News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Switching from Common Lisp to Julia (2017) by stassats on Monday August 05, 2019 @11:37AM (#20614986)
I don't want to ruin the language just so that it appeals to some people, it's already fine for me.
Re:Switching from Common Lisp to Julia (2017) by oblio on Monday August 05, 2019 @12:24PM (#20615394)
> I don't want to ruin the language just so that it appeals to some people, it's already fine for me.

To an outsider his comments seem pretty reasonable. Why would they ruin Common Lisp?

Re:Switching from Common Lisp to Julia (2017) by varjag on Monday August 05, 2019 @01:12PM (#20615916)
* There are larger incompatibilities between implementations in other popular languages, like C, C++ and Java.

* It's easy to suggest designing an OO system better than CLOS. It's harder to point out any examples tho.

* Remove unused functions, what?

* "Make FOO standard" but a bunch of popular languages don't even have a spec, why is this an issue even?

Re:Switching from Common Lisp to Julia (2017) by zeveb on Monday August 05, 2019 @04:08PM (#20618336)
That other languages are worse than Lisp is no reason not to improve.

I didn't read him as suggesting that CLOS be replaced, but that it be embraced.

I have no idea what he meant about unused functions. My experience has been that when I think something in Common Lisp is pointless … I'm wrong.

One of the great advantages of Lisp in the 90s was that it standardised things that other languages left undefined (indeed, this is still an advantage Common Lisp has over Scheme). It seems like a good idea to keep on expanding the standardised area, as we gain experience & understanding.

Re:Switching from Common Lisp to Julia (2017) by varjag on Monday August 05, 2019 @04:36PM (#20618642)
All good points but well.. this discussion appears to be about possible reasons people migrate to other languages. And I just can't see how addressing these (rather arbitrary) points would reverse it.

Some people just don't like CL much, despite solid foundation and steady progress with community projects. That's okay, we all have one or another language we are not very fond of.

Re:Switching from Common Lisp to Julia (2017) by pcr910303 on Monday August 05, 2019 @12:15PM (#20615294)
> ruin the language just so that it appeals to some people

May I ask why this can be considered ‘ruin’ing? These sort of changes will be useful for all CL users IMO.

> it's already fine for me

Maybe to you, but not for me or many, many people who went to Clojure apparently.

Re:Switching from Common Lisp to Julia (2017) by a0-prw on Monday August 05, 2019 @12:27PM (#20615423)
I don't mean this in a hostile way, but seriously, just go, then. If Clojure is best for you, vaya con dios :)
Re:Switching from Common Lisp to Julia (2017) by pcr910303 on Monday August 05, 2019 @12:35PM (#20615514)
Okay, maybe I should clarify. I’m not a Clojure-lover; I use CL as my side project language and I love CL. I was just suggesting a way that CL can be more appealing language so that CL can reach more adoption (as CL has it’s strengths that Clojure can’t follow along).
Re:Switching from Common Lisp to Julia (2017) by zeveb on Tuesday August 06, 2019 @08:26AM (#20624487)
Speaking as another Lisper, I am glad that you're sticking with Lisp, not moving to Clojure.

… and maybe someday you can propose your own project, something like CL21!

Re:Switching from Common Lisp to Julia (2017) by a0-prw on Monday August 05, 2019 @12:24PM (#20615396)
That's exactly the way I feel about it :)