But... a picture of specific problems with the measure the fed uses (PCE, apparently) would be better than vaguely implying it's bad. Apparently it does include housing expenses, medical care, education, and even recreation, so it's not clear it's just "a basket of consumer goods."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Personal_consumption_expenditu...
https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/USSTHPI
Remember: the Fed governs the entire US economy, not just San Francisco and Seattle like HN would prefer.
California Urban Inflation http://www.dof.ca.gov/Forecasting/Economics/Indicators/Infla...
You can see average inflation averages about 4% for LA, San Diego and San Francisco.
I believe the St Louis FRED also has these inflation numbers for West Coast Urban CPI which reflect similar rates.
https://www.trulia.com/real_estate/Chicago-Illinois/market-t...
Now I'm interested in seeing the current metric of home prices divided by median income. Hmm... once source is this.
https://www.longtermtrends.net/home-price-median-annual-inco...
Would be also interesting to see this as a heat map.
> Remember: the Fed governs the entire US economy, not just San Francisco and Seattle like HN would prefer.
Reports from the field, meaning friends with family in the rest of the country makes it sound like the Fed is doing even worse in those places.
Almost every time I see a decent non-remote job it's in an expensive city.
(Note: I am in Garner, which is a less affluent town, but hardly a bad place to live).
But I work remote and it's a risk to leave the city - growing up in northern California the idea of owning a home without an enormous amount of debt (and thereby meaning I had to decide to maximize income whether it meant doing what I wanted) was foreign.
This played out quite nastily in regards to consumer goods. Walmart et al came to town, promising low prices based on foreign production and domestic economies of scale. But they destroyed local towns' commercial economies, putting many people out of stable living-wage work. Economic orthodoxy would expect the remaining local economy to cope by providing the still-employed more purchasing power (say, dual income families being able to drop to single income, now-richer still-employed people hiring household help, etc). But any lower prices were only temporary due to that policy of forced inflation, and everybody kept needing the same level of income. So the net result of that innovation ended up being to lower the standard of living with lower income and poorer quality goods. (Then along came heroin from Afghanistan, but I digress).
https://www.federalreserve.gov/monetarypolicy/bst_recenttren...
The lowering of rates now coupled with balance sheet stabilization, during the longest expansion, prior to any REAL sign of economic turmoil (backed by Powell's own statements earlier this year when he was advocating "patience", the fundamentals have not changed substantially since then although his tune has) is to many a bad sign that the fed is being driven by political/wall street forces to keep the party going despite losing leverage down the road and promoting asset inflation. (Housing is often discussed but to avoid the inevitable rebuttals to that, I'd also cite the average PE ratio [1] being far above the historical average.)
[0]https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-fed-powell/fed-to-sto...
[1] https://www.multpl.com/s-p-500-pe-ratio
[2] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-fed-balancesheet/fed-...
The rate of return is the opportunity cost of capital. As long as you have economic growth there will be an interest rate.
When the government puts an interest rate below the natural rate it is making the machine work harder, but not necessarily better. It gives people that have access to the natural rate of return an above-natural return.
Thats when Bitcoin hits 6 figures, or thats what the libertarian in me has been saying for a decade.
I notice that goldbugs in particular get very upset about low interest rates -- as if there is something "natural" or "normal" about 7% vs 3%. But there is no magical number -- if you can create wealth without inflation, you should obviously continue to create wealth.
Also, the government doesn't owe you a risk-free return of 7%. In theory, the risk-free return should be equal to the rate of inflation -- nothing ventured nothing gained.