News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Social exclusion fuels extremism in young men by xwdv on Monday August 12, 2019 @02:13AM (#20672884)
I have found myself socially excluded most of my life. I see the world mostly as a hostile place, and easily get a feeling that people do not like me. Though I have obtained a good status in life by some metrics, what good is it if the world is so toxic to me?
Re:Social exclusion fuels extremism in young men by hutzlibu on Monday August 12, 2019 @03:24AM (#20673228)
Try to put it in perspective, do you think, it is possible, that other people view you as toxic as well? I skimmed through some of your recent comments and it seems to be the case. You don't seem to give a shit about other peoples feelings, so why should they care about you?

Now it is of course a chicken egg thing. If you became that way, because others did not really care about you, .. then it might not be "just", but it still does not change the outcome. You experienced toxic and now you spread toxic.

Money does not change that and there is no easy solution. It would require a inner change in you to adopt to your surroundings, and/or a change of the surroundings, if they are bad to you, until you are at a place where you want to be, with people you like and who like you.

Re:Social exclusion fuels extremism in young men by plutonorm on Monday August 12, 2019 @06:34AM (#20674144)
This is seriously unhelpful. The correct answer is go see a therapist for several years to a decade.
Re:Social exclusion fuels extremism in young men by hutzlibu on Monday August 12, 2019 @07:14AM (#20674358)
Ah yes, the modern solution to loneliness. Go and pay someone professional to listen to your problems.

Seriously, I know people in that place and they did see a therapeut for some years and then got seriously depressed, after they realized, that they were just a client to the person who they thought, they had a deep connection with, who in reality, also did not like them and just did their job for money.

Now sure, a good therapeut can help certain people, but I don't know the poster, so I would not dare to know the "correct" answer for him and if it is really a therapist. Might help, might also kill him. Hyperbole? Well, I wish. But a close family member got along (miserable) on his own, then went with the pressure to get "professional" help and now he is dead.

Oh and he is not the person from the first example, this person is probably still alive, but that can change any day. So I have some reason to not see therapists as the magic solution.

Re:Social exclusion fuels extremism in young men by majos on Monday August 12, 2019 @08:47AM (#20674905)
I mostly disagree.

A good therapist can be very helpful in helping you unpack why and how you think about things, and how you might change both for the better. That can be a valuable professional service. Especially for people who might otherwise have few or no relationships where they can talk about those things.

It is tragic that your family member did not get enough out of therapy, or perhaps was actively harmed by it. But I think therapy has helped enough people that I find it strange to blanket recommend against it.

Perhaps we can at least agree that short-scale (a few months, not years), deliberate therapy has a place?

Re:Social exclusion fuels extremism in young men by hutzlibu on Monday August 12, 2019 @09:27AM (#20675190)
"I find it strange to blanket recommend against it."

Where did I do that? I wrote:

"Now sure, a good therapeut can help certain people, but I don't know the poster, so I would not dare to know the "correct" answer for him and if it is really a therapist. "

"So I have some reason to not see therapists as the magic solution."

Psychoanalytical therapy definitely has its place. Also for years, if necessary, I never advised against that per se. I just blanket recommend against the "just go see a therapist" solution, as it really depends on the therapists and the person and the situation.

Edit: maybe to elaborate a bit more: the op said he views the world as hostile. So he does not trust people. So why would he trust "a therapist"? And if he finally do seek one and that one is a bad one .. or even a really bad one who tells his friends in the bar at night about his nutcases and they all laugh and the op finds out, because he is paranoid and has bugged his therapists mobile or have him followed (he has money) ... then the consequences can be fatal. As then he has proof, "yes, the world is indeed hostile to me"

Re:Social exclusion fuels extremism in young men by ancarda on Monday August 12, 2019 @12:22PM (#20676887)
A decade? Can therapy really take that long?
Re:Social exclusion fuels extremism in young men by scotty79 on Monday August 12, 2019 @03:02AM (#20673112)
> I see the world mostly as a hostile place,

I think that you understand subjectivity of that perception. World is not hostile, just indifferent and doing its own thing regardless of your existance or needs. You just gotta become fine with that and your outlook on life will improve.

> and easily get a feeling that people do not like me.

Some don't like you. Some feel your mistrust towards them. Some empathize with you and in your company begin to see world as more hostile to them and they don't like it. When you feel safer in the world your relationships will improve.

Re:Social exclusion fuels extremism in young men by alexis_fr on Monday August 12, 2019 @02:35AM (#20672973)
I’ve sold my first startup and the second is a great success, multimillionaire and I have a Youtube channel talking about men’s issues where dozens of thousands of boys (and benevolent women) learn and talk about men’s issues. But the only people I wanted to be listened by were my family, for support in dealing with women, and that will never happen.

I have the exact same vision as you: I can’t work in a company because I feel directly hated by the diversity programs (funnily enough, I hire women). Success and money is not happiness and life is... very ironic sometimes.

Re:Social exclusion fuels extremism in young men by Roritharr on Monday August 12, 2019 @02:58AM (#20673096)
Not sure why you are downvoted.

Thank you for sharing, I don't think you troll as some of my younger employees shared the same feeling of disenfranchisment in their 1:1's.

Even if the view of being othered by diversity programs etc. is a little bit skewed, it's definitely having an impact in their psychology, as it's an easy scapegoat for why a raise was not given, a talk got rejected, etc. etc.

The actual cases numbers of these things happening must be much much smaller, but that's beside the point, as it's the psychological aspect that's ruining their perception of themselves and what society expects from them.

