First, what's "lately"? HN has had since forever upvoted blogposts on all kinds of things, and they more often than not had simple or simplistic content. It was never about academic standards or some such.
Second, who said academic-proper (as opposed to "academic-lite") material is necessarily "high quality" or of more interest? Most papers are drab affairs, to get someone a degree, or to pad someone's publishing numbers. That they might be full of the proper references, doesn't make them necessarily insightful (or appropriate for a general audience).
And in any case, HN is not a journal, nor is the HN crowd comprised mainly of scholars...
Is "Worse is Better" (a seminal post) academic? Are PG posts (the closest to holy scriptures for early HN) academic?
> it's a double-edged sword that makes everyone think they're an expert
I did not get the impression that the author thought he was an expert. By reading, I think it’s clear the author is aware that he’s not an expert.
More generally, I don’t mind articles written by people who aren’t subject matter experts. Mainly because I think most new ideas come from outsiders.
Third sentence I had a disclaimer and my solutions at the end had a disclaimer.
Discussion is INCREDIBLY valuable for learning about new topics. Further, many major contributions have been from people with different and unusual backgrounds.
The biggest blunders and worst outcomes, have historically come from "expert solutions"...
https://www.smithsonianmag.com/smart-news/why-experts-are-al...
On the other hand, tons of creative solutions and amazing inventions came from non-experts -- people like Mendel, for example (and in fact any new domain must by necessity be founded by a non-expert, since there's no domain to be an expert of beforehand).
"I might be wrong but would love some feedback. It’s an exceedingly complicated topic which has been researched for hundreds of years so it might be that this observation has been made before."
... so there's to be NO discussion on the Internet of complicated topics. Got it!
I think you're attacking a straw-man here. That's not what I said at all. I also write blog posts on complicated topics, but they are thoroughly researched and generally, though not always, within my purview of expertise. You literally only read the Wikipedia page.
Can you please not do that? We all have a bias to dismiss others as idiots on the internet, and it's necessary to consciously discount that in order to have any chance of being fair. Otherwise you end up posting a shallow dismissal while criticizing someone else for being shallow, which improves nothing.
If you know more, that's awesome, and in that case you could write a much better comment by teaching the rest of us some of what you know, so we can learn something.
Doesn't seem like he attacked a straw-man. You literally doubled down saying (to sum it up): "There's to be NO discussion on the Internet of complicated topics [unless you're an expert of them, like I'm on the topics I write on the internet about]".
This is exactly what I'm talking about. You have NO idea of my background. You don't know what I've read.
Do you speak to people like this in person? Common decency goes a long way to further academic discussion.
> Being that my background is in CompSci I tend to think about thinks in terms of probabilities, statistics, game theory, and distributed systems.
Well. OK.
But then a bunch of:
> This would need to be validated experimentally but I suspect that the probability of cooperation (the opposite of defection) would be inversely proportional to the size of the group.
:-|
And the whole post is of about that quality. Fine as a "dear diary" I guess but it's very low-value even as an amateur effort.
To say that the blog post brings nothing new to the table is an understatement. I really wish OP just gave a newbie-friendly introduction to the problem (which would seem more appropriate given their exposure), as opposed to proposing a "solution" -- the hubris is palpable.
I mean, take a look at this quote: "Interestingly enough, the optimum solution is always present when N=1" -- it's wrong on just about every level. First, that's not a solution (and saying optimum is incredibly telling; the term of art is equilibrium, anyway), and second, common property (even if you're the only actor) is still not your property (think about a park in a city of population 1; there's a difference between that park and your back-yard). That's the whole point of the thought experiment.