News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by JackFr on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @10:44PM (#20512019)
> of the 3,009 flight segments Dad booked for himself from May 2005 to December 2008, he either canceled or was considered a “no-show” for 84 percent of those reservations.

So for a period of three and a half years, he booked about 2.3 flights a day, every day, and then only flew on about 1 in 6 of them. And he did a similar thing with his companion ticket.

There is a cost to this — 1st class seats the airline couldn’t sell or give to more valuable customers. The greater cost to the airline it seems was not flying this guy around, but his cancellations - which cost him nothing. And I think the judge, and many reasonable people would say that while the rules are unclear, he was clearly acting in bad faith.

Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by halter73 on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @01:22AM (#20512546)
It was AA who was acting in bad faith.

If they wanted to stop the so-called fraudulent usage of the pass, they could have just asked. He cancelled so many flights because he thought that was allowed. If they told the guy he would lose his lifetime pass if he kept cancelling or no-showing, he would have stopped.

AA didn't give him a single warning. He always booked through an human agent, so they had plenty of opportunities. Instead they let him through airport security, and took his lifetime pass at the gate leaving him without his luggage.

This was clearly the act of a company that had a huge liability based on a one-sided contract that was easy for them to break out of. The only question is whether it was worth the PR hit, but it doesn't seem like the blowback has been that bad so far.

Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by josefx on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @09:39AM (#20515118)
> they could have just asked

According to court documents they asked him when he was using fake names[1] in 2004. Instead he switched to names of friends that never showed up. They didn't terminate him until 2008.

> He canceled so many flights because he thought that was allowed.

He also made reservations for people that either didn't exist or had no idea that he made them. And in contrast to the article he didn't just do it to get space, he apparently let strangers he met at the airport use the seats.

> AA didn't give him a single warning.

Warned in 2004 terminated in 2008

[1] https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/illinoi...

Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by matthewdgreen on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @02:26PM (#20518117)
Reading that decision: it looks like Rothstein specifically asked the sales agent what constituted "fraudulent use" at the time he purchased the pass. The court doesn't explain the agent's response, but goes on to argue that Rothstein could have forced the company to include it into the contract language -- and since he did not do that, that response doesn't bind the company.

Again, I don't know what the actual response was, but this hints that the explanation Rothstein was given at sales time was not the same as what American enforced upon him. I guess this may be a reasonable legal outcome, but it doesn't seem terribly just.

Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by jquery on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @02:26AM (#20512782)
I feel like they were both acting in bad faith. He blamed his alcoholism and depression, AA blamed the speculative purchases, there’s more to the story on both sides.

I completely sympathize with him emotionally. But at the same time, he had a golden ticket with rules, he broke the rules for a long time and it took AA and an army of investigators to prove it and a court that agreed. You can say they should’ve warned him, but that’s business, the court found him in breach of contract, a contract that was costing AA $millions, it’s no wonder they sued him for breach instead of warning him when his booked seats were empty most of the time. You don’t get to play the victim when you’re in breach of contract and costing the counter party millions. Again, I sympathize with him emotionally. It sucks. Life isn’t always roses. It would have been nice of AA to warn him, yes. But they weren’t obligated to, and he was a smart finance guy who understood contracts. Even he seems more upset that they were “mean” about it than surprised it happened at all.

Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by laGrenouille on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @08:18AM (#20514401)
I would generally agree with your logic, but the problem here is that he broke AA's interpretation of a vaguely worded rule rather than clearly committing a violation of the terms. Given this AA should have contacted him about their view of "fradulent" usage.
Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by DebtDeflation on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @08:51AM (#20514686)
> AA's interpretation of a vaguely worded rule

It's debatable whether or not frequent speculative bookings constitute fraud. It's not debatable whether booking a seat for your luggage with the companion pass under a fake name is fraud.

Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by listenallyall on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @09:24AM (#20514993)
“The example given to me [by AA] was that Yo-Yo Ma ... flew with his [cello] in the next seat. Under those terms I bought the extra seat.”

AA endorsed the practice.

Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by sverhagen on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @04:53AM (#20513360)
I agree with you.

And while I am quite sympathetic to this gentleman's story myself, and while I also don't even think the revocation of the AAirpass for him was morally warranted (or at least there we go into the fuzzy details of the suit), I just wanted to add that the brief "FRAUDULENT USAGE" excerpt does not at all create an expectation to my "IANAL" eyes that there were any advance warnings to be expected. So, while I can see a legal argument over the validity of the cancellation, I don't see it over some demand of having to be warned ahead of time. But again, IANAL, just a guy.

Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by theelous3 on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @05:07AM (#20513420)
While I agree, even worse is that they were the final implementors of the supposed fraud. Their own booking concierge put every single one of those flights through.

They shot themselves in the foot thousands of times and then said it was fraud, even though he gained nothing.

It was abuse, but they didn't have an abuse cause.

Can't side with AA.

Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by piokoch on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @05:28AM (#20513514)
I don't think concierge could refuse booking - This guy had lifetime ticket. What should concierge say? I will not book a flight for you since you cancelled the one yesterday and the day before yesterday?
Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by pbhjpbhj on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @05:54AM (#20513631)
How about they have a policy of X cancellations and then a cool down period, then they could say "I'm sorry sir, because of your cancellation yesterday I can't book your flight until next week" and then allow only booking in an emergency (like they're trapped away from home).
Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by ubermonkey on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @09:44AM (#20515171)
No, they totally could. They didn't because they didn't care until they decided they wanted to axe the pass, and then they went looking for a pretext.

Dude is rich as hell and probably very hard to sympathize with on most other counts, but he got screwed by AA here.

Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by theelous3 on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @08:31PM (#20521557)
Sure they could. Just as a bank will refuse a transfer if they think it is fraudulent.

Clearly he wasn't too rich and too special to be accused of fraud, as that's exactly what they accused him of, so why not refuse the booking and nip the fraud in the butt?

It's plain as day that the whole thing was retro-marked as fraud to take his ticket away.

Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by ryanmercer on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @08:09AM (#20514332)
>What should concierge say?

I'm sorry sir, the system is not allowing me to do this, You will need to contact corporate offices.

Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by jfoster on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @09:59AM (#20515322)
"What's going on, why have you cancelled so many flights? This isn't how the pass is intended to be used. Please only use it when you are likely to take the flight."
Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by hatfieej on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @02:04AM (#20512704)
Listing the number based on flight segments makes it sound much worse than it really is. It seems like he flew internationally a lot -- so every round-trip cancellation could easily be 6 segments. I've often had to reschedule a trip twice. On those occasions, I'm only flying 0.33 of the segments I booked. His cancellations are only twice that. And with the golden ticket and no consequences, I could easily see a person with a busy schedule often booking two trips to have the seats reserved and then only taking the one they need. While he was abusing the system since there was no penalty, there are some of legitimate reasons too.
Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by opencl on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @10:40AM (#20515740)
He literally said that he repeatedly booked flights that he had zero intention of ever taking just so he could talk to somebody on the phone.
Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by JackFr on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @01:13PM (#20517318)
> I'm only flying 0.33 of the segments I booked. His cancellations are only twice that.

Every single day for 3.5 years

Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by listenallyall on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @01:45AM (#20512635)
You are quoting/repeating the very specific parameters, and words, specifically chosen by American's army of data analysts to best support its legal case and put Mr. Rothstein in the worst possible light. I seriously doubt American offered the raw reservation data to Mr. Rothstein so he could counter. How long was the average reservation active before it was cancelled? How many days before the flight were the reservations cancelled? What percentage were cancellations vs no-shows? What percent of the flights had open seats at all, or in first-class (prior to comped upgrades)? Why go back to exactly May 2005 -- was his cancellation rate declining by 2008?

>> There is a cost to this

A lower cost than if he actually flew all 3009 flight segments -- which he was fully entitled to do.

Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by carlivar on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @01:47AM (#20512643)
American doesn't have to offer that data. His lawyer could demand it in discovery. I'm sure that was done, any competent lawyer would have done so.
Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by hatfieej on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @03:26AM (#20513012)
He was entitled to fly all 3009 segments, but if those were at least 2 hours per segment -- that's over 1700 hours a year. Way more than a pilot flies at 1000/year. So at a certain point it just becomes too impractical to fly that much. It's easy to book that many flights, however.
Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by jquery on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @02:31AM (#20512803)
>which he was fully entitled to do.

And AA was entitled to sue for breach without warning. The blade cuts both ways.

Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by listenallyall on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @02:43AM (#20512849)
How is that relevant to the quote? Anyone can sue anyone for anything. Are you claiming he was not entitled to fly all 3009 segments, had he chosen to?
Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by jquery on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @09:40AM (#20515125)
No, I’m saying if you want to go by the letter of the rules, AA had no obligation to warn him, even if that would have been the nice thing to do. So pointing out what he was “legally entitled” to only makes AA’s case stronger because from a legal perspective he was more clearly in the wrong by booking empty seats with a fake name.
Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by listenallyall on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @06:00PM (#20520321)
Please don't misquote me, I never used the phrase "legally entitled." Further, my post had nothing to do with his legal rights. The parent post that claimed AA was burdened with costs due to Mr. Rothstein's habitual cancellations, to which I noted the cost to AA of cancelling those reservations was far lower than the cost of him using all of those reservations.
Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by jquery on Thursday July 25, 2019 @03:36PM (#20528701)
Sorry, instead of "legally entitled" substitute "fully entitled" and I believe my point is the same, and I don't think you are steelmanning your parent post. Nobody in this thread disagrees that it's cheaper to have a cancelled reservation than a fulfilled one, so we must apply the principle of charity[1] here. Yes, the cost to AA would be far higher if he rode all of those trips that he cancelled. And if he flew all those 3000+ legs he booked, I would be 100% on his side, because that would show good faith on his side. However, I believe he was only able to book so many flights because he had no intention of flying most of them, which is evidenced by the fact he did not end up flying them. Because there is near-zero cost book and cancel, that is why the airline specifically put "no speculative bookings" in the golden ticket contract. Booking and flying requires the cost of the golden ticket holder's time which serves as a limiting factor.

