News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by hannob on Saturday August 03, 2019 @05:22PM (#20602756)
It is often interesting how things are framed in international media when you know the local discussion.

To put this in perspective: The role of hydrogen in the German energy system is extremely small. There are a couple of test plants, but that's about it. Yeah, lately there have been a few calls for more investments in that area, some articles discussing a larger role in the future. But it's certainly not at the center of the debate. The headline seems heavily overblown.

Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by the8472 on Saturday August 03, 2019 @06:08PM (#20603004)
There's also a few experimental train lines running on fuel cells, they seemed successful enough that more have been ordered.

Trains may be better candidates than cars. There are many non-electrified branch lines that currently run on diesel and you need far fewer gas stations that have to deal with hydrogen and all its problems.

Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by majewsky on Sunday August 04, 2019 @06:09PM (#20609530)
> There's also a few experimental train lines running on fuel cells

Your wording is a bit funny, so let me clarify: That's an actual train line with actual passengers. More train lines will be converted from diesel to hydrogen soon.

Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by jillesvangurp on Saturday August 03, 2019 @07:58PM (#20603520)
BMW just appointed a new CEO who is supposed to come up with a strategy that apparently they expect to still involve hydrogen cars. They have been partnering with Toyota on hydrogen fuel cells. The last CEO kind of failed on the BEV front after launching the i3 and then failing to follow through with more/better cars. His failure on this front is widely cited as the key reason for being replaced as they are feeling the pressure now from other manufacturers (Tesla, VW, Mercedes, etc.). The new CEO is apparently under a lot of pressure to start announcing things that are not lame concept cars to reassure investors that they are still relevant.

I don't see a big hydrogen movement happening in Germany any time soon no matter what the wishful thinking on that is at BMW and elsewhere. What I do see is two of the three car manufacturers flooding the market with BEVs in the next five years. They've been a bit slow to catch up to Tesla but VW and Mercedes seem to be quite serious about ramping up production.

Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by rasz on Sunday August 04, 2019 @01:46PM (#20608041)
Too bad they didnt appoint new development director. Klaus Frölich: https://www.forbes.com/sites/michaeltaylor/2019/06/27/bmw-sa...

"BMW's answer is to commit to continue building gasoline and diesel engines"

Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by kiba on Sunday August 04, 2019 @02:54AM (#20604838)
I have no idea why auto companies are still pursuing hydrogen cars when BEV is just better?
Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by neals on Sunday August 04, 2019 @06:58AM (#20605679)
Because the power grid and city infrastructure do not allow for enough (fast) charging-points. In some European cities, for government BEV goals to be achieved, over 700 charging points have to be placed, every single day, for 5 years.

Now imagine a charging point using more electricity than your avarage household.

The grid is not ready for this and upgrading it might not be the best option.

Also know that there is up to 50% loss of electricity when transporting over long distances (like from wind-farm to the city).

Last, but not least: charging large vehicles like busses or trucks take a long time (and a lot of energy) time that is paid for by the company.

Now look at hydrogen: Produced and stored at decentralized locations, distributed through existing infrastructure, available at existing gas stations: Less stress on the grid, shorter charging times. Produce it where and when is most beneficial, store and transport it to when and where it is required.

I could go on. And probably somebody could go on with a lot of counter points.

However, this just states that 'BEV are just better', as you stated, is just not as simple as just that.

We are in a mobility and energy transition: Nothing about this is going to be easy.

Full disclosure: I operate both a corridor of electric car chargers and a hydrogen fueling station in Europe.

Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by 205guy on Sunday August 04, 2019 @04:10PM (#20608951)
Can you explain how you can say "up to 50% loss of electricity when transporting over long distances"? That seems very high, and in my opinion disinformation.

The first search result I found [1] says an average of 6% among US states, broken down as 2% loss in high voltage transmission and 4% loss in local distribution. The spread among states is from 2.2% total loss to 13%, so even given that wind farms may not be sited as close or optimally as fossil fuel plants, your figure of 50% seems implausible.

[1] http://insideenergy.org/2015/11/06/lost-in-transmission-how-...

Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by majewsky on Sunday August 04, 2019 @06:13PM (#20609557)
I think the actual number will fall somewhere in the middle. In parallel, we have a shift ongoing to renewable energy sources which deliver their output less steadily than coal/gas/nuclear. So the grid will not only need to adapt for increased car battery charging, it will also need to add grid-level storage to meet demands when wind turbines and solar panels are not supplying enough at the moment. Storing energy in grid-level batteries will incur some additional loss. Most certainly not 50% though.
Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by 205guy on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:21PM (#20610939)
neals clearly said "50% loss of electricity when transporting" which has nothing to do with intermittent generation and need for storage. He claims to be an operator of electric charging and hydrogen fueling networks, and I was hoping to learn something from his experience, but that unqualified statement undermines his position entirely.
Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by kwhitefoot on Sunday August 04, 2019 @07:19AM (#20605779)
Hydrogen is less efficient than batteries and we already have a the infrastructure for normal overnight charging for battery electric vehicles where the vehicle can be parked of the road.

The only time I need to use a fast charger is when I am on a long trip. Normal commuting, shopping, day trips, works perfectly well charging at home on a 230 V, 16 A circuit (Tesla S 70D).

I agree that there must be more fast chargers but municipalities should concentrate on making it practical for people who live in blocks of flats to charge overnight. Just put a couple of normal Schuko sockets on every lamppost with a simple network controlled contactor. Insist that all parking spaces have such a connector.

Also:

> Also know that there is up to 50% loss of electricity when transporting over long distances (like from wind-farm to the city).

This affects the cost of production of hydrogen just as much as it does the charging of batteries so what is the relevance?

Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by neals on Sunday August 04, 2019 @07:58AM (#20605951)
Yes, I agree that you describe a use case that works and is solved for you and many other early adopters. Which is great for the overall acceptance of BEV driving.

Also great to hear you live in a home where you can actually park your car close enough to the building to have the luxury of charging it through your own infrastructure.

I too have these benefits, and, probably like you, I too drive a Tesla vehicle cheaply, thanks to tax incentives and company benefits.

Now let's look at the other 99% of the world:

If you look at the totals, the situation you describe won't hold up in a full electric future. The sum of the energy requirement for all miles driven, against the opportunity to upgrade the network to meet demand, especially in zones where cars usage is dense (cities) and room for net-expansion is difficult or extremely costly (cities).. there is a huge deficiency.

The transportable and storable nature of hydrogen might come as a solution.

Also, I mention the electricity loss on the network because this actually is not well known. This discussion would likely have started with 'with hydrogen, 50% is lost' if I hadn't mentioned it. That's a go-to counter argument for hydrogen, but one that we should not be focusing on.

Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by matthewdgreen on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:14AM (#20606998)
Seems like both hydrogen and electric charging at large enough scale require infrastructure upgrades. However, there's a huge difference: there are zero hydrogen stations I can find in my state, which makes early adoption impossible. Whereas BEV charging infrastructure exists today at my house: this means there's an easy on-ramp for millions of early adopters, and the future infrastructure upgrades are understood because we've been dealing with industrial-scale electric deployment for decades. Hydrogen cars can't even get to "early adoption" for most people until the infrastructure has been massively built out, but this probably won't happen once BEVs cruise past a certain threshold.
Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by groestl on Sunday August 04, 2019 @03:22AM (#20604950)
Auto companies that do this are essentialy motor engine companies. At their core, the structure is aligned to the R&D and supply chain required to build a complex machine with thousands of small parts. BEVs threaten this model, as the components are much simpler and require a different organizational structure. Hydrogen engines, in contrast, do not (or to a much lesser extend) so the relevant actors are more inclined to push this idea.
Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by turbinerneiter on Sunday August 04, 2019 @03:21AM (#20604942)
You can use hydrogen as fuel for an ICE. Given that the knowledge of German carmakers is in ICE, transmission and assembly, the have a problem with battery cars, which have no ICE and no (complex) transmission. They would be reduced to their assembly lines.
Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by rbf on Sunday August 04, 2019 @03:08AM (#20604896)
Hard to say. Their hydrogen efforts seem half-assed at best; so maybe it is just management not yet convinced BEV will work, and assume hydrogen at some point will be good enough so they want to have some experience with it.

