I believe my main post or the responses might have been unclear. If so, my apologies.
But your understanding isn't correct. Other companies are not insuring your downside. We are the only counter party you have.
The problem is if a recession happens, then a lot of our properties actually decline in value. As a result, we might not be able to pay you back. So to make sure we can pay you back we buy financial instruments on the open market, kind of like buying a stock of apple for example. These instruments work in a very interesting way. Their prices go up, if the real estate market goes down. Their prices go down, if the real estate market goes up.
So, with these instruments. We can ensure that in the event of a recession, we can still afford to pay you back, because we can sell the instruments for higher prices than we originally paid for. We then use that profit to cover the losses our customers experience.
The way this works out is that events that would cause large declines in the property values are covered by these instruments. Which means, as a company, we just need to pay specific attention to the potential losses between 0-20% range. Here, we deposit the 20% value of the original purchase price into the 3rd party account.
In the event that our company stops operation. These hedging instruments don't expire or disappear. They are bought at the beginning of our agreement with our customer. As a result, these instruments will be passed off to our lawyers along with the 3rd party account for them to maintain. This way, your loss coverage will still be guaranteed even if we go out of business.
Is this more clear? If not, I can always elaborate :)
So, you've hedged against a broad real-estate market decline, but you aren't just making broad, representative real-estate market investments, you are investing in properties selected by the combination of your algorithm and customer choices. There is no guarantee that the subset of the properties selected by your algorithm that also appeal to buyers interested in your product will perform as well as the general market (your algorithm could turn out to suck[0], your customers could simply happen to select the worst of your algorithm’s recommendations, or an unpredictable event could occur which negatively impact values in a subset of the market which just happens to disproportionately correlate with the properties your customers selected.)
[0] And, sure, you think it doesn't, but the problem with any ML algorithm that is supposed to outsmart the market is that the market is full of people using tools like that to try to outsmart the market.
If you know a stock which actually goes up in a recession, please let me know!
No one knows what's going to happen...
You can go with Dalio's claim that as long as you have 10 hedges that are sufficiently un-correlated, your risk is incredibly low. But even that might not hold up under future unknown conditions.
However, options contracts are a form of derivatives, meaning they are contracts financially engineered to hold a specific correlation. So, you can build perfect hedges using options contracts, which is what they were originally invented for. People just started betting on the markets with them, which created all kinds of risks in the market.
You just need to make sure the instrument you are betting against is representative of the overall market.
And what instruments are you actually buying? Are there put and call options for CoreLogic Case-Shiller???
They are not traded OTC and thus would not face liquidity problems like the OTC instruments people couldn't offload during the GFC (specifically like those guys in the Big Short).
As far as what the instruments actually are: they are puts on broader market REITs/ETFs as well as localized ones. We cannot name the specific instruments as we do not want their prices being bid up.
Hope this clarifies and of course happy to answer any more questions you may have!
What happens if the house goes down 25%? I have coverage on the first 20%, and then I'm liable for the other 5%?
So we personally guarantee up to a 20% drop with our own capital and use financial instruments to hedge any drop greater than 20% so as to make you whole regardless of the size of the drop.
Edit: generally, I wonder if you have a huge perception problem even if you've designed a responsible insurance product due to the fact that people are (reasonably) suspicious of taking on enormous amounts of counter-party risk from a pre-seed start-up.
Also, you have a great point on the perception problem, which is what we are trying to tackle right now. We have genuinely designed a product that is meant to be the most customer-friendly buyer model out there, but because we are a seed-stage company, many people are just concerned, because we lack a long standing reputation in the industry.
This is an absolute non-starter.
Sorry to be blunt, guys, but if you can't cover your promises, they aren't promises.
Your customers should be nuts to agree with this. Or misinformed. Again, sorry, I don't want to bash you, but what you are offering is simply too bad for your customers.
to make sure we can pay you back we buy financial instruments on the open market, kind of like buying a stock of apple for example. These instruments work in a very interesting way. Their prices go up, if the real estate market goes down. Their prices go down, if the real estate market goes up.
So, with these instruments. We can ensure that in the event of a recession, we can still afford to pay you back
Hopefully they provide more detail here.
I'm old enough to remember 2008 and recall many financial instruments with a traditionally inverse correlation to each other behaving unexpectedly. Similar unexpected behavior led to the LTCM crisis in 1998.
There are no guarantees in life (except maybe death and taxes). They seem to be taking reasonable precautions. They don't deserve to be lambasted for being a bit green and failing to phrase their comment like smarmy con artists pretending there is zero risk -- just trust me (wide, toothy grin).
We have tried to engineer the agreement to the point where only during times of nuclear war or some crazy natural disaster, would we not be able to cover the losses.
And per our contract, we are not liable for these act of god events. So, we recommend all of our customers to purchase insurance on property, especially if they live in risky areas related to weather phenomenons.
Down the line, our priority is to incorporate climate modeling , so that we just no longer recommend properties prone to natural disaster damages.
For example, assuming the cell phone market only had 2 players, apple and samsung. And let's assume investors think it's a winner takes all market. So, historically, if apple shares went up, it means investors think they will dominate, which means investors think samsung will lose. This may lead samsung stock to decline when apple stocks increase and vice-versa.
Now imagine a recession. Investors don't care about that relationship anymore, because they just want to pull their money out of the market. Now everyone is dumping both apple and sumsung, so now, the correlation has changed.
I assume this is what you are talking about for the instruments you were mentioning. But, we use options, which are artificially created, so when we buy put options, they will always be 100% inversely correlated to the underlying REIT/ETF. Therefore, if the REIT/ETF goes down during a recession, our options will increase in price.
Hope this clarifies things!
Of course, we engineer the product so that we can pay people back. But I wanted to show people our thought process, which is what happens if there was a recession and most of our portfolio declines by more than 20%. If we didn't have hedging instruments, we wouldn't be able to pay people back.
Therefore, our next step was to purchase hedging instruments for every contract we take part in. Hope this clarifies things. If not, let me know, and I'll be happy to elaborate more.
Seems like an awesome idea in principle...
though, those indices are only granular at the city level, whereas during a recession all neighborhoods in a city don't drop in value by the same rate - eg for bay area in 2008, east bay got decimated, whereas palo alto/peninsula barely dropped 5%.
We also don't just hedge with options on 1 index, so a blend of hedging instruments can get us pretty close to 100% granularity. Any percentage points that are not covered in a granular manner should be offset by performing contracts, and the worst case is we use our own capital to cover maybe the remaining 1-2% uncovered risk.
If I read your post right -- the way your insurance works is:
I'm a home buyer. I think the housing market is frothy right now, but I want to buy a home anyway. So I can use your insurance to protect myself in the event the value of my house decreases in the future.
Your company is directly responsible for the first 20% decline. After that, other companies are responsible for the rest. And even if you go out of business, I'm still covered by those other companies.
Firstly, is that correct?
Secondly, if so -- what happens if you go out of business and my house goes down exactly 20%? I assume that means I have no coverage.
Thirdly, who's insuring the houses after a 20% decline? And why should I have any reason to believe they'd still be in business if the market collapses 20%+? The last time that happened, almost every insurance company and investment bank went out of business.
Finally, how much does this cost as a percentage of the house's current value yearly? Roughly...
It's an interesting idea. Despite the fact that most home buyers anticipate house price appreciation to underperform historical averages (and a lot of buyers actually think prices will go down) -- a lot of houses are being bought. I think a lot of those people would want an option like this.