News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by ryan_j_naughton on Thursday August 15, 2019 @07:18PM (#20710639)
While it is absolutely valid to discuss Amazon's market power and the nature of monopoly in the modern era, the ideas that a featured product would be featured because it makes the company more money is in no way scandalous!

If any retail store has an end-cap product placement of an item that they are featuring, everyone presumes it is because it is a profit maximizer for them. Why is it presumed that Amazon must be a more impartial arbiter of quality versus traditional brick and mortar retail? In part it is because Amazon is a marketplace, but both are middlemen (except for private label products from your grocery store or Walmart/target).

Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by filmgirlcw on Thursday August 15, 2019 @07:34PM (#20710739)
I would say the difference here is that you can’t see ratings/reviews from other buyers on an end-cap the same way you do online. So the phrase “Amazon’s Choice” suggests that there is a level of editorial oversight that might not exist if the phrase was “featured by Amazon.”

Overall, I agree that this isn’t a huge surprise, but I think the fact that Amazon has data on things like returns, ratings, reviews, makes it totally understandable why someone would assume a “choice” product was chosen because of those factors and not because the company paid to be featured.

Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by CobrastanJorji on Thursday August 15, 2019 @08:01PM (#20710908)
"Amazon's Choice" certainly suggests editorial oversight, but only in the way that "Quality Inn" suggests quality. For anything that isn't an objective, measurable fact, companies are allowed to lie.
Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by GavinMcG on Thursday August 15, 2019 @08:36PM (#20711106)
The difference is that Quality Inn represents itself as "quality". Amazon is advertising other products as being chosen by them. We know not to trust a company's claims about its product, but if you ask an employee about a product you expect an honest answer – not one based on a kickback, for example.
Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by wolco on Thursday August 15, 2019 @08:55PM (#20711210)
I worked for electronic stores in the 90s. Certain products gave more commission. We sold the products that paid more. I sold phones at some point.. Depending on the brand I might get an extra 5 dollars. Those are the phones that were sold more.

An employee isn't going to give you an objective honest answer or they would tell you walmart has it for cheaper.

Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by Benjammer on Friday August 16, 2019 @12:09AM (#20712094)
I'm sorry, but that's BS. What brick and mortar store doesn't promote third party products in the exact same fashion?

Case in point, literally a brick and mortar store with "<store name>'s Choice" as the slogan, to market a brand created by a third party company: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sam%27s_Choice

Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by jjwhitaker on Friday August 16, 2019 @02:33PM (#20718131)
Unethical behavior is still unethical if other people are doing it too. In the case of Amazon there isn't a physical evaluation of a product if it's "on and end cap" and promoted like a typical brick and mortar store. I've purchased the Amazon Choice item many times as I didn't have time to read reviews on a dozen similar products and assumed the one they recommended was well rated, reliable, the best choice. If it was properly labelled "Featured by Amazon," I'd have assumed something very different and inspected the product carefully.

In a physical store, I have ignored the end cap because the product was visibly a smaller volume than a competitor at a similar price. I can also go to the aisle section and directly compare all the options the store presents vs products filtered down and advertised to me by Amazon's algorithms. There is bias but more transparency like bottom shelf vs eye level. Amazon is a black hole unless you still trust their review system.

Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by Retric on Friday August 16, 2019 @12:23PM (#20716761)
It’s very common for stores to advertise money losing items to get people into the store. In store they often promote their extremely low price on something to make a positive association with their customers and move more products.

Amazon’s approach is micro optimized to make money today at the cost of customer satisfaction, a long term losing strategy.

PS: It might just be my circle of friends, but many Amazon early adopters have mostly moved on. That opening the box and wondering how you where screwed this time feeling is a major issue for the company.

Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by sciurus on Saturday August 17, 2019 @05:16AM (#20723017)
Moved on to which alternatives?
Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by GavinMcG on Wednesday August 21, 2019 @05:47PM (#20762189)
Again, that's a store representing its own product in a certain way. And a full brand called "Amazon's Choice" isn't what's happening here.
Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by onion2k on Friday August 16, 2019 @01:55AM (#20712506)
By the sounds of it "Sam's Choice" is similarly deceptive. That doesn't let Amazon off the hook here though.
Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by barbecue_sauce on Friday August 16, 2019 @03:00PM (#20718458)
I don't see how Sam's Choice is deceptive. Private label product programs are created by retail organizations, often at the behest of the founders/top management (usually the same in family run retail organizations). This is how I imagine it went down:

-Sam Walton said "We should have a private label soda program. Loblaw in Canada has President's Choice." -Category manager of Soda floats this to potential suppliers. -Cott Beverage says "Hey, we'll do it. How 'bout we call it 'Sam's Choice'?" -Category manager of Soda says "Great! I'll tell Sam." (or more likely, the VP of Grocery/Merchandising) -Sam Walton says "Great Job! Sam's Choice, nice touch. That's my name!"

Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by barbecue_sauce on Friday August 16, 2019 @02:55PM (#20718393)
The way private label grocery works is very different. Private label CPG products are developed through partnerships between the retailer themselves, consultancies like Daymon Worldwide (now owned by Acosta), and producers (often called copackers in this instance). Depending on how commodified the product is (like canned corn or frozen vegetables), it might be simply a matter of white labeling and sourcing through reverse auctioning. Sometimes the retailer will work on the product development lifecycle to create unique offerings.

Generally speaking, these copackers do not pay the retailers to get into their store, because the retailer is paying them for these products, and the retailer is possibly sourcing at least the packaging if not the development on their own. Whereas Amazon acts as a platform, retailers actually purchase and take possession of the product that they have had some hand in creating. Essentially, PL (private label) products start much further back in the supply chain. By the time they reach store shelves (even by the time they reach the warehouse), the supplier has already made their profit. You would rarely if ever have a brand in a store that gets upgraded (or downgraded depending on the power of the retailer's brand) to private label due to sales considerations or lobbying on the copacker's part. If anything, the retailer might take on lesser known brands the copacker is trying to promote as part of their sales agreement, even though they could be the same exact product that is in the retailer's branded packaging.

Speaking to Sam's Choice specifically, as it relates to Amazon's Choice: - Sam's Choice is only tied implicitly to its retailer (at least as far as Walmart is concerned, at Sam's Club I'm sure the connection is far clearer). You need knowledge about the organization (or to read the packaging) to understand that this is a private label product. Amazon's Choice is much more explicit. - Amazon's Choice is a designation more than a brand. As far as I know, the products retain their own branding and identity. Most customers understand that private label products are not manufactured by the retailers themselves, but if you want to find out that Sams' Choice (and much of the private label soda and soda adjacent products category in the majority of food retail) is actually manufactured by Cott Beverage, you need to do some research. - The idea that Sam's Choice was "created" by Cott is kind of strange, though I can't dispute it directly. PL brands like Sam's Choice (and Great Value, Walmart's other PL brand) are owned by the retailer and usually entail working across multiple categories, which means working with multiple suppliers. It's possible that "Sam's Choice" the brand was created early enough during the evolution of the PL ecosystem that Cott coined the name of the brand (even though its almost a complete copy of President's Choice, the PL brand of the Canadian supermarket chain Loblaw), but to consider a PL product a "third party" product is very strange to me. Cott doesn't have any claim to Sam's Choice products that are produced in non-beverage categories.

Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by morroc on Thursday August 15, 2019 @08:56PM (#20711216)
Store employees might also have been incentivized to suggest a specific product based on kickbacks the store receives. There is a precedent there. You shouldn't expect unenforceable honesty from anyone.
Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by ramblerman on Friday August 16, 2019 @07:03AM (#20713915)
> but if you ask an employee about a product you expect an honest answer

That just seems naive.

Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by wccrawford on Friday August 16, 2019 @08:08AM (#20714282)
Not the OP, but I also expect an honest answer. But I'm wary that it might not be, because humans are humans and none are perfect.
Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by 27182818284 on Thursday August 15, 2019 @10:06PM (#20711542)
hahaha, oh wow.

I have been completely incorrect on my interpretation of Amazon's Choice.

Historically when I searched for something, I've often find a product in the results with 80-90% of the features I'm looking for. That result was often listed as Amazon's Choice, so I built it up in my mind to mean "users of Amazon mostly get this one" I was fine with that because, like I said, it usually wouldn't fit the criteria exactly, but it was 80-90% of the way there so it made sense to me that it would be the choice of most people, but not all.

Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by nightfly on Friday August 16, 2019 @12:49AM (#20712270)
That's what the Amazon's choice feature is supposed to do. Instead of having their customers paralyzed by the many options they choose /something/.
Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by WalterBright on Thursday August 15, 2019 @11:34PM (#20711961)
> isn't an objective, measurable fact, companies are allowed to lie.

Pedantically, it isn't a lie if it isn't objective and measurable. It's an opinion, and opinions are not lies.

As for "Amazon's Choice", it's literally true. Amazon chose it. They make no representation as to why they chose it.

Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by mikeash on Friday August 16, 2019 @12:10AM (#20712101)
Even more pedantically, lying is all about intent to deceive. A correct statement is still a lie if you think it’s wrong. The key question here is: does Amazon intend to deceive? It’s probably impossible to know but the odds are decently good.
Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by mattrp on Friday August 16, 2019 @09:32AM (#20714946)
The more comparable products are Sam’s “President’s Choice” and Costco’s Kirkland. Both of which have long developed brand promises that represent at least above average quality and some level of curation. Choice is a specific word chosen by Amazon to give the impression its products have similarly been curated. It’s deliberate subterfuge.
Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by unethical_ban on Friday August 16, 2019 @10:28AM (#20715473)
I agree with other users. I took it as an official designation that Amazon had vetted the product and/or vendor for consistency, and that returns/reviews/volume of purchase were all factors in a genuine recommendation for the product.

I'm a tech savvy 30-something cynic, too. Think about how it would fool others.

If the name of the product or brand line was "Amazon's Choice" then I would consider it branding. But when used as a designation, I expect more.

Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by rexpop on Thursday August 15, 2019 @10:38PM (#20711681)
> companies are allowed to lie.

And that's in no way scandalous?

Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by paulific on Friday August 16, 2019 @08:26AM (#20714438)
Yes, I remember my local supermarket had 'recommended' products that were marked like they were specials, but were not actually discounted at all. I appreciated the business logic, but basically stopped shopping there.
Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by bambax on Friday August 16, 2019 @03:39AM (#20712955)
Depends on what you mean by "allowed". Is it legal? Yes. Will customers retaliate when they find out -- or at least, learn to ignore that lie as just another marketing tactic with no value? More than likely.
Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by markdown on Thursday August 15, 2019 @10:27PM (#20711634)
> companies are allowed to lie

And this is just accepted. Ridiculous.

Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by ajross on Thursday August 15, 2019 @11:40PM (#20711998)
Again, though, the practice is pervasive. Are the "best value!" items you see at the ends of grocery aisles really the best value? How often are things "on sale" from prices for which they were never offered?

I mean, I guess it's OK to be outraged about this. But doing it specifically about Amazon seems maybe a little unobjective.

Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by rapind on Friday August 16, 2019 @12:42AM (#20712230)
I find marketing in general outrageous. I'm not surprised by or find Amazon particularly egregious in their marketing. This is apparently the system we want, at least until no one wants it anymore.

I will almost subconsciously assign a negative mark to companies who aggressively market, and a positive mark to those I deem authentic (spoiler, very few). I'm at the point now that I'm saving a ton of money because I'm simply turned off by the hard sell. It's like when you immediately close a tab on an article you were about to read because 4 different "Join our newsletter" modals slid in. I'm guessing I'm not the only one (but maybe one of few?). Is it possible that marketing practices have gotten so out of hand that they are very gradually nudging consumers away from what they're selling?

Anyone know if marketers talk about this sort of backlash at w/e conventions they have, or is it just push push push. The data must identify at least a hint of a negative trend right? How long until there are "authenticity consultants"?

Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by TeMPOraL on Friday August 16, 2019 @08:02AM (#20714244)
You're not the only one. I too am the less likely to buy something from someone the more they seem to be pushing it.
Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by pilsetnieks on Friday August 16, 2019 @03:07AM (#20712817)
> How often are things "on sale" from prices for which they were never offered?

At least in the EU that's blatantly illegal.

Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by TeMPOraL on Friday August 16, 2019 @08:01AM (#20714238)
Doesn't seem to stop shops from trying. I think the general workaround is "briefly raise prices, then make the sale price equal to original price".
Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by 4ntonius8lock on Thursday August 15, 2019 @09:22PM (#20711345)
If a mommy blogger who makes $0/month from her 'business' gets a free product to promote a product on a youtube video watched by 100 people, they have to disclose this. Even reviewers on amazon.

Yet Amazon charges for the 'Choice' wording without disclosing the financial side. And they are making way more, and therefore can be way more biased, than the mommy blogger who gets fined a few grand for not disclosing her endorsements.

More than just the monopoly situation, the extreme disparity in enforcement of rules, and the amount of fines as a percentage of yearly income, is quite galling.

Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by wbl on Friday August 16, 2019 @12:33AM (#20712197)
Does your grocery store disclose the stocking fees paid for end isle placement?
Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by 4ntonius8lock on Friday August 16, 2019 @10:54AM (#20715733)
Two wrongs = one right I take it? I don't agree.

Disclosure should apply across the board. I personally don't even agree with the disclosure rule, but if it's there, it should be for everyone under the same standard. That's actually literally the whole basis of the concept of rule of law.

Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by kadoban on Thursday August 15, 2019 @09:56PM (#20711509)
Bloggers "have to" disclose free products they get? Who enforces that?

I've been under the impression that the ethical ones do, the rest don't.

Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by Rychard on Thursday August 15, 2019 @10:17PM (#20711576)
> Bloggers "have to" disclose free products they get? Who enforces that?

In the US, it falls under the FTC.[1][2]

[1]: https://www.ftc.gov/tips-advice/business-center/guidance/ftc...

[2]: https://www.ecfr.gov/cgi-bin/text-idx?SID=e37d3cd088c6b4724a...

Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by lonelappde on Thursday August 15, 2019 @11:15PM (#20711868)
And Amazon does not have to:

> Does the FTC hold bloggers to a higher standard than reviewers for traditional media outlets?

> No. The FTC Act applies across the board. The issue is – and always has been – whether the audience understands the reviewer’s relationship to the company whose products are being recommended.

> If the audience understands the relationship, a disclosure isn’t needed

Surely the audience understands Amazon's relationship with... Amazon.

Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by 4ntonius8lock on Friday August 16, 2019 @10:59AM (#20715812)
I'd suggest you fully read the text and enforcement you are quoting.

The FTC has a clear standard: Would the average person know that an endorsement was done for money.

Amazon's relationship... with is with it's sellers... is literally the topic of this whole post. I'm really not sure why you are bringing this up (amazon sometimes choosing it's own), other than to subtly defend something clear by muddling the waters.

To be clear: if I asked the average person whether an 'amazon preferred' product was a paid endorsement by the brand owner to amazon in the form of cash and revenue sharing... I'm sure they would say: "No, we didn't know that as being obvious'. That's the standard mommy bloggers are held to.

The thing is, Amazon will present the flimsy argument you brought up with a team of lawyers. The mommy blogger will just take the fine.

If you haven't dealt with the FTC, and seen the dirty sausage machine up close, I'd suggest you look into it before continuing on defending them.

Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by lonelappde on Thursday August 15, 2019 @11:12PM (#20711855)
Amazon's Choice is clearly labeled as Amazon's choice, not customers' choice or anything else.

It's not their fault that you ascribe weird motives instead of the obvious.

Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by 4ntonius8lock on Friday August 16, 2019 @11:00AM (#20715823)
"Mommy Bloggers Choice product is clearly labeled "Mommy Bloggers Choice', not customers choice or anything else.

It's not their fault that you ascribe weird motives instead of the obvious."

See? It works both ways. The FTC doesn't allow this argument from Mommy blogger; it isn't applied evenly. I'll remind you that one of the higher ideals of the US is the rule of law.

BTW, I'm not ascribing anything, this is about FTC standards. If you don't know what fines the FTC puts out, I'd kindly suggest you research before further 'theory commenting'.

Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by completelylegit on Thursday August 15, 2019 @07:44PM (#20710806)
The vast majority of people don’t think about or understand advertising and marketing - if they did it wouldn’t work as well as it does.

Amazon has tons of little “ha ha tricked you” ways of making more money these days.

