News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Elsevier threatens others for linking to Sci-Hub but does... by mettamage on Sunday August 04, 2019 @09:52AM (#20606503)
A couple of silly questions:

1. How did publishers like Elsevier get started?

2. Was their value proposition true back in the day? How did it change over time?

3. How did the industry evolve?

3b. What are the barriers to entry and how did those evolve?

3c. What was the business model then and what is it now? Who are the clients (universities, I presume)? How do they pay for this (taxpayer money? If so, that's a huge clue). Who is the decision-maker regarding these purchases?

4. How is it possible that they still exist? If they don't provide value anymore, then what is it? Are people habitual creatures? Are they pressuring universities? Did they somehow get a vendor lock-in effect (can people get out)?

I'm simply trying to get why it became what it became and why it isn't dying in the slightest despite researchers trying to organize themselves a bit for open access.

Re:Elsevier threatens others for linking to Sci-Hub but does... by jdietrich on Sunday August 04, 2019 @10:06AM (#20606586)
Strange as it is to imagine, scientific journals used to be printed on paper. Elsevier was founded in 1880 as a book publisher, then a magazine publisher before expanding into scientific publishing. Subscribing to a scientific journal was not fundamentally different to subscribing to any other kind of magazine; university libraries paid a fee to receive a printed document every month, containing a collection of articles related to that field.

The internet should have changed this model, but the publishers had amassed a secondary form of value - prestige. Scientists don't only want to share their research with their peers, but share that research in a prestigious publication. Getting a paper published in Nature or the BMJ has a meaningful impact on the author's career.

The internet makes it trivial to distribute documents for free, but nobody thus far has found an adequate substitute for the prestige of a highly respected journal. Universities keep paying to subscribe to prestigious journals because they publish some of the most interesting and significant research; academics keep sending their best work to the most prestigious journals because it's valuable to their career prospects.

This problem can probably only be solved through coordinated action by academics.

Re:Elsevier threatens others for linking to Sci-Hub but does... by mirimir on Sunday August 04, 2019 @07:21PM (#20609869)
Sure, but the "Elsevier" that existed from 1880 to sometime in the 1970s or so was very different from today's Elsevier. Basically, some entity bought it, and set out to monetize its reputation, by raising prices to what universities would tolerate.

We've seen the same process in the pharmaceutical and newspaper industries, and likely others.

Re:Elsevier threatens others for linking to Sci-Hub but does... by flatline on Sunday August 04, 2019 @10:49AM (#20606833)
> The internet makes it trivial to distribute documents for free

While I agree with pretty much everything else you wrote, I have to take some exception to this. Yes it is trivial to put something online. But library sciences exist for a reason, so if you want a nice collection of things online with some sensible structure it becomes less trivial. Worse yet if you want some way of ranking in importance the things in your collection, it requires a lot of manual intervention.

I think your solution is ultimately correct, but the peer review process is harder to solve than the technical one, and there is still a cost of some sort to implement and maintain the technical one.

Re:Elsevier threatens others for linking to Sci-Hub but does... by dredmorbius on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:02AM (#20606919)
Oddly enough, there are institutions devoted to the curation, preservation, and circulation of written matter.

Not publishers.

Libraries.

Re:Elsevier threatens others for linking to Sci-Hub but does... by jacobolus on Sunday August 04, 2019 @04:37PM (#20609083)
> nice collection of things online with some sensible structure

Publishers do not currently do this. Their websites are a confusing jumble with difficult navigation, poor search features, no useful discovery features, ...

The “nice collection” with “sensible structure” is provided by external citation indexes like Google Scholar.

Re:Elsevier threatens others for linking to Sci-Hub but does... by canjobear on Sunday August 04, 2019 @12:02PM (#20607300)
Many fields do peer review just fine without help from academic publishers.

All academic publishers contribute to the process is an early-2000s web interface.

Re:Elsevier threatens others for linking to Sci-Hub but does... by jdietrich on Sunday August 04, 2019 @12:32PM (#20607503)
>While I agree with pretty much everything else you wrote, I have to take some exception to this. Yes it is trivial to put something online. But library sciences exist for a reason, so if you want a nice collection of things online with some sensible structure it becomes less trivial. Worse yet if you want some way of ranking in importance the things in your collection, it requires a lot of manual intervention.

Specifically, what structure do paid journals have that Arxiv lacks? How much would it cost to provide that structure outside of the current system, bearing in mind that editors and peer reviewers aren't paid a dime by the publishers?

Re:Elsevier threatens others for linking to Sci-Hub but does... by jasode on Sunday August 04, 2019 @01:05PM (#20607757)
>, bearing in mind that editors and peer reviewers aren't paid a dime by the publishers?

