this is why i m an advocate of making the law === to ethics. The reason a company is unethical is because those that are ethical are punished by the market (as an unethical, but completely law abiding company can outcompete them by virtue of having less costs involved).
That said, I definitely agree that the law needs to change for these situations. It's tricky though, because the entire reason people create corporations is to avoid personal responsibility for their actions.
Also, corporations allow you to avoid personal financial liability but not personal responsibility.... society and community still holds people accountable for social violations. People are also still accountable for criminal activity.
That violates the law of non-contradiction. Either one is wrong and one is right, or both people are wrong and they haven't realized what is right yet. Moral subjectivism as a principle makes absolutely no sense, and Aristotle destroyed that argument in Nichomachean Ethics.
I don't disagree with GP, just pointing out that it's a bit more sinister than just writing tickets. many situations where police abuse their power and/or use excessive force begin with a legal traffic stop.
Why can't we have something similar for such professions?
The problem isn't lack of knowledge or skill, it is that management refuses to commit the resources necessary to build secure products. When the difference between building secure X and not-secure X is often 2-3 times the effort and time commitment, managers will almost always pick not-secure X and roll the dice on nothing going wrong.
From their point of view, adding security does nothing for the product. The customers are paying for the value-prop and marginal improvements on it, not the integrity of the backend.
If you want to solve the problem of lax security, you need to make security breaches a buisness-ending proposition. You also need to increase the likelyhood of being compromised so that people aren't tempted to roll the dice. If you want regulation, I would support some kind of white hat law that says if you compromise sensitive company data, the corporation has to (1) pay an amazon-bankrupting amount of money and (2) they have to give 20% of it to the team that broke them.
I'd love to see this even though I know it won't happen but I want to go through a mental exercise:
(Off-topic but) where does this money go to? I think about things like traffic tickets or any other fee or fine and I can't think of anything that's any good. If it goes to anything that taxes would go toward, it will cause pressure to decrease taxes and make our governments dependent on this income.
Is there any good answer to this? Prison for the CEO and the board seems much easier in comparison.
But if it is the more normal circumstance (some vulnerability in the 30 libraries you use, led to the breach), there should absolutely be a monetary punishment but jail time seems too much.
For profit companies are often quite unethical. Laws that put executives in jail if they do not perform basic due diligence might help, e.g. proof a security program is established and executed on, to ensure their own defined standards and policies are met. There are quite a few CSO/CISOs from breached companies who should not be allowed to continue performing their profession.
Startups are often perfectly falling into this bucket unfortunately. As soon as one has more then a certain amount of customers, stakes should become extremely high.