News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by Despegar on Thursday July 25, 2019 @04:40PM (#20529448)
>On July 24, 2019, the Board of Directors of Alphabet authorized the company to repurchase up to an additional $25.0 billion of its Class C capital stock

The reason the stock is up so much. They're going to stop blowing money on stuff they aren't good at.

Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by seldonnn on Thursday July 25, 2019 @06:40PM (#20530524)
That’s 3% of market cap, try again on your explanation. Hint: accelerating revenue growth
Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by Despegar on Thursday July 25, 2019 @07:01PM (#20530710)
Investors have always disliked Google's bad capital allocation. They'd much rather have the cash. The expansion in the buyback is a signal for a new era of capital return.
Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by UncleMeat on Thursday July 25, 2019 @08:25PM (#20531217)
If they'd rather have cash then why do they own GOOG instead of holding cwsh?
Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by etaioinshrdlu on Thursday July 25, 2019 @09:04PM (#20531409)
Investors like GOOG but would rather it focus on it's money printing machine than the founder's moonshot visions.
Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by v7p1Qbt1im on Friday July 26, 2019 @04:48AM (#20533334)
This kind of thinking leads to companies becoming irrelevant over time. I for one would much rather go for an interesting 50-year vision instead of pushing for quarterly stock gains exclusively. Ad revenue growth is slowing down across the board. FB is still showing increased growth because of Instagram which is just so perfect for ads. AMZN is a small player to begin with, so their growth will naturally be high. Also their platform is very well positioned for display ads and especially sponsored product ads because they tie in to their main business so well.

Alphabet will have ad revenue for a long time, yes. But cloud will eventually be more important. So they need to make sure they catch up to MSFT and AMZN eventually. And the moonshots are very important as well. Their very nature is risk. If successful anyone of them could potentially be worth hundreds of billions. Morgan Stanley speculates that Waymo could be worth a quarter of trillion in 10 years. DeepmMind and Google Brain/AI are two of the leading AI entities in the world. Wing could be very important for Google Shopping. And they really need to build out their shopping offerings. And then there are the healthcare/life science efforts. No one even knows what Calico is doing exactly.

What they are missing is basically a space initiative. Yes there is loon and Access but Amazon is already in the process of launching their Starlink-like satellite network. And then there is Bezos's Blue Origin.

My (amateurish) prediction is to be positioned in: AI, biotech/genetic engineering, space industries.

Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by repolfx on Friday July 26, 2019 @05:27AM (#20533486)
I for one would much rather go for an interesting 50-year vision instead of pushing for quarterly stock gains exclusively.

That's great if you're, say, under the age of 50 and plan to hold your stock your entire life until retirement.

But consider a company whose stock price never went up but which had a great 50 year vision. Maybe towards the end of the 50 years it starts going up fast, but by then you already lived a big chunk of your life and passed many moments when you could have used some of the money.

At some point you're going to want ROI. One quarter is short for sure, but 50 years is the opposite extreme. Why wait such a long time for hypothetical ROI that may never come?

For Google specifically their problem is their revenue has way outpaced their ability to come up with new ideas. Since Larry Page stepped into the shadows the ambition and drive are gone. I'm not sure there's any vision, let alone a 50 year vision. The only highlights are their successes with AI, and maybe Waymo, but those are small parts of the overall company. AI mostly seems to be leading to incremental improvements in their existing products.

When you cast your eyes wider you see large amounts of what might uncharitably be described as self-indulgent waste. How many chat services are they up to now? And how many of them had any kind of interesting competitive advantage? How many languages and VMs without any obvious competitive advantage has Google created? How many internal systems do they rewrite without any clear idea of why, other than because someone needs to get promoted?

Dig around and discover just how many projects there are producing uncompetitive 'experimental' pseudo-products nobody has ever heard of and likely nobody ever will e.g.

https://nsynthsuper.withgoogle.com/

https://www.blog.google/outreach-initiatives/google-news-ini...

https://www.blog.google/outreach-initiatives/arts-culture/ex...

https://www.blog.google/products/photos/gallery-go/

Google has so many products they end up reusing their own names! Google Go is one thing, Google Gallery Go is a totally different thing - a mobile photo gallery app specifically for Nigeria, for some reason.

