News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Minimizing Defection Might Be the Solution to the Tragedy... by coldtea on Saturday August 03, 2019 @06:11PM (#20603023)
>There's been a trend lately of low-quality academic-lite blogposts being upvoted on HN. This, unfortunately, continues the pattern.

First, what's "lately"? HN has had since forever upvoted blogposts on all kinds of things, and they more often than not had simple or simplistic content. It was never about academic standards or some such.

Second, who said academic-proper (as opposed to "academic-lite") material is necessarily "high quality" or of more interest? Most papers are drab affairs, to get someone a degree, or to pad someone's publishing numbers. That they might be full of the proper references, doesn't make them necessarily insightful (or appropriate for a general audience).

And in any case, HN is not a journal, nor is the HN crowd comprised mainly of scholars...

Is "Worse is Better" (a seminal post) academic? Are PG posts (the closest to holy scriptures for early HN) academic?

There are no comments on this comment yet.