Most likely there is internal company politics in many of these car companies which makes it hard to convert to BEV development, it will mean many people losing their jobs, factories closing, etc.

Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by lrem on Sunday August 04, 2019 @04:15AM (#20605132)
There's the dream of powering ICE cars, with their ease of traversing long ranges, with solar panels thanks to water electrolysis.
Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by llampx on Sunday August 04, 2019 @05:01AM (#20605281)
That ease only comes from the infrastructure that has already been built over the last few decades. Petrol fueling stations can more easily be converted to electric charging stations than hydrogen filling stations.
Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by HellDunkel on Sunday August 04, 2019 @04:19AM (#20605144)
If you take a closer look at the complete lifecycle of BEVs they turn out to be not as eco friendly yet- especially those with bigger batteries. hydrogen mighty be reasonable for a while but eventually bevs will come down in price and fcevs will have a hard time to compete. it is hard to say how long this transition will take.
Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by marcell on Saturday August 03, 2019 @05:58PM (#20602937)
Google the “Gell-Mann” effect for a name to attach to this phenomenon.
Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by ethbro on Saturday August 03, 2019 @06:16PM (#20603053)
That's hilarious. Apparently Michael Crichton named it after a physicist he talked about the phenomena with, in a semi self-referential nod to the effect itself.

Tl;dr: appeals to authority work, even when there's previous proof the authority has no pants.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gell-Mann_amnesia_effect

Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by onetimemanytime on Sunday August 04, 2019 @11:03AM (#20606924)
>>Still the Govt is investing:

To get emission cuts back on track, the government announced in July that 20 new research laboratories will receive a total 100 million euros ($110 million) a year to test new hydrogen technologies for industrial-scale applications. Even more money is earmarked for labs in “structural change” regions, or those most affected by the nations’ shift.

Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by _ph_ on Saturday August 03, 2019 @06:00PM (#20602951)
I have to second this. Mercedes has a nice fuel cell demonstrator car, but will lease out only a few of them and no larger production is planned at this time. Other than a few projects which get shown to the press to have something new to show, there is no larger activity around hydrogen in Germany.
Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by new_realist on Saturday August 03, 2019 @06:41PM (#20603177)
Germany has over 100 H2 stations, with plans for 400.
Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by rmoriz on Sunday August 04, 2019 @03:14AM (#20604919)
Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by solarkraft on Sunday August 04, 2019 @09:14AM (#20606336)
These are only the stations built by H2 Mobility, which is a joint venture of Daimler, Linde, Air Liquide, OMV, Shell and Total.

I wonder how much money they have spent on it so far.

Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by rmoriz on Sunday August 04, 2019 @06:19PM (#20609583)
To my knowledge it includes all public available H2 stations, for example the test station by Fraunhofer.

After the explosion in Oslo some of them are shut down until further notice due to rework.

Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by ethbro on Saturday August 03, 2019 @06:10PM (#20603019)
But this graphic from the article indicates that (starting in 2030) hydrogen use will soon be widespread (by 2050)! /s

https://assets.bwbx.io/images/users/iqjWHBFdfxIU/i1uJSbkueQN...

Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by bubblewrap on Saturday August 03, 2019 @07:12PM (#20603306)
Things that are projected to happen 10 to 12 years in the future seem to have a pesky tendency to happen 10 to 12 years in the future indefinitely.
Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by VvR-Ox on Sunday August 04, 2019 @04:36AM (#20605188)
Yes, it seems a bit clickbaity to me...

The Germans sold their cheat-cars as long as they weren't detected and even now when their own children protest against the political practices regarding climate change they don't really do something serious about it.

The sad thing is that this could be as good as the world will come with combating climate change. Nice.

Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by dgellow on Sunday August 04, 2019 @05:06AM (#20605302)
> The Germans sold their cheat-cars

You mean “some German companies”.

> even now when their own children protest against the political practices regarding climate change they don't really do something serious about it.