When you look at the firm closely you see a firehose of projects with zero business case and often near-zero impact. Why does Google think these things are better ways to invest the money than what other companies are doing?

Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by RestlessMind on Friday July 26, 2019 @10:50AM (#20535202)
> When you look at the firm closely you see a firehose of projects with zero business case and often near-zero impact. Why does Google think these things are better ways to invest the money than what other companies are doing?

Silicon Valley often sees "a firehose of startups with zero business case and often near-zero impact." And yet, it is considered a key driver of the economic growth / innovation / good jobs and places all over the world want to replicate its success. Maybe, Google just wants to have an in-house Silicon Valley?

Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by bduerst on Thursday July 25, 2019 @10:52PM (#20531976)
If the majority of investors felt that way then the board would adjust leadership. Are you sure you're not projecting?
Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by tdhoot on Friday July 26, 2019 @01:53PM (#20536762)
Voting power in Google is controlled by the founders, regardless of how much ownership they have.
Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by repolfx on Friday July 26, 2019 @05:12AM (#20533433)
In the hope that GOOG pays out cash in future. Either via dividends or stock buybacks.

At least, that's why I've been holding my shares. I was thinking of dumping them for better performing tech stocks, given the malaise I see there, but if they're finally starting to admit they may have run out of ideas and start returning money for reallocation elsewhere in the economy, then ... well ... maybe I'll hold a little longer.

Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by plankers on Thursday July 25, 2019 @10:30PM (#20531886)
Ummm, I think inflation has something to do with it.
Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by 0xDEEPFAC on Thursday July 25, 2019 @05:05PM (#20529695)
"For most of the 20th century, stock buybacks were deemed illegal because they were thought to be a form of stock market manipulation."

https://www.forbes.com/sites/aalsin/2017/02/28/shareholders-...

Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by asdfasgasdgasdg on Thursday July 25, 2019 @05:14PM (#20529779)
Thank goodness that has stopped. They are not materially different from dividends, besides being more tax efficient.
Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by scarface74 on Thursday July 25, 2019 @05:33PM (#20529992)
There is no logical reason that dividends should be taxed differently than capital gains (the result of stock buybacks) and really no reason either should be different than regular income.
Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by formercoder on Thursday July 25, 2019 @05:42PM (#20530070)
It's not just the question of capital gains. Dividends mandate a taxable event. Buybacks give you the option to continue holding and not pay taxes. That option has value.
Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by markvdb on Thursday July 25, 2019 @06:46PM (#20530572)
Stock buybacks versus capital gains makes all the difference for Belgian residents. No capital gains here. Foreign dividends get taxed at >= 40.5%, local dividends at 30%.

Which is why accumulating funds are getting rather popular in Belgium...

Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by bduerst on Thursday July 25, 2019 @10:54PM (#20531981)
Because it creates a tax loophole? Im not sure if that's something to brag about.
Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by markvdb on Monday July 29, 2019 @12:37PM (#20556451)
I just highlighted one aspect of the Belgian tax system relevant to the discussion. Observing a tax avoidance loophole does not in any way correlate to bragging about it.

Just to make things absolutely clear, I'll even happily make it explicit: I oppose it.

Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by scarface74 on Thursday July 25, 2019 @05:49PM (#20530127)
Yes but if you do sell you still pay a lower capital gains rate in the US.
Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by davidivadavid on Thursday July 25, 2019 @06:38PM (#20530512)
What about the fact they're unrealized?
Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by scarface74 on Thursday July 25, 2019 @07:01PM (#20530711)
I have no problem with only paying taxes when they are realized. I think I would be okay with not being taxed on dividends if they are reinvested within x number of days.
Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by leetcrew on Thursday July 25, 2019 @09:47PM (#20531660)
if capital gains were taxed like income (ie, at a higher rate), people would invest less money. is this good?
Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by skybrian on Thursday July 25, 2019 @10:58PM (#20531991)
Maybe? If the alternative to investment is spending the money, this boosts the economy.