The peer reviewers may not be paid but the prestigious academic journals (Nature, Cardiology, etc) do have paid editorial staff. E.g. the initial rejections of papers and rounds of back-&-forth copy-editing with the author are handled by the paid editors and not the unpaid peer reviewers.

That's not to say there are also journals that are run by 100% unpaid volunteers but I'm unaware of any particular Elsevier journals with that labor structure.

(However, this is not an endorsement of Elsevier's high subscription fees.)

Re:Elsevier threatens others for linking to Sci-Hub but does... by mistrial9 on Sunday August 04, 2019 @10:25AM (#20606702)
"meaningful impact" in the second paragraph is an understatement ...
Re:Elsevier threatens others for linking to Sci-Hub but does... by dredmorbius on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:22AM (#20607044)
"Prestige" is a red herring.

Science and technology progress on correctness, accuracy, and efficacy, not popularity.

It turns out that gatekeeping, cabal-fostering, orthodoxy-preserving, and kingmaking are lucrative practices. But truth cares not for prestige. As the motto of the Royal Socity states: In nullis verba. By the word of no one. Evidence, not authority.

(The situation may be different in some of the arts and letters. Which speaks to another can of worms.)

Re:Elsevier threatens others for linking to Sci-Hub but does... by j7ake on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:33AM (#20607120)
This is a nice ideal but science is still an intensely human endeavour. The human part of science brings with it the politics and prestige that is associated with scientific work.

To try to bring an analogy, D. Knuths recent comment on the recent sensitivity proof has brought the discussion of the topic on a different level because it has basically been stamped with the approval of a highly prestigious scientist.

So although the sensitivity proof is a mathematical proof, the recent buzz around it has rocketed it to another level. This brings about real rewards in the form of promotions and invitations to exclusive social circles, all of which are desirable to humans.

To be slightly cynical, the majority of research output is not worth your time to read, so mechanisms that presort (E.g. by author list, keywords, and journal name) help to increase the chance you read a paper worth your time.

Re:Elsevier threatens others for linking to Sci-Hub but does... by dredmorbius on Sunday August 04, 2019 @02:09PM (#20608199)
"Red herring" in that it's not what the ultimate goal of academic publishing is.

Is prestige very much baked into the practice, profession, career, and culture of academia? Yes. Has it largely always been thus? To the origins of the modern university, if not before -- arguably.

But that's not a necessary role, certainly not for publishing to play, and though giving a thought to side effects and consequences, disrupting the publication cycle might solve a few more problems then it creates.

Or not.

The deeper problem is that demonstrations of correctness don't adhere to publishing, funding, teaching, or even career cycles. Things can be thought wrong for a very long time and proved right, or vice versa. And again, all the prestige in the world won't change the truth value.

Though it will change what truths, or myths, are socialised at any given point in time.

Re:Elsevier threatens others for linking to Sci-Hub but does... by beowulfey on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:39AM (#20607155)
As much as I personally agree and wish this were true, so much of academia does not work that way.

However, I do think it is getting better, and a growing number of scientists (particularly the younger generations) are pushing back.

Re:Elsevier threatens others for linking to Sci-Hub but does... by dredmorbius on Sunday August 04, 2019 @02:10PM (#20608207)
Oh, I'm very much aware that it doesn't. But that's what it says on the tin, whatever the contents may be.
Re:Elsevier threatens others for linking to Sci-Hub but does... by dreamcompiler on Sunday August 04, 2019 @03:47PM (#20608820)
Normally I'd respond to such a comment with an observation on the author's precious naiveté, but since you are well-known on HN with high karma, I'll refrain.
Re:Elsevier threatens others for linking to Sci-Hub but does... by dredmorbius on Sunday August 04, 2019 @03:50PM (#20608832)
I'm frequently wrong or misguided.
Re:Elsevier threatens others for linking to Sci-Hub but does... by notahacker on Sunday August 04, 2019 @10:19AM (#20606665)
1. Once upon a time there was no internet and not even any computers. Turning academics' scribblings into neatly printed compilations of articles sent out to academic libraries across the world on a regular basis necessarily involved a publisher that could handle that sort of thing.

2. Over time, their journals' proposition evolved to be less "distributor of print" and more "curator of the most respected content". As universities started scrutinising how good their academics were at getting articles published and journals they published in started being ranked by "impact factor", the value proposition of curated content got stronger

3. Computers made it relatively easy for academics to produce print-ready articles themselves. The internet made it straightforward for academics to distribute articles as neatly formatted PDFs and share their early drafts with peers for review without involving any publisher. But also, academics and students started expecting to be able to search through decades of articles online rather than hunt for a single paper copy of each on in library, which opened up a nice little opportunity to sell renewable subscriptions for digital access to the archives.

