bad, I don't mind a lot of the tiles, but something does seem off with it.

The problem I have with it is that it all looks really generic -- like default "RPG Maker" tiles or stock art. The old-school Exile art was simple, but it was unique and had its own distinctive style.

Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by sha666sum on Thursday August 22, 2019 @09:02PM (#20773766)
I never managed to play any games in the Avadon series, because they don't have as good keyboard shortcuts as the Avernum series. One of the Avadon games even has a Linux port, which wasn't done by Jeff himself
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by duskwuff on Thursday August 22, 2019 @10:33PM (#20774118)
Way back in the day (like, around 2000), there was a Linux port of Exile 3: https://www.spiderwebsoftware.com/exile3/linuxexile3.html

I don't think it'll run on a modern Linux system without a lot of hacking, though.

Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by Narishma on Friday August 23, 2019 @07:23AM (#20776355)
It's easier to run the Windows version in wine.
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by grawprog on Friday August 23, 2019 @11:28AM (#20778616)
The Linux port is what I've been looking at. I didn't realize it was ported by someone else, it would also explain why that's the only one of his games that comes up.
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by CydeWeys on Thursday August 22, 2019 @11:01AM (#20768843)
I haven't played these games, but I've put hundreds of hours into NetHack with pure ASCII graphics, so I totally get it. I briefly tried using some of the graphical versions but didn't end up liking them so much, so back to the ASCII it was.
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by perl4ever on Thursday August 22, 2019 @10:06PM (#20774024)
My first exposure to roguelikes was an Amiga graphical version of Hack in the 80s, so I always felt like they were "supposed to" have something more than ascii. But when I tried Diablo, I was really disappointed. It's not that the polished graphics detracted from anything, but that the depth of interaction was lacking.

I remember seeing a first person shooter after years of ignoring games, and being really impressed by the advances in graphics, but in seconds, I could see it was still a world made of indestructible cardboard, which was very disappointing. I suppose things have improved somewhat, depending on genre, but anyway, the issue is that people are easily distracted by graphics, not that they detract from anything per se.

Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by zapzupnz on Thursday August 22, 2019 @04:26PM (#20772046)
It's not my understanding that having a fond nostalgia for somebody's works excuses the article's salty tone that basically tells people they're wrong for thinking the games are ugly, coming up with all manner of excuses but never once embracing that the problem is entirely the developer's own and nobody else's; yes, that point is laid out there but it's given as an excuse, not as a justification. There's a fine line.
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by haolez on Thursday August 22, 2019 @05:32PM (#20772582)
He is not saying that everyone is wrong. He is saying that some people like it, most people don't, and the ones that do like it are enough to keep his business afloat.
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by eridius on Thursday August 22, 2019 @04:30PM (#20772077)
> unprompted

The guy's been getting criticisms for 25 years. I think he's justified in writing a single blog post in defense of his art style. If you don't like it, you don't have to read it.

Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by zapzupnz on Thursday August 22, 2019 @04:34PM (#20772112)
What does the 25 years have to do with it? There are developers who've been in the industry for far less time who are much more reactive and responsive to criticism. If anything, that mention of 25 years is an indictment, not anything worse praising.

Also, 'art style' is a stretch.

Finally, yes, if I don't like it, I don't have to read it. Yet, I did, and I'm free to express my dissatisfaction and disagreement with the article's message: if you don't like it, you don't have to read it.

Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by austhrow743 on Thursday August 22, 2019 @10:41PM (#20774139)
>What does the 25 years have to do with it?

It means it's not unprompted. It's a reply.

Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by tripzilch on Friday August 23, 2019 @08:17AM (#20776711)
> I think he's justified in writing a single blog post in defense of his art style. If you don't like it, you don't have to read it.

I think he's justified in writing a blog post about his business decision and should have kept it at that.

