News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:“We plan to hide ‘https’ scheme and subdomain ‘www’ in Ch... by eridius on Wednesday July 31, 2019 @03:43AM (#20572387)
I'm not sure why everyone is so up in arms here. I don't see how this change is detrimental to the web or somehow good for Google. Hiding the "https://" seems like a perfectly fine idea as long as there's a clear way to distinguish between https and http pages. Safari's done this for a long time; https pages display a tiny padlock icon and http pages display a much more prominent "Not Secure — " prefix (i.e. the obvious display is when you're insecure, which is the right way to go about things).

Hiding "www" seems less meaningful. I'm not really sure what the motivation is there, beyond the fact that the "www" prefix is mostly just aesthetics. My best guess is they want the url to start with "google.com" instead of "www.google.com", except that's not helpful from a security standpoint at all and might be slightly detrimental, if it trains people that the very first word they encounter is the most important, as paypal.whatever.com is not in fact paypal. But a lot of domains already elide the "www" anyway.

Of course, in both cases I am assuming that putting focus on the URL bar will display the full URL.

Re:“We plan to hide ‘https’ scheme and subdomain ‘www’ in Ch... by dao- on Wednesday July 31, 2019 @03:55AM (#20572443)
> Of course, in both cases I am assuming that putting focus on the URL bar will display the full URL.

It won't. From the issue tracker: "The full URL is also revealed by clicking twice in the URL bar on desktop," in other words, merely focusing the URL bar won't be enough.

Re:“We plan to hide ‘https’ scheme and subdomain ‘www’ in Ch... by anfogoat on Wednesday July 31, 2019 @07:56AM (#20573581)
Boy, they really don't want you to see it.
Re:“We plan to hide ‘https’ scheme and subdomain ‘www’ in Ch... by kart23 on Wednesday July 31, 2019 @11:47AM (#20575376)
Ok this is bad. On safari, I think it makes sense. They just show the domain and a lock icon if there is https to make the ui cleaner, and if you click on the adress bar, the full url shows. It's a good user flow, and it makes sense. This google move does not make sense, especially when people are so used to the full url showing, its going to confuse a lot of users.
Re:“We plan to hide ‘https’ scheme and subdomain ‘www’ in Ch... by eridius on Wednesday July 31, 2019 @02:41PM (#20576999)
How does that work? If you put focus on the URL bar but it doesn't show the whole URL, how are you supposed to edit it?
Re:“We plan to hide ‘https’ scheme and subdomain ‘www’ in Ch... by dao- on Wednesday July 31, 2019 @04:56PM (#20578447)
On focus you can only copy or replace the URL, not edit it. You need to click a second time to edit.
Re:“We plan to hide ‘https’ scheme and subdomain ‘www’ in Ch... by davman on Wednesday July 31, 2019 @03:54AM (#20572436)
Its not always just aesthetic unfortunately. Try this shining example from British local government:

http://www.manchester.gov.uk vs http://manchester.gov.uk

Re:“We plan to hide ‘https’ scheme and subdomain ‘www’ in Ch... by johnday on Wednesday July 31, 2019 @05:36AM (#20572857)
Those seem to redirect to the same place.
Re:“We plan to hide ‘https’ scheme and subdomain ‘www’ in Ch... by jonnybarnes on Wednesday July 31, 2019 @05:52AM (#20572917)
Re:“We plan to hide ‘https’ scheme and subdomain ‘www’ in Ch... by Avamander on Wednesday July 31, 2019 @07:19AM (#20573369)
So the problem is theirs.
Re:“We plan to hide ‘https’ scheme and subdomain ‘www’ in Ch... by idbehold on Wednesday July 31, 2019 @08:36AM (#20573891)
Yes, as in Google's.
Re:“We plan to hide ‘https’ scheme and subdomain ‘www’ in Ch... by Avamander on Wednesday July 31, 2019 @08:54AM (#20574004)
Webserver misconfigurations are hosts' problems.
Re:“We plan to hide ‘https’ scheme and subdomain ‘www’ in Ch... by darkarmani on Wednesday July 31, 2019 @10:17AM (#20574597)
But now you cannot distinguish between the 2 URLs. They look the same in the URL field but one is broken.
Re:“We plan to hide ‘https’ scheme and subdomain ‘www’ in Ch... by Avamander on Wednesday July 31, 2019 @11:38AM (#20575280)
The website host can absolutely distinguish between the two (two clicks on title bar). I guess this change has another upside of forcing website hosts to have working web server configurations
Re:“We plan to hide ‘https’ scheme and subdomain ‘www’ in Ch... by johnday on Wednesday July 31, 2019 @10:11AM (#20574544)
Oh - it gives me the error but then does redirect to the correct location (with https security).
Re:“We plan to hide ‘https’ scheme and subdomain ‘www’ in Ch... by ggggtez on Wednesday July 31, 2019 @10:55AM (#20574863)
No error for me, what exactly is the complaint here?
Re:“We plan to hide ‘https’ scheme and subdomain ‘www’ in Ch... by holstvoogd on Wednesday July 31, 2019 @09:28AM (#20574250)
I think the main issue people have with this all is that we all f*cked up by making Chrome into the new IE6 by pushing it to a monopoly position and only now realizing that. So now we get angry at Google every time we are confronted by our mistakes, for instance when they push a change upon us that we are not especially thrilled about.