3b. The barriers to entry used to be not having the facility to print and distribute and sell to libraries as well as the fact your new journal isn't Nature. Now it's just the latter. And also the fact you're simply not allowed to republish the decades worth of content they own, which includes a lot of must-cite texts

3c. The business model was getting academics to submit and review content for free which was then resold to universities staffed by people who expected [their students] to be able to read it as part of their research and expected the library to pick up the tab. Still is, just publishing new content is easier for everybody, and since the journal sub offers digital access to the archives and not just 12 bits of paper for the library they can ask for more eye-watering sums of money.

4. Regardless of whether open access journals ultimately inherit the prestige of the existing ones, academic publishers will continue own the copyright of decades worth of texts which academics and students are expected to have read to properly understand their field, and so university libraries will continue to be expected to subscribe to them. The lockin effect is that you can't do serious academic research without reading papers which they own. Which is also why they're not very keen on people pirating their content.

Re:Elsevier threatens others for linking to Sci-Hub but does... by imgabe on Sunday August 04, 2019 @10:13AM (#20606633)
Academia runs heavily on prestige. The journals are valuable because they are prestigious and it is more beneficial to an academic's career to publish in a more prestigious journal than a less prestigious one.

Because the academics who publish in those journals get jobs at prestigious universities, every university needs to keep those journals in those libraries, because that's where all the highest profile researchers are publishing their articles. Anyone who wants to join that group also needs to compete to publish in those journals. It's a self-reinforcing cycle.

Re:Elsevier threatens others for linking to Sci-Hub but does... by chaosite on Sunday August 04, 2019 @10:10AM (#20606619)
1. They were old-school publishing houses, that had a connection to some prominent academic or an academic society that decided they needed to start a journal.

2. The value proposition was that they were the only way to publish research. Libraries subscribed to them (or bought issues), and reading journals in a library was the major way academics learned of new research in their field, unless they learned of the research in a conference.

3. The Internet.

3b. The barriers to entry used to be needing to have access to a publishing house capable of duplicating issues, and having your journal be in major libraries (which is usually related to being related to a major academic or a academic society).

The barrier to entry today is due to papers published being a major benchmark using which the productivity of an academic is measured. Older, well-known journals that accept only a few papers are known as having a larger "impact-factor", which means that publishing in them is worth more to an academic.

3c. The business model is always selling subscriptions to libraries, mostly university libraries (but also regular ones and research outfits in industry). Once they don't actually print anything their costs are mostly administrative, so they're basically printing money. The decision maker are librarians, usually, but they get set a budget by whoever owns the library.

4. Because they own the major benchmark used to evaluate an academic career. If you are an academic and want to further your career (i.e., get a job, get tenure, get a grant), you have to publish in one of those journals. If you're another academic and you then want to read that research, you then have to have your library subscribed to that journal (or look it up and Sci-Hub).

Re:Elsevier threatens others for linking to Sci-Hub but does... by rmetzler on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:04AM (#20606932)
> 3c. The business model is always selling subscriptions to libraries, mostly university libraries (but also regular ones and research outfits in industry)

The main criticism I read about Elsevier is that universities can’t subscribe to just the most important Elsevier publications but have to subscribe to a big package while the content producers aren’t paid by Elsevier but work at the universities. This only works, because Elsevier is a monopoly and this is the reason why science hub is a thing.

Re:Elsevier threatens others for linking to Sci-Hub but does... by lazyjones on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:11AM (#20606980)
> 2. The value proposition was that they were the only way to publish research.

Was this ever actually the case? Researchers have always published on their own in one way or another. What these journals added was an established peer review mechanism.

Re:Elsevier threatens others for linking to Sci-Hub but does... by chaosite on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:34AM (#20607127)
Sure, academics have always self-published, but unless you were already a prominent researcher, publishing in a journal was the way to get a wide readership (or at-least by available in the library.)
Re:Elsevier threatens others for linking to Sci-Hub but does... by CJefferson on Sunday August 04, 2019 @09:56AM (#20606532)
They do still provide significant value, although it is weakening.

When I see an article punished in an Elsevier journal, it gives me a sign it is trustworthy. When I'm asked to submit something to an Elsevier journal, it gives me confidence the journal is trustworthy.

I, as I guess someone with an academic email address, give dozens of invitations to read, submit to, and help edit, journals every week. I have no choice other than to send the majority of these directly to trash.

Slowly, open source trustworthy journals are appearing, but they need to gain trust and that takes time. We need something like a Web of trust for academic work, but it would be a major undertaking to set up.

Also, who is going to pay for all the work of setting up and running these new journals? And don't assume there are zero costs, just because academics do tend to work for free.

Re:Elsevier threatens others for linking to Sci-Hub but does... by _jal on Sunday August 04, 2019 @10:19AM (#20606667)
> When I see an article punished in an Elsevier journal, it gives me a sign it is trustworthy

You might want to reconsider that.

https://www.the-scientist.com/the-nutshell/elsevier-publishe...