But defending this as an "art style" is like making really shitty cheap knockoff "vintage style" furniture and claiming part of the reason is because you love the artistic style of historic wood working. No you do it for the money, and people who actually like vintage historic wood work might get annoyed that you are pushing your work as the same.

Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by jimbokun on Thursday August 22, 2019 @06:13PM (#20772879)
> that basically tells people they're wrong for thinking the games are ugly

Uh, no, he freely concedes his games are ugly. The title of the article is "Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap".

Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by JamesBarney on Thursday August 22, 2019 @05:50PM (#20772708)
I didn't get salty from the article at all. Just an explanation about why their games look the way they do and why they haven't tried to improve it(money and risk).
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by ineedasername on Thursday August 22, 2019 @10:43PM (#20774148)
He's not saying people are wrong for thinking the games are ugly. Quite the opposite, he's very open to the validity of that opinion while also believing they're okay as-is. No, the whole point he's making is simply that, to his judgment, it doesn't make good business sense to invest more in art, and when he did so the results were no different.
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by gbersac on Thursday August 22, 2019 @09:33AM (#20767840)
I only played one of his game (avalon), but I finished it. As a casual / very hard to please player, finishing a game is a rare event. Congrats to him.

And the graphism are good enough imo.

Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by mumblemumble on Thursday August 22, 2019 @11:09AM (#20768929)
This, for me, is the thing that really distinguishes Spiderweb's games: it seems that nobody else out there is still making CRPGs that I actually finish.

Other games look beautiful, yes, but they also somehow always end up getting kind of boring several hours in.

Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by marktangotango on Thursday August 22, 2019 @02:02PM (#20770784)
Same here, very few games hold my attention long enough to finish, and his games do. Jeff's been a very good citizen of the indie game scene for a long time. I have a great deal of admiration for him and what he's accomplished.
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by baud147258 on Thursday August 22, 2019 @12:07PM (#20769576)
Vogel's using the level of graphic quality that work for him, but that doesn't excuse the inconsistent art direction and mixed art styles.
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by KyleBerezin on Thursday August 22, 2019 @01:37PM (#20770525)
The art style is mixed because he reuses most of his graphics. I think his pot sprite is almost 20 years old now. He just doesn't want to commission new art for every game. New objects and skills need new art, and I'd doubt Philip Foglio is still available to draw them.
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by sprafa on Thursday August 22, 2019 @05:49PM (#20772703)
Lol seriously the dude runs with sprites from 20 years ago? That’s seriously amazing
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by zaphar on Thursday August 22, 2019 @06:44PM (#20773055)
I agree, it's seriously awesome that he was able to get that much value out of that Sprite.
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by mark-r on Thursday August 22, 2019 @10:22AM (#20768362)
I suspect he knew exactly what the reaction would be when he wrote the article.
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by ehsankia on Thursday August 22, 2019 @02:01PM (#20770775)
Yeah, when you write such an abrasive post, literally ending with "haters gonna hate" and basically implying that anyone who doesn't like the art is stupid, I'm not sure what kind of reaction you expect to get.
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by sprafa on Thursday August 22, 2019 @05:50PM (#20772710)
Don’t know what article you read. He said the art being shit makes business sense to him
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by ehsankia on Thursday August 22, 2019 @07:29PM (#20773325)
I've been reading this article, which one have you been reading?

