News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

A comment on Apple Reports Declining Profits and Slowing Growth Again. Parent comment

Re:Apple Reports Declining Profits and Slowing Growth Again by scarface74 on Tuesday July 30, 2019 @11:57PM (#20571608)
You mean like the HomePod? How is that working out? People will buy a $600-$1000 phone for two reasons - it’s highly subsidized/payment plans and the phone is considered a necessity. The number of people who would pay $400 for a smart speaker is minuscule. Heck iPads only started seeing an uptick when Apple started selling good low end models at $329.

The AppleTV was a decently early set top box and those didn’t change the world. It wasn’t until Roku and Amazon started selling them at basically break even or maybe a slight loss for $50 that those took off.

[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:Apple Reports Declining Profits and Slowing Growth Again by vannevar on Wednesday July 31, 2019 @06:50PM (#20579422)
The HomePod isn't working out because: a) it was way late to the market, and b) Siri's technology lags behind Alexa.

Which supports my argument about lackluster innovation. I can say people won't pay $1200 bucks for a laptop with specs they could get for $800, either, but I'd be wrong because they do.

You might argue the AppleTV was innovative at the time it was released, but there were already very successful game consoles that had much the same functionality plus the games. Even if you count it as an innovation, it was announced in 2007.

Innovative products are not always successful. Now, if AppleTV had incorporated Alexa-level voice control technology back in 2013, that probably would've been innovative and successful.

[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:Apple Reports Declining Profits and Slowing Growth Again by scarface74 on Wednesday July 31, 2019 @07:45PM (#20579838)
People will buy a $1300 laptop because a computer is a necessity to get things done. Paying more for something you will use everyday. People will not pay $400 for a smart speaker. People just aren’t that into it b
[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:Apple Reports Declining Profits and Slowing Growth Again by vannevar on Thursday August 01, 2019 @12:57PM (#20585799)
Maybe so. But I still think if Apple had released an AppleTV with Alexa-quality voice control before the Echo came out, it would've been huge.

I'm wandering off-topic, but I keep imagining an alternative universe where Apple bought Nintendo and released an amazing Nintendo-AppleTV with fantastic voice control, leading to a game ecosystem today where you can seamlessly go from console-to-phone-to-watch playing the same game, with friends.

[ Parent | on HN ]