Re:Elsevier threatens others for linking to Sci-Hub but does... by CJefferson on Sunday August 04, 2019 @10:40AM (#20606779)
By "sign", I know it isn't perfect. However, 99% of the journals which email me are junk, so we need some method. And I don't just want to read papers by my friends, as that way I end up in a bubble.
Re:Elsevier threatens others for linking to Sci-Hub but does... by Nemo_bis on Sunday August 04, 2019 @02:31PM (#20608353)
That's also questionable. For instance, journals with higher impact factor tend to contain more articles which can be considered bad by objective measures.

"Deep impact: unintended consequences of journal rank" https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fnhum.2013.0029...

Re:Elsevier threatens others for linking to Sci-Hub but does... by omaranto on Sunday August 04, 2019 @01:55PM (#20608120)
> When I see an article punished in an Elsevier journal

I like the Freudian slip in "punished"!

Re:Elsevier threatens others for linking to Sci-Hub but does... by buboard on Sunday August 04, 2019 @03:21PM (#20608676)
> 3b. What are the barriers to entry and how did those evolve?

It 's a chicken and egg problem: Authors don't publish to new journals because they are not reputable yet and journals can't become reputable because authors don't publish to them. I don't know the theory of chicken and egg problems but i think they are solved when either a) a brand new discipline emerges therefore the first bidders win by default or b) some extraordinary action is taken

Re:Elsevier threatens others for linking to Sci-Hub but does... by pessimizer on Sunday August 04, 2019 @10:44AM (#20606815)
> 1. How did publishers like Elsevier get started?

I think people are answering this question as if it were about scientific publishers in general. They were just respected magazines, often published by scientific membership societies.

Elsevier specifically was a publisher that just gobbled as many of them that it could up until it got to a monopoly or near-monopoly position by specialization (meaning that it could own every important journal is some professions, and most of them in others.) Then it jacked up the prices infinitely, and their competitors took the signal and jacked up their prices too. Now, some major universities are defecting, which is actually a signal that the pricing is just about perfect for the market.

It's just the same old boring operations of capitalism. This is exactly how pharma, or the music business works.

Re:Elsevier threatens others for linking to Sci-Hub but does... by gravypod on Sunday August 04, 2019 @10:06AM (#20606583)
> 1. How did publishers like Elsevier get started?

Someone had a lot of money and knew many academics in a few fields. They asked some to review papers and others to send them papers.

> 2. Was their value proposition true back in the day? How did it change over time?

They derived value from peer review, prestige, and collecting all pieces.

Peer review is important for any journal to supply and is a useful step to put your own work through to make sure you are accurately conveying your ideas.

Prestige gets you funding and degrees. Some colleges don't let you get a master's or PhD if you don't have N publications from a X impact factor journal.

Before the internet your college library was your source of information. The librarian has many things to do (not now, we are talking pre-internet) and rather than find every single individual in a field and poll then for papers they go to a publisher and ask for a copy of all of the publications the journal gets.

> 3. How did the industry evolve?

Depending on the field not much to very much.

> 3b. What are the barriers to entry and how did those evolve?

Now that the internet is a thing collecting, indexing, and distributing data is "free". The barriers to entry are still prestige and peer review.

> 3c. What was the business model then and what is it now? Who are the clients (universities, I presume)? How do they pay for this (taxpayer money? If so, that's a huge clue). Who is the decision-maker regarding these purchases?

The business model is two steps. Librarians: you pay me an obscene amount of money each year and I'll organize a bunch of relevant papers for you. Researcher: we only accept "the best" so if you get to publish in my journal you are "the best".

Purchasing subscriptions to these journals is likely still done by a librarian but i say "done" for a reason. There is no decision. You must have these journal subscriptions. More info below.

> 4. How is it possible that they still exist? If they don't provide value anymore, then what is it? Are people habitual creatures? Are they pressuring universities? Did they somehow get a vendor lock-in effect (can people get out)?

The lock-in is that, while they suck, researchers will only hire people with a specific number of publications in a specific impact factor journal. These journals are usually evil but it's "the one I read" so to get in front of some very important people you need to have published in some of these places. If you do the same quality work and publish it in a smaller, open access, journal that is great but it won't necessarily move your career as forward as publishing it in an important journal will.

Re:Elsevier threatens others for linking to Sci-Hub but does... by dredmorbius on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:16AM (#20607018)
Some history:

"Peer review" is younger than you think. Does that mean it can go away?

https://sappingattention.blogspot.com/2017/09/peer-review-is...

Peer review : the end of an error?

https://www.the-tls.co.uk/articles/public/the-end-of-an-erro...

Peer review: Troubled from the start

https://www.nature.com/news/peer-review-troubled-from-the-st...

Why the National Institutes of Health Should Replace Peer Review With a Lottery — Pacific Standard

https://psmag.com/news/why-the-national-institutes-of-health...