Also, given the eagerness of investors to gamble on unicorns, it's unclear that there is any shortage of investment money. Occasionally there's talk of a global savings glut.

Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by scarface74 on Friday July 26, 2019 @08:04AM (#20534095)
Why wouldn’t spending money boost the economy? Besides when you “invest” in a publicly traded company, unless it’s at the IPO or another stock offering by the company, the company never sees the money and they aren’t getting any money from you.
Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by skybrian on Friday July 26, 2019 @05:36PM (#20538555)
Yes, I agree that more spending boosts the economy. (Sorry about the unclear phrasing.)
Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by bduerst on Thursday July 25, 2019 @10:58PM (#20531992)
This was debunked with the cap gains tax breaks made in the early 2000s. Lowering the tax rate did not stimulate more investing activity, just cut government revenue.
Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by Pfhreak on Thursday July 25, 2019 @10:36PM (#20531914)
Would they? I'm not sure that's true. If they still beat out the rate on my savings account, I'd still invest.

The super wealthy would just end up paying a bit more, but it's likely they'd remain super wealthy.

Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by mars4rp on Thursday July 25, 2019 @06:42PM (#20530537)
Why paying less taxes is good and something everybody agree on?
Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by asdfasgasdgasdg on Thursday July 25, 2019 @07:27PM (#20530880)
Do you donate money to your government above and beyond your taxes?

I don't mean to impugn your political feelings. I consistently vote for people who will raise my taxes, personally. That doesn't mean I'm volunteering to pay more than I'm obligated within a system that doesn't provide the social services my family needs. I just want to point out that almost no one pays more taxes than they are legally obligated to, regardless of their political views. This implies that substantially everyone sees value in optimizing their taxes.

In light of that, surely you can understand why the question you asked does not make much sense? The law is what it is, so of course within the law people will attempt to pay less taxes.

Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by snarf21 on Thursday July 25, 2019 @04:51PM (#20529554)
EDIT: Apologies, I was incorrect in this assumption

We need to solve this by requiring all repurchases to be with post tax money.

Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by samfisher83 on Thursday July 25, 2019 @04:52PM (#20529575)
Repurchases are done with post tax money. The reason why companies do that instead of dividends is because dividends are taxed for the investor again.
Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by dgellow on Thursday July 25, 2019 @05:10PM (#20529746)
Could someone explains this like I’m five?
Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by rfrey on Thursday July 25, 2019 @05:25PM (#20529904)
If there are 100 shares of a company worth $1000 each - the company has a value of $1000/share * 100 shares = $100,000.

The company has $10000 in after-tax profit that it would like to distribute, and you own 1 share. Since the money will be gone, the company will be worth $100,000 - $10,000 = $90,000 after the distribution.

- The company could pay a $100 per share dividend. You would get a $100 dividend but have to pay (say) 15% tax, so you now have $85 cash plus 1/100 of the company ($900), so $985.

- OR the company could buy back 10 shares. Now each share is worth $90,000 / 90 shares, or $1000. You don't pay any tax, your share is worth the same, but now you have 1/90 of the company instead of 1/100, so a greater share of future earnings.

In real life, the value of future earnings dominates the price (well, hope and greed do, but whatevs) rather than the cash-on-hand. The price should immediately go up once the buyback is announced to reflect that existing shareholders will get a bigger piece of the pie. That increase is not taxed until they sell, and the shareholder comes out ahead for the same cash distribution by the company.

Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by jbay808 on Thursday July 25, 2019 @06:09PM (#20530284)
This is a great explanation, but who would sell their share back to the company for $1000 if the value of the other shares will increase immediately after the buy-back?

I assume that if it's expected the company shares will go up in value due to the buyback, then they will have to pay a premium and buy the shares at a price that is close to the post-buyback share value.

So, perhaps at $1010/share.