Also, we love change as long as we are the ones doing it. All other changes are bad.

We == developers

Re:“We plan to hide ‘https’ scheme and subdomain ‘www’ in Ch... by xemdetia on Wednesday July 31, 2019 @05:13PM (#20578613)
I've been feeling like this for a while because at least back when chrome first hit it seemed like Mozilla and Google were mostly competing but modestly equal interests. Then Android took off. Then even the fringe browsers became webkit to keep up. Then about this time Google started testing the waters for this level of pushing through standards, and they've just kept pushing to what should violate something other than morality, but I don't feel like there is an appropriate mechanism to slap their wrist and push back. I really wish that most of these chrome standards would stop smelling as much "I changed it because it didn't work for my current project and I guess I'll force a standards change to meet my project deadline." I have not felt like most of the Chrome changes I have observed recently are given more thought than an intern/junior dev would give it and they don't have a Linus to tell them to stop breaking userspace.
Re:“We plan to hide ‘https’ scheme and subdomain ‘www’ in Ch... by playpause on Wednesday July 31, 2019 @11:53AM (#20575428)
I'm not sure either. URLs obviously aren't going anywhere, even if Google makes this UI change. Social media and email still exist. People aren't going to suddenly stop sharing links to news and blog posts. If Google Chrome really makes it too hard to copy the URL of the current page, then even my least technically literate friends will switch to another browser – they all send each other URLs all the time.

This part is puzzling though:

> The full URL is also revealed by clicking twice in the URL bar on desktop, and once on mobile.

Twice? I can't picture how that will work as a UI. What happens after the first click?

Re:“We plan to hide ‘https’ scheme and subdomain ‘www’ in Ch... by ggggtez on Wednesday July 31, 2019 @10:51AM (#20574837)
"Security sensitive context" are the key words here. On mobile devices, you get, what, 300 pixels across to show the URL? You want to show as much relevant info as you can, and if you can summarize "https://www." then you get more real estate for the domain name itself.

It seems reasonable to me. I get the hate for FAANG, but some people just lose their minds.

Re:“We plan to hide ‘https’ scheme and subdomain ‘www’ in Ch... by liveoneggs on Wednesday July 31, 2019 @01:43PM (#20576536)
people are up in arms because of AMP
Re:“We plan to hide ‘https’ scheme and subdomain ‘www’ in Ch... by bassman9000 on Wednesday July 31, 2019 @07:35AM (#20573457)
clear way

tiny padlock

ok

Re:“We plan to hide ‘https’ scheme and subdomain ‘www’ in Ch... by on_and_off on Wednesday July 31, 2019 @03:48AM (#20572411)
>I'm not sure why everyone is so up in arms here

It is a change made by Google and it also dares try to simplify things for non tech savvy users so it has to be evil !

Re:“We plan to hide ‘https’ scheme and subdomain ‘www’ in Ch... by penagwin on Wednesday July 31, 2019 @03:52AM (#20572426)
To me the problem is that it obscures the page URI, making it an unreliable source for exactly where you are.

Whether this is a real concern for usual end users no I don't think so. It's mostly more annoying for the HN crowd who need to see it for development or are very security sensitive.