Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket
by carlivar on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @01:47AM
(#20512643)
American doesn't have to offer that data. His lawyer could demand it in discovery. I'm sure that was done, any competent lawyer would have done so.
Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket
by hatfieej on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @03:26AM
(#20513012)
He was entitled to fly all 3009 segments, but if those were at least 2 hours per segment -- that's over 1700 hours a year. Way more than a pilot flies at 1000/year. So at a certain point it just becomes too impractical to fly that much. It's easy to book that many flights, however.
>which he was fully entitled to do.
And AA was entitled to sue for breach without warning. The blade cuts both ways.
Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket
by listenallyall on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @02:43AM
(#20512849)
How is that relevant to the quote? Anyone can sue anyone for anything. Are you claiming he was not entitled to fly all 3009 segments, had he chosen to?
No, I’m saying if you want to go by the letter of the rules, AA had no obligation to warn him, even if that would have been the nice thing to do. So pointing out what he was “legally entitled” to only makes AA’s case stronger because from a legal perspective he was more clearly in the wrong by booking empty seats with a fake name.
Re:The Man with the Golden Airline Ticket
by listenallyall on Wednesday July 24, 2019 @06:00PM
(#20520321)
Please don't misquote me, I never used the phrase "legally entitled." Further, my post had nothing to do with his legal rights. The parent post that claimed AA was burdened with costs due to Mr. Rothstein's habitual cancellations, to which I noted the cost to AA of cancelling those reservations was far lower than the cost of him using all of those reservations.
Sorry, instead of "legally entitled" substitute "fully entitled" and I believe my point is the same, and I don't think you are steelmanning your parent post. Nobody in this thread disagrees that it's cheaper to have a cancelled reservation than a fulfilled one, so we must apply the principle of charity[1] here. Yes, the cost to AA would be far higher if he rode all of those trips that he cancelled. And if he flew all those 3000+ legs he booked, I would be 100% on his side, because that would show good faith on his side. However, I believe he was only able to book so many flights because he had no intention of flying most of them, which is evidenced by the fact he did not end up flying them. Because there is near-zero cost book and cancel, that is why the airline specifically put "no speculative bookings" in the golden ticket contract. Booking and flying requires the cost of the golden ticket holder's time which serves as a limiting factor.
It's a similar line of thinking to a past conversation on HN about how health care in the UK is paid with time, where everyone pays the same price, but that price is time, and in the UK they wait significantly more than they have to wait in the US, which discourages seeing the doctor for minor ailments because it might take most of your day or it might get scheduled weeks out.
I understand and sympathize with him emotionally, 100%. I'm speaking more from a business perspective where I completely support AA's legal right to terminate his pass, and was just trying to point out through the thread why AA was justified.
>> There is a cost to this
A lower cost than if he actually flew all 3009 flight segments -- which he was fully entitled to do.