News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by sjwright on Monday August 19, 2019 @12:25AM (#20734879)
I keep hearing stories like this and I remain utterly bemused that the median narrative about Android vs iOS has barely changed in response. There's a lot to love about Android, but I think more people in the tech sector need to realise that their mental model of the phone marketplace has more to do with historical perception of Android being "hacker friendly" than the current realities.

Android is open source! Oh wait— it's becoming more closed every release cycle, to the point that a pure AOSP experience is something only a determined geek would ever love. iOS and Android are now both blends of open and closed source, albeit in different ratios.

Google's app store is developer friendly! Oh wait— approvals are now slower than Apple, they're banning developers with no explanation, yet the store is still full of crapware and scams. At least Apple's policies seem to have a tangible trade-off.

Android gives customers hardware choices! Oh wait— the choice is between a cheap device that got its final software update five days after it shipped, a mid-tier device that might get updated next year, or a flagship which will probably get next year's major update and only security fixes thereafter.

Android gives customers software choices! Oh wait— what's the current messaging platform that Google is pushing this month? Do you, the human reading this paragraph, really care if there are eight hundred or eight thousand camera apps in your phone's app store?

Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by Illniyar on Monday August 19, 2019 @02:18AM (#20735335)
All those things don't really matter, the only thing that matters is that you cannot sideload apps in iOS. As long as you can sideload apps in android, it will always have a better reputation than somewhere you cannot.

But even those things you mention, they are all part of a scale, even if android becomes more closed-source it's still miles more open-source than iOS, even if it delays new app submissions it's still doesn't require a mac to develop for, has a choice of IDEs and a dozen other development friendly features that we often take for granted outside iOS development.

And it is ludicrous to suggest that android has the same hardware choice as iPhones just because apple now has mid-range level priced phones. Hardware choice means that some models have replaceable battery, physical keyboard, bendable screens, childproof, waterproof and many more options.

Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by KenanSulayman on Monday August 19, 2019 @03:47AM (#20735752)
Just resign the app IPA file and you can literally drag and drop it through Xcode onto your iOS devices. Unless you mean pirating apps with sideloading...
Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by Illniyar on Monday August 19, 2019 @05:27AM (#20736225)
that's not even remotely usable by 99% of iPhone users. It's like saying you can sideload apps if you root your phone.
Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by ajscanlan on Monday August 19, 2019 @05:01AM (#20736111)
To run an .ipa on a real device you need to sign it with an Apple developer account, costs $99 a year.
Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by lotsofpulp on Monday August 19, 2019 @05:08AM (#20736140)
I thought it has been free for your own device for years:

https://www.pcworld.com/article/2933052/apple-frees-casual-i...

Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by ajscanlan on Monday August 19, 2019 @05:56AM (#20736362)
Ah! I did not know that, it's been so long since I've not had a developer account. But yes it seems you are right.

Do you still have to re-sign the .ipa every 7 days to have it run on the device?

Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by oefrha on Monday August 19, 2019 @07:49AM (#20736920)
You do unless you have a paid developer account.
Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by rahimnathwani on Monday August 19, 2019 @06:09AM (#20736435)
This only works if you:

- Sign up for a free developer account, and

- Are willing to re-install the app every week

Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by reyqn on Monday August 19, 2019 @05:04AM (#20736123)
You need to have macOS though
Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by mprev on Monday August 19, 2019 @03:20AM (#20735624)
Sideloading of apps is, at best, a niche interest.
Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by indy on Monday August 19, 2019 @04:45AM (#20736030)
When the number of devices number in the billions then of course sideloading could be considered a niche interest. But for people involved in software development it's extremely useful being able to sideload the latest build of an app to show to stakeholders.
Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by sjwright on Monday August 19, 2019 @07:42PM (#20742702)
You say that like nobody developing iOS apps has stakeholders. Apple gives developers solutions for that which are much neater and streamlined.

For development life cycles, sideloading is an unnecessary kludge.

Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by Illniyar on Monday August 19, 2019 @05:26AM (#20736216)
Until it isn't. The moment a popular enough app gets banned by google play store, the use of sideloading will skyrocket. If apple decides to ban Telegram, there's nothing you can do (which it did btw at some point).

The ability to sideload is more important than it's usage, both for your personal freedom and for keeping large companies in check.

Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by Yizahi on Monday August 19, 2019 @06:21AM (#20736483)
Until you discover that for example Android Auto is banned in your whole country, while being completely functional after sideloading the apk. And the only reason why there aren't hundreds of millions people sideloading apps (yet) is relatively slow rate of car upgrades. This is only one example.
Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by xvector on Monday August 19, 2019 @04:04AM (#20735835)
The number of people that side load apps are so small as to be completely inconsequential.
Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by bad_user on Monday August 19, 2019 @02:34AM (#20735410)
I'm an iPhone user currently, have been for some time.

However all of the points you mentioned are still true.

There is no open source in iOS and the entire platform has an anti open source culture. Android has a lot of open source apps available, including an app store meant just for open source (https://www.f-droid.org/).

If you don't like Google Play, at the very least you can distribute your app independently without jailbreaking the phone. It might take the users fiddling with their settings, but at least the option is legit.

Also on Android you can have actual Firefox (not allowed on iOS), with ads-blocking extensions and everything, as the default browser. And apps don't necessarily insist on opening up their own freaking web view, or if they do, most of the time there's an option for opting out.

And yes, you can find really good Android phones for cheap. Like the ones from Huawei. Which I stay away from, but for other reasons.

Apple's phones age well and I like to be environmental friendly, so I'll keep this iPhone 8+ I have until it breaks.

But my next phone is not going to be an iPhone, sorry.

Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by ninedays on Monday August 19, 2019 @03:55AM (#20735787)
> There is no open source in iOS and the entire platform has an anti open source culture.

People really have short memory and unfortunately have too much biais to even make a simple Google Search to get some informations. Trying to define this as "one is better than the others related to X" is childish at best.

https://developer.apple.com/opensource/

Warm vibes,

Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by bad_user on Monday August 19, 2019 @05:20AM (#20736192)
WebKit, you mean the source code that was forked from KHTML and because it was GPL, Apple would then do incomprehensible code dumps to comply with the law? WebKit that was forked by Google because they couldn't collaborate with Apple?

I'm glad that they ended up releasing it, but to show that as an example of open source from Apple ... indeed shows that people have short memories ;-)

Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by ninedays on Monday August 19, 2019 @05:41AM (#20736282)
> WebKit that was forked by Google because they couldn't collaborate with Apple?

You say "they couldn't collaborate" I say "Google really wanted to compete".

Remember that it was Google who decided to perform a fork because they had a different approach than Apple for how "multi-process" should be implemented. Google had an implementation that they didn't want to integrate into the Webkit branch - hence the Blink fork.[1]

Also Apple would have been happy if they could use the Google's implementation instead of using their own - they said that repeatedly [2]

You can also find more details of the story here. It looks more and more obvious that the decision to create a WebKit fork was more political than technical : https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5490242

[1] https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2013/apr/05/blink-goo...

[2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5490661

Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by bad_user on Monday August 19, 2019 @05:45AM (#20736301)
I am not defending Google. Google is really shitty in terms of open source collaboration. Many of Google's OSS efforts are OSS just in license, but not in spirit.

All I'm saying is that Apple's WebKit is not a good example of OSS and if that's what you have to show for iOS, then it's a really sad state of affairs.

Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by lloeki on Monday August 19, 2019 @04:12AM (#20735869)
> anti open source culture

I feel like it's more like anti-GPL (because of some specific licensing terms conflicts), and there's nothing intrinsically anti-FOSS in there.

Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by xvector on Monday August 19, 2019 @04:06AM (#20735846)
> at the very least you can distribute your app independently without jailbreaking the phone.

The discussion in the article is about developers. If you’re kicked off of Play by a robot, there’s nothing you can do.

> with ads-blocking extensions and everything, as the default browser.

Ad-blocking is easy and well-supported in Safari. Safari’s tracking prevention extends far beyond anything Firefox has even with the best extensions.

Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by bad_user on Monday August 19, 2019 @04:59AM (#20736103)
The discussion is indeed relevant to developers and developers can distribute apps outside of Play. How is that not relevant?

Also, having worked on an actual anti-ad-blocking platform I can tell you that Safari's content blockers are shit. They are the easiest to detect and circumvent and the reason for why many publishers still don't is because (1) they don't know it's possible, or (2) they are afraid of pissing visitors off, especially given growing GDPR concerns.

The most potent ad-blocker on the market is uBlock Origin. And Firefox on Android supports it, the only mobile browser that does. Soon to be the only desktop browser too, but that's another discussion.

Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by lol768 on Monday August 19, 2019 @04:12AM (#20735871)
>Ad-blocking is easy and well-supported in Safari. Safari’s tracking prevention extends far beyond anything Firefox has even with the best extensions.

Do you have any links so I can read further on this? I'd like to compare it to both Firefox's built-in tracking protection (and fingerprinting resistance) and the functionality provided by e.g. uBlock Origin.

Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by xvector on Monday August 19, 2019 @04:34AM (#20735966)
Not any links on hand, but try it yourself. Load up Firefox with the best tracking prevention tools you can find. Go to https://panopticlick.eff.org/. See how many bits of entropy you have.

Do the same in Safari.

Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by ajscanlan on Monday August 19, 2019 @05:22AM (#20736200)
I did some testing.

Android - Firefox - Ghostery + uBlock: "Strong protection against Web tracking" 17.59 bits of identifying information

iOS - Safari - Stock: "Some protection against Web tracking" 17.59 bits of identifying information

iOS - Safari - AdBlockPlus: "Some protection against Web tracking" 17.59 bits of identifying information (Exact same as Stock? Blocks ads though)

Mac - Safari - Stock: "Some protection against Web tracking" 16.59 bits of identifying information.

Mac - Chrome - Ghostery + uBlock: "Strong protection against Web tracking" Doesn't seem to finish the fingerprinting stage.

Mac - Chrome - Stock: "No. You are not protected against tracking on the Web" 16.01 bits of identifying information.

Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by bad_user on Monday August 19, 2019 @05:50AM (#20736320)
You could use uMatrix instead of uBlock.

Blocking JavaScript is the most potent form of fingerprinting resistance.

It's not comfortable to whitelist websites or pieces of functionality from websites, but at least you have the option. If on desktop Chrome, enjoy it while you still can, because Google just deprecated the underlying APIs ;-)

Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by xvector on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @08:00AM (#20745894)
That is strange. I had about 13 bits of information, so did my coworkers.
Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by bad_user on Monday August 19, 2019 @05:38AM (#20736272)
Not sure what I'm supposed to see, however this is my Firefox: https://www.dropbox.com/s/iiahhn1hb05nm5w/Screenshot%202019-...

And this is my Safari (with the most popular content blocker active): https://www.dropbox.com/s/4n4hxbnumcyqegu/Screenshot%202019-...

So my Firefox has less bits of entropy than my Safari, although I do admit that my Firefox has a custom configuration (it isn't out of the box), but so does my Safari.

Also Firefox might have plenty to work on in regards to resisting fingerprinting techniques, however there are ongoing projects for that, for importing techniques already used in the Tor Browser:

https://wiki.mozilla.org/Security/Fingerprinting

And Firefox does protect against entities known to practice fingerprinting, which you can't say about Safari:

https://blog.mozilla.org/futurereleases/2019/04/09/protectio...

Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by xvector on Tuesday August 20, 2019 @08:03AM (#20745917)
I got 13 bits from Safari. Safari 12 introduced advanced fingerprinting resistance, I think they’re pretty far ahead of Firefox here.
Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by snaky on Monday August 19, 2019 @03:12AM (#20735578)
> a cheap device that got its final software update five days after it shipped

Xiaomi Redmi Note 4, released 2016, MTK-based cheap smartphone, current official stable ROM is V10.2.2.0.MBFCNXM released May 2019.