[dead]
Re:Social exclusion fuels extremism in young men by Roritharr on Monday August 12, 2019 @04:00AM (#20673426)
Being othered is, as anyone in such a position, especially people with diverse backgrounds, can tell you, not "the notion that they're not the center of the world", but pretty much the feeling of being actively excluded in a "everyone BUT not (people like) me" sense.

Imagine you'd phrase the same statement directed towards people from a minority that are trying to express their feeling of being actively excluded in certain aspects of life, it would be rather vile.

Re:Social exclusion fuels extremism in young men by pavlov on Monday August 12, 2019 @07:04AM (#20674312)
Ok, maybe my experience is limiting my empathy. I’m a white man working for a big Silicon Valley company that has plenty of diversity programs, some mandatory training for all employees. The notion that these programs are seeking to actively exclude people like me seems so absurd that I can’t imagine believing such a thing unless I were essentially a white suprematist seeking victimhood.

When I don’t get a promotion, it’s because I didn’t do enough politics and went home every night to see my family rather than burn the midnight oil; not because diversity-brainwashed white men are somehow conspiring against me as a white man.

Re:Social exclusion fuels extremism in young men by Roritharr on Monday August 12, 2019 @07:37AM (#20674458)
I'd encourage you to try to be less judgmental when it comes to the perceptions and feelings of other people, they may be less valid than your own, but they are just as real and their effects on the psychology of the people experiencing them is.

How about we talk about an example that's easier to empathize with:

Close to where I live (Germany) is a social worker center that offers a very special program for kids with severe behavior problems, kind of as a last resort to save them from a life of crime and unemployment. This program includes going rafting and doing lots of exciting outdoor activities in general, constructing a building together with a tradesmen company and even travelling abroad. This is paid for by the child protective services on a case-by-case basis as it's deemed cheaper than paying for years of possible incarceration, drug abuse treatment etc.

A hot topic among teens that hear about this is that a majority of the kids going to this program are from a migrant/minority backgrounds, as our CPS equivalent already often has their attention on these families and suggests the program when it deems it beneficial. Especially kids from poor families that can't afford holidays or most after school activities ask:"So I don't get to do X because I didn't rob a store and my dad is working as a cashier?" as a way of communicating their feelings of being filtered out.

Their feeling of course isn't valid, the kids being sent to this program aren't to be envied as their lot in life is a tough one, but it's easy to emphasize with the teens p.o.v. that all the helping hands are pointed to other people and theirs isn't arriving.

Re:Social exclusion fuels extremism in young men by alexis_fr on Monday August 12, 2019 @07:16PM (#20681139)
Sir I’m so touch by the psychology and the empathy you use to explain what I tumbled at explaining... I’ll never have those speaking skills as I’m slightly autistic and socially awkward, but when I make a two or three millions (depending on valuation) with my startups, but I’m less than no-one in a (nerd) company, I know people are using my weakness.

World is wild ok, but diversity is just a way to exclude people who can’t defend themselves.

[dead]
Re:Social exclusion fuels extremism in young men by mieseratte on Monday August 12, 2019 @09:52AM (#20675373)
> These same reactionary-minded young men are often repeating mantras like “facts don’t care about your feelings”. Why don’t they apply this sentiment to their own workplace grievances?

You're building up a strawman-stereotype and tearing it down.

Blanket affirmative-action policies are by-definition discrimination, but they are typically viewed as acceptable because they help a group that is statistically disadvantaged. Statistics, if broad enough, will mask details. If your argument starts and ends with "The group this person is a part of most likely has X feature" you will absolutely end up discriminating against some amount of that group. So someone can be a part of a group like "white men" that has, statistically, been the biggest, baddest group in the sandbox in Western society but simultaneously derive no benefit from that being a part of that class.

Whether or not the ends justify the means is subjective opinion.

Offering a resource to a supposed out-group overlooks the fact that members of that out-group could have come from a very privileged background. Would you rather be a wealthy minority from a well-functioning home or a white man from a poor, dysfunctional home?

If you answered the latter, I would love to know why.

Re:Social exclusion fuels extremism in young men by david-cako on Monday August 12, 2019 @02:28AM (#20672944)
Very good question, and the only justification I can come up with is the opportunity to beam truth out from within.

This at some times more than others seems like enough, if no one else takes responsibility. We are hard wired to seek meaning and protect the will.

Re:Social exclusion fuels extremism in young men by lukaa on Monday August 12, 2019 @02:47AM (#20673031)
Religion was once answer to that question: What is life meaning in situations where I'm failure? Answer was: Meaning is obedience to God commands that are universally good since they are from God. Today unless you have family and satisfying job, I would say hope that you can find in fact that you don't know everything, so although you don't know meaning of your life perhaps there is meaning in all this. In the end we are all product of Big Bang so everything including you is equally meaningful or meaningless.
Re:Social exclusion fuels extremism in young men by TomMckenny on Monday August 12, 2019 @04:14AM (#20673499)
You do realize that the group in the study is highly religious. And that the extremism referred to is also religious.
Re:Social exclusion fuels extremism in young men by lukaa on Monday August 12, 2019 @04:41AM (#20673620)
I'm not advocating religion especially extremist version although there are way more cases in which religion helped people that's why it survived so long, I said once it was good solution and than I explained what is solution for today's world.
Re:Social exclusion fuels extremism in young men by vasco on Monday August 12, 2019 @05:47AM (#20673928)
Get a dog, it can change your life.