News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by habnds on Friday August 02, 2019 @02:54AM (#20591093)
people aren't mad only because tons of money is made on hft. It's also because money is _wasterd_ on hft. That's $100 million dollars spent on something that has 0 use to society. It's just rich people playing weird games.

Think about the social benefits of $100 million invested in nyc transit infrastructure.

The economy's incentive structure is broken and this is a prime example.

Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by saberdancer on Friday August 02, 2019 @03:21AM (#20591189)
Those 100m are not destroyed by burning them in an HFT furnace but rather used to pay developers, hardware, factory workers etc. Sure, it's not going directly into infrastructure but it is not lost.

In fact, it's quite possible that if it wasn't invested into HFT it would be held as cash by the company or paid out as a dividend (which is fine as well).

Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by jammygit on Friday August 02, 2019 @04:43AM (#20591473)
Your definition of 'waste' is awfully narrow. I'm not sure anything but destruction of the cash is waste in that view - except that its not even then a total waste because you are helping the money burning industry and furnace industry to thrive.
Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by snovv_crash on Friday August 02, 2019 @04:07AM (#20591347)
That is false. The 100m could have been spent on something which increases the productivity of people. It would still go to devs, factories, etc but at the end there is something from which society benefits.
Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by dna_polymerase on Friday August 02, 2019 @04:16AM (#20591384)
So paying hardware manufacturers and programmers for their work doesn't benefit society? It is not like firing these people would see more cancer research or other stuff you might regard as more beneficial for society.
Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by snovv_crash on Friday August 02, 2019 @04:48AM (#20591495)
It does, but it doesn't create anything which can be leveraged to improve things further. Might as well just give the people the money directly, with no expectations of deliverables.
Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by habnds on Friday August 02, 2019 @05:01AM (#20591555)
It's important to make money but,how much you're paid for your work is an exceptionally bad way to measure that work's value in our society.

Tim O'Reilly said "Create more value than you capture." I would argue that hft is the definition of people capturing value that they didn't create.

Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by vasilipupkin on Friday August 02, 2019 @05:49AM (#20591730)
Firstly, this article has nothing to do with HFT. Goldman is executing on behalf of clients who are not HFT

Secondly, your statement makes an implicit assumption that there is no value in providing liquidity to capital markets. This assumption is false. Think of your local grocery store. Sure, you could drive down to the distribution center and buy stuff there. But instead you go to the store where it’s conveniently laid out for you. Same with HFT. If it didn’t exist, you would still be able to buy and sell but markets would be a lot less liquid and buying and selling less convenient.

Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by habnds on Friday August 02, 2019 @07:34AM (#20592200)
An article titled "GS spending millions to shave millisecconds off stock trades" has nothing to do with HFT?

It isn't at all clear to me buying and selling at an auction even only once a day, let alone once a minute or second would make financial market end user worse off.

Grocery logistics is a terrible analogy for financial markets.

Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by growse on Friday August 02, 2019 @08:55AM (#20592569)
The "F" in in "HFT" stands for "Frequency". This is a separate concept from latency. GS are spending money so they can execute their clients' orders on the market faster, to reduce the risk of the price shifting between order and execution.

> It isn't at all clear to me buying and selling at an auction even only once a day, let alone once a minute or second would make financial market end user worse off.

Go look at the history. Back before the 80s, trading was done by hand, sub-second anything was impossible. Guess what! Spreads were enormous, and the cost of doing business was huge. As a financial market end user (I have a pension), I want the smallest spreads possible.

Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by habnds on Saturday August 03, 2019 @08:03AM (#20600013)
GS is spending the money on this project to reduce high frequency traders ability to capture some of the value of their trades on behalf of clients. Why do you think the price moves away from them? It isn't random. It has everything to do with hft, which has everything to do with market structure.

I'm highly familiar with the history, no one is advocating for a return to open outcry.

Your pension is almost certainly a GS client and footing the bill for this project through execution costs. A periodic auction model would make latency much less of a problem and society's time and energy could be put into solving real problems.

Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by Arbalest on Friday August 02, 2019 @04:24AM (#20591413)
This makes the assumption that time in and of itself has no relevance. Sure the money is reused, but ultimately what is valuable is labour output, and usually that has time relevance. Further, if we consider the activity as steady state, that now means a % of the labour force is semi-permanently unable to be used for something else.
Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by esailija on Friday August 02, 2019 @04:20AM (#20591398)
Actually he probably meant that 100 million are being used to redirect efforts and resources destructively. Your argument can be used just as well to defend an "investment" of 100m into efforts to dig up aluminium, turn it into dust and throw it into oceans.
Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by TheCoelacanth on Friday August 02, 2019 @10:55AM (#20593439)
Broken window fallacy. The work those people are doing could be used for something else, so if they are doing something useless, it is a waste.

If having people work on something useless was beneficial, you could just pay them to dig holes in the ground and fill them up again.

Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by sumnulu on Friday August 02, 2019 @05:51AM (#20591740)
Burning money is not that bad, even burning 99% of all the money in the world.
Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by MaxBarraclough on Saturday August 03, 2019 @05:25AM (#20599471)
...what?
Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by varjag on Friday August 02, 2019 @08:45AM (#20592531)
Is this the finance edition of broken windows fallacy?
Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by TomMarius on Friday August 02, 2019 @03:10AM (#20591153)
HFT has more benefit than huge villas and cars and private jets. It can bring benefit to software and hardware. I'm okay.
Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by habnds on Friday August 02, 2019 @04:57AM (#20591536)
What sort of benefits has it brought to software and hardware?

edit: honest question :)

Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by kortilla on Friday August 02, 2019 @07:40AM (#20592235)
Faster networks. Arista exists because hft was a big target market and now everyone using networks with Arista switches in them has benefited.
Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by gpderetta on Friday August 02, 2019 @01:13PM (#20594643)
SolarFlare as well. HFT shops have been early adopter of kernel bypass setups which now is becoming more common place.

On a related note, the architecture of something like ScyllaDB is very similar to some of the HFT systems I have seen.

Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by smolder on Friday August 02, 2019 @09:51AM (#20592883)
Faster networks would come for other more useful endeavors too, like high quality video conferencing/telepresence stuff. People say how important it is to be working in the same place because conferencing is "just not the same", not realizing it's mostly a technical problem, shitty ISPs, slow routes with high jitter or loss, and insufficient mics, speakers, and software.
Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by kortilla on Friday August 02, 2019 @04:07PM (#20596144)
But nobody is willing to put up the money to fund the research required to improve those speeds like HFT customers. A million dollars per switch is not a problem for them.
Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by TomMarius on Friday August 02, 2019 @05:14AM (#20591598)
I don't know, I didn't use past tense. I imagine that investment into technology is going to bring more benefit than pointless consumption. Also - what about effective markets, that's not a benefit?
Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by habnds on Friday August 02, 2019 @05:49AM (#20591734)
right, you used present tense. You meant hft "could possible have" more benefit? HFT is much more the product of the current regulatory structure than a feature of efficient markets.

Instead of reading Flash Boys, which is good but not really very academic, I'd recommend "The problem of HFT" by Haim Bodek. It explains how he set out to build a sohpisticated trading shop with modern technology and realized all of his competitiors were just gaming the market structure and being handed advantages by exchanges desparate for trading volume.

Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by TomMarius on Friday August 02, 2019 @06:56AM (#20592005)
HFT, being technology, has more benefit than pointless consumption, by definition - at the very least someone is creating something new and that is good for the economy. What are the actual benefits of this project in the market is unknown, especially because it does not exist yet.
Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by codyb on Friday August 02, 2019 @02:59AM (#20591114)
Who’s mad about HFT? 100m out of a what 40tn dollar world GDP?

I get it, just seems... unlikely. Who cares?

Re:Goldman Sachs is spending $100M to shave milliseconds off... by habnds on Friday August 02, 2019 @04:57AM (#20591532)
Maybe mad is a strong word, but, it isn't just $100m, That's one investment by one company. It's billions of dollars across the world to gain arbitrary milliseconds.

Restructuring financial markets, to use periodic auctions for example or by adding speed bumps rather than continuous trading would probably do away with an entire wasteful industry and benefit the actually relevant parties in the financial system, people who have money, and people who need money, at the cost of the unnecessary middlemen.