https://i.imgur.com/rZozQHD.png

Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by sprafa on Thursday August 22, 2019 @10:27PM (#20774084)
I don’t understand how that implies people who dislike his art style to be stupid. I’d see the expression more as a reflection of “find your niche, ignore everyone else”
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by ehsankia on Friday August 23, 2019 @01:06PM (#20779763)
Saying that you're glad people have attacked your art, and hoping that they continue is needlessly combative and reeks of an holier than thou attitude, as does the rest of the article.
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by tripzilch on Friday August 23, 2019 @08:23AM (#20776753)
It's not. It's not an art style, it's the lack of one. And then he compares it to retro games with an actual art style and says this is "good enough for him". Calling it an art style is an affront to people who DO spend the time and effort on these things. So he explains it makes business sense for him to not care about art direction. Okay fine. But then don't drag other games into it.
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by tripzilch on Friday August 23, 2019 @08:20AM (#20776731)
Yeah in the second half, and that would have made a fine blog post. He also said a lot of other things, which didn't.
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by nslav on Thursday August 22, 2019 @11:11AM (#20768961)
I have fond memories of playing Exile II as a 10 or 11 year old. My dad worked at Boeing at the time, and there was some sort of store where the company sold surplus supplies where he bought used Macs for me and my brothers. These were not fast computers so it was thanks to Exile II "looking like crap" that we were able to play it at all!
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by zapzupnz on Thursday August 22, 2019 @04:39PM (#20772159)
> There were not fast computers so it was thanks to Exile II "looking like crap" that we were able to play it at all

You're making the mistake of thinking that a game that looks good must use more resources. That doesn't make sense.

If one took the exact same resources and gave them a more consistent art style, keeping the same file sizes or even lowering them, the games could look just fine and yet still fine on a low-end machine.

Better looking graphics or art != larger file sizes.

Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by xtracto on Thursday August 22, 2019 @09:06AM (#20767572)
I havent played any of his games but now would love to do it. I like dwarf fortress and generally am bummed with the gameplay in current games.
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by IggleSniggle on Thursday August 22, 2019 @09:39AM (#20767889)
Try Cogmind.
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by eropple on Thursday August 22, 2019 @10:05AM (#20768175)
Cogmind is really cool and really pushes (to a screaming breaking point) what you can do with "ASCII art". It also helps that the developer is a very chill person, for sure.

But to the GP, you should go play his games! Try "Avernum: Escape from the Pit", his remake of his remake of his original game (he's got a system down pat). It's the best game he's made, IMO, and the iPad version is really good if you've got one lying around. PC/Mac version is good too, of course, but I found the touch interface really nice and a refreshing way to play a game I'd already exhaustively completed twice, so I'd hope it'd meet more modern sensibilities pretty well.

Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by steeleduncan on Thursday August 22, 2019 @03:21PM (#20771484)
Also in that vein, Caves of Qud is worth a try.
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by aoeusnth1 on Friday August 23, 2019 @02:06AM (#20774903)
Ever tried Factorio?
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by SkyBelow on Thursday August 22, 2019 @10:28AM (#20768425)
It has been a long time since I played his games but I always really enjoyed the original exile games. I haven't gotten into the newer Avalon remakes as much, but that is mostly a time constraint issue as there are many games and so little time. My memories as a kid are that they were great games if you liked rpgs.
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by stickfigure on Thursday August 22, 2019 @05:57PM (#20772769)
I still occasionally play Nethack. In a terminal. I've seen graphical frontends for the game but IMO that stuff just gets in the way.
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by perl4ever on Thursday August 22, 2019 @10:08PM (#20774029)
The first version of Nethack I played had graphics for the walls and empty space only.
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by BirdieNZ on Thursday August 22, 2019 @05:11PM (#20772381)
I remember playing Exile: Escape from the Pit. Great game, the graphics didn't matter because the story was what was important.
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by thecupisblue on Thursday August 22, 2019 @04:54PM (#20772263)
Me too! If it wasn't for the Avernum series, I probably wouldn't be speaking english that well or posting here right now!
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by arkades on Thursday August 22, 2019 @03:56PM (#20771789)
Yes. I’m looking forward to that n-gate’s webshit weekly take on this.
Re:Why All of Our Games Look Like Crap by awillen on Thursday August 22, 2019 @10:11PM (#20774046)
On the plus side, this is the top comment, so the silent majority seems to agree with you.

Art just isn't critical to making amazing games... some old BBS games like Tradewars 2002 will always be among my favorites, and their ASCII images barely qualified as art.