To flip it around to the companies, how useless would this job posting: "Internet company in North America looking for developers. We have fewer than 1 million employees and all employees get indoor working space." That accurately describes Groupon, Facebook, Dropbox, and Joe's Waffle and Website Sweatshop.
Things like blogs, twitter, etc are signals and they're useful for people that need to make decisions based on limited information.
And thus we need to expend resources on signaling, instead of on actually pursuing/growing within the field. Personally, I'd rather not hire the developers with the most beautiful tail-feathers.
At my startup of the 8 devs, we had 2 on twitter and 3 with their own blogs, so the bulk of us didn't do either. But we got along great. Why wouldn't we? What does Twitter and blogging have to do with interpersonal relationships?
It may be arbitrary, but github+blog+twitter has worked well here.
1. I don't think anything technically interesting can be accurately explained in the 140 characters provided by Twitter.
2. Simply announcing what I'm working on is self-congratulatory back-patting. No one cares what I'm working on that hour.
3. I have many non-technical friends (e.g., no one else in my frat is CS). I would not alienate them from a conversation by only talking about tech all the time.
1. I don't think anything interesting can be accurately explained in the 140 characters provided by Twitter.
2. Simply announcing what I'm working on is self-congratulatory back-patting. No one cares what I'm working on that hour.
3. I have many friends with different interests. I would not alienate them from a conversation by only talking about X all the time.
As for Twitter ... seriously?