It's a similar line of thinking to a past conversation on HN about how health care in the UK is paid with time, where everyone pays the same price, but that price is time, and in the UK they wait significantly more than they have to wait in the US, which discourages seeing the doctor for minor ailments because it might take most of your day or it might get scheduled weeks out.

I understand and sympathize with him emotionally, 100%. I'm speaking more from a business perspective where I completely support AA's legal right to terminate his pass, and was just trying to point out through the thread why AA was justified.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Principle_of_charity

Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by supercanuck on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @10:53PM (#20512057)
As a frequent flyer, 2005-2008 was also a period of time when there were empty seats on planes and the airline industry was still recovering from 9/11. You could fly and half the plane might be empty. Cancellations fees weren't nearly as bad either.

Let's not jump to conclusions that he was acting in bad faith.

Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by josefx on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @05:17AM (#20513468)
Officially[1] they terminated it based on him:

* Making up fake names

* Substituting these fake names for random travelers he picked up at the airport

* Once they warned him about the fake names he started to make up travel arraignments for friends.

As proof they showed his flight records. He argued that AAs ability to just terminate the contract based on his behavior was unenforceable.

[1]https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/district-courts/illinoi...

Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by koolba on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @11:01PM (#20512080)
First class tickets usually do not have cancellation fees. They’re fully refundable.
Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by discordance on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @12:50AM (#20512441)
That's true. Reminds me of a story of a guy who would buy a first class ticket, go to the lounge and eat lunch, and then reschedule his ticket for the next day, every day... free lunch for a year[0].

0: https://nypost.com/2014/01/29/man-uses-first-class-plane-tic...

Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by chrischen on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @01:03AM (#20512486)
Isn’t the lounge usually inside security after checkin? You can still cancel after checking in with a ticket?
Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by RyJones on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @01:31AM (#20512580)
Yes. I’ve done it before - plans change
Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by lscharen on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @01:57PM (#20517800)
I re-booked a flight while in the security line because I got an alert that my original flight was delayed and was offered a "tap here to re-book on this flight" button.

So I did.

It took a minute to explain why my printed boarding pass no longer matched my flight itinerary when I got to the front of the security line, but not too big of a hassle.

Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by eli on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @11:22PM (#20512163)
But there’s no lost revenue - no actual cost - for cancelling a ticket nobody else was ever going to buy anyway.
Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by chrischen on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @02:41AM (#20512843)
Nobody bought it because it was unavailable.
Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by msinclair on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @03:01AM (#20512914)
And if he had flown, it still would have been unavailable. Along with the other thousands of booked flights.
Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by theelous3 on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @05:18AM (#20513474)
This is a major part of the problem for me.

In my opinion, if you want to judge this as fraud, you have to do it, at least in part, by looking at it through the lense of a regular passenger.

If a regular passenger who pays for each ticket individually did this, would they have a problem? Of course not. AA could only dream of such a passenger.

They abused people's generally poor financial reasoning to claim fraud uncontested. It's easy to get people to think of this as "free flights for life, poor airline abused" simply because the ticket was so massively undervalued compared to the use potential. In reality, each and every one of those seats were paid for, AA were just upset with themselves for the price they charged and fabricated a fraud claim to end it.

Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by dfxm12 on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @09:40AM (#20515129)
These are two different products, akin to a subscription service vs outright buying something, so the comparison isn't apt. You can return something to the big box store where you bought it if you don't use it. You're not entitled to that with the subscription service.
Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by theelous3 on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @08:27PM (#20521529)
It's not a subscription, he outright prepaid for the rest of his entire life, for the service he was paying for individually. So similar is the product, that a separate system wasn't even designed for it and he'd still get stuff like airmiles per flight.

It was a prepay for the same product, not a subscription for a new one.

Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by cher88 on Tuesday July 23, 2019 @11:57PM (#20512281)
It sounds like the tickets were cancelled the next day anyway, so it's not like they couldn't have re-sold or given away..
Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket by awillen on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @11:50AM (#20516433)
Why not tell him to stop? Why wait until years later? The problem is that their actions make it clear that they didn't have issues with his conduct. Rather, they decided to cut costs and as a result decided to retroactively reexamine behavior that they had clearly condoned, at least implicitly, years later.

He wasn't acting in bad faith - when they asked him to make changes to his behavior with the pass, he did. Every indication is that if the airline had politely asked him to stop booking flights and canceling them without a good reason, he would have. They were, on the other hand, clearly not acting in good faith. That's the issue.