Next time you but an N-pack of anything on Amazon - more often than not the pack costs more per unit.. thats not how economy of scale is supposed to work right?

Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by davinic on Friday August 16, 2019 @12:37PM (#20716908)
Generally when you see that, the N-pack is sold by a marketplace seller (and there's a good chance it was packaged that way by the mp seller to get a better chance of a sale by offering something unique).
Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by steve19 on Thursday August 15, 2019 @08:34PM (#20711095)
I have noticed this in supermarkets as well. Either it is to trick the consumers but could equally be consumers would rather buy 6 cans of X in a pack than go to the effort of taking 6 cans individually off the shelf.
Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by rhizome on Thursday August 15, 2019 @09:01PM (#20711237)
The easy proof of this is in the cracker section: "family size" is always priced more per unit than smaller sizes.
Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by lonelappde on Thursday August 15, 2019 @11:11PM (#20711842)
I don't know where you all shop but I check unit prices all the time and rarely see an inversion.
Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by stickfigure on Friday August 16, 2019 @01:16AM (#20712380)
Agreed. It does happen, but it's an exception not the rule.

I spent my first 7 years out of college building business intelligence software for grocery retailers. My guess is that when it happens, it's a f-up rather than something nefarious. Especially with Amazon, whose seller interface is pretty much user-hostile.

Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by pixl97 on Friday August 16, 2019 @08:20AM (#20714383)
I would say it happens commonly enough that one must constantly keep one's eye out. For example at my local H.E.B. I see this all the time.

64oz Store brand half and half: $3.50 (avg range $3.25-3.68)

32oz Store brand half and half: $1.50 (avg range $1.25-1.68)

Um, wat?

Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by rhizome on Sunday August 18, 2019 @05:51AM (#20729268)
This thread will close by then, but I'll take a picture the next time I see it. Repost this in one year and I'll have something.
Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by wpietri on Thursday August 15, 2019 @09:14PM (#20711299)
> everyone presumes

[citation needed]

Having spent time inside a number of industries, I think there's a huge difference between insider knowledge and general-public knowledge. I'd guess that the average shopper would think something ends up more visible because it's something shoppers buy more frequently.

Also, the notion that X is terrible does not justify Y being also terrible. Do people object more to new or newly-revealed terribleness? Yes. Is that a reason not to take their objections seriously? Not at all.

Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by hrktb on Friday August 16, 2019 @06:25AM (#20713729)
> the ideas that a featured product would be featured because it makes the company more money is in no way scandalous!

This is completely true for most retailers. In particular for in person sales where people can straight assume they are getting bullshitted to close the sale.

The disconnect comes from amazon’s relentless push for customer satisfaction, clear labeling of the promoted and sponsored entries, separation between popular choices and well rated products etc.

That’s a corner of shadiness where we don’t expect it, which ends in a shock.

Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by rdsubhas on Friday August 16, 2019 @10:46AM (#20715650)
It's clear that a promoted item can be paid for.

What looks unethical / abuse of monopoly-ish here is - you (business) something else completely unrelated, like ads or whatever, and in exchange they get an unrelated "Amazon's choice" tag.

It feels similar to a kickback/bribe.

Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by alexandercrohde on Friday August 16, 2019 @09:19AM (#20714844)
Well, the fact that this has so many upvotes, sort of contradicts you. Some portion of people (maybe 15 or 20)% had brand-trust in amazon that their "choice" products were a service to the purchaser.

With that disproven, those same people (presumably the ones who were most trusting of Amazon) now have been bitten and are forced to reevaluate Amazon's honesty and Amazon's reputability. I imagine those upvoting this topic are the very 10-15% who find this behavior shocking and potentially self-destructive of amazon.

Re:Amazon offered ‘Amazon’s Choice’ to vendors who bought ad... by alexandercrohde on Friday August 16, 2019 @12:18PM (#20716693)
In fact, the more I think about it, the more I realize this is a dark-pattern. Amazon must realize that the "Amazon's choice" label ONLY increases sales if consumers misunderstand what that seal really means in that context.

A consumer has every right to feel outrage over intentional unethical behavior from a company. Similar deceit by other companies doesn't excuse this, nor does it mean the shopper's repulsion is invalid.