News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Skype banned from China by StavrosK on Thursday December 30, 2010 @10:49AM (#2052464)
This is entirely unrelated, but it reminds me of a comment I saw on reddit that was very telling. Someone was talking about a colleague of his who was Chinese and had come to the US, and who, over dinner with some other colleagues, said: "I can't believe how smooth your propaganda is here in the US. In China it is crude and everyone can see through it, but here you almost miss it." To which all of the other colleagues replied: "What are you talking about? We don't have propaganda in the US!"

I wish I could find it, it was very telling of the climate in China (I assume, I've never been).

Re:Skype banned from China by garply on Thursday December 30, 2010 @12:22PM (#2052797)
I'm an American expat in China and I've lived here for several years. I completely agree with the Chinese guy's statement and have thought the same thing myself many times, though I've never heard anyone else openly express it.

Living in an extremely alien culture allows you to see things about your own culture that are hard to notice when you're immersed.

I can be a little more specific about how the propaganda systems work.

The Chinese system:

According to the news, there are more blue skies in Beijing this year than last year, and more blue skies last year than the year before. The pollution situation is getting better and better very rapidly. It's definitely false, but they print it anyway.

Youku and Tudou (Chinese Youtubes) will often have videos of advanced Chinese missiles or other weaponry as the featured video on the front page.

When the Chinese media runs a story on the US, there is a high probability it is discussing some negative aspect of the US (high murder rate, copious drug usage, poor governmental handling of environmental disasters).

And of course you have the censorship end of it: Sina Weibo (Chinese Twitter) and Kaixin (Chinese Facebook) posts are ajax-filtered for sensitive keywords and give you a big red warning if you try to say "bad" things. Or sometimes you'll come back to your computer and some posts you made a couple hours ago are just deleted. Clearly someone monitoring the networks noticed and removed your undesirable content.

I think we can agree the system is used a bit like a blunt instrument. But it works. People, especially the mass population with relatively poor education, really do believe the stuff. America loves war. China is an extremely peace-loving country. Americans love guns and drugs. Chinese pollution is significantly better than a few years ago. Etc.

In the US, on the other hand, "propaganda" is more closely woven into consumer demand and people's value systems.

If an organization wants to convince you of a message, they don't lie outright, they omit information that would cause you to believe to the contrary.

Let's talk about Iran for a bit. In China, there have been a series of articles about recent terrorist attacks in Iran and evidence that the bombers were supported by US intelligence agencies. I don't have strong feelings about how America should treat Iran one way or another, but I find the notion that we were involved at least plausible. But the headlines in the US papers don't mention possible American involvement. If it is mentioned in the article bodies, it's usually as a passing statement which the reader is likely to casually dismiss ("the Iranian government issued a statement that the US was involved in the attacks").

So the emphasis is different.

If you looked at the NYT on the first day of the Wikileaks stories, they wove stories from the cables, and the story they chose to focus on was how Iran was angering many other nations in the Middle East.

Again, it's a matter of what the media chooses to focus on and what it chooses to neglect. There were tons of potential stories in those wires - why did they choose that one as the most important?

And a lot of information in the US media is conveyed on top of a set of assumptions. When Wikileaks broke, the major news organizations mentioned that not all of the cables were being revealed, as some of the information might have posed a threat to national security. Whose national security? The US's. Why is that necessarily a bad thing? What if the cables had contained information that posed a threat to Chinese or Russian or Iranian national security? Would that have been a bad thing too? Or would that, instead, have been a matter of freedom of speech?

And we can also look at how people in the US choose to consume information that confirms their existing beliefs. Fox News and the Huffington Post. The fact that liberal and conservative news exist at all should tell you that the information inside is politically biased. I think they could fairly be called conservative and liberal propaganda. In these cases, Americans are not bludgeoned by unwanted propaganda, they actively seek it out.

In short, in the US, people actively pursue biased information and news organizations don't blatantly lie, they just emphasize and deemphasize certain facts in accordance with a value system that the consumer already holds. I would call that a more subtle propaganda system than what happens in China.

There are, of course, a few similarities between the two systems as well. A short commercial that says "Support our troops!" may not seem like propaganda to you until you've seen one where there's a Communist flag waving in the background.