However, I think there's no premium price equal to the post-buyback share price that they can pay to buy back shares that doesn't result in the company total value increasing as a whole from the buyback. This seems to be a contradiction.

I can only conclude that it isn't known that the buyback will raise share prices, because the loss of capital from the company should balance the increased fraction of future earnings that each share represents.

(edit: rewrote post after working through its logic).

Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by manigandham on Thursday July 25, 2019 @07:45PM (#20530999)
The a logical equation assuming perfect rationality and an infinite timeline with a company that is only growing. Reality is clearly much more complex and there are thousands of reasons why someone would sell their shares.
Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by simonebrunozzi on Thursday July 25, 2019 @05:55PM (#20530182)
Man, I hope you do this for a living. You're amazing. Super clear explanation.
Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by milesward on Thursday July 25, 2019 @06:39PM (#20530520)
I agree, he did great!
Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by gundmc on Thursday July 25, 2019 @05:34PM (#20529996)
Fantastic and intuitive explanation. Thank you for this!
Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by mav3rick on Thursday July 25, 2019 @05:50PM (#20530137)
Really amazing explanation.
Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by dlp211 on Thursday July 25, 2019 @05:17PM (#20529806)
No because it's wrong. The correct way to say this is that by doing a buyback it allows stockholders to realize their taxes at a later point in time since capital gains are only realized at the time of sale. Dividends are immediately taxed at the capital gains rate which is the same as the LTCG rate.
Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by georgeecollins on Thursday July 25, 2019 @05:46PM (#20530100)
You are right about the buyback allowing shareholders to delay the taxable event. But you are wrong that dividends are taxed at capital gains rate. They are taxed as income.

Capital gains are taxed at capital gains rate (almost always lower) and they gain can be offset by losses. This is the main advantage of stock buyback.

Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by jonas21 on Thursday July 25, 2019 @06:43PM (#20530545)
I'm not an accountant, but I believe if the dividend comes from an American company, and you've held the stock for over 60 days, it's a qualified dividend and gets taxed at the long term capital gains rate.
Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by cshimmin on Thursday July 25, 2019 @05:21PM (#20529856)
Not an expert but I'll give it a shot: Company has extra money and wants stakeholders to get a cut. They can either give all the stakeholders some money based on how much stock they have (this is called paying dividends), or they can buy back stock, raising the stock price (reducing the amount of stock means a given stock now corresponds to owning a larger stake in the company). Dividends would be taxed as income for investors. The increased stock value would only be taxed if/when it was sold for a profit (capital gains tax).

Edit: dlp211 points out the income from dividends is (generally) taxed at the same rate as long term capital gains.

Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by koolba on Thursday July 25, 2019 @04:53PM (#20529590)
It is post tax money. Only difference from a dividend is avoidance of double taxation by shareholders as value goes up.
Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by mehrdada on Thursday July 25, 2019 @05:13PM (#20529769)
It's not the only difference. Dividends are paid to the shareholders of record as of a certain date. Buybacks effectively benefit all the future as-of-yet-unissued shares, e.g. unvested stock-based comp (which makes it a beloved thing for corporate executives who get their majority of $$$ that way).
Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by singron on Thursday July 25, 2019 @05:21PM (#20529853)
Just to be perfectly precise, dividends are usually taxed as income, but an increased valuation as a result of a buyback would only be taxed as capital gains when the shares are sold.

If there weren't a separate capital gains rate, then the only difference would be the tax would be collected when the shares were sold rather than when the dividend was issued.

However, if you had the intention of reinvesting your dividend, then you would buy new stock with post-income-tax dollars, whereas a buyback would increase the value of your stock holdings without using your own post-tax money.

Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by vonmoltke on Thursday July 25, 2019 @08:33PM (#20531259)
> Just to be perfectly precise, dividends are usually taxed as income

Who is usually getting unqualified dividends? Qualified dividends are taxed as capital gains.

Re:Alphabet Announces Second Quarter 2019 Results [pdf] by singron on Friday July 26, 2019 @11:46AM (#20535640)
Good point. I got the two flipped in my head, but I think the rest of the comment applies.