Germany is one of the best player in Europe in this domain. The country has ~35% of its electricity generated from windmills and solar panel (average during the year) and it’s in very active development. The main critic from my point of view is the fact that the country renounced using nuclear power, but that’s what people in Germany were asking for.

Just look at the most recent European Parliament elections, the Green Party got more than 20% of German votes. I expect to see politics spending more of their time and budget focused on ecological and environmental issues in the future as a way to gain those votes.

Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by bboygravity on Sunday August 04, 2019 @06:27AM (#20605582)
> The main critic from my point of view is the fact that the country renounced using nuclear power, but that’s what people in Germany were asking for.

Oh really? Germany held a referendum where the majority of "the people" voted against nuclear? I don't think so. There's no reliable way to know what "the people" really want other than a referendum IMO. I don't believe for a second that "we know" that this is what Germans wanted.

As far as I remember Merkel used the (German) emotions during the Fukushima nuclear disaster as an argument to shut down all German Nuclear reactors. The timing: the political campaigns for the next elections about 2 weeks later. The decision to close down Germany's nuclear plants was political. The votes on Merkel (her party) are not equal to German anti-nuclear votes. I don't agree that there is a way to know that "this is what the people wanted". Let's not pretend Germany is a direct democracy...

It's impressive that Germany got to 35 % renewable. It's CO2 emissions however have not gone down sufficiently to reach their 40 % reduction goal[1]. In part because "renewable" doesn't mean "no CO2 emitted". Renewables still emit significantly more CO2 than nuclear plants do per generated unit of energy. Solar panels need to be produced, transported, installed and maintained, they are not recyclable, their lifetime is very limited (25 to 50 years efficient production). A similar thing goes on with wind. Renewables are also more deadly per TWH than nuclear. Even when counting all the disasters [2].

Compare France (a nuclear power generation country) to Germany and this all becomes very clear. France has one of the lowest consumer electricity prices in Europe. Germany has the second highest consumer electricity price in the world. Yet, France has significantly lower CO2 emissions per capita.

Also, the "wasted CO2 cost" of shutting down nuclear plants prematurely is not 0. Significant amounts of CO2 are produced during installing and "uninstalling" of nuclear power plants. If you close such a plant prematurely it means the tons of CO2 per generated TWH go up. Your clean nuclear plant all of a sudden becomes dirtier. I wasn't able to find or calculate how significant this is however.

[1]https://duckduckgo.com/?q=germany+reduction+goal&t=ffab&iar=...

[2]https://www.forbes.com/sites/jamesconca/2012/06/10/energys-d...

Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by elproxy on Sunday August 04, 2019 @05:59PM (#20609475)
Just gonna have to shower your enthusiasm a wee bit on the electricity prices in France: they are rising steeply, but this is mostly for political reasons, as this was to allow the private sector to make money from the public nuclear production in the name of "free and fair competition". It's explained reasonably well here (in french only though): https://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/March%C3%A9_de_l%27%C3%A9lectr...
Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by bboygravity on Monday August 05, 2019 @08:11AM (#20613426)
Even so, consumer electricity prices in France (as far as I know) are still about !45 %! cheaper right now than the German ones at significantly lower CO2 emissions.

The Germans couldn't even do that nasty political thing that France is doing even if they wanted to. That's how high their production price (and subsidies through taxes) are.

https://selectra.co.uk/energy/guides/tariffs/electricity/eur...

Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by dgellow on Monday August 05, 2019 @06:39AM (#20612918)
Thanks for sharing, that was interesting to read
Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by dgellow on Sunday August 04, 2019 @08:30AM (#20606082)
I don't know how you read in my comment that Germany is a direct democracy.
Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by bboygravity on Monday August 05, 2019 @08:04AM (#20613390)
This: "but that’s what people in Germany were asking for."
Re:Germany Turns to Hydrogen in Quest for Clean Energy Economy by elproxy on Sunday August 11, 2019 @05:48PM (#20670752)
Some questions just shouldn't be asked if one is not willing to put in the effort to educate first. A recent poll in France found out that more than half of the people believed nuclear power was bad for the climate!