Re:Skype banned from China by mike-cardwell on Thursday December 30, 2010 @04:53PM (#2053696)
"news organizations don't blatantly lie" - This actually happens a lot more than most people realise. You've read countless "quotes" that were simply made up by a reporter because they couldn't get somebody to talk to them. I'd be surprised if there was a single issue of a major newspaper out there which doesn't contain at least a dozen outright lies.
Re:Skype banned from China by alex_c on Thursday December 30, 2010 @03:33PM (#2053528)
>A short commercial that says "Support our troops!" may not seem like propaganda to you until you've seen one where there's a Communist flag waving in the background.

When I watched a movie in theaters in the US last year, I remember being jarred by the strident nationalism and militarism in an ad for the Army shown before the movie. On the other hand, right after that, a movie trailer I'd seen in Canada a few weeks before had some mildly gory scenes stripped out in the US version. Go figure.

Re:Skype banned from China by mike4u2 on Thursday December 30, 2010 @07:03PM (#2053979)
Your post is interesting but it misses a key point: Selection bias is everywhere, but in the US and most other countries you do not get run over by a truck if you watch Fox News, run your own blog or decide to make fun of politicians.
Re:Skype banned from China by sdkslzdfk on Thursday December 30, 2010 @11:09PM (#2054476)
Yes. It's a long, well thought out post that's entirely non-sequitur. The poster doesn't understand the difference between true propaganda and spin.

The NYTimes has its own opinion, but it is definitely not an instrument of the US Government.

He also implies that because China has clunky methods which are obvious they don't have any subtle ones. Having clunky methods doesn't rule out having subtle ones. I don't speak Chinese, but I find it exceedingly hard to believe that China doesn't employ both clunky and subtle forms of propaganda.

Having clunky and detectable methods isn't better, either, as you claim, it's worse, because they're more invasive. That's the whole point. That's why we don't want censorship, or the great firewall, or our non-violent dissenters rotting in jail.

Anyway, maybe you live in a relativistic world where everybody's country is only as good as they're told, but I'm smart enough to discount my own bias, and I know that the US is a freer place to live than China.

Re:Skype banned from China by hackerblues on Monday January 03, 2011 @01:11PM (#2064017)
"I'm smart enough to discount my own bias"

I am genuinely interested, how did you establish that you have the ability to correctly compensate for your biases?

Re:Skype banned from China by jgwynn2901 on Friday December 31, 2010 @09:26AM (#2055436)
Q.E.D.
Re:Skype banned from China by pradocchia on Thursday December 30, 2010 @11:54AM (#2052687)
"I can't believe how smooth your propaganda is here in the US. In China it is crude and everyone can see through it, but here you almost miss it."

Having grown up the States, and having lived in China for many years, I'd agree with this statement wholeheartedly.

Re:Skype banned from China by jerf on Thursday December 30, 2010 @02:06PM (#2053238)
Just another special case of how centralized systems can't compete with distributed competition systems. Chinese propaganda comes from the government and doesn't have any reason to improve. In the US, you have propaganda from the two major sides of the government and various agencies, in addition to a wide-open market in propaganda in the commercial market which we call "marketing" and "public relations", in a constant unrelenting barrage in competition with each other: "Didn't you have ads in the 21st century?" "Well sure, but not in our dreams. Only on TV and radio, and in magazines, and movies, and at ball games... and on buses and milk cartons and t-shirts, and bananas and written on the sky. But not in dreams, no siree."

Of course we're better at it, we've got tons more practice. For that matter our government isn't all that great at it, the best and most effective ideological propaganda in this country actually comes from commercial interests like Fox News and the New York Times. (And if you think one of those is much less biased than the other... ha!)

And also a reminder that the market will efficiently execute pretty much anything, regardless of the desirability of efficient execution.

Re:Skype banned from China by stcredzero on Thursday December 30, 2010 @03:40PM (#2053547)
And also a reminder that the market will efficiently execute pretty much anything, regardless of the desirability of efficient execution.

A couple of things here: 1) Many trained economists would say this is a woeful oversimplification or flat-out disagree. 2) Exactly what is meant by "efficient" and "pretty much"?

Re:Skype banned from China by jerf on Thursday December 30, 2010 @03:59PM (#2053592)
"Many trained economists would say this is a woeful oversimplification or flat-out disagree."

