A couple of things here: 1) Many trained economists would say this is a woeful oversimplification or flat-out disagree. 2) Exactly what is meant by "efficient" and "pretty much"?
Many trained economists would also have to blow out the HN comment limit to fully explain what they meant. Accusing someone's economics of being "simplified" is a bit of a cheap shot, a PhD thesis is also "simplified". I don't think very many trained economists would have a hard time expanding my sentence into a reasonable claim. The propaganda market in the US is brutally competitive, and it almost all ultimate boils down to money for somebody in the end, no? (Some exceptions for truly ideological-only propaganda, sure, but those are the exceptions.)
Not if you're espousing the woo-woo of market infallibility. markets are very good at lots of things. They aren't great at everything any more than Bayesian filters or genetic algorithms are infallible oracles.
Some exceptions for truly ideological-only propaganda, sure, but those are the exceptions.
Market infallibility woo-woo is ideological propaganda.
I'm a big proponent of understanding why it works that way and trying to ensure the market works for us, not against us, and therefore I don't think letting it run unfettered is a good idea. I also don't think deliberately misunderstanding and demonizing it, then applying foolish and poorly-thought-out first-order-thinking-based controls are a good idea either, which is by far the most common alternative. It's like demonizing gravity and trying to legislate antigravity into existence.
There are certain things markets are not efficient or even particularly good at.
I also don't think deliberately misunderstanding and demonizing it, then applying foolish and poorly-thought-out first-order-thinking-based controls are a good idea either
Agreed. We probably need a better understanding of meta-markets.
Of course we're better at it, we've got tons more practice. For that matter our government isn't all that great at it, the best and most effective ideological propaganda in this country actually comes from commercial interests like Fox News and the New York Times. (And if you think one of those is much less biased than the other... ha!)
And also a reminder that the market will efficiently execute pretty much anything, regardless of the desirability of efficient execution.