> Apple shipped 33.8 million new iPhones during 2Q19, which was down significantly from the same quarter one year ago. Regardless of the slightly lower market share and device selling prices, the iPhone installed base continued to grow. The numbers show that now 3rd placed Apple may soon drop into 4th, with Xiaomi only 1.5 million handsets behind Apple.

Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by nobrains on Monday August 19, 2019 @04:30AM (#20735948)
Android gives customers hardware choices

You dilute your argument by mentioning this point.

Google does give better hardware choices. I am using a $150 android-one phone (Xiaomi A3) which has a high end comparable back and front camera. And comes with 2 years guaranteed OS updates.

Compare with the cheapest latest iPhone (iPhone XR) which is 5 times more expensive at $750.

Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by mav3rick on Monday August 19, 2019 @01:18AM (#20735072)
Yes everyone should be rich enough to buy a 1000 dollar Apple phone. Also, you get to decide if I want more than one camera app or not ?

Stop imposing your world view on others. Android made smartphones accessible to many people across the globe. You won't mention that would you ? Won't fit your narrative.

Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by nominated1 on Monday August 19, 2019 @01:46AM (#20735194)
> Yes everyone should be rich enough to buy a 1000 dollar Apple phone.

I bought an iPhone 7 from Net10 about 5 months ago for $220 shipped. It requires a minimum $20 a month plan for 12 months before I can unlock it. About 2 years ago I got my mom an iPhone SE for $140 with similar plan/unlock. Both brand new.

They’re not everyday prices and not the newest model but it is possible to go iOS without breaking the bank.

Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by amputect on Monday August 19, 2019 @02:47AM (#20735463)
The "1000 dollar apple phone" thing is such a weird myth.

My wife has been using the iphone 5s for years now, because the later models are too big for her to hold comfortably. It originally came out in 2013. It is still supported by Apple, and hers currently runs iOS 12.4, which came out last month. She is on her second 5s, because she dropped her first one in the lake trying to take a picture of our dog. I use it from time to time to help pull up music or navigation in the car and it runs just fine, it's a perfectly usable phone.

These days, you can get a "renewed" one for less than a hundred dollars, unlocked, straight from Amazon.

Android is the phone ecosystem where you actually need to spend a thousand dollars* on phone hardware, because all of the inexpensive android devices are cheaply made garbage that feel like they should come filled with candy. They are stuffed with manufacturer bloatware (if you're lucky, or malware if you're not), and are obsolete right out of the box. If you spend a hundred dollars on an android phone, I absolutely guarantee you that you will regret it.

I'm not exactly an apple partisan here, I work on android apps for a living, I've used android phones for years, I actually like the Android OS and I want it to thrive, but the current state of the overall android hardware and software ecosystem, outside of the very high end devices that most people frankly can't afford, is just dire.

*- I have a pixel 3 XL, I know a thing or two about spending a thousand dollars to get a usable android device.

Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by mav3rick on Monday August 19, 2019 @02:55AM (#20735501)
There are enough cheap to mid range devices that do the job in Android. I dont think you understand the value of even 100$ in a developing country. Most people don't care about updates in this scenario. They want a phone that works. And far more people in the lower strata have access to cheaper Android phones than Apple.
Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by amputect on Monday August 19, 2019 @03:13AM (#20735583)
I have a genuine question: what are some of the "cheap to mid range devices" you're thinking of here?

Honest question, not trying to be a jerk, I genuinely want to know.

Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by mav3rick on Monday August 19, 2019 @03:38AM (#20735702)
https://www.digit.in/top-products/top-10-best-phone-under-50...

Keep in mind 5000 Rs is equivalent to around 80 USD.

Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by RugnirViking on Monday August 19, 2019 @12:37PM (#20739258)
If you are looking for a brand-new phone in the solidly mid-range for around $250, you can look at pocophone or OnePlus for smaller but still well-known companies making excellent phones. These phones compete in pretty much every way with the more expensive offerings by google or samsung, and have no vendor bloatware.

OnePlus's latest models have become a bit pricier, going on $450, but you can still buy the oneplus 6 straight from them for a good price.

Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by omnimus on Monday August 19, 2019 @03:56AM (#20735791)
I have xiaomi m1a1 and i think it's well made. The production quality doesnt seem to be issue nowdays.
Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by abenga on Monday August 19, 2019 @01:24PM (#20739703)
The best phone I ever owned was a Moto G. Cost me about $200. I currently use a Nokia 6.1. Cost me about $250 a year ago, and regularly gets updates.
Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by nobrains on Monday August 19, 2019 @04:36AM (#20735974)
Try the Xiaomi Mi A2 or A3 (if good cam is your requirement) or any android-one device in the $150 to $250 price range.
Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by bad_user on Monday August 19, 2019 @02:23AM (#20735365)
So your iPhone 7 actually costs $220 + $20 * 12 = $460

Is that correct?

Not sure what the situation is over there, but in my country I've got a $5 prepaid plan with unlimited minutes, 10 GB monthly bandwidth and I can stop paying at any time.

So I hope you don't go around pretending that the $20 you're paying per month isn't for that phone ;-)

Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by maccard on Monday August 19, 2019 @03:20AM (#20735620)
You have to actually take the cost of the plan you were playing anyway off the monthly for a fair comparison. In this case $400.

Chances are the OP doesn't have the option of a 5$ plan with 10GB data - I certainly don't (that's closer to $20 here).

Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by mav3rick on Monday August 19, 2019 @02:37AM (#20735425)
Thanks for catching that subsidy
Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by mav3rick on Monday August 19, 2019 @02:22AM (#20735352)
Again why should consumers not buy a newer phone for cheaper. Who are you to tell them what's right for them ? In India $220 dollars is a luxury many people can't afford.
Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by nobrains on Monday August 19, 2019 @04:34AM (#20735964)
I got my mom an iPhone SE for $140

How is the 16gb storage holding up for her?

Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by MaysonL on Monday August 19, 2019 @05:23AM (#20736207)
My $140 SE from Walmart has 32GB.
Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by lstamour on Monday August 19, 2019 @01:52AM (#20735222)
An iPhone SE is $238 in India, $299-449 in the US. Similar pricing exists for the iPhone 6 & 6s, and the iPhone 7 is quite good while still well under $1000 most places.
Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by jeroenhd on Monday August 19, 2019 @03:01AM (#20735534)
The average wage in India is a little above 5 dollars a day. That's about 160 dollars a month. Translated to American wage standards, the $238 dollar iPhone would cost about $6000 (1.5 the average monthly wage).

A $238 dollar smartphone is inaccessible to most people in India. A "well under $1000 dollar" iPhone much less so.

Dollar values don't really translate as well to other countries as much as we'd like. Translating the price to a month's wage can bring a lot of perspective.

Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by e12e on Monday August 19, 2019 @11:32AM (#20738631)
You'd probably want to use median rather than average for such comparisons - I don't have those on hand right now, but it'd be interesting to compare/contrast.
Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by snaky on Monday August 19, 2019 @03:17AM (#20735611)
It seems iPhones ain't very popular in India.

> Xiaomi has now been India’s top smartphone seller for eight straight quarters. The Chinese electronics giant shipped 10.4 million handsets in the quarter that ended in June, commanding 28.3% of the market, research firm IDC reported Tuesday. Its closest rival, Samsung — which once held the top spot in India — shipped 9.3 million handsets in the nation during the same period, settling for a 25.3% market share.

Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by sieabahlpark on Monday August 19, 2019 @01:47AM (#20735201)
I personally like that my phone has expandable memory and iPhone features 3 years before the iPhone.
Re:Open letter from an Android developer to the Google Play ... by dvfjsdhgfv on Monday August 19, 2019 @02:44AM (#20735453)
I'm not sure why you've been downvoted. The current trends are quite interesting: Huawei & co. are bending over backwards to introduce innovative solutions into their phones, whereas Apple seems quite conservative and seems satisfied with putting in more powerful chips mostly. I'm amazed what you can do with some Chinese phones, and I wonder why Apple is less aggressive about new features than they used to be.