Many trained economists would also have to blow out the HN comment limit to fully explain what they meant. Accusing someone's economics of being "simplified" is a bit of a cheap shot, a PhD thesis is also "simplified". I don't think very many trained economists would have a hard time expanding my sentence into a reasonable claim. The propaganda market in the US is brutally competitive, and it almost all ultimate boils down to money for somebody in the end, no? (Some exceptions for truly ideological-only propaganda, sure, but those are the exceptions.)

Re:Skype banned from China by stcredzero on Thursday December 30, 2010 @11:56PM (#2054573)
I don't think very many trained economists would have a hard time expanding my sentence into a reasonable claim.

Not if you're espousing the woo-woo of market infallibility. markets are very good at lots of things. They aren't great at everything any more than Bayesian filters or genetic algorithms are infallible oracles.

Some exceptions for truly ideological-only propaganda, sure, but those are the exceptions.

Market infallibility woo-woo is ideological propaganda.

Re:Skype banned from China by jerf on Friday December 31, 2010 @12:24PM (#2055850)
I didn't say infallible. I said efficient. Many of the problems with markets are that they are efficient in ways that people don't want them to be; they will ruthlessly pollute the environment or squeeze people right out of the system if that is what brings the maximum reward. Or, to the point at hand, ruthlessly optimize propaganda without much thought about the consequences. Many people make the mistake of conflating "efficient" with "desirable", but they are only related, not identical. (Actually damn near everybody makes that mistake, even economists, to be honest.)

I'm a big proponent of understanding why it works that way and trying to ensure the market works for us, not against us, and therefore I don't think letting it run unfettered is a good idea. I also don't think deliberately misunderstanding and demonizing it, then applying foolish and poorly-thought-out first-order-thinking-based controls are a good idea either, which is by far the most common alternative. It's like demonizing gravity and trying to legislate antigravity into existence.

Re:Skype banned from China by stcredzero on Friday December 31, 2010 @08:31PM (#2057001)
I didn't say infallible. I said efficient.

There are certain things markets are not efficient or even particularly good at.

I also don't think deliberately misunderstanding and demonizing it, then applying foolish and poorly-thought-out first-order-thinking-based controls are a good idea either

Agreed. We probably need a better understanding of meta-markets.

Re:Skype banned from China by jedsmith on Thursday December 30, 2010 @11:03AM (#2052512)
I would say that anecdote is more telling of the alleged climate in the United States, depending on how you read it.
Re:Skype banned from China by StavrosK on Thursday December 30, 2010 @11:54AM (#2052689)
Both, really.
Re:Skype banned from China by maeon3 on Thursday December 30, 2010 @11:18AM (#2052571)
I had a Chinese girl lecture me on how I was taken in by propaganda by believing that the Yuan/RMB was not pegged to gold. I had proof that it was pegged to the US dollar from 3 independent reliable sources but she wouldn't believe any of it.

Banning skype is simply an ineffective attempt to protect the propaganda misinformation machines in the people's republic of China.

Re:Skype banned from China by MikeCapone on Thursday December 30, 2010 @11:42AM (#2052652)
> Banning skype is simply an ineffective attempt to protect the propaganda misinformation machines in the people's republic of China.

It's also very probably economic protectionism.

Re:Skype banned from China by stcredzero on Thursday December 30, 2010 @03:41PM (#2053549)
If it was pegged to gold, shouldn't it have gotten kinda huge of late?
Re:Skype banned from China by maeon3 on Thursday December 30, 2010 @04:54PM (#2053699)
Trust me I used that line of thinking. Cognative dissonance can be a doozy. It was like arguing with someone who believes in flat earth. No evidence can overpower a need to believe.
Re:Skype banned from China by tubecat on Friday December 31, 2010 @05:56PM (#2056705)
Many still believe the USD is backed by gold.
Re:Skype banned from China by stcredzero on Thursday December 30, 2010 @03:36PM (#2053535)
Everyone should read Manufacturing Consent.
Re:Skype banned from China by tubecat on Friday December 31, 2010 @05:47PM (#2056691)
That's exactly my experience. The average middle class person knows for a fact that he is lied to and information is withheld from him. They know what youtube is and they know their government is blocking it.

In spite of even wikileaks, no one can believe the exact same thing goes on here.